June 23rd, 2010
04:00 PM ET
For two people who said they'd appreciate privacy after their breakup, neither of them have been very private.
Both Jake Pavelka, 32, and Vienna Girardi, 24, are on nearly every celebrity weekly magazine cover, supposedly spilling details about where it all went wrong.
But it seems, just like with most break-ups, there isn’t a lot of consensus on why it ended, and each weekly is telling a slightly different story. Read on for who said what in which weekly.
Ok!: “Vienna & Jake: It’s over!”
First, there’s the story that Vienna cheated with some guy from “Greek” while Jake was working, but Vienna told Ok! – through a source close to her – that she didn’t do it.
“Greek” actor Gregory Michael told Ok! he had no idea who Vienna was until later, but added that yes, he’d like to hook up with her again.
Us Weekly: “Bachelor Backstabber: Vienna cheated!”
Then, there’s the story that Vienna not only cheated, but broke up with Jake over the phone, according to Us Weekly. (At least she didn't text? Or worse - leave a PostIt note!)
Jake said he was “shocked” when Vienna did her “it’s not you, it’s me” speech via phone, since he had no idea she was enjoying the company of the “Greek” actor, Gregory Michael.
Gregory Michael told Us that they made out over the weekend, and she was clear she wasn’t with the “Bachelor” guy.
Vienna had no comment.
Life & Style: “Vienna caught with another man!”
Once again, Vienna is the one who reportedly was unfaithful, but this time, not with the “Greek” guy: Life & Style reports that Vienna actually still had feelings for her ex-boyfriend, Lee Smith. Vienna’s stepmother denies the cheating allegations, saying the only proof Jake has is an “innocent” photo of Vienna at an event, and he just wants to play the victim role.
Vienna, Jake and the guy from “Greek” had nothing to say in this one.
Star: “‘Jake’s a Monster!’”
In Star, Vienna provides an "exclusive tell-all" interview saying they hadn't been intimate in months and that Jake was "cruel" to her puppy. She claims Jake made light of her Pomchi’s dire health conditions, which were brought on when Vienna sent the dog to her parents house because Jake complained it was too noisy and shed too much.
The dog became sick with separation anxiety, lost a lot of weight and had to be hospitalized, Vienna told Star. Jake’s response, according to Vienna? “ 'Oh, I'm sooo sorry your dog is so spoiled that she can only maintain one relationship at a time.' ”
We're hoping Jake will address this animal cruelty issue in the People magazine cover story, which should explain why he left Vienna.
At the root of it, according to People's cover? "Jealousy killed" their love.
About this blog
Our daily cheat-sheet for breaking celebrity news, Hollywood buzz and your pop-culture obsessions.