Irish dancing and 'Ringo Starr' on 'SYTYCD'
June 2nd, 2011
10:17 AM ET

Irish dancing and 'Ringo Starr' on 'SYTYCD'

You know it's a good audition episode of "So You Think You Can Dance" when the words "That's my new favorite" come out of your mouth more times than you can count. Such was the case with Wednesday night's episode, featuring tryouts from Salt Lake City, Utah and Brooklyn, New York.

First in Salt Lake, steppers Devon McCullough and Micah Clark proved to be a dynamic duo, though only Devon ended up moving on past choreography to Vegas. He will certainly be one to watch.

"SYTYCD" superfan Chyna Smith seemed tailor-made for this show, not only because her dance was choreographed by Allison Holker, but she pulled it off flawlessly and has one of the best personalities so far this season.

Tadd Gadduang had an extraordinary level of musicality, not to mention a very unique take on popping and locking. But never mind that Annie Graton - who had one of the more impressive contemporary auditions so far - put her dad through to Vegas!

Then there was Chase Thomas, who wore the least we've seen on a male dancer since Brandon Bryant. He's not quite up to Brandon's level, but he's certainly got a great style of his own.

I was sad to see Samantha Hiller, who was suffering from amnesia, not make it through past choreography, but I think we'll see her next year.

We simply can't talk about the Salt Lake auditions without mentioning Brittany Morgan Starr, one of the most bizarre characters seen in this show's history (and yes, that includes "Sex"). The producers even went to the lengths of visiting her home to find out more about her father, who claims to be the real "Ringo Starr." Personally, I think the several minutes spent on Starr could have been used to feature one of the "montage" dancers who went to the Las Vegas callbacks, but that's just me.

On to New York, which started off with a bang, as "whacker" Samara “Princess Lockaroo” Cohen wowed the judges with a style of dance that can best be compared to voguing, but much faster-paced.

Then came the sure-to-be-controversial krumper Brian Henry, who insulted season 6 Russell Ferguson and Lil' C right out of the gate as being too "mainstream." There's no doubt that he's got talent... in fact, I would say he is a better krumper than Russell. It remains to be seen if he is as versatile as Russell, however.

Mary Murphy made a good point, though, that it was really bad form to come out dissing other dancers who have come before him (especially since Lil' C is an occasional judge on the show). Brian's tears of joy when he got past the choreography round to Vegas could go a long way in gaining audience sympathy, however.

As for Brandon Jones, I have to say he didn't especially stand out to me, but I could be convinced otherwise in Vegas.

New York gave us three dancers who have the potential to garner a lot of votes, if they make the top 20.

First, there's Irish dancer Mary Kate Sheehan. I don't recall any previous Irish dancers, so she certainly has her work cut out for her. However, she charmed the judges and this viewer, and I look forward to seeing what other styles she can do. I have a feeling she will gain a lot of fans.

I feel that the judges were far too tough on Jesse LeProtto. One can't help but be reminded of Evan Kasprzak, since he's a Broadway-style dancer, but he doesn't have Evan's personality. Despite that, I tweeted "audition of the season" when I saw him last night. Whatever his talents might be in other styles, this routine absolutely blew me away and I was left scratching my head as to why he was sent through to choreography. Didn't he just prove that he can perform choreography?

And OK, I may have said that Jesse had the audition of the season, but that was before I saw Robert Taylor, Jr. Can I get a "woooo!"? This guy was absolutely phenomenal. I would not make the comparison to "tWitch" lightly, but I really think he has that X factor (sorry, Simon). Look for him to get a lot of votes, if he can get through Vegas (please, oh please!).

I would be remiss not to mention popper/locker Virgil "Lil' O" Gadson, and ballroom dancer (another example of an inexplicable decision to send to choreography) Kristen Dobson. I enjoyed them both well enough, but with the level of talent we've seen thus far, it's hard to say if they will make it through Vegas.

So which ones were your favorites? Do you agree that they were too harsh on Jesse and Kristen? Would you also have preferred to see less of "Ringo Starr's" daughter? Share your view on iReport or comment below.

soundoff (8 Responses)
  1. Deena

    I meant "and." Sorry about that!

    June 2, 2011 at 6:10 pm | Report abuse |
  2. Deena

    I'm glad this show highlights male dancers who are masculine. Hopefully someday society can break down the stereotypes about male dancers and accept dance as an activity for men an women equally.

    June 2, 2011 at 6:04 pm | Report abuse |
  3. Sam

    They spent way too much time on Brittany Starr! I'm sure there were plenty of other dancers who auditioned that were very talented and we missed seeing because they spent so much time on her.

    June 2, 2011 at 2:12 pm | Report abuse |
    • :-Donna

      Agreed, however, it is still an improvement over the first couple of seasons where they spent nearly the entire audition hour on failures, jokes,, etc. rather than letting us see some of the great dancers audition. I was ready to skip watching the auditions entirely and wait foe the final 20 before starting to watch the show!

      June 2, 2011 at 5:26 pm | Report abuse |
  4. Two Previous Irish Dancers

    Ashley Purl from the Trinity Irish Dance Company was on SYTYCD in 2005. Three-time world champion Ashley Smith from the Smith-Houlihan School of Irish Dance was on SYTYCD last season. Both dancers made it to Vegas. Purl was featured heavily through the auditions in Vegas, but did not advance. Smith was hardly shown at all in Vegas and did not advance.

    Best of luck to Mary Kate!

    June 2, 2011 at 1:34 pm | Report abuse |
  5. elm

    Oh good...more queen shows.

    June 2, 2011 at 12:22 pm | Report abuse |
  6. Rants of A Crazy Person

    I do think they were too hard on Jesse. I thought he was great and his dance was excellent. However, I was not impressed with the dances this episode. Most of the contestants got on my nerves, or just weren't memorable and I can't believe 10 minutes was wasted on NOT Ringo Starr. Seriously?

    Check out more of my recap at my blog:

    June 2, 2011 at 12:12 pm | Report abuse |

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

About this blog

Our daily cheat-sheet for breaking celebrity news, Hollywood buzz and your pop-culture obsessions.