January 20th, 2011
11:55 AM ET
'American Idol's' return: What's the verdict?“American Idol” returned on Wednesday night to mixed reviews. New judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez settled into their seats nicely – perhaps a bit too nicely. Gone were the often harsh but always honest comments of the curmudgeonly judge Simon Cowell, and neither Lopez nor Tyler seemed to have it in them to be so tough. Sean Highkin from Paste Magazine worried that the lack of Cowell might lessen the quality of contestants.
“Unfortunately, while it’s admirable that the show’s producers opted not to bring in a Simon clone, the formula simply does not work without someone willing to be an ass to kids with big dreams but no chops,” Highkin wrote. “Granted, the audition rounds are always rough at first, and Jackson, Tyler, and Lopez are still getting used to working together, but I couldn’t help but to notice how much the show’s standards are lowered with Simon out of the picture.” Entertainment Weekly asked in a poll whether fans enjoyed the first episode, inquiring: “Will the inclusion of 15-year-olds turn 'Idol' into glorified tryouts for 'Glee'? So much to take in, but let’s bottom-line it: Did it work?” “I liked it,” wrote a commenter named Tierra Berry. “I kinda became smitten with Steven Tyler...his accompaniment to contestants’ song[s] must make them feel better more [often] than not.” When CNN.com asked “Can a reboot save ‘American Idol’” quite a few commenters remarked that they were reserving judgment. After the show, viewer RoscoeC gave it thumbs up. “After last season's disastrous show, I'd given up on Idol,” he wrote. “I watched it [Wednesday night] and was knocked out. Steven Tyler is like having Adam Lambert as a host. You don't know what to expect, you're on the edge of your seat in anticipation of what may come out of his mouth." "Die-hard" "Idol" fans and CNN iReporters Al and Roberta Mealey also loved Tyler, and CNN iReporter Nadya Alvarez said she's digging the new judges. But not everyone dug Tyler’s schtick. According to The Hollywood Reporter, blogs were ablaze with complaints that Tyler was hitting on underaged contestants. The story quoted the New York Times, which wrote: "The show overplayed the aging rock star’s bad boy reputation with a montage of Mr. Tyler leering and flirting with some very young and sexy female contestants — he looked too much like a long-haired version of Italy’s prime minister, Silvio Berlusconi." Alas, for those who long for the former days of the show, there is always the website BringBackSimon.com.
Next entry »Willow Smith to star in 'Annie' remake?
« Previous entryRicky Gervais to guest on NBC's 'The Office'
 |
  About this blog
Our daily cheat-sheet for breaking celebrity news, Hollywood buzz and your pop-culture obsessions.  |
© 2012 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
| Advertise with us | About us | Help | Advertising Practices
I used to be very pleased to search out this net-site.I wished to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I've you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.
I HAD MY DOUBTS, BUT I THINK JENNIFER AND STEVEN FIT RIGHT IN. I THINK STEVEN BRINGS A LOT OF HUMOR AND JENNIFER BRINGS COMPASSION. STEVEN IS ALSO VERY KIND TO THE KIDS. ALSO I LOVE RYAN GLAD HE IS BACK. THANKS.
Why do American tv stations continue to kick a dead horse for a few years.
I didn't like Steven Tyler at first but he kind of grows on you. He has a strange face. JLo is like a beautiful angel between two devils! I miss Simon though. I will probably continue to watch as it still is rather entertaining. This show provides some excitement in my mundane life!
I have only one question? For years now we've watched all this talent on Idol and other talent based shows...than why is it there are so many so called stars" being paid big bucks that have no talent????? I just don't get these shows whats the point? Sign some of these kids up instead of all the hype for the final one who won't be around long!
FINALLY – Amercican Idol is worth watching. The chemistry between all three of the judges is just perfect. I've never had such a good time watching this show until now. JLo brings genuine true heart to the show because she is real. Tyler brings some comic relief and the Dog – brings his same ol self – the best part of the show's past. JLo and Tyler are the magic of this show. I'm 46 and a teacher of music. I am so happy for a solid American Idol. The past 4 years have been pathetic boring and felt rigged. Bringing JLo in brings true talent to judge. I am a new fan. Now, to the reporters dogging JLo. Just give it a rest. You guys are pathetic. Go get real jobs. Glad you idiots are not in charge of the show or it would still be B O R I N G and showing rotten shows.
I Love all of them they are doing such a good job !!I just loved the Albanian girl From Kosovo i hope she is going to be next American Idol
What I find truly disturbing, having read some of the comments: WHY does anyone CARE this much???????????????????????????????????????????
Doesn't anyone just hate this show and want to trash it? Please? Anybody?
I had given up all hope for American Idol some time ago. With the annoying and contradicting rants of Kara, and the talent getting through that didn't seem to be anywhere near as great as previous seasons, I decided not to watch anymore. I did tune in for the first episode of American Idol this year and found these 3 judges are hilarious together. I laughed and enjoyed watching those auditions for once! I'm excited. But somehow, I think the excitement will die down in a few episodes...
Didn't miss Simon as much as I thought I would, and it's nice to have just three judges again. Fifteen is too young to audition for AI, they just aren't equipped to handle the stress. Look forward to Hollywood week.
"I couldn’t help but to notice how much the show’s standards are lowered with Simon out of the picture.” -ummmm lower standards? It's about entertainment and always has been. They purposely (even Simon) let people through to Hollywood who weren't good singers (ahhem BIKINI GIRL). They have to have that perfect ratio of reallllly good and horrible to make the show entertaining. You don't need Simon for that!
I absolutely love the new judges. For one, I am a huge lover of ALL music, so I have respect for all 3 judges. They didn't seem to focus AS much on the bad singers but focused more on the talent, which I really liked. Simon Cowell was very entertaining and brought ratings but personally I respect the opinion of Steven Tyler over Simons anyday. Aerosmith has withstood the test of time and have continued to break records for years. J Lo is also a huge talent, being a triple threat and breaking records of her own. At least the judges are actual artists who know the drill. They know what works and what doesn't from pure experience of being in the spotlight. Lovin the new line-up. For anyone who doesn't watch anymore because of this – you were never a true music fan and do not appreciate what the show has to offer and what it does for those who just need to catch a break. I will NEVER stop watching!!! I support ALL of those people trying to make it big!
I haven't watched the show in 2 years because the show had become stale IMO. I tuned in this year because of the new panel and I was sure I would hate it. Wrong! I absolutely loved it! Steve was hilarious, J Lo was sweet and actually gave some good advice here and there, and Randy was his usual self. In fact, I'm glad Randy is still around because he is the one connection to the original panel. I love Simon and will miss him, but I will definitely stay tuned this year. Oh, and contestant Jacee Badeaux just captured my heart!
1. No TV show can last forever, none ever have.
2. Simon's toughness in the opening rounds didn't make any difference as far as the final outcome is concerned, since the real bad ones never made it to the final stage.
3. I find it a positive change that very little time is wasted on the totally ridiculous entries.
4. Tyler was a good choice. He was and still is an "idol" on his own merits. Why wouldn't he know the quality difference in other singers? If anyone, he surely could tell whether X, Y or Z can sing well or not. He is new at the job, obviously a bit careful and withdrawn at this point. Give him some time, I bet he will bring an although different (from Simon), but equal feel to the show. As far as I know, he is not the kind who is mincing his words either.
5. All the kudos to Simon (don't get me wrong, I liked him), but under his directions Idol failed to produce a worthwhile new character (a real star/idol) since what......since Daughtry? That was in 2006 and he didn't even win. It seems that even Adam Lambert got lost in the shuffle.
6. Simon exuded the liking of somewhat conservative music. Thus the contestants tried to please HIM, by singing a somewhat, basically boring (at least to me) songs. Tyler's hard rock persona will likely to induce a different song selection to Idol. Most likely to a positive direction.
Let's see what happens. I for one pull for good music, isn't that the bottom line?
I personally do not think Idol will make it. The formula that did work is gone. I dont think that lowering the age was a good idea. Stop copying other programs. Is the viewing age on TV that low. CAN THEY AFFORD BUYING A CAR? I also think S.TYLER was thewrong choice. I also think this is the last year for Idol. There isa huge lack of star quality talent!
I don't understand your comment about the viewing age being that low. I'm FAR from 15 but I really respect the younger ones going for it. When I was 15 I could have never done that!! If you love music and you respect the talent and ambition these people have, young or older, than you appreciate the show for what it is. If you just want entertainment value, like reality tv type things, then perhaps this show isn't for you anymore. No show will ever last forever but Idol has a long way to go if you ask me. They produce great talent year after year.
American idol sucke!
Loved all three of them. I do not miss the mean spirit of Simon.Randy seemed to enjoy Steven and Jennifer. I will be watching this season.
Keep Steven Tyler, he's awesome, boot JLo, I can't stand her and she comes off as being fake. Get another judge to replace her and maybe the show wouild have a chance. I don't miss Simon at all, most of his nastiness seemed forced and only for the cameras.
Hey they are just starting out together. Towards the end of the premiere and second show they seemed nicer and honest with the ones they broadcast and sent to hollywood. The show is for amatures and not for the judges and snid comments like simon did. These are real artist and performers. Those looking to get their kicks off being just mean, go and enjoy your cage fighting of MMA. Plus I like the tryouts and wished they showed more and stop some of these profiles. Some look setup like plants. Just sit back and enjoy some of the singers that move you to tears like me on a few that blew me away.
We have watched since season 1. Had our doubts. Really thought this could be the end of the show.
Wrong!! Jennifer and Steven bring a new breathe of, yes, fresh air to the show. You have two artists that
actually know what it takes to make it in the business. Kinder gentler Idol? Yes it is. Is that all that bad?
I don't think so. So far so good.
The show was better than I had expected. I don't care for j lo, but for some reason I didn't mind her too much. I just thank God that the other dip is off...and I don't mean Ellen, I mean that yawner that was a complete nobody!! What was her name, and where the hell did they dig her up from??? P.S. Please, NEVER bring her back!! : )
I liked it better than last year.
Tyler was great, at least hes a musician, and a great one at that.
J-Lo, though not the greatest singer, is still a singer.
And Randy is a legend.
its about time...no more Ellens etc.
I watched for the first time in 3 years or so,I was not happy with the whole Paula/Ellen thing & did not care for Kara so I skipped it.Glad I watched it & will likely watch again.I liked Steven and Jennifer & Randy was his usual self.Really the only thing not good about it was them giving in to that one chicks crying hissy fit and putting her through.Hope someone toughens up some so that kind of crap doesn't happen again.
Not the same without Simon. The show became all fluff and lies. Never heard so many good comments in all the years the show has been on the air. Really, can everyone be so talented and make it to Hollywood?
AI is still featuring too many freaks and no talents for me. But I definitely liked Steven Tyler. Who would have thought he'd have so much personality and be so funny. And he does love the ladies and they him right back. Ah, to be a rock star, even an old one! Jennifer Lopez is good for the eyes and has a softness that I never expected. Randy is still Randy... Boring! Watched first show except for a 1/2- hour break for Modern Family. Watched Big Bang at 8;00 on Thursday and then switched to AI for last 1/2-hour. Again, too many freaks and no talents. Will stick with AI with exceptions as noted only because nothing else is on at the competing time slots that appeals to me more.
Watched it for 15 minutes and that was to long...It;s not the same with out Simon....He made the show
Well, I don't know if I found it boring, but it's definitely NOT one of my favorite shows any longer...not without Simon. He could spot talent a mile away, and at the same time, spot an imposter from the same distance. He was harsh when he NEEDED to be; but if you all remember, he could easily dish out a golden compliment if it was deserved....but only if it was deserved. These three are just too NICE. And some of the 'talent?' No. I saw a bunch of teeny boppers get put through. If that keeps up, I probably wouldn't be too interested in watching anymore.
Bring back Simon, drop JLo she can find another way to pay off her hubby's taxesLOL!
Simon who?... I can't get enough of the new judging panel. LOVED IT!! Looking forward to a great season of Idol!! I've watched every season and I loved Simon, but they won me over and I was very skeptical going in. What a fantastic surprise. The chemistry between Jennifer, Randy and Stephen is the perfect mix. I'm sure they'll get tougher when it comes down to the nitty gritty and I can't wait to see who the finalists will be!
I appreciated Simon's insight but the whole show was getting old. I really enjoyed both shows (Wed/Thurs).It was refresing and fun. Steven was right on the mark with his comments, he was funny and lively. J-Lo will hopefully act more like a judge than a den mother as she goes along. Randy is the same. He could be more critical. All together they had good chemistry and looked like they were having fun, so thats contagious. I had fun too and look forward to more. Hey, some contestants were great!!! Its a talent show for singers and thats what I want to hear, good voices, no matter the genre.
Love love loved it!!! I think its going to be even better now!!!! love randy steven and jennifer . always have loved aerosmith so excited to watch again tonight!!!
The show was great. And we plan to watch again tonight.
And there are contestants put
through every year that shouldn't go through, so what. Steve and Jennifer did great and will toughen up once they settle in. The change was good.
We will miss Simon & Ellen but Jennifer Lopez is a joy to watch and Steve was great. A refreshing change.
Since it wasn't produced by CNN, it's a success.
I do miss Simon – they need someone to honestly say THAT WAS HORRENDOUS.
I hated last year. Thought I'd give it another try for the new season. Steven Tyler had me laughing all night. Funny as hell and not at all pretentious. J-Lo is more beautiful than ever and Randy is middle ground. I enjoyed it!
Ive never been an Idol Fan especially even when I was rejected season 5....oh well....I'm still sang'n my songz....
Simon who?
I loved the show last night. Pleasantly surprised how sweet JLo is, how funny Steve is and same ol Randy. I will not miss Simon.He was disrespectful and it as all about him and his arrogant self. It's about the contestants and the new judges know that. It is going to be fun to watch again. Looking forward to an awesome season!
I loved it. Thank goodness Ellen is gone. I have watched 8 of last 9 seasons. Yes I had a little prob with JLo not being able to say no. Lol. Usualy I would love that in a woman. Lol. And yes I love Glee also. And no I am not gay. If I was I would be the General of the California National Guard.....
Seriously folks? The only thing I'm appalled at is the downright atrocious spelling in here... Come on, really? Is the general public really this poorly educated?
Advice – spend less time watching Idol, and MUCH more time learning to read / write...
Perhaps some folks are undereducated, however, at least most of them know how to stay on topic.
Appalled...really? This is a blog about a television show...not a trip to the National Library of Congress. If you require deeper intellectual stimulation, take your own advice and read...something else. Geez...
Umm, for all those complaining about Simon's rudeness....what on Earth do you people think made the show popular to begin with???
Here is my assessment after the first show:
Randy: Ok judge but growing very tired of the 'Yo Dog' factor.
J-LO: Worthless! If you can't tell people NO then what is the friggin point of being a judge??? (Oh yeah, money).
Steven Tyler: Cool guy but he is out of his element on this show. He came from one of the top ROCK bands of all time. What is he doing in the POP arena?
Overall rating: Epic Fail.
I thought it was terrific. They were a great team and had fun. Definitely tuning in tonight.
Randy needs to pull more of Simon's gestures if they (the producers), are gonna leave him on the show. Come on Randy, MAN UP! As for Tyler and JLO, let them hang themselves...they're doing a goiiod job!
Loved last night and am watching tonight! I thought it was awesome! I love the new panel J-lo and steven were awesome! Also love the younger crowd and talent. Not just because I'm a teen either. Will keep watching!=)
It sucked the 5 minutes I watched did!! Tyler looked like an old woman with too much plastic surgery hitting on teenagers so that made it more stranger!! So that was sickening along with the show... Plus JLo can barely sing herself so why is she a judge I'm still trying to figure out!! Oh well I won't be watching it anymore so it doesn't matter.
Joi, you and the others who say Jennifer can't sing are idiots. So they give multi platinum albums to people who can't sing, right? Idiotic people buy records from people who can't sing, right? She's a triple threat. She can sing, dance, and act, and I'm so fed up of idiots like yourself who probably never had any talent and never will, yet you keep criticizing someone who has all of that. Someone who is on TV, film, and I don't know where else. She has star power. She's beautiful, gorgeous, and multi talented. So to you and the other idiots, please stop posting these lame comments about how JLo shouldn't be a judge. You just confirm that you are morons and idiots. It's like criticizing an author of 10 books and saying he shouldn't judge an upcoming author of a children's story. Geez, give it a rest, will ya?
OK I watched it. But who is going to be the one that tells a contestant that their performance sucked? You have three nice judges and no hard bold faced honest one among them!
I’m trying to give Jennifer Lopez the benefit of the doubt but it really killed me when she stated that she has a problem saying “no” to the contestants. She did not have any problem saying no to me in a very sarcastic manner a couple of years ago when I attended the same event as her at the United Nations. I politely asked if I could take a photo with her and she went ballistic. She outright said, “NO that she did not have the time to do so” and talked down to me like if she were a queen. My work colleagues noticed how she spoke to me and were also shocked to see that side of her. I lost complete respect for her since that day. I decided to give Idol a try and was surprised to see how sweet she portrayed herself. Not the Jennifer that I came across.
I didn't get the impression that he was hitting on underage contestants. I get the feeling that he likes them young, but not that young. The man has daughters and it seemed to me that he was trying to give them courage with compliments. None of his compliments were creepy. I remember that he told a few girls that they were pretty or were dressed well. I didn't get creeped out by it and I have excellent creep-dar.
I almost turned the TV last night. And not because of Steven Tyler and JLO themselves – I adore them as artists – I am fans of theirs. But last night they should that they have no business judging American Idol. 51?! 51 people put through?!?! For New Jersey?! Uhh...no, I don't think so. I have been watching the show since the fifth season and I don't remember ever seeing more than 30 people put through in a city. The majority of the people they showed being put through on last nights episode were appalling! Mediocre at best and Simon – HELL – even Paula would never have let them leave those doors with a golden ticket! Last night – I saw four people – FOUR people that went through that deserved to go through. Only FOUR. And then the producers parade around six other people like they are awesome – and so do the judges! And what was up with that crazy crying girl who begged the judges to put her through?! She liked cried and begged and looked absolutely ridiculous and the judges gave in! uuuugggh – that was the moment – right there – when I almost changed the channel. Unacceptable. Simon would never have gave into such begging. She was a HORRIBLE singer! She has no business going to hollywood! Get it together Judges! Your top 12 better be the best! Or I'm done with the show! *SIGH* Only 8 more months till X-Factor...only 8 more months till X-Factor. And I can't believe I missed Paula's 'Live to Dance' for that crappy episode either.
American idol is certainly not the same without simone; however steven does bring something to the table. (only if he would not hit on young contestants! J-LO does not have a good enough voice to critique anyone let alone fresh wanna be singers. Randy really don't have a voice he just goes along with the flow!! Im going to watch a few more shows and make my determination then.......
Since when do you have to be a good singer to judge good voices? That's like saying you have to be a gourmet chef to know if good food tastes good. Keep in mind that neither Simon, Paula, Randy, or Ellen had great voices. It's all about recognizing talent and potential, and knowing what it takes to make it in this business. All 3 judges are more than qualified.
I actually stopped watching the show 2 years ago but tuned in because of the new panel. I absolutely LOVED it! Steve was hilarious, J Lo compassionate but honest, and Randy was well.... Randy. I will definitely stay tuned this year.
I did not watch for the last two seasons as I had gotten bored, plus I never liked Kara (no offence) and didn't think Ellen was a fit. I'm glad they're gone. I decided to give it a try last night and was pleasantly surprised that I enjoyed it. I however have a few comments and reservations.
Steven Tyler is wonderful and energetic and spontaneous. Love that. He does have to turn down the flirting, and the singing along with the contestants. We need to hear them sing, on their own! He also has to be more firm in saying no.
Randy has to grow some. He is the veteran in the show now, and should not be afraid to stick to his guns and say no. It's like he's afraid of being termed the bad guy, so even if he says no, he allows himself to be persuaded by the other two and therefore changes his vote. Randy, you're the Dawg man! Let them respect your opinion even if it opposes theirs.
J-Lo is so sweet. She's a mixture of Paula and herself! What I mean is you're seeing her knowledgeable, professional side, but also that sweetness of Paula. She doesn't want to start off the first show by dissing the young talent, but be patient with her cause I'm sure that will soon change after a couple more episodes of those terrible singers. She'll soon be saying no much more.
All in all I think it's going to be a good season. While I do miss Simon, it's not the show that was getting boring, it's Simon who was getting bored, so he was passing on his feelings onto us the watching audience. It is good that he left if he was no longer happy there. The show can survive without him, once people get more familiar with the new team, who does have chemistry together.
I wish Simon all the best. Don't diss him people. He was good at what he did, but some people know when it's time to move on. He did. You should too.
Forget to clarify what I meant concerning J-Lo and Paula as it seems to imply Paula was not knowledgeable and professional. Paula was all that, but also had that ability to be incoherent yet still sweet. She used to make us feel she was confused at times, or maybe she was, I don't know. But that's the difference with J-Lo. She doesn't have that behaviour, but all are sweet and I still love and miss my dear Paula. Love J-Lo though.
I liked Steven's antics and Jennifer's professionalism and of course Randy, as always – was actually pleasantly surprised. However, my gripe is with the producers – it seems as if this was sooo scripted – meaning that the contestants you gave their "stories" (the little poor twin, the girl whose father recovering from throat cancer, etc) were the ones that always made it through – sooooo determined in advance -sooooo "scripted" I don't know if I will continue watching if the spontaneity is gone.
This show is not the same without Simon. Thanks dawg but I'll have to pass
Total crap, JLo is worthless
who's the woman on the left? Steven Tyler was a guy
Day one and already JLO needs to go. What's with that whiney "I don't know what to do" and "this is so hard" furrowed brow? Make a decision already.
Now you see what I have to put up with.
Loved it. Loved Steven (fun) and J Lo (sweet). They both have their own opinion. Now they just need to replace Randy. Last night was much better than the first night of previous seasons.
Without Simon the show is a big Bore and a mess. The judges look freaky. Lopez voice squeaks when she talks. I will wait for XFactor with Simon.
I have always been a fan.I loved it I Thank they done a great job.
Fool yourself all you want with OLD (not "aging") rock star, self satisfied diva and been there done that Randy, this show beyond BOOOOOOORRRRIIIIIG!
Anything that has Jenniffer Lopez I refuse to watch. The talking finger from the little boy from "THE SHINNING" is more entertaining than her. BOOOOOO! Get her out of there!
Judges lacked any enthusiasm!
I loved the show. No wishy-washy Paula. Simon was usually on target with his comments (both good and bad) but he wasn't the whole show and this new panel proves that. I think the interaction was phenomenal. My friends and I never laughed so much at the panel's reaction to some of the "singers". I got quite a kick out of J-Lo's discomfort when she had to tell a contestant NO but by the 2nd day she had gotten it more together and was able to do so without cringing so much. I keep hearing this will probably be the last season. I so hope the critics are wrong. I really, really, really enjoyed last night and can't wait to watch tonight
I watched the first hour on American Idol then switched to my favorite show Modern Family. I do like Steven and Jennifer as judges. The chemistry works well with Randy and they will make a great trio. I thought I would miss Simon but to my surprise I did not. It is nice to not hear Paula or Kara, they were both annoying to me. Smart move on FOX to let those two go.
Too bad they couldn't have snagged Steven Tyler for at least one year when they also had Simon Cowell. It would have been an awesome combo. I believe the beginning of the end of this show was when Kara was hired a couple years ago. Hopefully, they can bring back some of the lustre, but i do feel Randy Jackson is way too weak to be the lead judge. Sorry to say, he never has had charisma. Steven and Jennifer would be better than him. Already. (!)
This show is going to be nothing without Simon. Steven Tyler is so REPULSIVE to look at that I had to turn the channel
and will not be able to watch Idol with him on it. The Middle and Modern Family are much more appealing. Too bad no one
could come up with anyone better than this for judges. He is not only revolting to look at, but he acts like a fool. Puke.
Steven Tyler??? I think you mean Joan Rivers.
Steven was kind of annoying to me...he's really loud.
This show "jumped the shark" two years ago but rather then departing gracefully, we get to watch the inevitable downward spiral with the same macabre facination as a train wreck.
I loved Steven Tyler and JLo. It was a welcome change after last season which was a dissappointment after the prior season. I couldn't wait to see what Tyler would do/say. JLo was so sweet. She does need to learn to say no. Looking forward to tonight.
I enjoyed the show. Better than when Simon was there but the panel got a little pitchy toward the end.
Steven Tyler???? I thought it was Joan Rivers.
Westboro Church at it again. This time its a dead actor. http://sportsmansdaily.com/afterdark/?p=430
There is one ugly black dude, one hot chick, and one fugly chick.
I have to say I liked Tyler and J-Lo. I had not really seen Lopez in a while, and kind of forgot how smokin' hot she is. She seemed very nice as well, but I don't know if that's good for the show. In any event, the easy on the eyes and ears Lopez gets my vote. Tyler too, but for obviously different reasons.
Tyler rocked, and was very funny. A great choice to get him. JLo needs to pick up the pace; hopefully she'll settle in. Randy is.....well, same ol' Randy.
I love the new panel. Refreshing to watch Tyler interaction with contestants and Lopez is cute as she finds a way to say no. Lovin it!
I liked the show I got so tired of Simon that I quit watching the second season and Steven Tyler is awesome and JLo is a real treat I thought she would have been the new simon but she was not anywhere close. I thought I would give the show a second chance now that its different and I am glad I did. Too bad survivor has chosen wednesday nights too as their new night because that is when my viewship will decrease, sorry Idol but I may still watch since its on multiple nights and they basically replay alot the second night.
Simon was the show, period. Without him, there is absolutely nothing. The shark has been jumped and the skier has landed safely on the other side.
Loved it! I wasn't going to watch this year, but happen to fall on the channel, and I think it's going to be amazing...love Steve Tyler...always loved Randy, and I am shocked I actually liked JLo!! It's going to better than I thought!
I skipped Idol the last couple of years because it was getting old. Love Ellen but knew she wasn't a fit for this type of show. J-Lo, Tyler and Randy have real possibilties. Enjoyed the show more than I thought I would. I think 15 inclusion is a little young but that's the trend in show business these days. I liked the fact they showed us more talent and loved the backstories. That really added to the feel of the show.
I'm on the fence as to whether I think the revamped panel will work or not. With all due respect to JLo and Steven Tyler, who have both enjoyed monumental success in the industry, I really didn't feel like there was much value in the job they did. I think Simon was frequently the voice of reason, and that his harsh criticism often helped contestants more than it hurt them in the long run. I don't see anyone here that is willing or able to play that role. The reality is that critics are harsh, and in order to survive in the entertainment industry you have to develop a thick skin. Simon knew that, and he saw to it that the contestants understood that as well. This year it just seems like they are going through the motions.
Ruby take your plastic wannabe oscar trophy of your breakfast nook and insert it in your rectum.
There have been some AWFUL contestants that made it to the final group while Simon was there. Let's not get carried away. Remember Sanjaya?
Loved it! It was fresh and new and will only get better as judges settle in their new roles. And how a singer translates in person and on tv can be two different things. After editting and everything, no one watching really knows how these auditions really went unless yiu were there! So to judge talent based on what little they showed you on tv – please how stupid could you be?
I didn't watch American Idol until Season 9, so I guess I missed out on the formal glory that people rave about. But I thought last nights auditions were funny.
I actually thought it was better than what I expected. I think Tyler flirting with girls young enough to be his granddaughters was a turn-off!!
First adding Steven Tyler was brialliant. Next if one more naive person acts like J Lo sings like Celion I will faint. She adds nothing to this show. She's Paula...CAN"T SING but can dance. Diddy gave her a career in exchange for a@...end of story. Randy genuinely luvs music so he stays. I miss Simon but Steven made the show for me. I luv rock. Oh Steven do tone down the remarks on the UNDERAGE girls! hahahaha Just say " She has the look" because ugly won't make it in the industry anyway....correct J Lo? Singin gisn't a REAL requirement hahaha
I have problem with the melodramatic stories. All these parents pinning their hopes and dreams on teens and Idol? Give me a break. Most of these kids won't make it in the cut throat music industry. I have no problem with them pursuing their dreams BUT be realistic and get your butts in school or stay there. If my daughters idiolized J Lo I would have a serious problem. She represents nothing but making herself richer.
I miss Simon already and plan to watch his show and Oprah's Masetr Class with him. Oh I LUV Oprah's Behind the Scenes Shows. When her and Gayle get together it sooooo funny! More road trips O hahahaha
I miss the old days, but honestly things were getting sort of stale on Idol the last year or so. I like the new guys and already a HUGE fan of Steven Tyler. Also I think we will see a side of Jennifer Lopez that is most endearing. I have not really watched her in person and I was really charmed at what seemed to be sincere kindness. I will keep watching this season. : )
Will get better as the judges settle in.Miss SIMONS TIGHT BUNS.LOL
I thought it was pretty good last night I have been watching since day one and i think after last years fiasco with the chemisrty of the judges this years judges will bring new life to the show. J-Lo was a great choice and Tyler is priceless! Randy will always be randy King of the "Dog" pound! I think they just may have gotten it right this year. Good riddens to kara and Ellen was a big dissapointment. I loved Simon but it was time for new blood I will be watching!
I was also pleasantly surprised, and the singers did seem more relaxed. Tyler, Jackson and Lopez seem to have a good connection. It works. I'm glad. I'll miss Simon, but the show must go on.
I miss Paula. She had a way in making the singers feel good about themselves. J-LO I don't think so. She is too self-centered. I did like Tyler
Ahhhh it was great to see actual performers judging the talent...Simon was such a bore...so predictable...Steve rocked it.
I watched until the Frank Sinatra wanna-be started singing "My Way." Then I turned out for the rest of the season. Bye, bye, A.I.
I thought the new judge line-up was great. The judges seemed as excited about their new roles as the contestants were about auditioning.
Need to switch things up every now and then to keep it interesting.
Didn't think I would like it, but found it very entertaining !!
I'll reserve judgement until Hollywood week is over and the final contestants are determined. Only then will we really know how good the new judging panel is at spotting talent, or not. Not so sure I like the 15 year-old inclusion. I would rather have seen them raise the limit on aging out.
Well what a long wait for IDOL to return.I have been watching IDOL from the 1st season and although Steven is no Simon he was entertaining and as for Jennifer,well she reminds me of Paula trying to be nice and not telling people no. I will continue to watch though as I'm a fan of Steven Tyler and Jenny from the block is just plain fine. Mark Anthony is a lucky guy to be married to her.
People over the age of 14 still watch this show? I should hope witha new decade we'd rid ourselves of the miedocrity that has always been American Idiot, opps, American Idol.
If you are so above it all, why are you on this blog!
I was prepared to hate last night's show, not being a fan of J-Lo and thinking Mr. Tyler was wasting his time, but I actually found I liked it more than the last 2 seasons. Tyler is funny and refreshing, Randy is talking more and being a bit more serious this season, and J-Lo will eventually learn to just say no. As far as them letting people through who wouldn't have made it in past seasons, don't worry, those people will be gone by the end of Hollywood week – That's what it's for.
BORING! Judges have no character any more. Idol is now dead. Was fun while it lasted. Where's that new show Simon is on?
I'm glad they didn't try to give us a poor imitation of Simon – that wouldn't have worked, but they haven't changed the show enough. More celebrities, less contestants.
I've seen that format in other countries and loved it – where the show brought in real music acts almost every week, and there was much more in the way of interaction between contestants and real acts. The long and short of it, is you got to see famous acts every week, and didn't just have to laugh at talentless wanna-be's.
Actually thought I'd hate it, but it's ok. Jenny from the Hood needs to toughen up a bit, but overall I thought it was a good first night. Randy seems somewhat lost in the clutter, since he rarely seems very insightful, but I think these three will sort it out and end up with some serious talent to judge. Remember, they have to have a certain number of people make it through, but some of them will never even leave the bus!
I absolutely loved it! I thought the new team worked very well together. They gave good critiques when they needed to. I felt that Steven Tyler was really involved and listening when he would close his eyes and focus. It was especially fun when he and J. Lo got involved with the performances. I will agree that some of his comments toward the younger females were a bit off color and he'll have to watch that. I look forward to a great season! Yayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy Idol's back...!
I lasted 10 minutes maybe???? Steven Tyler lately looks like he needed to be sprayed down – he just looks so unhealthy to me. wrinkley and nasty. And I really like(d) Aerosmith in the past. I think I will just stay caught up on the show via friends and the internet.
Simon who?? J-Lo is adorable and Steve is funny as hell. Their just might be a couple more years of Idol.
I've never posted before – but this banter caught my attention, as did last night's Idol. I had no intention of watching, much less liking what I saw. Steven Tyler was surprisingly FUNNY and added a dimension the show had not seen. Jlo compassionate and Randy the glue. Two thumbs up and a new fan!
I felt like they wasted too much time on one person. After ten seasons, I'm bored of horrid singers getting 15 seconds of fame. Not to mention that the judges are allowing people through when they clearly do not deserve it. Where is Simon Cowell?! Bring him back!
This show sould have been canceled after the first season. Done and done.
I hated it. Bottom line is that it is just not the same without Simon. I will not be watching it anymore this season and I have been a loyal fan since day one.
Idol lost me several seasons ago but Modern Family has a new fan.
Tyler comes across as a pedophile, cannot stand watching with him on it. His comments made me cringe...ewwww
awwwwwwwwwww shaddup.........
Someone has to be there to speak the truth.. Simon is sorely missed.. He was the entertainment in the audition rounds... now its just jokers singing and lopez and tyler Smiling... Steve tyler is too big for this show... i wonder what he is doing here anyways!!!
I LOVED EVERY MINUTE OF IT! The new judges were a breath of fresh air. I liked how the interacted with the Idol hopefuls and with each other. I really liked the past cast of judges but it was time for a change!
A role model (if that is what he is) should at the very least know how to speak proper English. Someone tell Tyler that when describing how a singer sings is an adverb. He constantly says they sing beautiful. Come on, even a ten year old knows they sing beautifully.
Grammar aside, who ever said that Steven Tyler is a role model...are you kidding?
Stephen Victor Tallarico (Tyler) is Italian... It's mobster talk... Get outta here you!
the 2 new show how irrelevance of the carryover from years past. in short, ditch randy and his attempts to recapture his ownyouth, importance and talent.
The show overall has won my vote, however, I was a little disappointed that some of the singers who are flat, middle of the road cover bar talent worthy were allowed to make it to Hollywood. The show for me was refreshing and funny and I will definately be watching the rest of the season. I liked them more than I will ever wish for Simon's rude senseless opinion to be back bashing young people with unnecessary tactless jabs. Maybe the business of it all is harsh, but there is no reason to personally attack these kids as Simon did. It was definately entertaining!
Is that you, Abdul?!
Even if some middle of the road singers make it to Hollywood, they can be weeded out at that point, and then it will be up to the viewers after that. I think it is better to let a few extra make in, sometimes they will be surprising later on. The try-outs are a long and tiresome event and the contestants are quite nervous. If you remember, Simon was a little hesitant about Adam Lambert because he felt his singing was too theatrical; and even if you don't like Adam's style you have to admit he can sing.
I feel they let a few people go through to Hollywood that never would have in the past. Steven is funny though, I've always been a J.Lo fan- I'm sure they will toughen up as they get used to judging.
We all must accept Simon's gone- let's embrace the reboot cuz we don't have a choice! I'm glad Randy's still there. I do miss the original 3. Oh well!
It was as bad a typical J-lo movie! American Idol is done for me!
See ya!
Did we all watch the same show!? I thought Steven Tyler was hilarious, Randy actually has a voice this year and J-Lo...while a bit soft...was authentic, and will only get better. The show is fresh again.
Fresh? How?
You're right. Best show ever. Thought they clicked and was impressed by all three judges. Good start
absolutely agree!
Loved Steven Tyler. While I know some of Aerosmith's songs, I have never followed them. But he was funny and real.
Jennifer doesn't bring much, Randy, well he waits to see what ever the other judges say before he committs, wats new?
I loved last nights show but I have to say that Steven Tylers high notes were getting annoying.. Yes, we know that he is a Rock star and he can hit it, but it got to be too much
IT WAS STILL PRETTY BAD BUT I THOUGHT IT WAS FUNNY THAT ONE WOMAN WITH THE SCARVES STEVIE WAS A BIG P00N HOUND SHE KEPT HITTING ON ALL THOSE YOUNG GIRLS IT WAS ABIT UNAPROTIONAL
OKAY THANKS FOR YOUR INPUT
You should probably take the time to proof read your comments and perhaps dig out a dictionary.
I was prepared to hate the show but, I was surprised it wasn't horrible. Some people got through that Simon wouldn't have voted through but then he turned down some people that had talent. I will watch again.
Steve Tyler is hilarious! How can you not love the guy? He's straight up like Pierce Morgan but not rude like Simon Cowell. I love it when he sings those high notes, he's a rock star, come on... Just roll with it! He is the life of the party! He's got my vote! Jennifer will soon learn to say, "NO!" Come on Jen, we are counting on you! It's about "talent" not "talent wanna be's!" I love how Steve barks and howls at Randy, "the dog!" How can you not laugh? Mo-betta panel!
It was GREAT !! I loved it.
I like the three. We'll see more as Jennifer L. and Steve T. get more comfortable in their roles. At least the hurtful comments aren't there anymore. Nice to have another expertise of rock amongst them. He does give a perspective that compliments the other two.
Yes because lying to someone and tell them they are good and talented is the right thing to do....This will end up being a butt kissing fest where "Yo Dogg Randy" ends up looking like he's mean compared to the other two.
I hated it. I've watched American Idol for the last 9 seasons and ended up turing the channel about 30min through to watch Modern Family. Won't be watching it anymore, unless they end up having some really good talent in the Hollywood rounds.
I'd believe you, except Modern Family wasn't on last night.
Jacob....Man up and watch something a little less gey. The only thing i saw as I was flipping thru channels was Steven Tyler looking alot like someone's grandmother who had too much plastic surgery. As for the show Jacob you need to move on to other entertainment not intended for teenage girls and lonely housewives.
JM,
Know what you are talking about before you post. Modern Family WAS on last night. New Episode. I DVR'd it while watching Idol and watched it after Idol went off...
Uh, I turned the channel to Modern Family, too. It was on.
@JM According to ABC.com, Modern Family was on last night at 9pm. Give the furry werewolf a break, now.
Modern Family was on last night JM, just like it is every Wednesday.
SERIOUSLY?!?!?!?!? how can you say that! That sixteen year old from North Carolina gave me the goosebumps! She was TERRIFIC! I can't wait for next weeks show!
Well I don't know how so many of us watched Modern Family last night if it wasn't on. I watched it too and it was hilarious!!!
Yes, I agree with you. I too thought it was terrible but will watch again tonight because I think maybe I should give it a chance.
And as to JM.....Modern Family was on last night as I too watched that. My DVR makes it so easy.
I could not stomach this show for even 5 mins. What a joke. Can't wait till X-FACTOR.
Modern Family was, indeed, on last night. I stopped watching Idol to watch the show.
I lasted only 15 mins...couldn't believe the "talent" that got through to hollywood. It definitely was a "kinder, gentler" show, but not at all interesting!! Agree with you Jacob...Idol would need some really great talent later in hollywood or later in the season to get me to watch. Sad, because the try-outs were my favorite part of the show.
too bad you don't like change because this one is definitey a change for the better. they will settle in very nicely but you have to give change a chance. modern family? really? and yet you don't like crap tv? LOL No matter, there will be plenty of viewers and you will no doubt miss out on a good season. Loved the new lineup and can't wait for this to get going!
Lukewarm. I agree that Idol is first and foremost a "singing" talent show and the crop this year is not impressive at all. J LO and Tyler are still trying to feel thier way through as judges with him flirting with 15 year olds and her giving away passes to Hollywood like they come with a Mc Donalds happy meal. Randy is playing Ed Mc Mahon this year trying to lead, prompt and set up the others, even having to tell Steven when to vote. JLo is having trouble breaking people's hearts and dreams, Tyler is trying to be diplomatic as a rocker can be and the show hinges on the talent pool which is very below par thus far making us wish Simon was around to entertain us with his witty remarks until someone comes through the side doors that impresses us. Not happening yet.....
The best 3 one with great bussines since , one with endurance as a performer , one thats loved by all and still has a big heart ! How could you go wrong ?!
Ralphie, you make no sense.
Outstanding, I have seen maybe 5 shows in the 9-10 years. Well I watched last night because of Steven Tyler. My friends and I have never watch but 5 show total. We will watch from now on and YES I loved Steven. He is so hilarious also. As for Jennifer Lopez she is great. It has to be hard to tell someone their dreams need to be redirected. She has a heart. Randy YOU are wonderful. Keep Steven on and I will pass the word about how wonderful this show is. Thank You for making some changes it has paid off.
Lay off the booze, Ralph. We're serious readers here.
Ralph, is English your first language?
I watched with an open mind...I knew nothing could be as abd as the Ellen/Cara/Simon combo.....
I was pleasantly surprised.......NO drama here....Just honesty and civility......
These jusdges are a good fit....... Randy dropped all the goofy "Dawg" crap......Tyler was very genuine in his remarks and not rockstar God at all......J Lo was sweet and had it together.....
It is a winning group and should be a great Idol season....