'Idol' Top 11 redux: So did we love it?
March 30th, 2011
10:05 PM ET

'Idol' Top 11 redux: So did we love it?

I'm still stunned over the kudos for Haley.

Sometimes I wonder whether the judges are hearing the same thing we are as we watch along at home.

Anywhoo, the performance show is done, and I'm anxious to hear what you thought of Elton John night? Will it be hard to send two people home this week? Any predictions on who those two people might be?

I'm going to be on pins and needles during elimination. Don't forget to join me here live while I blog the results.

Peace out "Idol"-ators!


« Previous entry
soundoff (365 Responses)
  1. real estate,real estate listings,real estate foreclosures,remax,real estate value,commercial real estate,real estate careers,google real estate,real estate companies

    Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I've truly loved browsing your blog posts. After all I'll be subscribing on your rss feed and I'm hoping you write again very soon!

    April 5, 2012 at 10:30 pm | Report abuse |
  2. Jessy

    I think all of you girls criticizing Pia are a bunch of jealous CORNBALLLLLSSSSS...How long did Alicia Keys just sit on her piano and do nothing but sing and play the piano? I was at her concert in Jones Beach and she did not dance once and all I wanted was to hear her SINGGGGGG...because her songs and voice were amazing..she then added movement to her performances, but talent was there..this chick Haley annoys the crap out of me..she is not talented and her and her cheerleader friends need to hit the road..she also smirked when Pia got voted off..I hate her!!!!!! and her Elton John performance was AWKWARD..Randy Jackson needs to stop repeating DUDE so many times and needed to realize that by saying she was the best performer of the night, during the Elton John night he looked like a FOOOOOOLLL!!!!!

    April 8, 2011 at 9:59 am | Report abuse |
  3. Patrice

    I think that this year is fabulous and that's because the judges all have been performers. They know how to select talent. Simon always ridiculed the contestants, and the judges didn't put through the best talent to begin with. I was driving home after going furniture shopping with my husband yesterday afternoon. I have a new SUV which has a SYNC system. The technology is brand new and sometimes there are quirks in the system. My iPod is sunk into my car and Clay Aiken came on singing all the songs from his season. By the way, he's extremely handsome, and it was only for a short while on Idol, that he was a bit geeky looking. My husband and I listened to "the voice" and there's nobody on that show that can compare to his vocal expertise. The way his voice effortlessly hits those high notes is remarkable, and he has a gorgeous lower register as well. There's just something very special about the quality of his voice, and I can't find another artist to replace him. Scotty is going to get all the Clay Aiken votes, and he should, because he's humble, respectful and extremely talented. He reminds me the most of Clay, because he knows who he's as a performer and doesn't deviate. Though, there will never be another Clay Aiken, Scotty will be famous as a country singer and will be the "new" Garth Brooks, and I hope the next "American Idol."

    April 1, 2011 at 4:27 am | Report abuse |
  4. mizer

    Stefano and Hayley. He can't really sing unless his eyes are closed and I feel like she's always screaming at me. Just sayin.

    March 31, 2011 at 6:52 pm | Report abuse |
  5. Mike

    I think Naima, and probably Thia are gone tonight. Wouldn't be shocked if Stefano replaced one of them, but I think its between those 3 based on last night. James is my favorite, along with Casey. I can't stand Jacob, he is so dramatic and looks constipated as he is over-singing all his notes. Pia-boring as heck. Paul is too weird for me. I like Lauren, and Haley grew on me after last night. I like Scotty, and he will have a good career, but he is too one-dimensional to win the whole thing.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:48 pm | Report abuse |
  6. Ken

    They all suck, none of them are interesting. Guess Simon made the whole show interesting.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:34 pm | Report abuse |
  7. 121

    the top three will be scotty, pia , and james. Possibly Haley, one of the best but doesn't get the votes, but I think Scotty will win.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:28 pm | Report abuse |
  8. bernardo

    let me write it in capital letters:the only original,interesting,talented,deserving of being the winner is:
    CASEY ADAMS.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:27 pm | Report abuse |
  9. bitnar

    Jacob is a sweetheart and has the most powerful voice, but I cannot watch him sing. His face keeps shifting around; his lips disappear when he opens his mouth. I think Lauren Alaina is the "whole package," but she's seemed kind of deflated ever since they (unjustly) criticized her Shania Twain performance a few weeks ago.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:15 pm | Report abuse |
  10. Sugar

    Naima has to go....I don't get her direction or why she would do a 360 on such an awesome song. Thia...needs more life experience to feel the music the way that the judgrs want her to.

    March 31, 2011 at 5:03 pm | Report abuse |
    • B=dog

      You mean a 180, not 360 :)

      Bottom 3 tonight... Thia, Paul, Stefano.
      Thia is safe.
      Bye bye Paul who CAN'T sing, and bye bye Stefano and his tight pants.

      March 31, 2011 at 5:24 pm | Report abuse |
  11. Beth

    Paul and Naimi should go! I've never thought Paul could sing...they say he's unique...I say...he's a poor singer!! Naimi is better than him but not by much...odd voice.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:56 pm | Report abuse |
  12. Sheila

    Naima and Paul should go - followed closely by Haley. Nothing in her performance last night felt real - she has a strong voice, but her growling is laughable. Everything about her feels like a high school musical.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:55 pm | Report abuse |
  13. CritiquelyAcclaimed

    I think Naima needs to go, but I'm not sure if she will. I think she has some kind of strange cult following – kind of like Sanjaya. I'm not saying she lacks talent, but compared to the others she has the least amount. I think Stefano's time is coming as well. I think he has a nice voice, but he just doesn't "wow" me. I think Casey is a musical genius and Paul is so wonderfully different and talented, I want both of them to stick around. For the girls, they can all go as far as I'm concerned EXCEPT Lauren who I thought did a wonderful job last night. By far her best performance yet! Oh, and I LOVE Scotty. I don't care what you think about country music – that guy is going to be a HUGE star.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:53 pm | Report abuse |
  14. Josh

    So in love with Haley. Her singing makes me wet. :P
    Anyone saying she sucks is retarded. I love everything about her.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:53 pm | Report abuse |
  15. migo

    stefano and pia should go home!

    March 31, 2011 at 4:43 pm | Report abuse |
  16. WHAT!!!

    PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE send Naima home, she has no talent and she makes me change the channel. She's just painful to watch and listen to. Thia and Pia have to step it up, just no range as a full performer. Let the rest battle it out...

    March 31, 2011 at 4:36 pm | Report abuse |
  17. The Vixn

    Well, the missing Bronx Zoo cobra was performing on stage last night during Haley's "Bennie And The Jets" performance. Sssssssssss........ Very annoying!

    March 31, 2011 at 4:35 pm | Report abuse |
  18. Tracy

    anyone else annoyed by James. the kid is too arrogant – and what was his joke about Coke ?

    March 31, 2011 at 4:14 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      He said he didn't want the pyrotech stuff to turn into a Pepsi experience (referring to Michael Jackson), and Ryan mentioned something about Coke being a sponsor of the show.

      March 31, 2011 at 5:31 pm | Report abuse |
  19. arachne blue

    Lauren Alaina is one of my favorites. I couldn't stop laughing during Hayley's performance last night due to the buh buh buh buh bit. I know Elton did it, but it just wasn't the same, and it definitely wasn't good. Pia and Thia, along with Jacob, would make great church soloists. Nuff said. Stefano sounds like a lounge singer. I like Scottie, even though he is somewhat limited. Paul's main attraction seems to be that 1000 watt smile. Casey was somewhat better last night than last week, but still not all that. Naima at least tried to make her song sound like her own, but I can't say I really liked it. Reggae is not my fave. What's up with the judges by the way? They are being so, so kind. Randy seems to be the only one even trying to be constructive. If Jennifer doesn't quit saying "amazing" I may vomit. And Steven seems to have just kind of checked out lately. Whatever Randy or Jennifer says, whoever says it first, he agrees. Where is Simon when you need him?

    March 31, 2011 at 4:07 pm | Report abuse |
  20. Tricia

    Who knows, but I'm gonna say Naima and Haley will go. I personally liked Haley's performance but I'm not sure everyone would get it. I didn't like Naima's performance last night, it seemed fake. I like it when she stays natural. Oh well...I'm really enjoying the season so far, I hate to see any of them sent home, but atleast they all get the experience to tour this summer.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:02 pm | Report abuse |
  21. Chandra

    Ok here's my take. Thia should be doing Disney voiceovers. That's about all she can sing. Her voice is too young sounding. I mean, she's young. What do you expect? Scotty tries too hard to get that country twang in his voice, and he sings out of the side of his mouth. He looks like a young George Bush with that smirk. Ugh. Paul was good on Beatles week in Vegas, but he's gotten worse. He has a whine to his voice that drives me crazy. And he dances like Martin Short. Jacob is a drama queen. And he sings through his nose! It's horrible! Lauren is so cute and goofy. And I really think she's got a great voice. Loved her last night. Stefano is AWFUL and I think it's kinda gross how JLo drools over him. Pia has a great voice, but she really does have to do something other than ballads. At first I thought James sounded too much like Adam
    Lambert (who I can't stand) but now he's growing on me. Hayley is just plain weird. Don't like her. Casey is my favorite. I have to say he had a few bad weeks where he did that singing-through-his-teeth-gritty-scream thing WAY too much. But last night was good. I just went back and counted and I had only talked about ten contestants. It took me three times to realize that I forgot Naima. Yeah. That shows how much I like her. She's trying too hard to be different. Don't like her.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:01 pm | Report abuse |
  22. Dog Biscuit

    American Idol = Fail. Cookie cutter pop musicians. The show needs to go off the air immediately and the producers thrown in jail for crimes against humanity.

    March 31, 2011 at 4:00 pm | Report abuse |
  23. Holly

    I love country but I just don't think Scotty belongs on AI. He's great, but not versatile enough. Hated the song last night. Naima needs to go and either Scotty or Paul (cant stand him at all).

    March 31, 2011 at 4:00 pm | Report abuse |
  24. Kareen

    To all you Pia lovers
    Would you sit through a 2 hour concert listening to her? Not me
    As a 72 year old, I sure would sit through a concert listening to Paul.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:59 pm | Report abuse |
    • Babs

      I totally agree. I'd spend money on Paul. Buying Cd's or concert tickets. Good entertainer. Pia and Thia put me to sleep.

      March 31, 2011 at 5:15 pm | Report abuse |
  25. Ralph smith

    Yo. That show was dope as heck.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:55 pm | Report abuse |
  26. mls

    Wow, a lot of criticism. I've grown to like Naima more and I thought a reggae version of that song was very cool. I love James and feel that if he were to win, what a feather in the "caps" of the "handicaps". He has challenges and he really can sing beautifully as he has shown. I think Hayley is incredible, unique. Pia is the beauty queen type but seems about 40 years old in her delivery. Not that being 40 is bad. I am enjoying this season a lot. Last season was the first time I tuned out halfway through. What a bunch of sleepers! I think Paul is annoying, sorry, Jacob is starting to get on my nerves, everything is over the top. Very interesting and enjoyable show this year, despite Simon's absence.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:43 pm | Report abuse |
  27. Dprang

    I tune in to watch James and Naima as both are original and energetic. Let's face it. We like music that suits our own preferences and I like edgy, creative music that gets me to move and get lost in it.

    I find that many of the performers, although with good voices, range etc are just not ready to bring the house down. They are not memorable performances.

    Since I am not really a country fan save for the Dixie Chicks and Sugarland. Most country singers are somewhat boring to me.

    Hayley finally broke out last night and it showed. I was glad she repressed her yoddles.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:35 pm | Report abuse |
  28. cloudnine

    Who cares!!! Stop watching Idol since Simon left the show. They really need to call it a day. Can't wait for X-Factor!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 3:32 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      Will X-Factor rely on the American public for a vote? If so, the show will suck just as much as the 'vote for the worst' campaigns and the towns who vote for an average singer just because they're from there.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:36 pm | Report abuse |
  29. AMBER

    Pia is sooo boring..we get it now run for miss universe.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:27 pm | Report abuse |
  30. confused

    OK, so I just DON'T GET THE CASEY THING, he gets the save this early on and then they announce that it will be T-11 instead of T-10 for the tour. Does he have a relative who is influential or connected to the Idol company because I just don't think he has the star quality. I do have to admit that last night I "kind of" liked his song but it didn't blow me away.
    Pia is boring, lovely voice as we all know but a clone each week and no star quality to speak of. Niama has spark and with a bit of guidance and direction to get her to sing outside of her comfort zone (last nights didn't do it for me) – change the hairstyle and soften up her look and I think everyone will be surprised – if she survives tonight that is my suggestion.
    James is great but he needs to show another side of himself – other than the high energy rock all the time.
    Stefano – its a matter of time if not tonight.
    Pauls voice makes me think of nails on a blackboard – time to get another drink when he is on. Tonight may be his night to go.

    All in all I am struggling to keep awake each week – waiting for a real "OMG" moment with one of them and hope it comes soon otherwise I'm done.

    My wish for cast off tonight: Casey.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:25 pm | Report abuse |
    • fred

      I agree. I think this year's voting is rigged. Why the H would they save Casey? And so early on? And now there are 11? Why the rule change? Can we see the rules? Something is fishy in Denmark! (That's from Hamlet)

      March 31, 2011 at 3:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • Babs

      I disagree. Casey is the most talented compleat musician up there. I want him in the top 2 with Paul.

      March 31, 2011 at 5:12 pm | Report abuse |
  31. The One

    'American Idol' delivers 'Crocodile Flop' to Elton John fans

    http://www.masslive.com/television/index.ssf/2011/03/american_idol_delivers_crocodi.html#postComment

    March 31, 2011 at 3:25 pm | Report abuse |
  32. thepearl

    I don't watch it, but for some reason my sis always text me when Jacob comes on. I don't know why because I can't stand his singing! Oops I mean hollering!!

    March 31, 2011 at 3:17 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      Who can be an American Idol without mastering rap....I'm not talking old school rap, I'm talking about the new rap (or *rap) with variations of the same beat, nobody's 'singing' but instead they're just saying words that rhyme with a few words left out here and there (you know, 5 different names for the singers 'important' body parts of a girl and what he wants to do with it)

      March 31, 2011 at 3:26 pm | Report abuse |
  33. fred

    The frightening thing about American Idol over the years is that the judges/produces/handlers pick these songs or genres (Mototown, etc.) and these kids sing the songs as if they never even heard them before. Songs that have been classics songs for 30-40 years and these kids don't know the song, the original bands/singers or in what context and time/culture the song was made. Its like watching a TV news "anchorman" try to be a real hardboiled news reporter on when he is just reading something he is seeing for the first time as it is coming across the telepromter live. Same on AI. They learn it yesterday and sing it on TV today. Part of your talent should be initimately knowing your music.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:17 pm | Report abuse |
  34. bxrkris

    I think Teen Wolf (Casey) and Paul should go. Its obvious that the public does not like Casey because he was eliminated last week... He does not have much to show, so my bottom three will be Casey, Paul and Nahima.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:10 pm | Report abuse |
  35. Melanie

    @Lisa Kenney, they announced last week that all 11 will go on tour since they did the save on Casey. Very good season this year. Alot of good talent. I also think Naima should go. Then maybe Paul. I don't think he was very strong last night.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:09 pm | Report abuse |
  36. Munkey River

    Lots of great performances last night, but Naima was my least favorite. Her fake accent really annoyed me.
    After her I think Paul or Thia should be the ones to go.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:09 pm | Report abuse |
  37. Tina

    I think the reason everyone says they are singing the same old songs is that AI is using the same old songbooks that they have rights to use. Some new songs are definitely in order. I think Naima and Paul are done.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:06 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      I was encouraged when I heard the 'new' music during auditions, but the last few shows fell back into what we've been hearing for the last 10 seasons.... The judges continue to criticize the young ones when they don't sing age appropriate stuff, and then we have themes where they have to sing songs that were made before they gave their first breath. What's up with that?

      March 31, 2011 at 3:19 pm | Report abuse |
  38. terry

    Jacob,niama and lauren bottom 3.Gotta say though they could let scotty go now and it wouldn't matter he's going some where anyhow.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:05 pm | Report abuse |
  39. Sandy

    Casey and Naima . . . it's time to go!!!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 3:05 pm | Report abuse |
  40. Babs

    Please, for the love of all things musical, let Thia and that ditzy blond girl go home this week. How unremarkable do people need to me. Don't get me wrong. They both seem like nice kids. Pretty voices. Big deal. no Star quality at all.

    March 31, 2011 at 3:03 pm | Report abuse |
  41. Lana2

    Please take Naima off,she is so vulgar!

    March 31, 2011 at 3:00 pm | Report abuse |
    • How Sweet

      Awww...lets all gather around the Queengger with her flaming red suit. Yes thengger is so loved and admired, especially when its a flaming queen.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:03 pm | Report abuse |
  42. FLAME - ON

    I notice they have the Flaming Queen dressed in red and front & center.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:59 pm | Report abuse |
    • fred

      Is it me or does it seem that Jacob turned from Luther Vandross into a gay man since this show started?

      March 31, 2011 at 3:21 pm | Report abuse |
  43. Kimah Dawg

    The bottom three in my opiion, Paul Thia & Naima,, my fav's are Lauren, Casey & Scotty although Scotty may be too inside the box.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:54 pm | Report abuse |
  44. texican

    Naima and Paul are the next to go. Dont be surprised if Casey gets the boot and Naima stays.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:49 pm | Report abuse |
  45. jojo

    The girls are all over the place. Naima tries to entertain but she is truly just a train wreck. Thia is too timid and meek with no life experience to bring to the lyrics. Pia sings the same power ballad every week – we've seen this before! Hayley's growls are irritating and reveal a lack of talent. Lauren honestly is the best of the girls. More upbeat, has personality, can sing and move pretty well.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:47 pm | Report abuse |
    • Casey

      AGREED! Thia=NO personality. I wouldn't feel bad for Scotty if he was voted off because he is about to BLOW UP country radio whether if he wins or not.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:52 pm | Report abuse |
    • mls

      Last night was the first time I enjoyed Lauren. She is so young and silly. Although Cary U. was somewhat like that as well when she was on the show and good for Cary U.!! Lauren gets on my nerves though. She needs to grow up a bit, doncha think?

      March 31, 2011 at 3:48 pm | Report abuse |
  46. fred

    First off, I suck at names................................
    I am beginning to think the voting is rigged. How on Earth could the homeless looking guy with the bug beard still be on this show? He sounds like he would yanked from singing karaoke at the corner bar at 3am.

    Thia has a pretty voice but ZERO stage presence. No on will go to see her in concert. Sorry.

    The blondish guy with the guitar sucks. Naima is fantastic and importantly she is original. I hope she goes far. The last blond girl to sing is great and she has the total Hollywood/People magazine look. Her song choices don't fit her voice though.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:45 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      Thia's pretty, but sounds like the average filipina. They'd much rather see Charice in concert.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:50 pm | Report abuse |
  47. Scoot

    Paul and Casey should go home. Both have been consistently bad.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:44 pm | Report abuse |
    • Goober Gobbler

      Hi Scoot...you have a cute name I would like to gobble on your goober then we do the Scoot Poot Boogie.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:47 pm | Report abuse |
  48. Jeff

    Didn't 'love' the sound, but I'm not sure if it's the sound tech's or the singers that make it sound karaoke. (There's a live band, but why does it sound like a tape?) Also, I really wish people would quit drinking alcohol or taking drugs while watching the show and voting for their favorite. Some of those singers should have been sent home by now. Darn those "vote for the worst" campaigns!

    March 31, 2011 at 2:44 pm | Report abuse |
  49. BadBack

    Paul's an acquired taste - love him or hate him ... his bad break was choosing an Elton John song the week before, then having Elton John week. My teenaged daughter swoons over Scotty. I don't get the Lauren and Haley love. Pia seems like Katharine McPia to me. With the younger contestants, it seems they don't take the coaching as well, and they don't know how to stretch their bounds. Final 5 whether they deserve it or not - Scotty, Jacob, Pia, Paul and James. Naima and Thia say goodbye tonight, perhaps Stefano.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:44 pm | Report abuse |
    • Casey

      Thia is too emotionless to win. I agree that Stefano is OUT tonight... with Thia. Both boring... theyy just sing. I don;t get excited listening to them.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:47 pm | Report abuse |
  50. jojo

    Casey and James are far more interesting performers than anyone else. Paul could be a great performer, but his voice sounds so frail lately. Stefano and Scotty are not unique. Jacob has a good voice but he performs like a drag queen. No offense to him or drag queens but his body and mouth movements are similar to how a drag queen lip syncs and moves on stage.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:43 pm | Report abuse |
  51. Fred

    If I had my way Stefano and Naima would be heading home. Stefano needs to find/start a boy band, his voice lacks the character needed to be a solo artist. Naima just doesn't have the x-factor, and her fake Jamaican accent was embarrassing. I totally agree on the writer's point about Haley, what the *heck* was J-Lo hearing? And it's not "BUH BUH BUH" Benny and the Jets! That was unsettling, she got it right once (I think the 4th time? or the 3rd) and the others were shockingly bad. Lauren was awesome, I've watched a few country music award shows and she sang as good as any live performance I've seen. Scotty was BORING, so boring, he could've interpreted a classic but instead he chose the only song that had the word country in it. Lame. Jacob is still strong but ready for his own material, his versions are starting to run into each other. Thia is adorable but clearly not ready for this. When Jimmy was talking to her she gave that blank "teenager" look, the one that says, "um, like, ohh kay." This is production, not a homework assignment. The rest were ok. James is getting very karaoke, not getting all the fan admiration, may be misplaced sympathy, of which I have absolutely none, should've found a guitarist and paid his dues.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:43 pm | Report abuse |
    • fred

      Yea, what the "H" was with the BUHBUHBUH Benny? Totally the wrong song for her to sing.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:48 pm | Report abuse |
  52. FRAN

    My #1 last night had to go to Haley.
    Pia is a stuck up snoozefest!
    Liked Paul at first but it's getting old fast.
    Naima should never have made the top 24 list.
    Like Casey but don't think he will win.
    James way to Korney......
    Lauren who even rememnbers what she sang?
    Stefano holding his own has a good voice not much of an audience connection yet

    March 31, 2011 at 2:38 pm | Report abuse |
  53. Casey

    Thia and Stefano... Boring... OUT please.

    I love Casey, Paul, Jacob and can I please say that I personally thought that Naima did a wonderful job? If no one knew that elton john song, they would have thought it was a great reggae jam.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:36 pm | Report abuse |
  54. Sunny

    I wonder if Naima had Pia's looks and Pia had Naima's voice how the voting would go.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:35 pm | Report abuse |
  55. LLJ

    Naima and Stefano should go.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:34 pm | Report abuse |
  56. Sunshine Girl

    Am I the only one who thinks Haley looks really cross eyed? Close up shots make it 10% worse. When she sings she growls so much it reminds me of a dog in heat. I dont like her singing at all. She doesnt dance. So whats left? Last night that prolonged ssssssssss at the end of the song was ridiculous. She looked like a cheap/trampish lounge/dive singer. She should gobhome fast.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:32 pm | Report abuse |
    • mls

      Hey, if Haley is crosseyed, which i didn't notice, maybe because I am crosseyed, she ws born with that give her a break. And as for the ssssssssssssssssssssss at the end of the song, that's the way elton did it. I did not care for the buh buh business. Its b b b benney. I still think she's got it though.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:55 pm | Report abuse |
    • ab

      Well she has great control over a really interesting voice and she's cute as hell so there are two things.

      April 1, 2011 at 1:11 am | Report abuse |
  57. Kareen

    Idol is in bad need of Simon Cowell.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:29 pm | Report abuse |
  58. Alienate

    Ummm, 2 points.
    1. Who the fark wrote this article? I see no Byline in this report, therefore, 2. I don't know who to ignore in future articles about season 10 if they didn't "get" Haley's Super Performance.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:24 pm | Report abuse |
  59. Dolores Van Ryn

    Thia has a pleasant sing voice, but it quality is too weak. In my opinion she is the weakest link and should go home first tonight. For me who to send home after elimination of Thia is difficult. Being forced to make a decision the second elimination would be Scotty. Scotty has a nice county voice, but every song he sings sounds the same without any originality.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:22 pm | Report abuse |
  60. Karentoo

    It's interesting there are so many comments about the youth of several of the contestants – and I tend to agree. But for this reason alone I do not understand why AI lowered the age limit – it makes no sense! Lower the age limit, get younger contestants, then complain because they do not have the life experience to "feel" the lyrics. Stupid. My take on the top 11: Paul won't win but is good looking, quirky, and different. Thia and Stefano sing relatively well but I find their performances but pretty shallow. Pia – beautiful but not very deep. Jacob way over the top – if he could rein it in he'd be awesome! Casey – he's okay, I kinda don't get his popularity. James – I agree that he needs to mellow out some – but I tend to like him quite a bit. Naima – not worth the initial save. Lauren sings well but she is just goofy when not singing. Hailey – I don't like her growling – she's trying just too hard. Scotty – he's okay. IMO:)

    March 31, 2011 at 2:21 pm | Report abuse |
  61. SM

    I'm SOOOOO bored this season!! Yes, everyone can sing.. that's a given. They wouldn't be on the show if they couldn't. But I honestly feel like I'm watching really amazing karaoke every night. According to these judges, every performance is beautiful, great, amazing, brilliant, fantastic, etc.. Where's the criticism??? I MISS SIMON!!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 2:18 pm | Report abuse |
  62. TheWorddMaserter

    Naime and stephano gotta go. Now.

    Final two? James...and Casey
    We'll lose Pia next week, then Hailey, Jacob, Lauren, etc. Paul will make it to the Top 5. The rest is a mystery.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:06 pm | Report abuse |
  63. CherylS

    Everyone did a great job last night except Naima and Paul. They will be the 2 to go tonight. They were both horrible.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:05 pm | Report abuse |
  64. AC

    Arlee are you serious, I tell you what I like everyone else but her, she cannot dance, she cannot sing, she is a drama queen just like Jacob and she has horse teeth that I am tired of seeing, and about your ignorant remark, grow up this is for you to post your opinion contradict someone else's RETARD.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:52 pm | Report abuse |
  65. LA

    Top 3 would have to be Scotty, Pia, and Lauren. They all have incredible voices and I could easily see them in the industry in each of their music genres after the show. All of the artists are great, but the whole purpose is to have a star come out of the show, someone who can put out an album and stay in the spotlight for years to come like Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson. I think those top three have the best chance at that. Scotty will be a big time country singer either way. His voice is amazing and he has all the poise of a true performing artist (and at such a young age!). It all comes so natural to him. His performances remind me exactly of other fameous male country singers from the dozens of country concerts I have been too.

    I think Pia is by far the best vocals for all of the girls but she needs to start singing some more current upbeat songs to show America she can be a current singer/star after the show.

    I think Lauren's voice is sooo great for country! love her!

    Thia has an amazing voice but she never sings anything that is fun or current either. For being so young you would think she would sing some more recent tunes! She has the potential to be in the top 5 for sure.

    I haven't been too impressed with Haley in the past performances, although I think she has an extremely unique voice. I loved her performance last night. I thought the vocals were unique and she had a lot of courage to perform that song!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:49 pm | Report abuse |
  66. dilberto

    The two that need to go are Casey and Casey. There has never been a worse performer on this show...does he actually think that constant snarl is cute? It's all a done deal anyhow...the kid with the deep voice and big head will win. Maybe he'll be as memorable as Kris What's-his-name.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:48 pm | Report abuse |
  67. ac

    AMERICA KICK NAIMA OUT PLEASE SHE IS HORRIBLE HOW DID SHE MAKE IT THIS FAR ARE YOU PEOPLE DEAF AND BLIND KICK HER OUT PLEASE!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:47 pm | Report abuse |
  68. Tracey

    The smirky country kid and Jacob the Gospel singer need to LEAVE ~ they're so predictable and boring, just a one trick pony the pair of them. Naima is a train wreck happening in front of my eyes every week, she can leave tonight. Thia can go too, she's so deathly DULL all the time. Paul is quirky and weird but at least I look a tiny bit forward to what he's going to do. Stefano butchered one of my favourite songs with that camera mugging and general performance. Basically, leave me Lauren, Casey, James and get this show over in a week LOL

    March 31, 2011 at 1:47 pm | Report abuse |
  69. Carol

    I agree, I could not understand the raves about Haley. Hope she goes. As for the second choice, I wouldn't mind if it were either Stefano or Naima, although I don't think Casey lived up to the expectations after last week, haircut and shave aside! But he is unique, and that alone should keep him around.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:46 pm | Report abuse |
  70. erin

    Eric, Kelly Clarkson is far from the only person from AI to make any good cd's!! Chris Daughtry, Carrie Underwood, Jennifer Hudson, Kellie Pickler, and Adam Lambert have all been very successful.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:42 pm | Report abuse |
  71. Jim

    This season has bored me a bit. I mean, so many have such unique voices. None of them have had a wow moment yet, though. Pia can certainly sing; no doubt. But, I dunno, she has no emotion behind it. I hear girls sing like that every week at karaoke bars I frequent. She needs to connect to a sing, and make it happen. Last night Casey was the most connected to me. He stayed somewhat true to the nature of his song, but also added his own touch. Stefano has an amazingly brilliant voice, but again, he needs to connect. He may be better for broadway. Hayley has the most interesting voice for the girls. She is the only one that I'm curious to see what she does. It was still lacking slightly, but I would agree with the judges that it was the best female performance of the night. Thia...oh, Thia. I want her to do well, but I cringe whenever she comes on. She just has no idea what to do to make a song her own. She is too young. Lauren Alaina...loved her at the beginning. She was filled with confidence and swagger. Now, she looks so scared. I want her to come out and own it because I think she can. Paul...such a unique voice. I would love for him to pick the right song because he could make hits for the radio because of the uniqueness of the voice. However, it won't come from most songs; it is going to be something different. He hasn't done that yet and I am not so sure he knows how or what that is. I dunno...I struggle with this season. They are all good, but none have been spectacular. . Naima may be the most creative but she lacks the most vocally. Sad but true, because she is the one that if she had the voice, she would know how to use it. James, James, James. Kid can sing, and is a natural. But is soooo cliche. His tone and pitch are PERFECT. I can't imagine him singing a bad note. He wants it. He knows how to work it. But he works it like somebody from the 80's...like his idols. Unfortunately, it's 2011 and he is going to need to do something that defines himself beyond that amazing ability to hit those notes.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:41 pm | Report abuse |
  72. Pam21

    Naima should have gone home two weeks ago, She CAN'T sing. She dances so that audience can focus on her dancing. This is not a dance show. Lusk is boring. Pai the best ! Durbn Rocks.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:40 pm | Report abuse |
  73. Idolfan

    My 1st vote to go home would be Paul. Stefano, Naima or Thia to follow. Paul should stick with Rob Stewart only. Although I do like Naima's voice she is over-doing her performances. Stefano has a nice voice but not strong enough to win. And little Thia, beautiful voice but has lots of work to do. I feel no connection to her and her singing! Love Casey! Can't believe America could have voted him off! Love Lauren, James, Jacob and Pia. I do like the smokey sound of Haley's voice- don't think she can win though. Oh Lordy, don't forget Scotty that sweet little country bumpkin! This year has had so much talent. Tough year.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:40 pm | Report abuse |
  74. chasity

    I think naime and that blonde should leave and i also think that the guy they used their only save of the season on should win

    March 31, 2011 at 1:37 pm | Report abuse |
  75. Dawn

    Haley must go..... Pia is boring!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:32 pm | Report abuse |
  76. danni gunderson

    naima, pia, james, casey, jacob, and paul have my vote! lauren and stefano are elimanated, they should start da packing!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:31 pm | Report abuse |
  77. dannie gunderson

    who the hell are u guys to say naima should go! naima, pia, and james are the only ones who are creative and they are the ones that do good, i think stefano should go, he shouldn't made the top 24! and paul, casey, and thia did amazing, i think haley did good but i think that its time for lauren to go home cuz they already got scotty as a contry singer so they don't need a nother one! i think either pia, james, naima, jacod, or scotty will win!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:27 pm | Report abuse |
    • Holly

      Uh they would be people with their own OPINIONS! Why are you so offended by someone elses opinion?

      March 31, 2011 at 4:03 pm | Report abuse |
  78. California Mama

    Paul needs to pack it in. He just bugs us. He sounds like a couple of other artists out there. Stefano needs to hit the road too. We will see what happens tonight. BUT, if you don't vote, there is nothing you can say......Peace.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:27 pm | Report abuse |
  79. Sarge

    My predictions...next in order of going home: Naima, Stephon, Haley, Thia, Paul, Pia, James, Scotty, Jason, Lauren, Casey

    March 31, 2011 at 1:26 pm | Report abuse |
  80. WisdomVSknowledge

    I'm a nice guy so I'll say they all did fairly well. They sounded good on my theatre sound system and looked really good on my large screen HDTV. Each picked a song that best fit their style, etc. Casey cleaned up his appearance some but the beard is still there... not a smart move. It would have been a better move if he had trimmed it down to a goatee. That would have given him a truly fresh new look and be more age appropriate (at least more acceptable). His performace was better this time but I'm getting tired of his jazziness. I'm beginning to visualize Jimmy Durante when he sings!

    I think it will come down to over-all performances over the past few weeks, in which case... I would say, "Paul and Thia, start packing!" Naima and Casey... don't get too comfortable. The weeks ahead will make it or break it for you two.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:23 pm | Report abuse |
  81. LusciousDC

    Naima should stay. At least she has showmanship. Pia on the other hand ONLY sings BALLADS and stands like a stick figure. Then promises "next week I'll show you I can be diverse". She's gotta go! NOT understanding why Paul is still there. His voice is unnerving. Maybe he needs his own songs that fit his voice. Sounds like Rod Stewart covering other rocker's songs (disaster). I don't like Lauren either. Has anyone else noticed that when Ryan asks her questions she anwers questions that hadn't been asked? She seems a little off to me.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:21 pm | Report abuse |
  82. Jerry C

    Great show! Been reading some of the comments here. Stop with the unrealistic expections! Half of the contestants are in the 16 year-old range and have made it where they are because–since kids–they had great voices and could sing songs that made adults happy. So...don't criticise that they aren't emotionally connecting to one artist's pop music that's been around for 30+ years.

    Paul is unique but lacks the range to pull an audience in to a concert-length performance. James is fresh and fun, Casey the most talented musician, Jacob the best singer. Pia is a beauty contest of talent and for what America wants will likely be the most popular.

    After last week I have no idea who goes home.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:20 pm | Report abuse |
  83. Karen

    I think it's time for Paul and Naima to head home. Paul sings half the words and slurs the rest and I'm not sure I've heard anything in tune yet. Naima is OK but the least talented of the rest left.
    Pia has a nice voice, but zero personality. She's a pageant contestant; she has no connection to the audience or what she is singing. Stefano is trying... maybe if he opened his eyes more and didn't try to over-sing he'd be OK. Thia has a nice voice; but she just has not connection to anything at all... she bores me.
    Haley did a nice job last night. I'd love to see her just sing a song and not crouch or throw her arms around... she's a blues singer and would do better in a small club atmosphere. Casey did better last night. He is so musically talented, he just needs to figure out how to perform and not come off so odd.
    Jacob is a gospel singer. He is way way over the top when he performs; but I think he'll find success in the gospel world... but not as the American Idol. James has a nice voice... but last night it was more about the "performance" than the actual singing. Stop playing the part of the rocker and start just singing with added performing and maybe being yourself.... he comes off as fake to me.
    Lauren – too bad that she believed her hype in the beginning and her head got so big that she became annoying... I wanted to like her. She has a nice voice.... maybe she can redeem herself; but I'm not holding my breath waiting for that to happen. The judges sure were trying to build her back up last night.... with every word I could see her head inflating bigger and bigger.... oh and the Kellie Pickler act is getting old too.
    Scotty knows who is and the country world is going to embrace him big time. I'm not sure he even has to win this thing.
    I'm not a fan of his very traditional country style... I like the more pop/country.... Carrie Underwood, Rascal Flatts and the like. If you believe Dial Idol he's running away with this thing... but who really knows.
    Bottom line at this point I can't see myself buying anything that any of this group would be selling. I also don't see any of them being able to put on a 90 min + show by themselves.... none of them have the personality or the chops for that yet.... but it's early. None of them excite me enough to cast a vote.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:17 pm | Report abuse |
  84. cabbagepatch

    No one else is saying it, so I'm just going to come out with it: Jacob. It's SO Jacob's time to go. I loved when Jimmy told Jacob, "Whatever you do, don't be overly dramatic," and then Jacob comes out on a dim stage, in a tight spotlight, and sings BIG on another BIG song, looking like he's going to cry (again) every second! What part of "Don't be overly dramatic" didn't he understand? For the life of me, I don't understand why the judges trip over themselves every week to praise him.
    Enough Naima already too. And I've lost patience with waiting to see if Stefano, Thia, and Haley can bring anything else to the table.
    Even though everyone is dumping on Paul, his unique voice and mannerisms are still keeping me interested. Now him I'd like to see do something a little different before I dismiss him.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:12 pm | Report abuse |
  85. Donna

    I agree with Jason. I TVO the show and within about 10-15 minutes I am done passing though each performance. Everyone is good but the performances are boring. Where is the variety. Although not everyone liked him, Adam always gave us something different. This is the same thing week after week. I think this was my last week in watching.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:03 pm | Report abuse |
  86. Gal from Montana

    So glad Idol Xpert gets his kicks from putting people down, including the contestants. By the way, I watch AI on a 42" LED TV and live next to the Country Club. And really what difference does it make what type of TV I watch the show on or where I live. I still love country music and Scott is one of my favorites. You sound and write like you have anger issues!

    March 31, 2011 at 1:03 pm | Report abuse |
  87. FrankP

    The judges tell Pia to work the stage, but when Jacob hits the floor it look as if his shoes are stuck to the stage. The judges say nothing.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:02 pm | Report abuse |
  88. seriously?

    Did anyone else notice Naima's teeth last night? Did she get them fixed or just whitened?

    March 31, 2011 at 12:48 pm | Report abuse |
  89. kevin

    Wasn't Naima the blue lady in the 5th element? The 2 that should go are Naima and Paul. Last week I would have dumped Stefano but this week he redeemed himself.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:40 pm | Report abuse |
  90. jbog

    I feel there's no passion with Thia, Niama has hit and miss days...she's ok, but she's trying to hard. It's as if she needs to be noticed with her zangy ways and all she has to do is find a good song and sing. Pia, I'm sorry she sings through her nose...she's all nasal. Last week she wasn't so what happened this week? Scotty, he's just country all the way...boring boring boring!!! Do something else...show versatility. Paul kind sounds like Katharine Hepburn...nice smile, but can't get passed the voice. Just do Rod Stewart and Kim Carnes covers and he's be all set. Haley, why is she always hunched over when she sings? She's ok...she's be good doing Janis Joplin tunes.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:37 pm | Report abuse |
  91. Sandy

    I think Pia will win it all in the end. Naima and Jacob need to go...sorry. Jacob sings well, IN A CHOIR but he will not sell records.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:36 pm | Report abuse |
  92. Fred

    I don't get why Haley is getting such raves. I thought she picked a boring song and did it terribly. Ugh!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:35 pm | Report abuse |
  93. Linda

    I'm hoping the two that gets booted off are Thia and Haley. Sorry, but if I have to see another one of Thia's boring performances I'm gonna scream, and Haley's voice is just all over the place. But knowing "Idol", there'll probably be a few surprises. X-ing my fingers!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:35 pm | Report abuse |
  94. Jeremiah

    Correct. There is no front runner. Just different styles for various tastes in music. So don't be hateful and bash someone because you don't like their style. They all have sometthing to offer. I really don't think the theme nights do most of them any good. Scotty should stick with country...each one stick with your genre and seek variety within those borders. It's almost more about presentation than it is about style. Remember most people watching are not musical nor are performers, so why do we think our opinions are valid? Because we buy music and go to concerts.
    From that point of view the most entertaing are: Scotty, Casey, James. Pia and Thia are not exciting. Neither are Paul, Stefano, or Jacob. Haley was pretty exciting last night and Lauren could be more so. That leaves Naima who is doing a lot better, but will not have a wide enough appeal to win. Now you see, I've said it without being hateful.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:34 pm | Report abuse |
  95. Cynlee

    Getting tired of Pia

    March 31, 2011 at 12:31 pm | Report abuse |
  96. ac

    Naima makes me want to puke she is HORRIBLE, she sucks and Jacob he is so dramatic, as long as Naima gets kicked out today I'll be a very happy human being, LOl

    March 31, 2011 at 12:30 pm | Report abuse |
    • Arlee

      Niama makes you want to puke? Well who did you like, so we could see what kind of taste you have. If you have a bad taste in your mouth about her pehaps an example of what exquisite taste you have for a bench mark next time.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:49 pm | Report abuse |
  97. Martie

    I think Naima and Paul should go home tonight. Neither one is very good. They bore me to death. Love Pia, Jacob, and Scotty. It will be hard this year to pick just one. First time this has happend since I have been watching Idol.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:28 pm | Report abuse |
  98. larissa

    I'm still trying to recover from America putting Casey in the bottom two instead of most of the others who are a cure for insomnia! So let ANY two go home except for him and I'll keep watching. Otherwise, I'll just have to catch up on my reading instead.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:27 pm | Report abuse |
  99. Idol X-pert

    Gal from Montana: Are you sure the rabbit ears on your 19" tv is getting the same show the rest of us are? Are you freakin kidding me??!
    "This season has blown me away..." What do you do for kicks up there in Montannie anyway? Go watch your neighbor milk a cow? Go to a rock quarry and look for pretty rocks? If you "love that country music" than you should HATE Scotty because he's a country wannabe not the real deal. Great call on the final 3 too. All wrong on all 3. And the reason I "bother" to watch the show is to laugh and bich and make people like you see through the facade. You're welcome.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:24 pm | Report abuse |
  100. Jenn

    I can't believe so many of you are harping on Paul. Hes extremely unique and he brings something different to the show as does Casey and Hayley. I don't think there is a single one of them that doesnt deserve to be there! They are all talented. Peoples choice this season is going to be left up to the sound you like. Casey, Paul, and Hayley have the folk appeal- and a definite stand apart sound to their voices. Pia, Jacob, Theia and Stephano have the pop star sounding voices or R&B, Lauren and Scotty are the country crooners, Naima is the funky singer and James is the rocker! Everybody brings something to the table and everybody sings amazingly, but people are going to vote based on the type of sound they like. Me personally its Paul, Casey and Hayley. But thats not degrading any of their talent.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:22 pm | Report abuse |
  101. Sue

    Ask yourself who you would pay to see in concert? Pia has a great voice, but how many similar sounding ballads in a row could you take? And how much quirkiness and white teeth flashing could you stand from Paul? Stefano and Thia would put me to sleep. James & Casey would keep it interesting. I'd need ear plugs with Jacob and horse manure on my boots with Scotty. Haley –now she is always full of surprises -she fearlessly tackles songs from Alicia Keys to Elton John and doesn't just imimatate them, but puts her own stamp on them. She is one of the Idols worth paying money to see.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:21 pm | Report abuse |
  102. Tracy

    I love it how the country kid can be country each week but somehow jacob being gospel each week is a bad thing. This show is so skewed towards the white contestants. Naimah is going home , but hopefully the Casey joins her. I'm also tired of all the Pia love , the girl is an avg singer – Haley is better and the young country girl is 2x better.Nothing wrong with being a Diva but have a real voice.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:21 pm | Report abuse |
    • ?

      Don't make this a race thing. People are citing their opinions, not making this about race. I am white as white can be and I like Jacob and think Scotty should go. Does that make me anti-white? Get a clue

      March 31, 2011 at 12:24 pm | Report abuse |
  103. dougo

    Lisa you are a MORON Haley is GREAT !!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:18 pm | Report abuse |
    • someone

      She rocks!
      A touch awkward at times, but that's kind of a plus in a way.
      Hot too!

      April 1, 2011 at 1:02 am | Report abuse |
  104. CAK

    I predict that Paul, Naima and maybe Stefano will be bottom 3 tonight. We shall see! I though Casey was great and I can't believe I am going to say it, Haley was great too. I really do not care for Elton John's songs, but I was pleasantly surprised last night. This show is just so much fun!!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:18 pm | Report abuse |
  105. Im_Abbie

    I'm sorry, but I just can't stand to watch Jacob. He's a good church singer, but not the American Idol and there's something about him that I just can't watch. I do love Naima, but she isn't going to make it either. Bottom 3 tonight should be Naima, Jacob and Paul. Pia needs to step it up next week though or I think she's going to lose fans. Maybe she needs to be in the bottom 3 for a wakeup call!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:14 pm | Report abuse |
  106. Gal from Montana

    Don't agree one bit with Idol X-Pert and believe me I'm over 15 – 21 – 30. This season has blown me away. The talent is great and each with their own individual style. Naima's time is up. Thia's performance last night was incredible, so much from the heart. I keep wondering if Casey will really be going home tonight. Of course, Scotty is one of my favorites. Love that country music! I think the final three will be Pia, Scotty and Jacob. After reading some of the comments, I really wonder why these people bother to watch a show you don't like!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:14 pm | Report abuse |
  107. barb

    Naima, really! What is that? And Jacob made my skin crawl! Awful. They should both go.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:06 pm | Report abuse |
  108. mannysmom11

    You know what great about this season though, there are those that I hate and those that I love and some I have even learned to love or learned to hate! Its great! Every week my opinion changes and that's never happened with this show for me before... it gives me that "what happens next" feel!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:05 pm | Report abuse |
  109. nikkai

    I really think Naima should go home tonight.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:59 am | Report abuse |
  110. Tracy

    I thought the last contestant who sang, Bennie and the Jets, Haley? Anyway, I felt that she was really good and Lauren did an excellent job. I think Stefano could be really good if he could settle his nerves a little. The judges made a good decision saving Casey. It would have been a shame to see him go and the no-talent Naima get through. She absolutely slaughtered that song, and not in a good way either.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:54 am | Report abuse |
  111. Joanne

    I don't get why anyone likes Casey. To me, he is an average singer and reminds me of a singing clown who needs medication. This was never more evident than after his save. He is scary. Pia is boring, but so was Carrie Underwood at first. I think that Pia will be in the top 3 left standing. Although I am not a country music fan, I think that Scotty has a great voice and is consistent. I also like Lauren a lot. I would like to see Paul and Thia go tonight.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:54 am | Report abuse |
    • Idol

      I am not sure exactly what you are listening too, but Casey is great, has natural talent and you can tell he is just bursting at the seams with talent. He is truly original and a little bit of a throw-back to more soulful times. I for one can't wait to see what he does week after week. I hope he plays the base again. Casey, Pia, Haley are all powerhouses!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:22 pm | Report abuse |
  112. Idol X-Pert

    Well I guess everyone agrees with my truthful wisdom!

    March 31, 2011 at 11:52 am | Report abuse |
  113. DDSilks

    Jacob should go home. He just wails too much. Naima and Thia next.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:49 am | Report abuse |
  114. Robert P.

    I can't believe James is still in this.I have to turn the volume off every time he sings.Vote him off america.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:47 am | Report abuse |
  115. ChristyinFL

    Stefano, Paul and Thia should be the bottom three. With Stefano going home.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:44 am | Report abuse |
  116. Idol X-Pert

    Love it? LOVE IT?? I absolutely abhor and loathe it. This year's contestants are the absolute, indefensibly worst in the history of the show. Paul is a complete stooge who tries (without success) to fall back on this only strong "suit" – his white flowered suit! And Steven Taylor (as Stevie Wonder called him last week) called him out on it last night! And what planet is Naima on? Trying to sound Jamacian in her stupid, self-indulgent reggae version of what ever the heck she sang was just plain, well self-indulgent. (Sorry CLAUDIE, but you are an idiot). And the country boy; yeah, awesome dude. The Oak Ridge Boys called from the assisted living home – they want the baritone vocals back. The cute little Javone; too much lipstick dude – no substance (like season 8's winner, the likable but FORGETFUL Kris Allen). Pia, Barbara Strisand; Connie Francis; Crystal Gayle – what's the difference except they all apeal to OLD PEOPLE! And that big eared, pointed head stooge of a "rocker"... What??!! He wouln't cut it as a sidekick in the insipid move "The Rocker" with the Office's Rain Wilson. I mean did Steven Tyler REALLY say what he was feeling? He had to be laughing on the inside. Aerosmith has shared the stage with great rock and roll singers for over 35 years and that stooge had the gall to prance around Tyler like HE can rock? That kid is a joke! The 2 blondes are just OK. Thia MaGhia is gonna be gone-ia. Jacob: awful tonality to his voice. Very very very very typical curch singer that can be found in any church in America on any given Sunday. And Grizzly Adams (Casey) – dog, dude, dog... you peaked 4 weeks ago and you are not even that good. Randy likes you ONLY because you both play the bass. Now that's what an American Idol makes! Did I leave anybody out? Probably because every contestant is FORGETABLE! I dare anyone with any sense of musicality to intelligently challenge my truthful convictions (unless of course you are a 15 year old thus spare me).

    March 31, 2011 at 11:44 am | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      I must agree with you on most of your critique's – However on at least 3 you were; well as Simon would say "Self Indulgent"! First – Scotty – Awesome singer and if your only fault is his tone is like that of the Oak Ridge Boys; Well thats quite a compliment, that you attempt to pass as an insult! Especially considering they are still one of the best known Country acts around. Second – James; is one of the best on the show! And yeah, Steven did say it – dude is awesome, and he should know! James has always shown respect to Steven and everyone knows imitation is the best form of flattery – although I don't really see James as imitating Steven at all! James is very distinct in his range and controlled at all levels. Third – Javone – Really? Dude, as a so-called X-pert, I guess you missed the part where he never made it past the first round!!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:07 pm | Report abuse |
  117. Shanna

    Stefano and Naima will go home.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:39 am | Report abuse |
  118. gamugamu

    The show needs a (winner who can be a) credible recording artist that can sell like Kelly and Carrie. The only ones who can come close to doing that are: Pia, Lauren, Scotty. May be James and Stefano. Other than those five, I don't see any of the others making it to mainstream.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:36 am | Report abuse |
  119. ned smith

    Lauren and Haley are "average" singers! Why do the judges NOT see this!! Scotty has turned "Motown and Elton" into Country. Everyone is picking on Naima, but she delivers a "fresh-creative" performance each week, unlike Scotty. IDOL is a SINGING contest, and Jacob and Pia are the best SINGERS!! Honestly, can you think of a better singer than them?? Correct? OK, no more saves, Lauren and Haley need to go tonite. Then, Stefano, Paul and Thia. Thia has a great voice, [much better than Haley or Lauren] but, she is young and predictable.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:20 am | Report abuse |
  120. CLAUDIE

    Wow Wow Wow!!!!!! most of u guys amaze me, i can't believe that our horizons are SOOooo narrow, we are not diverse enough to appreciate other Genre of Music, whats wrong with Reggae, and what's wrong with Rastafarism. Naima is not imposing anything on anyone, she is just a courageous young lady , adding a different flavor to the show. I applaud her for taking chances, and she may not have the best voice, but she ROCKS!!!!!!!! PLEASE QUIT BEING SO NARROW MINDED. The talent is exceptional this year, very unique vocals and all. Its hard to say who is leaving but i can say who better not leave or who most likely wont leave: Jacob, Jason, Pia, Naima, Stefano and Casey. Those six rock the most.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:19 am | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      I guess by Jason, you mean James. But YES – your almost spot on! I don't see Niaima making it though. Actually Scottie will make it further than she does IMO. James, Pia, Jacob, and sadly, Casey will be here the longest.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:18 pm | Report abuse |
  121. nat

    Bottom three: Naima, Thia, and Jacob.....who will go home: Thia

    March 31, 2011 at 11:18 am | Report abuse |
  122. beth

    Doesn't anyone hear how sharp Jacob is sometimes? I played it back for my husband and he heard it also. Paul and Naima should probably go this week. At least Naima is now singing much better, but who knows after last week? Casey will probably survive because his fans will get out and vote – I agree that the talent is very good this season. Although I did not go to a summer show last year, this year I will try to go again. I used to write as a "music expert" (I had a four year scholarship to Julliard) for a reality website – this year there really is no clear front runner. LOL!

    March 31, 2011 at 11:17 am | Report abuse |
  123. Critique

    I think Pia and Casey should go. Pia is extremely boring as she hardly moves and Casey really didn't do a well enough
    job last night.
    Who did a great job and should go further: Stefano and Haley!

    March 31, 2011 at 11:16 am | Report abuse |
  124. Garryb

    Time to go Paul & his mom's Pant suit & my gawd,..eat something,.. Naima,,.you did your African thingy last week,..& it was par Raggae Elton,..barf & Stefano,.. Ba bye! You look like Joey from Friends trying to hit the high note . & Scotty,..Elton John's not Country & c'mon..staying true but it's not American Idol gone Country, I love my Grandma Too Awwwwee? Haley you'd make a fairs Klondike Kate, James,..Sing a balad instead of screaming so your foreheads not twitching,..Kudo's to Jacob, Pia ( a bit Boring & the same ole same ole), Lauren's ,..better than she thinks, Casey,..Is this guy another Billy Joel,..Love this guy,..Jacob,..Be careful,..your becoming too gospel,..the rest not worth talking about...
    Judges,..Randy,..Keep true, Steve,..You can be negative ,..they need it,..& Jennifer,..I could look at you talk BS allday :)))) Over & out!

    March 31, 2011 at 11:15 am | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      Your right! It's not American Idol gone country! Or R&B or Pop, or Reggae! It's whatever the heck they want to sing! and in Scotty's case he does it awesome! He's country, no need to change just to suit you or anyone else! Thats one reason, he's so good – he knows who he is, and sticks to it!

      March 31, 2011 at 3:05 pm | Report abuse |
  125. M&M

    I think Pia should go. She thinks she sings better than she can and I don't see her as a pop star. I can tell the judges are like "neeext" Randy told her, yea you can sing we know that but I think she is just singing each song exactly the same even with the same poses. This also goes for Pia, it is the same exact thing week after week. Paul was a little dull last night but there are some people that over exagerate like Jacob and Casey soooo hmmm. As far as James goes, he has a very good whistle in his voice.

    March 31, 2011 at 11:14 am | Report abuse |
  126. Ken

    I think Haley and Casey did very well. Tough songs to sing, but they did well. I think Naimi and Paul should go. I agree with Randy, the Reggae twist on it was just corny! Thia did well also, but I have a feeling that if she does not pick a fast, upbeat song next week, she will be in real trouble. Agree with others that the judges seem very passive this year and a bit out of touch with what we are seeing at home. I bet they think differently when they watch it back after the show. Still say it is Jacob's to lose, but man, wish we had another David Cook to root for!!

    March 31, 2011 at 11:01 am | Report abuse |
  127. MKae

    Seriously.....Haley best performance of the night?????NOT!!! are the judges tone deaf???!!! horrible!! I think Naima, Haley, and Stefano need to go! James, and Pia are the top runners!!

    March 31, 2011 at 10:58 am | Report abuse |
  128. Bookenz

    I've never understand the fascination with Paul – he can't sing at all, he just gets by on cute. He should go, but it will probably be Thia and Stefano.

    March 31, 2011 at 10:51 am | Report abuse |
  129. daveee

    Paul reeks. After that they're all good, some are fantastic, and most a likeable kids. Jacob is talented but I cannot stand watching or hearing his mush mouth. Pia is, well, WOW.

    I love the show this year. All the contestants have some nice skills, most of the gals are more than easy to look at incl J-Low (I do mean "Low") and the judges are actually interesting.

    March 31, 2011 at 10:44 am | Report abuse |
  130. 68susan

    ELTON JOHN: knew it was going to be amazing hard to follow i liked that pick for an artist. I am actually lovin this year i think its going to a very exciting season.. Why 2 this week and does anyone know if they used the save. I t would make it exciting if they used it this week. i just wished that Elton John would have been a celebrity judge !!!!

    March 31, 2011 at 10:43 am | Report abuse |
  131. Deliverance

    It was a weird night. Some Elton songs suit certain voices better than others and while Haley didi do a good job, she was not the best of the night. Pia once again blew them away (ballad or not) and Jacob did great again with a sad song.
    It's time for Adapo, Stefano, Scotty and Paul to go home and then Thia and Casey.
    It is now clear who should be the top 5. In order of best to worse...Pia #1 Jacob #2 Lauren #3 Haley #4 and Jason #5.
    The rocker is getting old (Adam Lambert has already didi it best) Haley has a unique vocal and song selection is her key. Lauren has country recording artist potential (similar to Kellie Pickler) Jacob will be recording for some label soon (perhaps Luther Vandross label?) and Pia will be fought over by several record labels (get her primed to take over as Celine Deion faces retirement). BUT the american voters are very fickle and don't always see talent ...but winning won't matter to Pia and Jacob -just sign on the dotted line.

    March 31, 2011 at 10:31 am | Report abuse |
  132. gigi

    Thia and Pia both have beautiful voices but are BORING. Naima should get the boot. In general, all the guys are better than the gals this year. Tired of Jacob's over-the-top emotion. Stefano can be good but is inconsistent.

    March 31, 2011 at 9:57 am | Report abuse |
  133. Ryann

    I don't understand how you could not love Haley's performance. I am a HUGE Elton John fan & found it hard to listen to alot of these covers but I think Haley nailed her version- as did Casey & Pia. I did not think that Thia did very well, and I found Naima to be incredibly annoying. I love reggae but her campy version did not do it for me. James was entertaining but I didn't love it. I feel like Stefano is really trying but Tiny Dancer was just a bit too much for him to tackle- I didn't really like it. I love Jacob and his voice but he does always look like he's about to break down crying, I'd like to see him be passionate but not overly dramatic just once. I loved Lauren in the beginning but I think her immaturity and age is really starting to come out. Her voice is amazing, but she's too pageant-y and her comments leave something to be desired. I don't believe her when she sings. I appreciate Scotty's desire to stick to what he loves but I would personally like to see something just a little different. I'm kind of bored with him now. Paul is adorable, I liked his version of Rocket Man, but he never seems to blow me away. I don't see him lasting much longer.

    Personally, I think Naima and either Stefano/ Thia deserve to go hom this week.

    March 31, 2011 at 9:52 am | Report abuse |
  134. carl

    CHARLIE SHEEN IS BACK. no one coul d compare or take his place. he is one of a kind super talented guy,
    charm , you da man.

    March 31, 2011 at 9:49 am | Report abuse | Reply

    March 31, 2011 at 9:51 am | Report abuse |
  135. Malori

    BYE BYE naima and thia.

    March 31, 2011 at 9:07 am | Report abuse |
  136. Zman

    I Think Scotty (aka Mad Cartoon Man) Should be booted off along with Paul (enoough with that outfit, man up dude). Pia & Haley Rock!

    March 31, 2011 at 8:38 am | Report abuse |
    • dannie gunderson

      zman, your stupid and wrong, theres a reason they saved casey, GREAT ROCK VOICE!, DUH. SCOTTY IS IN THE RANKS OF CARRIE UNDERWOOD COUNTRY, if anybody should go its lauren and stefano! IDIOT!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:42 pm | Report abuse |
  137. Weihana

    Why this reviewer dislike Haley? She had couple average performances but Bennie and the Jets was fantastic! Singing so damn good ya didn't even notice her arms flailing all over the place. Anyways she's hot. :-) Definitely performance of the night. Other good ones was James definitely... and Scotty pretty good. Pia good of course but switch it up!

    Naima... not much into her singing... got cool vibe.. but that reggae arrangement had potential I quite liked it. Would buy that. Bottom three, Thia, Stefano and Lauren.

    March 31, 2011 at 8:28 am | Report abuse |
  138. tinb

    What is with the judges? I miss Simon. I am so sick of the gushing "ooh you're so good because you're here". Tyler get some balls man. No one wants to hurt anyone's feelings. Have some guts! Simon used to ramp up his critique...as you get closer to the top, of COURSE they're all good. But you're supposed to compare the performances, not keep telling everyone how wonderful they are. J-Lo is so obsessed about being loved by everyone, she's making this BORING. And the two guys are being just as wimpy going along.

    March 31, 2011 at 8:21 am | Report abuse |
    • Weihana

      I agree they could be bit harsher on some of them. But Steven isn't there to be critical he's there to make strange comments where we spend the next minute trying to work out what he's saying.

      Also, it is a pretty good selection this year compared to some.

      March 31, 2011 at 8:34 am | Report abuse |
    • Bookenz

      Tyler just looks bored.

      March 31, 2011 at 10:56 am | Report abuse |
  139. G. W. Snark

    They all SUCKED! time to cancel this show. Really need to get some good shows on TV. What a frickin waste of time!

    March 31, 2011 at 5:49 am | Report abuse |
    • M&M

      I agree. Idol! let them sing what they want to so we can feel their performances and personality a whole lot more!

      March 31, 2011 at 11:19 am | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      @ M&M – the singer makes the song – not the other way around! Besides; each singer chooses the song, AI just gives a catagory. It's the singers job to make the song thier own; not mimic the original. How many country songs has a R&B group remade to fit thier style, and vice versa! It's the singers that make it great, and if these Idols can't do it, then they should go home!

      March 31, 2011 at 2:44 pm | Report abuse |
  140. Al

    Best to worst:

    Scotty – all country all the time, but good at it
    Pia – probably best pitch of the group, but getting boring to watch
    Naima – comfortable on stage, better performer than singer
    James – good performer fun to watch, needs to stick to rock
    Thia – nice voice, better singer than performer
    Haley – better than average karaoke singer
    Casey – average karaoke singer
    Lauren – needs to sing country songs instead of adding country to every song
    Paul – voice keeps him from being very diverse
    Jacob – muffled and sort of nasal, stick to church choir
    Stephano – seems disconnected from audience

    March 31, 2011 at 2:47 am | Report abuse |
    • Chamdexor

      I find it interesting that you say Paul's voice is too one-dimensional but you have Scotty as the best. And that is because he is so versatile? Note sarcasm.

      March 31, 2011 at 8:43 am | Report abuse |
    • Arlee

      Al I agee with every observation you have correctly made. But i disagree with the order of a couple, switch Lauren for Haley and move Jacob up somewhere strictly on potential alone. But the observations were correct. Good job!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:07 pm | Report abuse |
    • Edyn

      I liked Paul. I liked Naima's version of that song. I agree with you about Haley. More of a lounge singer. I don't get the growl or why that would be appealing. Imagine it playing on the radio while you're driving. I'd change the station in a heartbeat.

      Mostly agree with your assessment.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:46 pm | Report abuse |
  141. Kathi

    Based on the performances tonight, I think Casey and Haley should go.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:10 am | Report abuse |
    • Weihana

      C'mon.... both of them hand stand out performances, especially Haley's. People just don't like her, don't get it. :-\

      March 31, 2011 at 8:37 am | Report abuse |
  142. Eric

    Interesting year.

    Jennifer: Probably the best judge, though it's a tough call between her and Randy. Usually says something nice, sometimes gives a little something to work on, then something nice. Good technique. Though tonight she was mostly just saying nice stuff.

    Randy: Probably the most honest judge. At first I thought he was trying to channel Simon, but now I think maybe he just feels more free to express opinions than maybe in the past. (Always thought he was a waste of space before.)

    Steven: Nicer guy and with more personality than I'd have thought, but terrible as a judge. Speaking of "channeling," I'm hearing Paula.

    Paul, Naima, Haley: Y'all seem nice, but you're not going to win it and the masses aren't going to buy your albums. Enjoy the ride, but I don't see it lasting much longer.

    Thia: Beautiful voice, but others have beautiful voices too. And I wish you'd have listened to the guy who told you to forget what they taught you about showmanship as a little girl. You don't have to smile when singing a touching song. You're right not to plaster your arms at your sides, but they don't need to float around as if gravity free, either. (Haley, you too.)

    Jacob: What a voice! And what a story. But, man, the guy who said you could slip into being overly dramatic hit it dead on as far as I'm concerned. I always think you're going to break down sobbing. It's ok to stay with a particular type of music, but mix it up within that type. Sing something that rocks a litlte. Sing something that lets you smile. Not so many runs that we lose the great melodies the composers gave us. It's like putting diamonds all over a Porsche. Pretty, but not what the automaker intended.

    Stefano: Sadly, I think you're probably toast this week. That's sad because I think if properly managed you're probably one of the few (if not the only one) who could actually sell albums if you were given original songs. Fantastic voice and the confidence would come after enough performances. But I don't think your'e going to get that far.

    Country girl (Lauren?): If I were coaching you, I'd say stop hiding behind laughs and sass. Soemtimes shy people try to make a joke of everything, and I think you do that. You do it in your song choices, your response to comments from judges, pretty much whenever we see you. Serious up for a song or two. Nice job on "Candle" tonight. Do something else sincere, just to show us it wasn't a fluke. Don't paste that big smile on your face in the middle of a tender song like they taught you in elementary school. I suspect you have the pipes to blow this away if you can come across as sincerely interpreting the lyrics of your songs.

    Rocker Guy: Sorry, I can't remember your name and I'm too lazy to look it up. No ill intention intended. You might be able to sell some records too. If I were a rocker, I'd probably love the heck out of you. I"m not, so feel free to ignore me. That said, just like the judges tell Pia and Thia to do something other than a ballad, you might try just once singing a song with a good melody straight. I don't know you really have to do that to win. Pop stars need to be able to do more than ballads, but rock stars fans are usually pretty happy with nonstop screaming. But it would convince some that you actually have the ability to carry a tune. With the type of music you're doing, it's hard to know if that's true. (I'll take my fiber and go to bed in a minute.)

    Scotty: Great voice and great low notes. Your fans'll carry you through to the last few stages, maybe to the end, so you don't need my comments. But here's what I'd tell you. First, we'll appreciate those low notes - like Jacob's highs - if you don't show them to us every single time you sing. Don't do it once or twice, then when you hit us with those lows we'll sit up straight and listen, instead of yawning. You're a baseball guy; remember that the best fastball pitcher doesn't make every pitch a fastball. Second, listen to the comments Jennifer has made about acting being part of singing. Sing your songs like you know what they mean. When I watch you, it seems like you're thinking "Look at me. Boy, I'm gonna hit you with a low note now and you're gonna say I was great." Not so much conceit as immaturity. Then again, give it a year and you'll be able to buy and sell my sorry self ten times over. (But what about in five?)

    Pia: Jury's still out on you. You have the whole package: breathtaking good looks, beautiful voice, perfect control, great style. I'm sure the boys and half the girls follow you around with slack jaws everywhere you go. But I can't see people buying your records. I agree with Randy; show us something else. You don't have to do country (though you'd probably kill 'em at it) or rap to prove you have variety, just do something with a different beat. I said Lauren needs to serious up in a song or two; I'd love to see you have fun with a song.

    Casey: As an Otis Redding fan, you've been my guy. And I'm glad they saved you last week. But I'd like to hear more of what I heard in the the early stages of the show. The last few weeks you seemed to want to be a rocker, and I don't think that's you. Tonight you sang it too straight, without any of your unique style. Go sign some Ray Charles to get back in the zone where you shine. And lose the beard. By not cutting it tonight, you came across as timid. I don't think that's you.

    Not that any of them will read any of this.

    March 31, 2011 at 2:05 am | Report abuse |
    • Floyd

      @ Eric, His name is James. You say you were too lazy to look up his name? C'mon, look ta the novel you wrote. I think there is some ill intentions there. Not an ounce of credibility now in all that.
      Rock on James!

      March 31, 2011 at 2:17 pm | Report abuse |
  143. Paulie

    It really creeps me out the way James Durbin throws the horns (is he into devil worship or what)? Thia sings well; but looks like a piece of wood. I haven't warm-up to her from the start.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:55 am | Report abuse |
    • monkey

      he creeps me out too ! i will listen but i cant watch him. i want to tape his ears to his head so they dont stick out – it really bugs me...

      March 31, 2011 at 12:38 pm | Report abuse |
  144. David Malli

    I'm a huge Elton John fan, so I had high expectations...

    I am NOT big on Haley... but she was on point tonight, slayed it! Paul's Rocket Man was flatter than Thia's chest. Pia reminds me of the old adage "show me a hot girl, and I'll show you a guy who's tired of F'in her"... she bores me to death. Casey came back strong with a song most butcher.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:54 am | Report abuse |
  145. franz

    Naima was the most original performance of the night ! She took a song and recreated it as a reggae tune ! The words could have been written and performed by Bob Marley! I couldn’t believe that J-lo and Randy didn’t applaud her for the best performance of the night! Go back and read the lyrics of the song and imagine Bob Marley’s voice singing the song. It sounds just like one of his lyrics ! I’m still standing could have been one of his greatest anthems ! Her performance is the only one of the night that I would buy ! Everyone else, with the possible exception of Jacob, just tried to imitate the Elton John versions of the tunes they chose.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:42 am | Report abuse |
    • mrskool

      I like Naima and i dont get all the hate for her – she's an original to be sure and i love that she did Reggae with that song !

      March 31, 2011 at 12:36 pm | Report abuse |
  146. Barefoot

    I think either Jacob or Casey were much more deserving of the judges' call for best performance of the night. I've never liked Haley because to me, I think she's one of the contestants whom the judges and producers are trying to hype up (the other is Lauren). Jacob did very well as usual, and it seemed that Casey took the judges' advice after what happened last week. I HOPE America didn't buy into how they were "spinning" Haley tonight, and put her in the bottom three with Thia and Stefano tomorrow night. I would like to see Haley and Stefano go home, but after the judges' miscall (or whatever that was), it'll probably be Thia and Stefano to go home.

    Oh, and I foresee the judges throwing out a second save sometime around the end of April to early May.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:23 am | Report abuse |
  147. 2pac

    Dis gots ta b da uglyest group of ppl i eva seen n american idol racist. How u got 1 gay black dude outa 11 n erybody kno black ppl sing betta den whities ne day?

    March 31, 2011 at 1:13 am | Report abuse |
  148. Indy

    My wife and I miss Simon.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:11 am | Report abuse |
  149. Lifelister

    Naima and Scotty have talent but not in the broad spectrum. Scotty may still get a country recording contract nod somewhere. He bores me to tears. Thea is pretty and talented, but just not enough star power or unique sound there. Casey, Pia, James and Jacob have what it takes to make it to super stardom, with the proper handling. I actually think Haley did a great job with a tough, iconic song that ONLY Elton John ever sang. I really like her but apparently America isn't giving her much love.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:10 am | Report abuse |
  150. Indy

    Haley still sounds like Cookie Monster – the judges are clearly deaf. Paul is like a homeless guy, always wearing the same clothes and he's gotta smell terrible. Pia is a great singer but she is starting to get really boring.

    Jacob's gonna win the whole thing.

    March 31, 2011 at 1:04 am | Report abuse |
    • omg

      Are you serious? I think the judges are judges for a reason. They KNOW MUSIC and TALENT. your opinions have no credibility. Haley sang great last night.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:12 pm | Report abuse |
  151. lana

    Since the Idols had to move because the Mansion is supposely Haunted, they should sing the "GHOSTBUSTERS SONG, WHO'D YOU GONNA CALL", GHOSTBUSTERS OF COURSE.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:46 am | Report abuse |
  152. Lori

    Yeah, I'm thinking two performers whose time has come might be Naima and Haley. Or Thia. I just didn't feel their performances. At all.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:44 am | Report abuse |
  153. lana

    Idolmance Jacob & Hayley are an item according to Channel 5 News NYC station.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:42 am | Report abuse |
    • WOW!

      Absolutely the HOTTEST lesbian relationship the world is likely to ever see! (Please Note: the level of sarcasm in this comment may be hazardous to your health.)

      March 31, 2011 at 11:10 am | Report abuse |
  154. GH

    Sheesh, are the judges gonna break out into Kumbayah after EVERY performance?? We all know they had to slobber over Casey to save face after last week but please, some of these were brutal. Can ANYone be critical??? Just once??? Im so getting tired of Steven's "aww shucks, you were great" moments. And Im gonna ram knitting neeedles into my ears if Paul stays another week!

    March 31, 2011 at 12:42 am | Report abuse |
    • Sunny

      LOL!

      Simon probably can't even bear to watch the judges sit and bake cupcakes at their table this season.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:05 pm | Report abuse |
  155. Roscoe Chait

    The performers were good tonight, but could have been a lot better if the record producer had not interferred. He gives terrible advice and unfortunately most of the singers listen to him. In particular, I thought Thia, Casey and Haley did a poor job, based on the producer's advice. Even Jacob pulled back too much. Randy pointed that out, but didn't attribute it to following the producer's advice. I noticed that if a singer disagreed with the producer then he/she got a snarky reply. When Scotty disagreed, the producer said he was like a one-note Charlie. Well, what do you want Scotty to do? He's not a rocker. He doesn't sing pop. He knows who he is–he's a great country and western singer. This producer has got to go.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:23 am | Report abuse |
    • lvk

      Are you nuts????? Casey was the best performance of the night!!! You must of been doing something else at the time. Casey and James should be top two.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:50 am | Report abuse |
  156. lynn

    Jacob would do better as a drag queen. He is way beyond too melodramatic. It is hard to take him seriously. He is certainly talented and a good singer but too hard to watch. I honestly thought he was about to break out in tears tonight as he sang his song.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:19 am | Report abuse |
    • Kenny

      I could not agree with you more! He needs to pack his bags and move on over to RUPAULS DRAG RACE. I can't stand his voice and he looks like he is about to eat his microphone. NOT A FAN!

      March 31, 2011 at 11:44 am | Report abuse |
    • bernardo

      ha,ha,at least someone with a brain!!!!!!I do think Jacob should be like Sylvester,the popular gay disco queen from that era.Who says you need to hit high notes to be good???He's just boring since he's always the same.And it's painful to watch all those mouth's movements!!!!!Can't stand Stephano and the rest quite uninteresting.The only original,talented,interesting is CASEY.People should really understand this simple fact

      March 31, 2011 at 5:24 pm | Report abuse |
  157. American Idiots

    Scotty McCreepy (Howdy Doody) is really horrid, seriously, every dull song he spews sounds the same, exactly the same, boring, dull, mono tone drool. McDreary has no versatility, plays safe with every last dreary country rendition on every horrible, no talent, waste of time song he bores us with. Remember Taylor Nobody Hicks? some nowhere career he ended up with, McDreary is even worse! stop wasting our time. Then there's Rod Stewart boy, what is this guy trying to emulate!? he stinks! he's like a a bad lounge singer doing Rod Stewart doped on heroine, sad really sad. Then there is the guy who for some really strange reason got saved, he looks like Will Farrel in the hot tub skit on SNL, he is really awful, are the judges deaf? The reggae girl, she's got some talent but she thinks this is Rastafarian Idol, wrong country, wrong show honey, save the reggae for Jamaican Idol, this is American Idol.. Ok so the good, Pia is incredible, she is so pro already, can not even wait to see what she does beyond this ridiculous show, she is too good for this amateur hour, perfect pitch, perfect phrasing, timing, range, dynamics, the whole package. Stefano is really good, he just needs to chill some on certain songs, Haley has alot of potential but she is quirky, she needs to just stay loose and not over think her phrasing and timing and she will be fine. The rest all leave me lukewarm, don't really care about them much, well that's my two cents, I feel better now.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:10 am | Report abuse |
    • lana

      Scotty reminds me of the "MAD" boy, from MAD Magzine.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:36 am | Report abuse |
    • GH

      lana LOL you nailed it!!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:52 am | Report abuse |
    • Indy

      I agree with you on most of this, but Casey is a more talented musician than any of the others. Haley is the one-trick pony, all she knows how to do is that annoying growl. What was up with that lame wave? And as for Jacob, every time he sings it sounds like he's giving every ounce of energy he's got – I love that.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:09 am | Report abuse |
    • Shellrocks

      I am SO glad you hear the same stuff I do when Scotty McCreepy (to take from you) sings. This kid does the exact same thing over and over no matter what song he sings. I really can't believe he has made it this far, I wonder if Simon would have kept him.

      March 31, 2011 at 10:48 am | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      At least I remember Taylor Hicks name....I don't remember last years AI winner...what has HE done lately?

      March 31, 2011 at 12:31 pm | Report abuse |
    • Sunny

      Jeff – last year's winner went on to put out an awkward, weird "hit" and no one knows beyond that. Adam Lambert didn't even win but is raking in the money, hits and booked solid on tour. Funny that we vote like crazy as if the 'top' winner really even matters.

      Original Poster – okay, even though your post was pretty vicious, it was the first one that made me laugh out loud. My only disagreement is about Pia/Celine. She'd be a good lounge or cruise singer. You can tell who the men on this forum are because they all think she is top-notch with no performance flaws, whatsoever. Okay, I can't sing like her, even in my dreams, but don't think someone with that ego would ever give any of us lesser beings a second glance when she becomes 'famous' (or now, for that matter).

      March 31, 2011 at 2:01 pm | Report abuse |
    • adam fan

      Scotty looks just like Alfred E. Neuman from Mad magazine. This is all I can think of when he sings. He is good though.

      April 5, 2011 at 12:40 am | Report abuse |
  158. dave_in_altmar

    Does anyone see themselves actually buying an album done by *any* of these contestants? Honestly, this is one of the most mediocre groups ever. I could close my eyes and throw darts at a board with all 11 names and would be fine with whichever two got nailed getting the boot...

    March 31, 2011 at 12:09 am | Report abuse |
    • wendy

      No way will I be spending my cash on any of these guys/gals CDs. None of them have that extra star quality be it voice or personality.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:46 am | Report abuse |
    • Bettina

      Lets be honest , of all the years of American Idol, I think the only one that came close to making any good albums was Kelly Clarkson and still, I would never go and buy her album or any other Idol winner. I think Clay Aiken had a great voice, but strange looking. Simon always got on him about his image. I think that Thia has the potential to be a really great artist, look at her now she is only 15. Pia is a Celine , cookie cutter singer, so is Stefano. I liked Karen Rodriguez, but she is gone. I thought Hayley did a good job tonite and she hasnt been my favorite. All and all good voices, but nobody stands out. Scotty and Lauren will get a record deal. Will be interesting to know who wins.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:56 am | Report abuse |
    • JR

      I already own Paul's band's albums (I used to see them in concert a lot last year). I know he's not the singer with the best range, but there are LOTS of really awesome bands with singers who probably wouldn't win American Idol either. I hope they find success after the show!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:14 pm | Report abuse |
    • Sunny

      Bettina – I agree about Karen! She had a pretty voice and was always so humble and grateful and heartfelt. People keep voting for the pretentious ones with over-inflated egos yet probably 99.9% won't buy w/e CD Idol puts out when all is said and done.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:56 pm | Report abuse |
    • Long Time Music Lover

      Ever wonder how Bob Dylan or Neil Young would do on AI? They'd probably have been cut in the tryouts and cried all the way to bank for the 40-50 years after. Variety and imagination have to go with some vocal talent and often account for more star power than the vocals alone. I agree. Some artists have been way too one dimensional, but hang on becuase their cliques like them. Cliques die out though like the fads of each season. It's better to burn out, than to fade away. I remember people saying they didn't like Elton cause he played the piano or Chicago because of the horns or Santana because of the Latin and World Music influence. Guess they knew a lot...

      March 31, 2011 at 3:44 pm | Report abuse |
    • mrshannigan

      Remember Carrie Underwood? Quite the star, and she came from American Idol.

      March 31, 2011 at 4:03 pm | Report abuse |
  159. Jake

    Love Scottie he wil go far in any case, reminds me of Jim Reeves

    March 31, 2011 at 12:07 am | Report abuse |
  160. minny

    Please take Naima off, that one drives me crazy, she can't sing, she dances to make up for it, and once again Its American idol, not your heritage Idol, she always mentions her heritage. I also think Stefeno needs to go. I would like to see Scotty in the final and Pia. KC is also good

    March 31, 2011 at 12:03 am | Report abuse |
    • marty rogers

      my dog has a wider range than Scotty! nice kid but he is completely unidimensional!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:28 am | Report abuse |
    • mrskool

      There is nothing worse than a boring singer = turn the channel ... so PIA and SCOTTY need to GO HOME NOW !

      March 31, 2011 at 12:32 pm | Report abuse |
    • NYC

      Marty, I have your dog's album. Amazing.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:22 pm | Report abuse |
  161. Beth

    So relieved to read the first line of the article, because all of us watching were stunned as well. Even my 9-yr old boy who was only half-listening said, "All I heard was a bunch of screaming." What in the world were the judges thinking? And best of the night? I thought was clearly a bottom 3 performance. She's a good karaoke singer, but not a future star by any means. And she always resorts to the same cloddish wobble/stomp for movement. I was surprised that Pia chose another ballad when instructed to break out more. She could have gone much further and really wowed us all instead of putting on essentially the same show, different lyrics.

    March 31, 2011 at 12:01 am | Report abuse |
    • marty rogers

      why do women always go after other women, specially when they are pretty? is it envy? are they afraid these women wills teal their husbands?

      March 31, 2011 at 12:26 am | Report abuse |
    • Beth

      Well, that's one way to look at it, or dismiss it without trying to rebut, but my comments had nothing to do with their gender, only with their performances. I'm actually a voice teacher with a Master's and teach men and women equally. I chose to focus on those two because Haley closed the show and got the crazy comments (seriously, Randy?), and because Pia is one of a few who shows the most promise, but specifically did not take the judge's advice which means that as talented as she is, she's giving the impression she can't do anything other than what she's shown– big emotional ballads. I often tell my students facing auditions that people will assume that what you show them is all you have. If you don't show it, they don't know you have it. Pia may have "it", but she's not showing and so people are starting to believe that she doesn't in fact have anything other than the one thing she's showing week after week. Pia should continue on the show but show some flexibility in style, tempo, and mood. Haley, on the other hand does not have a career (or much of one) beyond this show.

      March 31, 2011 at 11:26 pm | Report abuse |
  162. nono

    Paul needs to go. He is a dime a dozen in any coffee shop on open mic night. People keep drinking the kool aid about him and the "character" of his voice. There are people out there with just as much "character" that can actually sing without cracking and actually have some sort of range.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:55 pm | Report abuse |
  163. Robert

    Idol's over? When did it start? Or maybe...who cares...

    March 30, 2011 at 11:52 pm | Report abuse |
  164. kris

    The final three should be Casey, Paul, and Pia. But Pia needs to mix it up a bit if she wants to stay in. Thia, Haley, Niama need to go home.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:50 pm | Report abuse |
  165. None

    Wish I could send home Haley, Stefano, Thia and Naima. All are BORING. PIa is a great singer but she sings like she is ina beauty pageant. Jacob is an emotional mess. Scotty is a great singer, but he only knows ONE style – country. Durbin is OK but another one trick pony. Finals should consist of Paul and Casey. Versatile, creative AND talented!!!

    March 30, 2011 at 11:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • Marty rogers

      Sorry but Paul is a disaster. He simply cant sing. he is very good looking, why he is still there, but boy he just cant sing.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:23 am | Report abuse |
    • LVK

      I agree...Paul is horrible!!! He should pack his bags...who in their right minds would vote for this guy....Oh Yeah the idiots who do VOTE FOR THE WORST

      March 31, 2011 at 1:47 am | Report abuse |
    • Arlee

      How could you call Niama boring, she is the only interesting one on the show. Is she the best singer, no, but she is far from boring.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:39 pm | Report abuse |
    • JP

      Wow, the Paul Haters don't know much about the real music industry. Paul could have a hit album right now, in fact his bands new album is climbing the charts as we speak. LOL worst...not that would be Thia, Stefano, Scotty, Pia, Jacob UHG boring and unoriginal.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:44 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jennifer

      @JP- i think i agree with every single post you've posted. I LOVE LOVE LOVE paul....and as far as the ones you've listed as boring..you coudln't be more spot on in my opinion. :) REAL music is originality-uniqueness..charisma...Paul displays all of these. I know america wont' vote him to win of course..because they'd rather see kereoke wannabe's take the stage...But...GOOOOO PAUL. It would be better if he didn't win anyways-not stuck to an AI contract. THere has only been VERY few instances where the winner actually did something w/ their music. With all that said...Paul rocks my world!!! :)

      March 31, 2011 at 2:02 pm | Report abuse |
    • EmSeeDubayou

      So @JP, how do YOU know so much about the music business?

      March 31, 2011 at 4:29 pm | Report abuse |
  166. Kaylan

    Thia, Jacob, and Pia have NO ORIGINALITY at all. For this reason, they should be eliminated the soonest.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:26 pm | Report abuse |
    • wendy

      You are sooooooooo right. I find them terribly boring to listen to week after week. Time to go.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:42 am | Report abuse |
  167. stevie68a

    Nobody outdid Elton himself. Makes me think what a superb talent Elton John is. If I could vote for my favorite all time Idol
    moment, it would be for Carly Smithson singing "Here You Come Again". As to who should go home, I say Paul and Scotty.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:25 pm | Report abuse |
  168. David

    I think I'm done with Casey...he hasn't been awesome since the audition days. Haley is among the best of this batch, always surprised at the hate she gets.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:25 pm | Report abuse |
    • Kaylan

      I think it is because the growling is so faked.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:28 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jason

      I agree, I think Haley is wonderful... she can sing so well in so many different ways! How does one "fake" growling exactly?

      March 31, 2011 at 4:11 pm | Report abuse |
  169. Jazmin

    Listening to Paul is like listening to fingernails scraping a blackboard. Can't believe people actually like to listen to him.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:20 pm | Report abuse |
    • suzanne

      I adore Paul and his unique performances.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • JP

      That is definately a matter of opinion because he's my fave of the group because I'd actually buy his bands album unlike most of them. He's got soul...he's a REAL musician..plays like 5 instruments and has a unique voice. Go Paul!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:38 pm | Report abuse |
    • somewhatentertained

      I Love Paul!!!!! He won my heart when he sang Maggie May. :) I dont' predict him winning my any means..but i still like paul alot. I wish Pia would leave...then i wouldn't even care who won. PIA is a self centered little beauty queen wannabe who's SOOOO boring. She thinks she has the show won...GOD I HOPE NOT!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:56 pm | Report abuse |
  170. Jigs

    I think Thia was the best last night. She really sang her heart out! at a very young age with that kind of depth and emotions is just superb. I definitely think Naima should go !

    March 30, 2011 at 11:16 pm | Report abuse |
    • LVK

      Sorry but Thia Pales in compariosn to everyone else. She looks like a scared puppy and she has no power to her voice. Final three should be James, Casey, and Lauren....Pia is BORING, BORING, BORING....SNORE....

      March 31, 2011 at 1:45 am | Report abuse |
  171. mike

    It's not hard to see who's going home, THEY ALL NEED TO GO. What a bunch of talentless losers. Where is Simon Cowell when we need him? Why don't the judges has the guts to tell these kids that they are worse than bad kareokee singers.Time to scrap this group and start over.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:15 pm | Report abuse |
  172. IdolFan

    Not too excited about the Reggae performance, Casey, Paul, & Scott did great. I disagree with Randy Jackson about the last performer being the best – it was OK, but paled by comparison to James. I'd say about half the contestants sounded like they were already cutting their own records.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:15 pm | Report abuse |
  173. Island Girl

    I loved Elton John night! He is my favorite singer. In all honesty, it is very hard to see anyone leave. They are all so talented. However, if two had to go tonight, I would choose Thia and Stefano... :-( Tomorrow will be very hard to watch. I bet that Jennifer Lopez will get tears in her eyes. She hates that part of the show. Don't we all??? Oh, yes! What is up with all the ladies in the audience and their signs to Steven Tyler? They reallly think he is hot! I can't wait to see him perform... I want Pia to win!!

    March 30, 2011 at 11:13 pm | Report abuse |
  174. Ida

    KJ – I agree with you! Stefano and Paul should go home....

    March 30, 2011 at 11:12 pm | Report abuse |
  175. Marnie

    I am not a fan of Reggae or Naima. sorry. But Naima did a really good take on that song. It was qute enjoyable.
    Scott and Lauren could be booted out tomorrow, but they will both go on to Nashville and have recording contracts.
    Casey looked like he had stage fright. The worst part of the show was no one did CROCODILE ROCK. so sad.
    Thia is boring the heck out of me. I am missing Simon succinct sacracstic and salatious critiques. It is a little too sugar coated in the judging, but I do love them all.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:10 pm | Report abuse |
  176. Joyce

    it's pathetic how you can tell which one's the judges wanted to be sent home. i think stefano is long overdue to go home. so is naima. thia rendered a heart wrenching performance and i think she deserves to stay.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:10 pm | Report abuse |
    • Carlo

      Haha are you Filipino? I know a lot of Joyce's that are Filipino... That's probably why you are all over Thia... IMO she really was the most boring... I am Filipino too but I really don't care for her because she was already on another reality TV Show and got eliminated (Americas Got Talent) her performance was heartfelt, but forgettable... That's why she was put into the bottom 3 last week... She's forgettable... I like her but boring... :/

      March 31, 2011 at 4:08 am | Report abuse |
  177. Tammy

    Naima both sucked and blowed tonight, and that ain't good even for a man!

    March 30, 2011 at 11:06 pm | Report abuse |
  178. KJ

    Stefano and Paul will go home. Stefano sings only for himself. Paul just sounds the same over and over.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:05 pm | Report abuse |
    • Pork & Beans

      Well if you're basing on someone sounding the same on whether or not they should go home then Scotty should and will be going home tomorrow night, along with Naima. Speaking of Naima, what the heck was she trying to do and why were the judges not brutally honest with her instead of blowing smoke up her butt?

      March 30, 2011 at 11:09 pm | Report abuse |
    • Ricky

      yeah Stefano does kind of come off as a little self centered while he's singing doesn't he? The judges are getting way too sugary to me, we need someone more like Simon on the panel now. JLo and Steven are way too sugar coated.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:14 pm | Report abuse |
  179. Jdecks

    I love Paul and Jacob. Lauren was great tonight too. I don't care for Haley or Naima.

    March 30, 2011 at 11:03 pm | Report abuse |
  180. Sunshine

    Great performances tonite! As usual James rocked it. Casey excellent. Naima terrible as always. Cant believe she made it this far. That reggae sh!t aint working. Haley still growling like a dog in heat. What a way to tear up an Elton John song. Randy was WRONG! Overall pretty good show.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:56 pm | Report abuse |
  181. AI fan still

    Thia and Paul should go home if voting was tonight. Thia's vibrato is wierd (she's young) and Paul's voice does not have promise for more depth like the judges think. I thought Haley's performance was oddly compelling, and does anyone else think Casey's diction is strange? It detracts from his musicality. Jacob was a victim of arrangement– and fog– and Pia just wants a Celine-type gig from all of this. James is a performer, but he won't be able to go all the way with that voice. Alaina and Scotty are looking like they have the staying power.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:56 pm | Report abuse |
    • Joyce

      i think naima will definitely go, and really stephano is long overdue to go. if there's justice out there. i think thia should stay.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:13 pm | Report abuse |
  182. Erik

    Honestly I don't think a single person in this group deserves to win. Only one contestant has any feeling, and noone has above mediocre talent. I have yet to hear a single one who sang a song where I went "wow" that was good.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:54 pm | Report abuse |
    • andrewsan

      make sure you take the mute button off next time you watch...it helps. Also clean the wax out of your ears.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:25 am | Report abuse |
  183. Lauren

    I liked Haley. Her voice has a rough tone to that works GREAT. She, Lauren and Casey got the brunt of my votes

    I hope Jacob goes home, his voice isn't idol material. I also can't stand looking at his voice when he sings, it looks like he's about to bust into tears.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:53 pm | Report abuse |
    • Edith

      Stephano, James, Pia, Casey, all perfect pitch to me. There is a lot of show left, let's not be too judgmental just yet. Naima, Jacob would be my 2 picks to go for tomorrow night. After that no particular order, it should be Scotty, Haley, Paul, Thia, but the top 4 people who can really sing are: Stephano, James, Pia & Casey, Pia being the total package & most sellable.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:53 am | Report abuse |
    • Truth

      AMEN!!!!!! Couldn't agree with you more!

      March 31, 2011 at 10:55 am | Report abuse |
    • John

      Stefano needs to be in the bottom every week till he goes home. Watching him perform is like nails on a chalkboard.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:58 pm | Report abuse |
    • Sam

      I like Lauren and Casey but Haley just is not likable. PIA can sing but she just is not an entertainer so there is not the entire package they keep talking about. She'd make a good backup singer but should not be the front person. Who would go see her stand in one spot for two hours singing the same type of song repeatedly....yawn....yawn....snorning

      March 31, 2011 at 4:10 pm | Report abuse |
  184. Superstarmuzik

    Everyone pretty much did good. The highlights were James, Lauren, Jacob, Pia, and Haley.
    I think Naima and Thia are goin home next week. A singer myself I live Thia's voice but her performances
    are kinda boring. She needs to step it up.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:52 pm | Report abuse |
  185. Chamdexor

    Thea and Scotty. Thea is too young to 'feel' the songs and Scotty has done all he can do- he is where he will be so let him go so he can make his country record and let's see what's left in the tank for the rest of them.

    And by the way- I love Paul. He's the only album I could see myself buying. I see him as this Bonnaroo playing- mix of Jack Johnson, G Love, Ben Harper but yet his own person at the same time.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:50 pm | Report abuse |
    • susan

      +Paul is just too cool.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:58 pm | Report abuse |
    • babs

      I love Paul too. He's the only one I would spend money on. He's sooooo cool. He's like Rod Stewart and Cat Stevens had a baby. Too cool.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:16 pm | Report abuse |
  186. Jane

    I really really wish they would not make them sing Elton John, Beatles etc. Let them do what they do best. Every time they have to sing a certain artist's music, the quality of their performance is lost.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:49 pm | Report abuse |
    • Pat

      I agree that forcing them into a certain style is very limiting and does not showcase their talent.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • lana

      You said it the BEST.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:35 am | Report abuse |
    • Chris

      Pia is BORING; great voice, but boring. She doesn't have the "it" factor. She also has already sung with Josh Groban so the fix is in as usual. You can tell by the way the judges react to her performances. I personally thought that the real talent was left during the auditions. I was surprised that many that auditioned, who in my opinion, were MUCH better than some of these so so singers, didn't make it, but this is a reality show and rarely the best win. You can't tell me that our of thousands upon thousands of great singers that auditioned that this is the best of the best. BTW, Simon Cowell already stated that he's looking for a Taylor Swift to win the x-factor, so don't think that your votes will count for anything. I was going to audition (46 years old) but decided that it will be a waste of my time. They already know what they want so standing on line for two days doesn't appeal to me.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:51 pm | Report abuse |
  187. Betty

    Thought Scotty was by far the best tonight. IMO the two going home tomorrow should be Thia and Naima.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:49 pm | Report abuse |
    • Bettina

      I thought Scotty's song lacked tonite, song was too low energy. He should have sung "Guess thats why they call it the blues." he can do it and its within his range and it would have shown that he can stretch a little.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:43 am | Report abuse |
    • kls817

      yeah Bettina: that song would have worked. I correctly guessed the song Scotty would sing; he is good, but somewhat predictable.

      March 31, 2011 at 6:15 pm | Report abuse |
  188. Snooty

    Does anyone else think Jacob is going to come out the closet soon?

    March 30, 2011 at 10:46 pm | Report abuse |
    • Amanda

      What does that have to do with his ability to sing?

      March 30, 2011 at 10:56 pm | Report abuse |
    • juliejet

      Unless he's trying to date your daughter, why should you give a $%!t???

      March 30, 2011 at 11:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • silkrose

      what closet?

      March 30, 2011 at 11:55 pm | Report abuse |
    • funny

      I think it's funny how you gay-bash (excuse the politically incorrect term) on an American Idol forum, especially on Elton John night. If you are so concerned about manliness, I'm sure in your opinion (not mine) American Idol is not a very manly show... so take your own ill-expressed advice, man up, it will at least improve the quality of the dialogue in this forum, and stop hating.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:45 am | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      It has absolutley nothing to do with his ability to sing! However – this is American Idol and as mentioned by the judges many times – it's about the whole package! America will never crown a gay as an American Idol – just ask Adam Lambert!

      March 31, 2011 at 10:14 am | Report abuse |
    • Me

      For the record--YES, I do think he will come out of the closet.

      March 31, 2011 at 10:35 am | Report abuse |
    • TonyB

      Good question, But... Honestly speaking, the only thing Jacob needs to do to be more obviously out of the closet is to wear a dress and a hot pink feather boa. Cannot stand the guy (girl?)! All that mewling, over-dramatized, blubbery facial contortionism is distressing to witness. Wish he was gone already!

      March 31, 2011 at 10:52 am | Report abuse |
    • Babs

      I'm sure he will. Right after you.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:13 pm | Report abuse |
  189. ugh

    This show is still on the air?

    March 30, 2011 at 10:45 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jay

      Oooh, you're sarcastic and cool – BTW the ratings are up this year. And yes you care; you took the time to comment.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:23 am | Report abuse |
  190. ned smith

    I thought Haleys song was the worst of the night, only to hear seconds later from Randy that it was the best?? Yikes. Bottom 3 are Haley, Lauren and Stefano. Jacob is the best, followed by Pia, then Casey, who was GREAT TONITE!!

    March 30, 2011 at 10:44 pm | Report abuse |
    • Finngirl56

      Something wrong with the judges this year....I want Simon!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:43 am | Report abuse |
    • Bettina

      I disagree, Jacob would have great potential if he would tone it down. The producer told him to tone it down and he did some, but not enough. Randy was right when he told him to pick one spot in the song to be the cilimax, he has too many climax's. He has to tone it down and stop being overly dramatic. He doesnt listen.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:39 am | Report abuse |
    • JBob

      Jacob sucks. I feel like i'm listening to a southern baptist minister sing every time. Stefano also blows the big one. I like what Niema is trying to do and am a big fan or raggae, this just isn't the stage for that. Can't lie I'm a Casey fan all the day. I say boot off Thia, Jacob or Stefano. I've had enough of all of them.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:13 pm | Report abuse |
    • Kay

      Lauren? Come one, give me a break. She's got a lot of talent. Jacob is not my cup of tea. James is doing way better than I imagined he would. I expect to see Thia, Naima, and Paul leave shortly. I don't think Casey will make it into the final 4. He's terribly talented, but I don't think he has the mass appeal (as noted by his placement last week).

      March 31, 2011 at 4:59 pm | Report abuse |
  191. juliejetj

    Last year I thought Adam was it; this year, Jacob – but I didn't like his wailing style much tonight.
    I don't think James holds a candle to Adam L.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • Barb1024

      @juliejet – I think it's great that James can perform like he does with Tourette's and autism against him. He's remarkable!

      March 30, 2011 at 10:58 pm | Report abuse |
    • rrjj

      we are definitely on the same page...Adam is the bomb and America got it sooo wrong with him...who was the guy that was idol that year??? EXACTLY!!

      March 30, 2011 at 11:06 pm | Report abuse |
    • Shell

      James needs to something different; something without screaming and acting strange.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:43 pm | Report abuse |
    • rustysrage

      Kris Allen! That's who beat out Adam! Was Adam good yeah; did he put on a good show yeah! If he would have kept his lifestyle choices to himself; he probably would have won. As it is, he chose to use AI as a stage to make a statement – guess what – America voted him off!!!

      March 31, 2011 at 9:55 am | Report abuse |
    • MGuiney

      maybe thats true, but james also has a different style. Adam was Glam rock, James is more metal, although he does have a but of glam influence.

      March 31, 2011 at 11:15 am | Report abuse |
    • Lauren

      Adam is doing great. Not winning and being tied to the AI contract was the best thing that could have happened.
      That final AI song was terrible.

      March 31, 2011 at 11:18 am | Report abuse |
    • Sandy

      I'm also an Adam fan. I'd ask you to remember that he did not parade his lifestyle choices while a contestant. When asked, he evaded. Then some clips that made it easy to put 2 and 2 together appeared on the internet and led to much speculation. At that point he wouldn't flat out lie about who he was, and I respect him for that. I also respect him for the work he has done helping gay teens cope with bullying with the It Gets Better campaign.

      I wouldn't be surprised if Joseph Lusk finds himself in a similar spot before it's all over..

      March 31, 2011 at 12:36 pm | Report abuse |
    • somewhatentertained

      I forget his name half the time too..but Chris Allen won because all the teenie-bopper girls thought he was hott and voted. YUCK. he was nothing special...and you never hear of him anymore...
      Altho i think Adam should have won-i'm glad he didn't..because he is already bigger than Chris Allen will ever be!
      GO ADAM!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:45 pm | Report abuse |
  192. Sulton

    I think Pia should go! She isn't listening to the judges, and even though she can sing-she is chosing boring songs.

    March 30, 2011 at 10:37 pm | Report abuse |
    • Terry

      Are you serious? Surely not. Check your meds. She has chosen some great songs and done them brilliantly.

      March 30, 2011 at 10:56 pm | Report abuse |
    • Shell

      I totally agree.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:39 pm | Report abuse |
    • car1944

      You're joking, right? You cannot be serious? Tell us you're just having a bad night..please. Pia is the best singer on the show, bar none....

      March 31, 2011 at 12:23 am | Report abuse |
    • lana

      lana here, whole heartly agree with Sulton. Tooooo Boring. I thought when she sang her first song by the Pretenders, that maybe this chick was going to be the edgy of the other young ladies. Sorry Pia, if I wanted to hear a Celion Dion then I would go to Vegas.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:31 am | Report abuse |
    • wendy

      Yeah, great voice and good looks BUT, such a bore! Week after week its the same old stuff.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:34 am | Report abuse |
    • Finngirl56

      I agree, Pia should go....she is not "humble" enough to deserve a spot on the stage.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:41 am | Report abuse |
    • cj

      Pia is beautiful, has a great voice and is very boring. She should have listened to the judges. Her song choices are all so similar and doesn't show any differences, which she is surely capable of performing. I can't watch her because she is always just standing and raising and lowering her left arm. She is talented, but her performances need more variation.

      March 31, 2011 at 10:57 am | Report abuse |
    • moon627

      ITA with Sultan . . . Pia is the worst ! It doesnt matter if her voice is good because she BORES us to tears !!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:27 pm | Report abuse |
    • Sunny

      Totally agree! The beauty queen is a total yawn and show-off. "Being all glammed up is right up my alley!" Okay, princess. Shouting your huge notes into the mic week after week doesn't mean you have any personality at all – unless shopping and little trophy dogs make you a quality person. Yuck.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • somewhatentertained

      Definitely agree. Sure pia can sing...but she's nothing special. She's got "looks" which is what is getting her by, in my opinion. I think she is very vain. She thinks she has the show won..and I'm hoping that doesn't happen. She will never have my vote-too stuck on herself.
      I like James-i know Adam did it better..(was a HUGE fan) but..James is the one that stands out to me-plus he's had a lot of hardships in his life..i'm glad he's making something of it!
      I know..nobody seems to like Paul..but i adore him! He is not the best singer..and definitely won't win..but..for some reason..i have a little soft spot for him.
      For the girls-she's young but i like Lauren. Some of her ditzy-ness strikes me as annoying sometimes..but..all in all she's been fairly consistant.
      I do not like Jacob-great singer..i guess..but not for this kind of music. He needs to go gospel-nothing wrong with that-but..you have younger people voting-and the majority listen to hip-hop-r&b...not gospel.
      Pretty good show this year-alot of talent-but boring. Wish they would do more stand-out performances. I too-miss simon-although..i'm LOVING stephen tyler. None of them have anything bad to say tho, EVER. I think more critiquing needs to happen.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • TRouble

      Top 5 will be Pia, Casey, Scotty, James and unfortunately, Jacob.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:42 pm | Report abuse |
    • Casey

      I think Pia has an amazing voice and she does sing great ballads, but she should take a Mariah Carey approach "Someday" "Emotions" and "Always Be My Baby" etc. You can use your voice and still have fun! She needs to bump it up!

      March 31, 2011 at 2:34 pm | Report abuse |
    • jaimie

      I'm reading all of your comments and what you people are basing things on is ridiculous. It's a singing contest. Someone likes James because he's had a lot of hardships in his life. Someone else doesn't like Pia because she likes to get glammed up. Thia doesn't have enough life experience. Holy bajeezus folks. The vote is for the best singer. Pia is an amazing singer whether you think she's boring or not. And yes, she's beautiful. She'll be a big star some day. James is a great singer and good entertainer as well. And Jacob, however annoying his mannerisms may be, can sing like a dream. Yes, Naima is ghetto and and unappealing to america in her choices, but the reason she won't make it is because she's not as good a singer. I loved Paul in the auditions, but he proves every week he's not Idol material. More of a singer songwriter type quirky musician. And Hailey, though she's all over the place from week to week, can sing her butt off. I just wish she'd quit growling all the time. Because she can actually sing very well.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:25 pm | Report abuse |
    • fred

      I agree she is the best singer, but not the best performer/entertainer. Certainly not a POP star. Rather she comes off like a serious singer/artist type. Great for a Las Vegas act, but she's not going to hit the pop charts/top 40 radio/i-Tunes market.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:32 pm | Report abuse |
    • aaron

      Pia and Jacob are the best two singers,even though Jacob sucked last night, when he is on,OMG! Pia is "on" every time she takes the stage. Haley is the the Dark Horse.

      March 31, 2011 at 4:56 pm | Report abuse |
  193. Nanci

    Naima & Thea -

    March 30, 2011 at 10:34 pm | Report abuse |
  194. holla

    Thia is the least passionate and hardest to identify with of all the contestants. I agree with your comments about Paul, but I find James, Casey, and Jacob much more compelling!

    March 30, 2011 at 10:32 pm | Report abuse |
    • Barb1024

      @holla – I'm with you! James, Casey, and Jacob are the ones who really perform consistantly well!

      March 30, 2011 at 10:56 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff

      I made a bet that Thia was going to sing a Disney song by Elton John....I lost....Darn you, Thia!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:27 pm | Report abuse |
    • Casey

      I am TOTALLY inlove with Casey's artistic capabilities (not because we have the same name). Following him is definitely Jacob and I find Paul very unique... I love him. He may have to much of an underground vocal for America though.

      Thia, Pia and Stefano... BORING! I think Pia and Stefano are out.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:28 pm | Report abuse |
  195. Nori

    Naima and Thia

    March 30, 2011 at 10:31 pm | Report abuse |
    • Joyce

      naima i think will definitely go. not sure about thia, i thought she gave a really good from the heart performance and i'm sure lots were touched by that.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:09 pm | Report abuse |
    • wendy

      Naima and Thia – time to go. Hope America gets it right.

      March 31, 2011 at 12:32 am | Report abuse |
    • jason

      I agree – Naima – because it's her time, and Thia because she just isn't leaving any lasting impressions. The only song I remember her singing is "Colors of the Wind", and that's because I thought it was the most ridiculous song choice for her. Each contestant is making the rounds of selecting the worst possible songs for their voices: Casey – Smells Like Teen Spirit, Thia – Colors of the Wind, Jacob – I Believe I Can Fly, Pia – Celine Dions note for note version of All By Myself, etc. While some of them may be singing them well, they are just rubbing me the wrong way. Wrong songs, wrong show, wrong goal. You want to be a stand-out pop-star, so stop copying every Idol contestant before you.

      March 31, 2011 at 11:24 am | Report abuse |
    • babs

      Niama is at least entertaining. (Not my cup of tea but whatever) Thia is a one note wonder. Dull little ballad, again. At this point i'm thinking Thia who? oh, yea, right. that little unremarkable kid. time to go home.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • fred

      Thia has a pretty voice, but can the public stand ( and will they buy concert tickets to see her just stand there song after song? NO. I think Naima is the best 'adult' in the bunch. In think you either geth er or you don't Apparently alot of people do get her since she is stil on without being saved. Saving Casey was a disgrace. He really sucks. they tried to clean him up last night and he still looks homeless. Goodbye.

      March 31, 2011 at 3:29 pm | Report abuse |
  196. juliejet

    As cute and quirky as Paul is, his time has come. And I still don't get Naima.
    Thia's performance was very touching. Almost everyone did a great job; so much talent this year!

    March 30, 2011 at 10:22 pm | Report abuse |
    • Barb1024

      @juliejet- I have to agree with everything you said. "As cute and quirky as Paul is, his time has come. And I still don't get Naima.Thia's performance was very touching. Almost everyone did a great job; so much talent this year!"

      March 30, 2011 at 10:54 pm | Report abuse |
    • Joyce

      i think naima and stefano should go! seriously, they made it this far – specially stefano.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:19 pm | Report abuse |
    • Sheill

      That is the two I would pick to be voted off. Paul and Naima

      I blieve they have more talent this year than they have ever had on the show; it will be hard to go down to one person.

      March 30, 2011 at 11:50 pm | Report abuse |
    • Bettina

      I agree Paul should go next, everyone has improved, even Naima , but she is next after Paul....Thia was great, Jacob inproved, surprise of the Nite was Hayley, she did a great job with that song, Its one that I dont think anyone else has ever sung except Elton John, its difficult to make interesting.

      March 31, 2011 at 1:33 am | Report abuse |
    • RavensPIT

      100% agree with you. Paul and Naima are the weakest remaining contestants. They should go, but I have a feeling it will be Naima and Thia.

      March 31, 2011 at 6:37 am | Report abuse |
    • marilib

      I gree with RavensPIT. Naima doesn' have mass appeal and Thia is just not experienced enough – not her time. But, she will be back...just look what happened to Pia!!

      March 31, 2011 at 10:43 am | Report abuse |
    • Jason

      I am so completely bored by every single contestant this season. Don't get me wrong, there is a ton of talent in this group, they just don't seem to be using any of it. Not even Pia. They continue to sing the songs that have been done a million times on Idol, and they aren't bringing anything worthwhile to their versions. Naima and Thia may be going home tonight – one for going too big, one for being way too safe. Haley was good when she let go and got into it, but it was still just so-so. I love this show, and have watched every single season. However, not even the Blake/Jordin season was this boring and unoriginal. It really does sound like – and I hate to be so cliche – a night of karaoke everytime they sing.
      Now, for Tim- the "rocker. The screaming rock thing just seems like something he can do, not who he is. I wonder what his actual personality is like, since the rocker vibe doesn't seem genuine at all. It's like he's doing all of the things he thinks a rocker should do – make devil hands, set something on fire, run around the stage, wear a ton of accessories – but he's forgetting the one golden rule: be original while doing all of this.
      Now – for Idol as a whole: it is far too early for Black Choir. That should be a finale thing only.

      March 31, 2011 at 11:17 am | Report abuse |
    • Critique

      Pia and Casey should go! Pia is extremely boring – doesn't move and Casey just didn't do a good job last night.
      Paul deserves to stay. Stefano and Haley were great last night!

      March 31, 2011 at 11:23 am | Report abuse |
    • lynn

      miss simon!

      March 31, 2011 at 12:41 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jana

      Naima so needs to go. Her performance totally sucked A$$!!!!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:02 pm | Report abuse |
    • Lisa Kenney

      now which of the chosen to leave is good enough for top 10 tour

      March 31, 2011 at 1:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • Dawn

      Pia is boring! Hayley is painful to watch!

      March 31, 2011 at 1:25 pm | Report abuse |
    • Jeff Dwyer

      The collection of talented singers is fantastic, making previous years look anemic and lame. Last night, Paul was the one and only performer who clearly doesn't have the pipes or energy to be a hit. He will go tonight. It is tougher to predicte the second person who will depart tonight. Scotty will probably be the other person to join Paul on the streets of LA searching fr an agent and producer. He has a great country sound but limited range, and appeal.Thia's voice is so pure and beautiful, but many Idol voters may bot be thrilled with her as a top performer.I would hate to see her go. Trimmed and clipped Casey was better, and he may have been able to rebuild a fan-base. Haley doesn't do much for me but many Idol voters like her style and appearance. Naima has talent, but her style often strays from my musical preferences preferences. When we get to the final 6, each departure will be as painful as root canal.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:04 pm | Report abuse |
    • Donna

      Agreed. I had Paul in my Top 5 back in Hollywood and he hasn't had a performance to my liking since.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:06 pm | Report abuse |
    • Kareen

      Funny how we all see things different. I look forward every week for Paul's performance.
      I think he is not just a singer, but an all around performer whithough trying so hard.
      I can't get the excuberance over Casey by the judges, Can't understand one word he is singing about!
      They all can sing, but an American Idol should be a entertainer too and look like one.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:22 pm | Report abuse |
    • Kim

      Jason if your so bored stop watching.

      I'm thinking that Naima and Stefano's time has come. Really hard to say with so much talent.

      March 31, 2011 at 2:52 pm | Report abuse |
    • patman

      pia is boooorrrring. Completely emotionless. Could you really sit through 45 minutes of her ballads. I think not.
      I hate to say it but Scotty is gonna be the breakout artist of this bunch. Paul will get the cougar vote so he'll be around for a while

      March 31, 2011 at 3:08 pm | Report abuse |
    • RHinWI

      Right you are! Great talent this year but it's time for Paul and Naima to both go. Glad they used the save last week Casey is awesome! Pia wonderful ~ I predict these two will make it to the end.

      March 31, 2011 at 4:07 pm | Report abuse |
    • EmSeeDubayou

      @critique – exactly the opposite of my thoughts – Pia is the best singer there but needs to shake it up, Casey is very talented but way boring in a Taylor Hicks kind of way.

      Outside of these two, everyone else just sort of beat up their renditions of classic John songs.

      And, finally, after so much promise, Steven Tyler is a pantywaist who caouldn't make a critical comment to save his life...Randy has to prod him most of the time to get him to say anything. And please stop with the inappropriate comments to underage girls.

      March 31, 2011 at 4:16 pm | Report abuse |

Post a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

« Previous entry
Advertisement
About this blog

Our daily cheat-sheet for breaking celebrity news, Hollywood buzz and your pop-culture obsessions.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 6,968 other followers