Howard Stern makes controversial remarks about 'Precious' star Gabourey Sidibe
While recapping the Academy Awards on his Sirius satellite radio show Monday, Howard Stern said some controversial words about best actress nominee Gabourey Sidibe. Stern, focused on the part of Sunday's show when the camera cut to the five actresses up for the Oscar, including Sidibe, whom he referred to as "the most enormous, fat black chick I’ve ever seen." "You feel bad because everyone pretends that she’s part of show business and she’s never going to be in another movie," Stern added. "What movie is she going to be in? ‘Blind Side 2,’ she could be the football player.”
Howard accused Oprah Winfrey, who introduced Sidibe at the Oscars when the best actress nominees were announced, of lying to Sidibe. “When we look at you,” Winfrey told the 26-year-old from the Oscars stage, “we see a true, American Cinderella who’s on the threshold of a brilliant new career.” Stern disagreed. “She told an enormous woman the size of a planet that she’s going to have a career,” he said during his broadcast. “Oprah should’ve said, ‘you need to get help, we don’t want to lose you.’ " For Stern, Sidibe’s size is not just a problem for her career, but her health as well. “You just want to say to her, listen, honey, now that you’ve got a little money in the bank go get yourself thin, because you’re going to die in three years,” he said. A recording of the show has been posted on YouTube, and reactions have ranged from disgust to agreement. One YouTube user commented that Stern was only saying what everyone else is thinking, while another found Stern’s remarks, regardless of their validity, to be unnecessary. Another wrote, “It’s not like what he’s saying is totally untrue, but he’s so rude and mean about it.” A Gone Hollywood blogger said that while he isn't going to pretend that Sidibe won't have a hard time in Hollywood because of her size, it looks like Stern is picking on an easy target. |
  About this blog
Our daily cheat-sheet for breaking celebrity news, Hollywood buzz and your pop-culture obsessions. 
This years #Grammys. Did you love it? Sound off! 4:32 am UTC, February 13 2012
We close out the #Grammys with Sir Paul McCartney performing 4:24 am UTC, February 13 2012
Album of the Year #Grammy win sets off the tears for Adele. Bless her heart! 4:21 am UTC, February 13 2012
And the Album of the Year #Grammy goes to Adele for "21"!!! 4:20 am UTC, February 13 2012
Diana Ross, winner of the Lifetime Achievement Award at the #Grammys, to present Album of the Year 4:20 am UTC, February 13 2012
Marquee's lists to follow:
 |
© 2010 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
| Advertise with us | About us | Contact us | Help | Advertising Practices
I can't stand that man, but I have to agree. She is a very unhealthy size and this isn't being mean, it is the truth. How many roles are there in Hollywood for someone that size?
This is why I don't listen to his show, never saw his movie and refuse to spend anymore gray matter on him.
Stern – you are an ass.
Yeah his comments were harsh and Howard does have a "thin" complex" , but he is right- she is young. Lose that weight now before dire medical situations hinder her career. And Gone Hollywood Blogger, he is NOT picking on a easy target- he will criticize anyone anytime for anything. If you don't get him, then don't comment on him.
Stern is one of those people that even if you agree with him, he puts you off by the WAY he says it.
Yes, he said what everyone else is thinking. She is far too young to be this heavy. It is not healthy nor is it a good role model for other young women, just as being too thin is not a good role model.
OK there is a way to speak the truth and not be rude, mean or disrespectful about it. The way Stern put it was just that. And i know all are going to say he just speaking his mind and blah blah blah,. but still to be unkind and mean in that nature is uncalled for and so not needed.
Stern = Loser
Stern is UGLY inside and out
Howard Stern is hardly the hottest guy around...
Don't get upset with Stern because he told the truth. I said the same thing. She will never get another part in the movie industry unless it has something to do with her obesity. There is no excuse for her obesity. Let me say this- people were harping on why she was not included in The Vanity Spread. I will tell you why because no magazine thats geared to rich white women want to see a dark 300 pound black woman sitting along with those skinny lilly white actresses. I am African American and I just don't know why people will not tell it like it is.
O boy – here comes all the people busting her on her weight. Don't judge my friends (this is coming from the queen of judgement). Unless you want to go and grab the iced cream out of her hands in the middle of the night just leave it be. She is a talented young women who showed us that no matter what, you can do what you want to do. Good for her – as long as she is happy and healthy then GOOD FOR HER!.
As for Stern, I hate to say it, but I like him, he just says stuff to get noticed. Don't we all?
artrain, you just did
Stern is an entertainer paid to say things like this, so who cares. Interestingly enough, he is right.
I agree. The industry is already difficult for African American women (even the thin gorgeous ones) so come on, what kind of roles does this young woman have in her future unless it's one of a heavy woman or one Oprah "buys" for her? It also saddens me that she is being lied to and that she appears to be so comfortable with her size and her body. Yes, Stern is an ass but he says what most people are thinking. I was a taken aback by her comment that her favorite junk food place was 14 miles from her hotel and how she was planning on "hitting it hard" the next day. Sad ...
The name 'Howard Stern' conjures up an image almost as ugly as Gabourey Sidibe herself. Stern's dark humor appeals to a very low class, low brow aspect of society so... does it really matter what Howard Stern says?
i'm sorry but Howard Stern is such a jerk! I'm upset because of the way he said it. There could have been a nicer way Mr. stern! and I'm pretty sure Tyler Perry or Oprah would hire her for another acting job... so i think she will be fine. And yes i agree that she needs to eat more healthy. but i think she knows that herself. and she is old enough to make her own decisions.
Look, his comments are consistent with who he is....I would not expect anything less of him. The truth is, he IS speaking the truth.....she will be a one hit wonder. You can be fat in Hollywood and get a few parts, but you cannot be THAT fat-as nice as she is, as talented as she may be, she is supermorbidly obese. And yes, now that she has some money-she needs to get to a weight loss clinic sooner rather than later because she will indeed have a short life . Everyone commenting on this knows this at some level, it's just people are willing to jump on the beat up Howard Stern bandwagon.
What is wrong with main stream America? Everyone seems ok with Oprah feeding this girl a bunch of BS about how great she is and how great she will be. From what I have heard having listened to Howards show for over 20 years, Howard always speaks the truth. The proof will be in the pudding (hopefully diet pudding for Gabourey Sidibe). Let’s just see what she accomplishes going forward.
Since when does being thin a requirement for talent? If that was the case Monique wouldn't have the Oscar!!!!!! Dom delouise was big as a house and nobody talked about hime being too big...Kathy Bates is a huge woman who is also talented but no one seems to care about her weight... Elvis was huge and is still being worshipped today like a God....get over it all ready...
Stern needs to hope that cancer from smoking doesn't kill him! I hate a racist hypocrite... Oprah is a large woman who happens to be a BILLIONaire....so weight doesn't matter ....now does it? duh
Pamela, I agree with almost everything you said except it doesn't matter whether she's black, white or something else, she's enormous and ugly. People might be sympathetic to the character she portrayed but it's hard to feel sorry for anyone who has let themselves get that effing big. She's a one shot wonder. Mo'Nique on the other hand...
“When we look at you,” Winfrey told the 26-year-old from the Oscars stage, “we see a true, American Cinderella who’s on the threshold of a brilliant new career.” is a LIE.
I love women who are offended by Howard Stern, because they are so stupid, lack a sense of humor, and therefore, find my lame comedy appealing.
Stern said the truth harshly. Will she have a hard time getting parts? If she has real talent, then parts will be written for her.Acting aside, she should lose some weight.
I don't like Howard Stern but i totally agree. Because she is so fat she won't ever be in another movie. She was perfect for this role cause it called on a big fat black girl but what other movies are out there for girls her size?? I hope she looses weight and is able to be in more movies she is amazingly talented but if she stays so fat she will never be seen again. I also think Howard is right about her health issues. She needs to loose weight or she will be dead in 3 years. What he said wasn't mean it was honest.
The Truth is the Truth, regardless of the source. Face it.
One man's opinion. He's entitled to it. It's his show. And he's right.
Howard Stern is a Jealous horrible ugly digusting person. He is just jealous because he thinks since she is black, a woman and overweight, she is up for grabs. Well she isn't.She has more talent in her little finger than he has in his entire ugly body. I don't listen to this chauvenist pig. Fat is the last acceptable prejudice and people that get hung up on it are losers. Americans, why are you so shallow?
I love Howard Stern! I love his boldness....best thing in radio ever
Gabie is talented. Howard Stern is not.
One thing that is bigger than Gabie is the size of Stern's EGO.
Gabie enjoy every minute of life and reach for your dreams
Morbid Obesity = extremely unhealthy
He may be right, but has he looked in the mirror lately? He is vulgarly disgusting!! He has absolutley NO right criticizing anyone!!!
I agree with Stern. This is the problem in this country, everybody is sooooo PC. It's sickening. Lets all be honest with each other and stop being so PC.
She is a train wreak waiting to happen. I hope the ONLY good that comes out of this is that Gabourey perceives this as an intervention and seeks help on her weight. NOTHING good can come from being that over weight. Maybe the "Shock Jock" will jump start a more healthy lifestyle for Gabourey and other!
Stern's old news, Listen to Opie and Anthony!!!!
Gabby should tell Stern to kiss her Big Black A**
and go eat some Wheaties himself....
fr the article:
>...Stern disagreed. “She told an enormous woman the size of a planet that she’s going to have a career,” he said during his broadcast. “Oprah should’ve said, ‘you need to get help, we don’t want to lose you.’ ...<
I wish someone would tell howie baby to shut his pie hole for once and for all. Has he never heard of the great Hattie McDaniel? Heaven only knows what he would have spewed towards her.
He needs to mind his own business and clean up his act for good. He's nothing but a racist bigot.
Howard Stern is awesome. He has built his career around saying shocking things. Are you really surprised that he said this? How long has he been around?
It is regardless if you like Stern or not – the truth is if she doesn't lose she will most likely die. Listen to the message and disregard the sender if you need to feel better about yourself. The girl needs help! NOW.
howard stern is right about her weight being unhealthy but why be so rude and crude about it. People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. No coincidence why he is in radio and not a tv talk show host–could it be because of his looks. I understand these people will say anything for rating but try having a little class
Stern rules!!!!
Baba-Booey!!!
The truth hurts.
Stern's comments may not have been sugar-coated enough for our politically correct, can't-hurt-anyone's-feelings American society, but that doesn't mean his comments weren't true. They clearly are.
Stern prays to God everyday to give him victims to slaughter for the sake of ratings. Stern, not just for these comments, is a worthless animal who makes a living out of inflicting emotional pain on people. If what he said is the truth and everybody knows it, why comment on it? Because he needs the publicity. Stern is a self-centered loser who only cares about how badly he can mangle people having a good time. Get this disease off the air – not for these comments – but for being an all around ANUS who spends every night figuring out monstrous things to say for the sake of publicity. Stern has such low self-esteem he cannot survive in radio without trashing others.
Has Howard Stern ever taken a good look at himself? He certainly is no Adonis! What gives him the right to make remarks about someone else's looks? He should keep his opinion to himself.
i really can't believe anyone cares about what this man says anymore. he's been rude and crude for YEARS. you have the option to turn him off. who gives a crap what he says. seriously, i have no clue why this is even a story. i swear i question whoever has the job at CNN to decide what goes on this site! NOT newsworthy. the man isn't credible.
Everything he said was sad..........but true.
Howard Stern may have a SMALL point, but who is he to make it?! No one asked his opinion on it and I agree with Hollywood Blogger, he is finding an easy target because it will get him attention. He is an idiot. We don't know if she is "healthy" or not. There are people that weigh 350 pounds that are healthy as horses and those that are 125 pounds that are unhealthy. This is another "don't judge a book by it's cover" kind of things. People need to quit thinking that just because someone is obese that they are going to die next year. Please....that is stupid. Ask your doctors....don't assume anything by the look of someone. Quit being asses and praise her for the work she did. Who else could have done that good for that movie? I beg someone to find anyone else...you won't. Grow up and do your research before crapping from the mouth, because, personally, Mr. Stern, you are starting to stink.
Howard Stern is a jerk. This guy is arrogant, and needs to leave Gabby alone. How does he know that she isn't already making plans to lose the weight ? She very well could be. And besides he can't honestly say that Oprah's a liar, and the girl has no future. If he'll recall, Oprah was rather large herself when she did The Color Purple, and she managed to slim herself down afterward. Many a time Oprah had gone and gotten herself overweight, and it didn't change her career one bit. Instead she slimmed down, and just kept plugging along. I didn't hear him criticizing Chris Farley when he was obese, or any of these other heavy male actors. If he's going to criticize her for her weight, then he should criticize male actors who get fat too.
What "talent" Stern may have lies in the fact that he is willing to go nastier and lower than anyone before him. Anyone can do that. Shame on him.
One way to look at it....
She can always lose weight but Howard will remain one of the most unattractive men on the face of the earth.
While it may be true, it was not necessary....why must someone always talk down about another person when they themselves are not up to par. When was the last time someone ask Howard to do ANYTHING???. She knows she's big and who said she was not aware of what goes on in Hollywood. And if she's the most enormous black chick he's ever seen, then he's not getting out much.
Piss off Howie..
Howard forgot about Fast Food Nation 2
Baba Boey!! Baba Boey!
I noticed that big-size Monique WON an academy award. I noticed that Kathy Bates (big-size) presented a category. So far his theory is wrong.
Sidibe can lose weight, but Stern, you will always be decrepit and vile.
He is the king of all media, he says what other people think. I know I thought she was a heavy girl, she is going to have serious health issues. Don't bash him for being honest, bash those that candy coat the reality, that she is obese and morbidily at that.
Everyone is always trying to be politically correct. Hollywood is about LOOKS. One day you are in adn on top, the next day the producer's will not even let you onto the casting couch. Healthwise, overwieght people need to get help. This is a drain on their health, their families and the healthcare system. Everyone is outraged about being too thin and being a sickness, so is being fat.
Absolutely true comments from Howard, while I do not care for his show I do respect his opinion on this matter. It made me sick how all these celebs were gushing over Gabourey Sidibe on the red carpet saying how beautiful she looked and how her career was about to take off...LIES!
The woman is sure to be dead soon from the enormous toll that is being inflicted on her body, no one in Hollywood would be envious of her like they were pretending to be during the Oscars.
So, it's ok to go after skinny people and ban them from appearing in model shows but it's ok for fat people to to be fat?
Stern is an ugly arsehole...He hardly has any room to talk because there's no cure for ugly. With that said, he is correct in my view (he didn't have to be an ass when he said though). She will probably not work again (or very little) because of her size. As a society, we worship the thin and beautiful. When society changes, Hollywood will change. Sad but true...
Well, when I read these comments I agreed with what he said. She will always get a role that is for heavier women. I do believe she should lose some of her weight for health reasons. Take a look at Monique, her co-star, she lost over 85lbs because she no longer wanted to be unhealthy and fat. She looks good. Now, Oprah and Monique should talk to GS about her weight and help her achieve a healthy weight to get more roles in movies and television. As for her skin color, thats who she is, and I doubt if shes into bleaching her skin like other actors and singers. Obesity is killing our country and I for sure think that Hollywood is a great place to start since many people like to mirror their lives to Hollywood. I chuckled at his comments because who wouldn't. Thats just who he is, a darn, stupid, funny FOOL.
TCM
He may enjoy his Freedom of expression.
But I choose my freedom to listen...and I choose NOT to listen to this man's dreck. I gave up on Howard Stern a long time ago because of remarks like this. He is, quite simply, an ass looking for cheap publicity. Unfortunately the media at large succumbs every time he opens his mouth.
It is painful to look at her not because she is unattractive, but because she cannot be healthy at that weight. It makes me sad.
Howard, are you even human. What kind of human being would say mean things to another human being as you do. Beauty is on the eye
Well, isn't he sweet to be concerned with her health. Or do you think he might have had a different motivation? So many people "use" the obese as a focus for their hatred and to make themselves feel superior. Stern is hardly above doing that. In fact, I can't think of a single, solitary thing he is above doing.
This is one of the main reasons why I do not spend money to go to theatres to see films because the industry is inherently discriminatory; it consists of a bunch of friends and acquaintances giving each other praises, gifts and statues for being selected by a very finite thinking group of people.
howard stern is an UGLY man..both inside and out. that is why he is in radio. he could never make it in movies. he is not at all good looking. beady, close set eyes, jacked up yellow teeth, and his hair color is a lie. come on...ya'll don't really think that that model he married really finds HIM attractive. he makes a lot of money. and that is what is attractive. he may not be over weight....but he is F-U-G-L-Y!
Howard tells it like it is... why do we have to pretend to be polite about everything?
Stern is 100% right. That poor girl needs to get healthy. And Tim, Stern = Loser? You're a moron. Look at the man's resume. It speaks for itself, There is a reason he's a shock jock and the King of All Media. The guy built himself an empire. Was what he said right? Yes. Was the WAY he said it right? Not at all.
Well Howard you have done it again, reminded us about freedom of speech which you thoroughly abuse over and over again. Have you looked in the mirror lately? You look like one fugly woman dressed in drag. You may have a lot of money, a lot of fans, but the one thing you aint got is HONOR and RESPECT. And that my boy is what makes a true man.
come on, we all know he has to make these kinds of statements. That`s how to keep the moolah rolling. The poor guy is condemned by his own image. He can`t stop or he`ll be history
I watched the Oscars and had the same type of reaction. There aren't a lot of roles out there for a lady in her position. Frankly, most people in the movie aren't going on to superstardom. Monique had a role she could really related to. I don't see her getting many big roles in the future.
well it could go either way, i mean look at that fat white lady from "Misery" Kathy Bates, she's a big girl and she's a very successful actress, so is James Gandolfini, let me see another big lady in show biz?????? can't think now, but how hard could it be to write a good part in a good movie for this actress? You see big black chicks all the time, some dudes even have a fetish for them. i don't but a got a friend who does, i don't understand it.
Wow. Stern looks really bad. Is he sick?
Stern, you got some money in the bank, go make yourself pretty. We are tired of looking at your ugly ass.
Howard who?
Hmmmm, I wonder if the same thing was said about Oprah, Mo'Nique, Whoopi Goldberg, or Kirstie Alley: "You'll never work in this town unless you conform to OUR STANDARD (whatever that is) of beauty! I guess they all had the last laugh!
Howard Stern's face looks like a camel....toe.
Come on now people. It doesn't matter if Howard Stern or Martha Stewart said this. It's 100% true, no one watching the oscars was thinking wow we have a real talent on our hands, can't wait to see her next film. Everyone was thinking damn she is tremendously over weight for her age and unless she does something about it her life is going to be shortened. Stop with the non sense people, call a spade a spade. You want to call Howard Stern a moron for 99% of the non sense he does on his show fine, but all he said is what everyone is thinking.
Howard is the man!
Howard is a pig. But he is right on this one. Perhaps too mean, but right just the same. This woman has issues and it's Howard's JOB to say mean stuff like that. If she was as skiiny as she is fat, he'd have said something about that too.
Stern, a true American Hero, tells it the way it is.
Isn't he just saying what everyone is thinking?
Stern is simply telling the truth in a blunt, careless way.
She will not be in any movies upcoming, she is totally typecast due to her enormous size, and it is highly unlikely a large audience will ever see her again.
But, if she has true talent (havent seen the movie), then she will likely have some sort of career in the arts, albeit not necessary in the spotlight.
Get your hair cut Stern. You would not look out of place standing in a field frightening the crows.
Totally agree with the guy.
Pamela there's not hardly any roles for healthy looking African American women let alone one that is heavy like her. She is such a beautiful young woman within though. Howard is not tactful in anything he says anyway.
Guess what? Howard Stern stirs the pot by making controversial statements in order to get people to pay attention to his show and get headlines such as this one on CNN. I'm not bashing on Howard by any means, he's doing what he needs to do to stay relevant. Anything in Stern's statement that can be categorized as a personal attack aimed at Sidibe should be filtered by Howard's true motivation.
True True. People are offended because he said what everyone is thinking and feeling, and they are ashamed to admit it.
Howard Stern says stuff like this all the time. He says whatever he wants about anyone. So why make a stink about this statement? How is this controversial?
Howard, are you even human. What kind of human being would say such evil words to another human being. You are such a lost soul and you dont even realize it. I feel very sorry for you.
The truth always hurt
but again, have a little heart saying it
Does anyone know what she looked like before this movie? Who's to say she didn't gain more weight for this role, as some actors/actresses do in Hollywood. Perhaps she does have plans to lose weight-has anyone addressed the issue with her? I've heard nasty comments like the ones Howard Stern made but haven't read any interviews done directly with Sidibe where her weight has been addressed. Regardless, I think she's gorgeous and will not have a problem getting roles in the future. Hollywood is opening up to people of all different shapes and colors-not just white women 90lbs or less-and yes, I'm white! I love you Sidibe!
He is such a creep. He's a male model, to judge?There's a reason he's in radio, not on TV. Sure, she's overweight, but how does he know she's not working on it? Way to go to try to rip out someone's self-esteem. And why isn't he going off on the anorexics/bulimics that are the standard of these shows and all movies?
"Stern rips Oscar winner's weight "
Talk about misleading titles.
he is completely right. same exact thing i was telling people. stop living in a dream world people
He's right, she isn't just overweight she is obese and it's scary to pretend like that is normal and encourage that when she really could lose the pounds.
But he probably shouldn't have said it to such a young girl, over the airwaves. Makes me wonder if Robin agreed or what she was saying through all of Stern's remarks?
"the most enormous, fat black chick I’ve ever seen."
As truthful as the above statement is, it could have been said in another way. However, it is Howard Stern...what did you expect. :-/
Her size is AWFUL and unhealthy! You can be PLUS-sized and be toned and healthy. Look at Queen Latifah and Mo'Nique for example. These women are not size 8's, 10's, or 12's. They are PLUS-sized and carry it well and are healthy about their weight. (They have even discussed their weight and being healthy about it.)
"Precious" could stand to drop alot. I am sure she would be better off for it!
What's more disgusting is the legion of ignorance and the ignorant crusaders who sell their wares to that legion, exclusively. Mighten't anyone have thought her health is conditional to other issues besides the moronic views on American obeseity? Many Americans suffer from glandular obeseity that is not caused by overeating. Plus I think Oprah sees a bit of herself in the girl. Oh yeah, why doesn't Stern puke that vomit of his about America Ferrera or Mo'nique? I agree, he thinks the child is an easy target and couldn't find anything nice to say because he himself is a GLUTTON for attention, lol! His unhealthy appetite seems to keep him in business. I think she's in the perfect spot – sitting next to Oprah and Dr. Oz!
She can lose wight but that odious man cannot change his ugly face !!!!!
Why did he have a need to rain on her parade ! UGLY Comments.
He is just rude,crude and socially unacceptable.
Unfortunately, Stern is evil, but he is correct. Even the Devil tells the truth once in a while.
UGH! Whatever Howard Stern says comes from a place that is selfish and cruel and he only does it to get cheap publicity like this. Who cares if what he said is right?! We're supposed to applaud him because he states the obvious?!! When you wonder what happened to politeness and just being nice to people – here you go. This is what happened. It's called the Howard Stern phenomenon. 'I'm just speaking the truth so I can be a complete jerk about it." Gabourey Sidibe may be overweight but she will never be as ugly a person as Howard Stern.
Although I disagree with the way Stern said it, I do agree with what he said. I said the same thing to my husband when Oprah said she was starting a great career – what kind of career is that? There are not roles for women in hollywood that are her size, black, white, or otherwise. Unless the movie is about being a morbidly obese person or something. She will never get cast in a "normal" role unless she figures out a way to lose that weight. She is a cute girl, great personality, and obviously talented. I wish her the best but I do hope she finds a way to lose some of that weight. It is not healthy and it will kill her career and eventually, her.
yes, she is far too heavy. the question is, why is this howard stern's business? it's not, and furthermore, he has no idea whether or not ms. sidibe has a future in show business. i mean, who would ever have thought that an unattractive jerk like him would ever have attracted a following?
The truth sometimes hurts. The woman needs to save herself.
I agree 100% with Howard. That girl has no acting future in Hollywood unless they are holding auditions to find the Michelin man a wife. That movie needed a fat black chic to fill a role and they found one. Now unless there are more movies coming out that call for a fat black woman then she better save her pennies and take Howards golden advice.
He is 100% correct. This woman has zero chance of another movie, and she is a walking heart attack. Why can't he be honest? When actors are addicted to alcohol, drugs, or are violent, we are allowed to say they need help. What's the difference with a chronic case of obesity?
interesting that this Clown thinks his opinion might matter to Ms Sidibe. As if she's unaware. This is simply The Clown stirring drama to get himself some publicity with the Bobble-Heads that make up his listeners.. Why do I have the feeling that this sort of comment by Stern is reserved for Media only? Does the brave Clown carry this on in public/in the street – if so, I'd have some respect for his conviction YET why do I feel there's a complete lack of B%*#S there. I only hope that one day (soon please) he insults the wrong person/wrong group and he gets beaten into a grease spot and please film at 11.....
Stern says what 90% of us think. The truth hurts. Props to him!
Yes Stern's an ass but he's a fair ass. He even gives it to himself on a regular basis.
Relax people...have you seen the biggest loser? She does need help.
Her heart is screaming and will give out eventually. Oh Boo Hoo the man was mean....shut up and buy a tread mill.
CNN, looks like you happen to agree as you have reprinted his words here for others to read. It's not THAT big of a story that CNN needs to report on it.............
I happen to agree with him. Howard's not a beauty, but he's a radio guy so he needs a strong voice. She looked so big and more movie jobs will be hard to come by...... It's just a fact.
She needs help.
Well whoever expected Howard Stern to be a sweet inoffensive guy anyway? Of course he's going to be brutally honest and blunt with his comments. He doesn't sugar coat anything and for that I admire him, for he says what everyone is thinking but doesn't have the guts to say. Anyway the point is he's right, that girl needs help, she should not be admired for her weight but rather encouraged to get healthy. Not because for looks alone but for her own life.
The English language does not have the proper words to describe such a useless individual as howard stern.
It's what's in her heart that matters,,,,not outside appearances. Mr. Stern needs to be a bit more tactful in his comments!
This is a classic case of the right message from the wrong person. This woman's health is at risk. She has morbid obesity. The problem is that the cure is not easy. There is a genetic aspect to it. Most human beings could not get that big if they tried very hard. Anyone who is capable of getting that big is going to have a very difficult time losing weight and an even more difficult time keeping it off.
Just the fact you are even talking about this.....Stern has accomplished what he set out to do...
Shock Jock......who could have guessed?
No one person determines anyone’s destiny!
I agree, Stern was only calling it as he sees it. At her size she may not live long enough to see a blossoming film career. Oprah should have directed the actress to get healthy first and worry about Hollywood afterward.
We need people like Howard to point out the obvious? he wouldn't have to if people like Oprah were .."keeping it real"....
If you hate Howard then you probably hate Simon Cowell too, as they both just call it as they see it. SHAME on Oprah, she has battled obesity her entire life herself.. here was an opportunity to save someone else but yet instead encouraged them down a false road of hope and dreams that will never exist.
Um... Stern is a pay-to-listen compelling comedian filling 4 hours a day on his talk show. Every comedian offends someone. Don't like it? Don't listen. Don't let it affect your day.
Let Howard speak his mind it is his precious right. Everyone knows that obesity is a big problem in this country, and Howard doesn't sugar coat the issue like everyone else. What's a nice way to say to someone that they are dangerously overweight?
Let's stop with the duplicity in this country, other than Opra how many fat stars are there?
Pam it has nothing to do with the color of her skin. Wether you are an african american women or not the truth is if she were white they would not have stuck her giant ass on the magazine either. No need to pull a race card here. I sat on the couch and said the same thing that Howard did. I also agree 100% with him. Thing is she will be on TV again. They will have her on the biggest loser or the celebrity fit club......
Howard speaks truth. Maybe Oprah was speaking to herself from 20 years ago when she was on stage. Oprah needs to send her to the doctor that got her from obese to just big and help the girl.
I agree she needs to lose some weight, but to put it so callously and blare it to the world that way, just shows his complete ignorance. Stern obviously needs to improve his social skills. Let's all take jabs at how ugly he looks or how ignorant he is, since he likes to put other people's business out there.
Stern rules and he always speak the truth. He says stuff like this about everybody all day. Why don't you all report what he says about ELLEN!!
Stern gets me through the work day every single solitary day!!!
Thank God for HOWARD STERN!!!
Stern is a rude, nasty person. Keep your thoughts to yourself. Did you ever stop to think how she feels when heard your comments?
He's right. What's the news story about?
Apparently she has found her "place" in Hollywood and the paying consumers and her fellow actors like her. Howard Stern should get a haircut and a life while he's at it. Money does not buy intellect or decency as he so aptly displays. What a waste of everyone's time he is.
He is 100% correct. I had to look away every time she was shown during the Oscars. She is the dictionary definition of morbidly obese, yet all the phonies in Hollywood shower her with praise. I'm sure she is sweet and talented, but will not be able to live much longer at her current weight.
If that girl was any other color than black do you think Oprah would care one bit! Oprah is a racist!
Not quite sure why he felt the need to quantify it by saying, "the most enormous, fat black chick I’ve ever seen." Has he seen fatter white women or asian, etc.
Regardless, Gabourey Sidibe can always lose weight. Howard Stern will always be butt ugly.
Howard Stern – hmmmm – isn't he the guy that has to hide behind enormous dark glasses because his face is not so handsome and who must resort to 'shock' D.J. tactics because his "talent" is so shallow? People who live in glass houses buddy.
AWESOME! Too bad you're all thinking the same thing, this chick is AWFUL!
Stern criticized a black woman. That makes him a mysogynist and a racist. Where is Eric Holder? Why isn't Stern and his repug friends being prosecuted for their hateful thoughts?
He speaks the truth! Just because he doesnt dance around the subject like everyone else don't hate him for that. Honesty is shunned in our society. I know I know it's the way it was said. Well when you are in the public eye these things happen so you have to have thick skin!
You could say the same for the 95lb crack body frame Stern sports. At least look manly if you are going to hurl insults at a woman.
Isn't he cute?
"Stern rips Oscar winner's weight"
CNN : she was only a nominee.
Finally, someone is saying what everyone else is thinking. Oprah is lying to the poor girl and enabling her bad habits by telling her that she's fine the way she is. She won't get another successful part in a movie like that...has Nikki Blonsky been in anything other than in Hairspray, in a part calling for a fat white girl?
Howard Stern speaks his "own truth"–leave him alone.We live in America:FREEDOM of SPEECH.She is over weight & will she ever be in another movie or was it just 15min of fame ??? I happen to be 50 lbs.over weight.
haha he hit this one dead on. I mean seriously, what roles are out there for this girl?
The Blind Side 2 comment was priceless.
Gotta love Howard! Guy has some big stones! Only in America can you make as much money as he does being an ass! What a country!
I love how everyone gets all up-in-arms about his comments. He speaks his mind which in this case seems to be the ugly truth. Her next role should a contestant on The Biggest Loser. Once she gets healthy she can resume her brilliant new career.
Wow! Really, Howie?? Have YOU looked in a mirror lately?
I was thinking the same thing that Howard said. This is a bad thing in America; ignorring and accepting that she is unhealthy and fat is unattractive. Do we want our children thinking that being fat is not only Ok but makes ou special?
I have to agree with Howard. She is a bit on the fluffy side. I think that if she loses a couple of pounds she could be the next Halle Berry. It just takes time and shes young. She gave a brilliant performance.
There is huge potential for her , she has a ton of talent. Theres alot of roles out there for big girls. Like she could do Dukes of hazzard 2. Playing boss Hogg's wife..she could be cast as professor Klumps little girl in the 3rd installment from Eddie Murphy and not to mention Rasputia. The possibilities are endless. Go Gaboray!
You wouldn't expect anything else to come out of Howard’s mouth. So if you don't want to hear what the obnoxious scumbag says – don't listen to him.
He obviously doesn't realize that if he can be successful in the entertainment industry- then anyone can be successful in entertainment industry. That is if you think what he does is actually entertaining.
Stern is right and if you don't get him move on.
If anyone had asked Howard Stern for his opinion I suppose he could be excused for having made such hateful comments. But no one asked him to opine about the health of an actress he has obvioulsy never met, much less state a medical opinion in such a gratuitoulsy mean way. He needs to shut up. Besides, Sidibe can diet and Stern will always be ugly.
Howard Stern Says something stupid. Sun rises in the East. Story at eleven.
Howard Stern is a pompous a$$! He really needs to take a look in the mirror and admit that he is not the most hansome WHITE male in the box. Yes, she has a weight problem. But to publicly ridicule someone is cruel and heart-less. To the comment from Pam, I too am Black. Why would you refer to her as dark and Black? You seem to have a hang up with Black people and their skin tone? So what, she doesn't pass the "paper bag" test? I am sick and tired of comments from people about what other people look like. It is so shallow and wrong. Being healthy is another matter. By the way, there are tons of skinny people who are extremely unhealthy in this country.
The only reason I read this story in the first place was because of The King Of All Media! He has a funny way of saying things everyone else wants to say but is to afraid to offend people. I think it is funny and true. Don't hate me for laughing at life!
We're not talking about hot, we're talking about health issues. I don't like Stern either...but here, he has a point. All those painted faces half-smiling at this poor woman, and on the inside, you KNOW that they're all thinking "yeah, we'll never see you again, fat black lady." I thought for sure that she was going to win, because this will probably be the only chance she gets.
And anyone that big is unhealthy, her or anyone else. There's "big-boned" and then there's bouncing around the downward spiral towards diabetes among other health issues. Everyone should watch their weight, her and everyone else.
she's really a size 6.....she just bulked up for the part.......she is the consumate actress
Howard Stern can have my children.
If he had said "She really should lose some weight because it isn't healthy" nobody would be talking about it. Now that he's called attention to this by the way he said it, people are talking about it.
Sometimes you have to be an ass to get people to notice.
I personally have not heard Mr. Sterns comments, but he has addressed an issue no one seems comfortable airing. This very talented young lady does have a very dangerous medically recognized health condition called morbid obesity. This condition leads to diabetes, heart disease, high blood pressure and a host of other health issues. We have a huge issue in our country w/ obese children and adults. Many people are food addicts and need help. Is Sidibe a food addict? I don't know, but nobody gets to 300 pounds w/out some kind of issues w/ food. I can only hope that she can find the courage to fight this disease and get the help she needs. She doesn't need people disparaging her or making her the butt of jokes. She needs the love and support of those around her.I for one will keep my fingers crossed for her. I don't want to lose this wonderfully talented young woman to soon.
I'm lily white and I thought she was far more beautiful and easy on the eyes than the anorexics there (James Cameron and Ashton Kutcher can't afford to feed their women?!?! WTF?) but that said, to be obese when there are people starving to death – that is something that needs to be examined. I doubt that Gabourey is losing any sleep over what Howard Bleedin' Stern thinks of her anyway.
How can anyone rightly say that Stern told the truth? What he said was more like an opinion. Being thin doesn't guarantee that you will live longer. There are plenty of thin, as well as fat, people dying everyday from all sorts of maladies. Life is too short to spend it tearing down others. When we tear down instead of bulding up, we only make our own lives more miserable. Howard Stern has more misery than most. Gabourey has achieved something that most will never achieved. She is a talented actress who deserves her moment in the spotlight. I guarantee you won't forget her.
Man I hate Howard Stern but in this case he's dead on. She's fat and ugly period. Great actress though. Perfect for this role. Oprah's mentorship well, what do you expect. At least she waited until after the election to jump for joy. or did she. I can't remember. Anyway the Academy Awards is all about political correctness, has been for years,Sterns a jerk, life goes on and Monique's got hairy legs
Jenny
"Howard Stern is hardly the hottest guy around..."
When has he ever said that? Never he says on his show at least three times a week he is ugly...
Your comment was really dumb...
How is this controversial? She is now affiliated with a business that is very difficult to survive in with any "physical flaws" despite how superficial they may be. To act like she can now expect to be a regular star is disingenuous at best and dangerous at worst. She needs to lose weight not just to continue working in Hollywood but simply to survive! So it's mean that Howard talks about this without sugar coating it? Big deal. I'd rather someone be mean and honest with me than sweet and a liar.
Howard always speaks the truth. He may not express it in a fashion that is politically correct, but it is nice to hear someone actually speak what is on his mind, without any worries of flack he might receive from others.....and more times then not.....he is right on point! Listen to him, you might learn something about the world we live in! Bababooey
His comments do not suprise me one bit!! Hello..it's Howard Stern!!
Why does anyone care what this loser thinks–Stern is living example of that adage–no one ever went broke underestimating the taste of the American people.
Health wise, yes – she should lose a bit of weight. However, Stern as always went way overboard on how he delivered his message. Would he be saying the same about an overweight male? Heck no! There are plenty overweight male celebrities. Is it unfair to place different standards on the female celebrities? Sure is. Unfortunatly Hollywood isn't fair. That aside, Gabourey Sidibe has a bright future ahead of her should she really want it.
She only 27 in May.
He doctor will dance around the subject of weight loss for about another 12 years or so.
Around the time she hits 40, she will get "the talk". It shorts and simple and goes something like this, "You are going to die in less than 5 years if you keep this weight."
I have seen several folks lose half their weight once they got the message. It's a shame more MD's won't put it bluntly earlier.
As much as I generally dislike Howard Stern, he's definitely on target here. Someone needs to speak the truth to Gabourey Sidibe about her size, her health and her future (if she even has one). I find it ludicrous that Oprah Winfrey, who practically built her career on self-help shtick and "miraculous" weight loss stories, doesn't tell this poor girl what's what. She looks grotesque. She has no future in show business. She probably has no future at all.
It was the truth and it was FUNNY.
Congrats to her for winning the Oscar but she is morbidly obese and needs to get healthy if she expects another job.
Unless she slims down, she has as much future in movies as Howard Stern does. And even if her movie career is over, I hope she slims down. Would be kind of cool to have a celebrity version of the biggest loser...
Stern told the truth and he isn't some monster like some of you make him out to be. I find it funny that most of the people that talk down on him have never even heard his show.
If people think this is controversial then they don't listen to Howard !
get over it, Stern is right and the reason that he says things rudely is because his paycheck depends on it and so that you people can be talking about it. If he had said "she's a little overweight and should lose some of it to prolong her life and be healthy" nobody would be talking about this. I hope his tough words open that actresses eyes and gets her to lose some weight.
I'm sorry. Did someone say something that really matters here?
Who listen's to Stern tired ass show anymore? Howard Stern is a HAS BEEN........ this is nothing more than an opportunity to give himself some wanted publicity.
#1-Stern never claimed to be Fabio (he often points out how hideous his own appearance is, and anyone who actually listens to his show would know that). #2- How can you criticize his comments and not be laughing at yourself?? This woman is MORBIDLY OBESE. The fact that anyone, or any organization would attempt to glamourize or approve of her physical condition is disgusting. This country was founded on principles like FREEDOM OF SPEECH so I thank GOD that there are a few people left that speak out against the status quo and say what they really feel! People who allow themselves to get into such ridiculously poor conditions drag down the rest of the country because at some point they can't take care of themselves. To approve of such behavior is offensive – someone speaking out and saying what the rest of us are thinking is admirable.
Howard stern show is played out and has been for years. He is a smart guy and I am glad he is using his intellect for something other than trying to get laid or glorifying the under belly of NY. Hopefully, he will continue to assert himself and envoke a response as he has done here.
I'll tell it how it is....Everyone is great at judging others but not themselves. Yes the girl is FAT and YOUNG, but that did not stop her from following her dreams. THAT is a true role model....what kind of role model can stern be? The guy is a ugly pathetic waste of life. He has money but lacks everything else that makes a decent human being. I'm sure Sidibe will work on her issues in order to please hollywood but i give her much props for standing up and not letting idiots like stern bring her down.
What goes around, comes around!
Why not rip on all the cosmetic surgery and too thin i.e. Mrs. Cameron people in the room. Here is a girl who made it to the top because of her talent. Thankfully, we can see greatness in her heart and soul and reveal the ugliness that is Stern.
I also agree that Stern said what everyone was thinking, and yes he could have been a little more PC about it. But being PC isn't what got him where he is today. So all the power to him.
Who I am really disgusted at is Oprah. Since when did Oprah, a woman who preaches her ridiculous thoughts to overweight housewives, take over the world? Does everyone and everything really need Oprah's stamp of approval? What business does she have presenting and making introductions at the Oscars? She should have been locked up after she ate Phil Donoghue!
I'm sure Ms. Sidibe is very aware of her size and the complications that can arrive from being overweight. With that in mind I'm sure she doesn't need to hear it from someone like Mr. Stern. Oh, yeah Howard, go look in the mirror, I'd rather be overweight that "butt ugly".
I DESPISE this man.. but I completely agree about this.
She needs to get HEALTHY and lose some weight.
Being that fat is not healthy for anyone.
Yeah everyone wants to be nice and be nice to the
fat girl with the huge smile.... but really...she needs help.
Her size should NOT be the picture of an American.. or
anyone for that matter.
She looks like she has a beautiful personality, but her size
is just not healthy.
Someone help her.
Stern is very right. I watched in disgust as everyone told that poor kid that she's made. As a physician, if she does not lose weight and quickly, her life expectancy is zip.
Howard Stern is a disgusting, vicious person and has no business
commenting on the flaws of anyone else. Too many people in this
world somehow get on radio or t.v. and spread nastiness. Enough
already.
My 38 year old sister died quite suddenly and unexpectedly last year- the primary cause of which was obesity. While I don't agree that shaming and publicly humiliating Sidibe is helpful, I do have to agree with Stern that someone needs to be honest with her in telling her, "you need to get help, we don’t want to lose you".
I too have to agree with Stern.
Sidibe easily qualifies as "morbidly obese" & this country has a HUGE problem with obesity!
If she wants to be a role model, she will work on herself, there is NO excuse to be that big.
And she is NO Cinderella, Oprah did not tell the truth.
How many little girls are going to say, "I want to grow up and be fat like her!"
What I can't figure out is how someone as ugly as Howard Stern is feels comfortable criticizing anyone about their physical appearance! The man is 'butt ugly' – who the heck is he to 'throw stones.'
Being rude is no excuse. Stern is always rude and that is why there is no excuse for him. Just put him out of your mind and let us deal with the problem that is so obvious. This young lady need help fast and serious health concerns are already putting a massive strain on her cardio system. Radical surgery is required and a good dose of health instruction is also needed. I hope she gets this assistance starting right now
So she can't have a career, huh? Well, if Stern can have a career, anyone can!
hello...the woman is a hugh mama! stern is right....this woman doesn't have a chance in skinny hollywood. the truth hurts!
Howard Stern was "brutally" honest. I blind man could see it. iI she doesn't take care of herself and fast, she will die very young and that would be sad. For Oprah Winfrey to hold her up as some Cinderella role model was the thing I found both absurd and offensive. She may be very talented, but there is a problem undeneath when someone allows themselve to balloon to such proportions. It's a death sentence, pure & simple. I guess people are so offended because when they see her, they see themslves, i.e., out of control fatsos who rationalize their conduct and their condition.
You can bet your bottom dollar Oprah will feed her parts in the future. Especially now that this has been said.
Howard Wife is crazy to marry him,MAN she has to sleep with that beast. $$$$ Why
How do you like it JERK.
Yes, she needs to get her weight under better control but she could do that and look quite beautiful. Howard Stern, on the other hand, has been hit with the ugly stick real hard and there is nothing he could do to improve his looks. He is not funny or witty, either.
Stern stated the obvious. You can disagree with his approach but his assessment is accurate. Remember we live in the United States. We have the right to freedom of speech, not the "right to not be offended".
Howard has always been, is, and always will be a man who says exactlly what he thinks. You dont have to like it. He doesnt care if you like it. Its his opinion, and like everyone else he is entitled to have it, voice it, and be proud of it.
Howard makes a great "Captain Obvious" here. What does he think he can say about her that she doesn't already know (and far better than he could)? Geez, next he'll be telling us about how the daytime seems a lot brighter than the nighttime, somehow....
I am not a skinny person by any means – heck, Stern would most likely rag on me too... HOWEVER, he is RIGHT. Mean, yes – but right. If I had new found wealth, I would hire myself a trainer and a cook – and take advantage of the new circomstances. That would be awesome, and what a story it would be for her to tell!
He 100% right. Any logical person looks at this poor girl and sees someone on the death clock. If someone weighs 400lbs they are killing themselves. Period.
And if you have an issue with the "WAY" he says things, its because your not from NY. There is too much emphasis on the manner in which a message is communicated versus the message itself. Why do we have to sugar coat serious things?
When you consider that girl 2 things come to mind...
- Theres the girl who did a good job acting in Precious
- She's morbidly obese and she needs to lose 300 lbs or die
Enough of that "pretty on the inside" BS. Lose weight or die. Someone loves you and your going to die if you dont lose weight..which is infinitely more important than acting
Why not focus that hate and jealousy towards something helpful, maybe the thing to take away is that we have a major problem with childhood obesity.
It might not be in a pretty package, but his point is obvious if you are intelligent enough to understand.
Howard Stren should take a look at him self he is butt ugley I would rather be fat than ugley dosent he know that is a very hurtfull thing to say to any body all of you who have put her down because of her weight shame on you who do you think you are GOD you should be saying helpful things to get her going on her health etc.
Kathy San Francisco Ca
Most people don't get it – the WAY he says it is FUNNY people! The old addage – TRUTH EQUALS HUMOR is Howard's mantra. I'll guarantee most of the morons who say, it's the WAY he says it – didn't even hear him say it and just read the quotes. Stern plays it for laughs and truth. He speaks his mind – he does it brilliantly and I wish there were more people like him in show business, politics and the world. He'll be the first to say he's not the hottest guy around. I ask people to stop hating Howard – he happens to be a very nice guy who says what he feels, has integrity, honesty and battles hypocrisy at every turn. Stern Rules – BaBaBooey to you all!
If you run in front of a speeding car and get squashed will everyone blame the car for being mean? Because the harsh truth is not delivered softly. Oprah is a silent killer for lying to that woman's face. Diabetes and heart disease are harsh killers. Stern is a crude and harsh witness to the horrible condition this woman is in and he is not the problem. Her health is. The rich, fit, PC Hollywood crowd uses people like her to grease their egos but nobody would trade places with a morbidly obese person. Nobody!
But it is the truth.
Stern is right. He spoke the truth
Howard Stern is an ugly, mean spirited idiot. Why he is popular is a complete mystery and a joke to me. No matter what the health ramifications, why does he (and other posters here) think it's acceptable to say things about and/or to others concerning weight? Did people make comments to him about smoking? it's just as dangerous (if not more). I don't see him making harsh comments about these uber-thin actresses, who get prescription drugs or take horse tranquilizers AND smoke cigarettes to become and stay thin. I don't see him calling them out. I think Anna Nicole Smith and Brittany Murphy are prime examples that show that Sidibe, despite her weight could have a much longer life span than many of these stick-skinny actors.
Did he ever say that kind of crap to or about Artie Lange? What about Artie's drug use? is that okay? Or is okay to be heavy as long as you're a man? Stern's mysogeny is well-documented.
For poeple out there who say that there's no excuse for her obesity-guess what? It's not your business, or my business, or anyone's but her own. In terms of her getting more film roles, from the interviews I've seen that doesn't seem to be her emphasis. She's a student who plans to continue her education. She auditioned, got the part, and was happy and excited to be in the film, but I don't ever recall her saying that acting was her life and that she planned to have a big career at it. That is part of her charm- she did it, had fun, and has perspective on the experience. Howard Stern has no charm (or talent for that matter) at all...go back to your cave, Howard. The civilized world wants no part of you. She can lose weight, but you can't get rid of an ugly that goes right to the bone...
HOW DARE YOU TO SAY THAT! – BONE KICKER
You do not have the right to insult such wonderful talent like that. I bet if you were on her shoes you can not act such great act like what she did.
Thank you Pamela for saying it as it is. The young lady is charming and totally different from Precious, with the exception of weight. The child (to me) is harming herself and now that she should have a higher self-esteem from being honored at the Oscars she MUST get rid of some of that weight. Not turn into a stringbean, just unload 100 lbs before it kills her.
Regardless if it is the truth or not. Words can damage a person for life. Once harm is done you can't take it back. So, I think we all should be careful about what we say to people.
What Stern said is true, she needs to lose the weight for her health, and maybe now she has the money to work on losing her weight which is not cheap. We all know how much time the "thin" ladies spend on trainers, chefs, clothes etc. She is a great actress!! I wish her much success.
I guess that Stern has some personal experience with this. Perhaps someone told him, at an early age, it would be best to pursue a radio career because he was so ugly.
ANYONE WHO THINKS HE IS WRONG: He might have said it "mean", but if she doesnt lose weight, she will die of a heart attack in 5 years.
I don't think anyone would disgree that she is heavy (I am sure she know it herself). However their is right way to get your message across and Stern's way just isn't it. But it's his way and if you listen to him, you just have to accept him. Now you know why I don't listen to him. Plenty can be said.... BUT I won't....
Stern is a loud mouth, big haired, big nosed jack ass who deserves to be put out of his own misery....
She may be a big woman, but she has more class than you or your skinny, blond haired twig of a wife....
"she could be a football player in blind-side 2?" how 'bout we use your wife in dumb and dumber (she can play both parts) for marrying your simple ass...
Howard Stern has been saying stuff like this for 20+ years now. Why is this such a shocker to people?
Since when has posting youtube comments been considered reporting?
First of all yes, she is overweight. But lots of overweight people have careers in Hollywood.
Second, he could have said the same thing in a much nicer way, but of course he is an attention whore.
Third, now let's critique HIM. Howard Stern has a face for radio, that's for sure... I can hardly stand looking at the guy. I almost didn't want to click the link on CNN for fear of seeing a pic of his ugly mug. His gawky facial features, awkwardly lanky body, and frizzy but ladylike hair are a haphazard combination that makes me uncomfortable and queasy. I once told a guy that he resembled Howard Stern, and he flew off the handle... apparently he agrees with my feelings about Stern's looks. And let's be serious, Stern doesn't say anything profound, or even anything of value on his radio show, which is why he hurls insults at people who have actual talent just to get attention. Do you ever hear anything about him EVER until he says one thing that is in the media for a day, and then he goes away again, thankfully, for a year. He's all about shock value and adds nothing to our society. He's a bully. I almost feel sorry for him. Almost. But not quite.
Did Howard said anything about all those stick-figures that paraded the stage? Some even admitting to starving themseles for the show. That can't be health either. What about it Howard ?
Stern is right on the money! Hollywood loves themselves so much, and Opra should be ashamed of herself exploiting that girl like she has. Opra loves her self and thinks she is the greatest, she is not!
I think Stern is right in what he said. The more you beat around the bush and pussy foot around things, the more they do not get done. If you dont like the words.. MOVE ON. Enough said.
a huge deal is made of anorexic actors and actresses being poor role models...with the state of pediatric obesity today...the other extreme is just as deadly...
from other reports, she is open to getting healthy, and when she does, it will make her twice the role model – for first, accepting who she is in the present without defining herself in pounds....and second, for taking the opportunity to turn her health around.
Oh boo hoo.
Stern said the exact same thing every one of you complainers said when you saw here on stage or the red carpet. Bunch of posers acting all concerned.
At first I was thinking the same thing until I realized that the same could be said of Moni'que, Queen Latifah, Oprah, Jill Scott, etc. All who are successful as actress/celebrities on some level. Regardless of the "reasons/issues" behind it, black women are more comfortable with being plus sized and the public is more comfortable with plus sized black women. Now if she had been a young white actress Howard may have had a point.
Seeriously....The last person that should be making fun of somebodys appearance is Howard Stern.
lol, and it's stuff like this that makes stern so fun to listen to.
Tim, Jenny, moon627: What does Stern's looks have to do with it? His looks wont kill him, her weight is killing her.
I agree with Mr Stern completely! Does it really matter that he didn't sugar coat it? Is there any way to have said this without it sounding mean? There are enough people lying to this poor girl, and I'm sure she knows that!
Why do people get so upset when they hear the truth? I told my wife the exact same thing...after the Oscars, we will never see that girl again. Stop with all the PC crap. The truth is the truth, no matter how it is delivered. Some of the funniest comedians that ever lived, were funny because they spoke the truth, openly and honestly. If Obama had said the same thing, everyone would feel all warm inside, but Howard Stern, OH MY. Get over yourselves.
It's Howard Stern what do you expect and to be perfectly honest he is right and said what most of us were thinking after Oprah's less than honest speech. What roles will she be up for? She is so young and her health will get worse each month the way she is going.
.....I hate to say this, I never watch Stern because he is beyond words mean and rude BUT I cringe when I see Gabby on TV. She is so young to be so heavy – it really wouldn't be right at any age. She said that she was going to hit Chick Fila "hard" when the Oscar's were over. I think she does care, especially now, about her appearance but probably feels she needs to act nonchalant about it. I hope that someone who really cares about her will lead her to a more nutritous lifestyle. Maybe Oprah spoke with her about this, but maybe she didn't. Monique lost some weight so maybe she can mentor her. She did deserve accolades for her performance though. She did nothing to deserve the way Stern talked about her. Shame on him, as usual.
what howard said is simply true. the fact that ppl gt upset about HOW he said it is a waste of time. so if he was tip toe-ing and politically correct, his opinion would be more valid? that's crazy. and he's right about oprah too; she is totally lying and pandering to the girl. this girl will not be in another movie of this magnitude; it just won't happen. it's not even a bad thing; hollywood values looks and sexiness mostly above talent. howard is just keeping it rea, AS USUAL, and if ppl can't handle it, that's on them.
True, she can lose weight. However, ugly goes way to the bone. Stern is/was/will always be a loser. Having money doesn't change that.
never accuse Howard of not being a straight shooter. The girls mom has been quoted as saying her daughter has 3 new movies in production already. She is heavier than John Candy was when he keeled over. Perhaps Mrs. Obama can make her the poster child of her child obesity program.
From the businessman stand point, the comments were accurate and down to earth. People need to stop buttering things up using race or gender as excuses and concentrate in the reality. Howard: you rule! besides of being so handsome you are very very smart.
Howard Stern is not the hottest guy around, but he's healthy. That' was the point.
I'm going to agree. A body so obese as Sidebe's is not lovely to look at.
So does this mean we can talk about all of the ugly actors and actresses? Because there are plenty out there. We can say "Look here Honey, you're ugly. Since you have some money, go make yourself pretty. its not healthy being ugly. You scare people and have low self esteem. Go get that fixed..."
The truth hurts.
Sterns a shock jock, he wasnt ever going to say the truth in any "polite" manner...this is what he does. Agree or disagree, but there's nothing healthy or good about someone being that size, young or old.
I still think its hilarious that we can treat Smokers like lepers, but not fat people
She may be fat, but he is UGLY........and she can diet.
As much as I detest Howard Stern, the fact is that he IS speaking the truth here, and there is simply no way to sugar-coat that message. If anything, it should be sugar-coated, so maybe she'll hear it. There is no way to have a long and healthy life with that kind of obesity. She will die, and soon, if she doesn't lose weight. She may very well be loaded with acting talent, but what good will it do her if she can't work? She's going to have a heckuva time getting insured to work due to her obvious dangerous health, so not only is she limiting her roles to "enormously obese women" (few and far between in Hollywood), most productions won't hire her because they can't get her insured. I hope she hears the message and does what she needs to do to get healthy. She has the opportunity to BE a Cinderella story, IF she does that! I hope she does.
Hoawrd Stern is brutally honest and always has been. Either you appreciate that or you don't.
OOOOOhhh maaaaannn... i cant believe he said this lmao.. Its sooo wrong what he said but he aint lying... I really thought like howard did when oprah said that... Hopefully she does use that money she made in trying to lose weight and not on FAST FOOD...
I am a large woman myself working on getting fit, trim and healthy. I applaud Gabby for being such a strong woman–you can't be a frail little thing to make it in Hollywood and I do believe that she will continue with a career. You can disguise talent. I do hope she gets healthier for her own sake but she will always be talented and beautiful.
So he figures that now that she has some money she should go and get thin. Maybe she should but that's her decision not his, not ours. What's his excuse then? He's got money so why doesn't he go and get some work done so he doesn't look like a dog's breakfast anymore. Seriously, the guy is the ugliest guy I've ever seen!
There is a difference between having genuine worry for someone and using their appearance as an attention getter on your radio show. There is no reason for Stern to have said these things. For all he knows she may have just started a diet or workout plan. Of course Oprah wouldn't say anything like that, she has TACT! That is just something you should never talk about, and it is really none of his business.
Its not about selling magazines to rich white women. ITs about the truth. Obese people are a health risk and soon to be a drain on taxer payers thanks to OBAMA care. I don't like Stern - but he has a point - America - not just her - lose the weight.
he is the most butt-ugly man on the planet and he has the gall to talk about her weight?
I've never been a fan of Stern's, but everyone knows by now that he does not hold back what he's thinking. To act shocked by these remarks is ridiculous. While I don't condone his attack on a young woman who is experiencing the best time of her life, I have to say that he is correct. There will not be a flood of offers for Miss Sidibe, regardless of her talent. Just as Marlee Matlin did not suddenly star in a slew of movies about deaf people after her Oscar win for Children of a Lesser God, neither will there be a demand for more dramas about a morbidly obese young African-American women. It's just not gonna happen. Miss Sidibe would be wise to take care of her health, regardless of how it affects her career–the future is never bright for someone as heavy as she is.
Do you people not think that she knows she needs to lose weight? It's probably what she thinks about all day. It's easier said than done to lose weight.
Yech, blech, ewwwwww.
I've never been able to tolerate Stern. I tried to listen to him years ago because it was cool, but I couldn't fake it. He's slimy and he uses/abuses other people to get recognition/attention.
The other day I had the misfortune to hear him berate Jay Leno about the Tonight Show. I'm fine with Stern's opinion that Jay should have backed out; I don't agree, but it's nothing to me what someone else thinks. But Stern had to absolutely blast the guy in such a low, slimeball way.
I don't see why Stern had to blast Sidibe – what was the need? What did we all gain by hearing that? The only thing and his true reason is to get attention.
He's a disgusting individual who doesn't deserve to be where he is.
Howard Stern is absolutely correct, like it or not. I thought the exact same things while listening to Oprah's sickening patronization of that grossly obese woman. The truth is that Sidibe should never have been cast in the first place, and obesity should never be glorified in any way. Hollywood liberals are more interested in making themselves feel like "the good guys" than in sending obese people the proper message – that they should lose weight for the sake of their own health, not to mention the solvency of our health care system.
I am a black woman who loves Howard Stern. He's the best thing that happened to radio and I miss him dearly on terrestrial radio.
Having said that, Gaby is simply too big. She is too big for any age. When I see her, I see someone crying out for help. This role was very specific and will not come around again. So, if she expects to get other roles, she must lose the weight.
BTW-did anyone hear her say that the first stop after the Oscars would be Chic-Fila? She even noted there was one approximately 15 miles from her hotel and that she would be "hitting it hard" after the show. Now come on??
Stern you SUCK!!! like you look great to be talking about someone else. People – really – you have got to stop this kind of talk. Bad crap happens for no good reason. Peoples' bodies are their own business. Repress the urge to comment on their appearance and what they are or are not doing with them. No, you shouldn't judge a person by their appearance. Who are we to judge. We don't know if that person is on medication or has a medical condition that causes them to have a weight problem or whatever. But, the problem is that society has fashioned us to be judgemental and that's a shame. We are not put here on this earth to judge others and we know who the real judge is. YOU SHOULD THINK BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH!!!
Hey, CNN, she is not an Oscar "winner", she did not win. Why cant you guys get facts straight?
Howard Stern should talk. He is one ugly man. Inside and out.
Howard Stren should take a good look at him self he is butt ugly I would rather be fat than ugly dosen't he know that is a very hurtfull thing to say to any body all of you who have put her down because of her weight shame on you who do you think you are GOD you should be saying helpful things to get her on the right track.
Kathy San Francisco Ca
They included Army Archered, but snubbed Dominic Dunne. That broke my heart more than Farrah.
I'm sure she's heard far worse and it hasn't stopped her before.
Howard's all mad because he didn't get the AI gig, so he has to pick on real easy targets to make himself feel better.
Howard is a pathetic excuse for a human.
I wish it was not true, but it is true. Time will tell...if she gets another role, it will be about her weight. And, let's face it...I love Oprah, but one day she will be doing a show about losing weight, and the next day calling her a role model??? I love Stern, and he's harsh, yes, but he doesn't mince words, he will make fun of himself just as quick. He tells it like it is, and this is how it is...
Come on guys! There are so many roles out there for her to be in. She can play a role as a Killer Whale in the next Free Willy Part 6 movie. Or perhaps she can be one of Eddy Murphy's sisters in The Nutty Proffesor Part or whatever. The future looks bright!
Howard did say what everyone else s probably thinking, but she does have a right to pursue a career in movies. She did a good job in her part.
Some of the problem is people like the red carpet interviewers who kept telling her how fantastic she looked in her gown. I'm sorry but those are ridiculous statements. How can anyone that over weight look good in anything! I'm sorry but that is the truth. She is not a good role model. She needs to lose weight and get healthy, or at least try, then she is a good role model. But you have to give her credit for making it that far in a very hard industry.
Stern is a genius. i hate the man and Opie and Anthony said this before he did that morning.. however. she is a fat mess and needs to do something. its disgusting to look at.
If Stern was so concerned for her health and career, he could've talked to her privately, sent her an email, gave her a call, or contacted her agent. There are many ways to get in touch with someone and give them a message of concern besides airing it on the radio. If he really cared, he would take her under his wing and be a mentor for her, get her in touch with others in the entertainment industry so that she can continue with her career...that's if you really cared.
I don't care about Stern either way. Only time I see him in the news is when there is controversy. So good on Stern to know how to work the press, media and the public.
As for Gabourey Sidibe...she is fat. No doubt about it. In fact, she is freakin enourmous. So what! It's her life.
What is this obsession with verbalizing every thought? These comments just did not need to be said at all.
I am definitely not a Howard Stern fan...but after about 15 years of hearing some of his comments, it sounds like he finally got one right. I'm a fat-blank myself, but I know to get the most out of my life, I need to lose weight. To think, or be told by someone (Oprah), that everything is ok is disingenuous at best. Stern was simply telling it as he sees it.
JD
Howard Stern did something that not everyone agrees with? No way.
Let it go people. He is a "shock jock". She's a big girl. I couldn't help but think how limited her career is in her current state. It's not like there's going to be a Precious II.
Before anyone jumps on the race card train, don't. This has nothing to do with her being African American. Huge white women don't have a place in Hollywood really either.
If you don't like Stern, just remember this kind of publicity only makes him bigger. The best thing that could be done is to ignore him.
Stern said what so many of us were thinking, and possibly even said out loud when we saw her at the Oscars. Get over it.
Sure what he said is true, but just because something is true does not mean it should be said. Hey Stern if that's what gets your rocks off go ahead and say it, just don't be surprised if someone breaks your nose for saying something similar someday.
Michelle Obama should put her on a poster for child obesity.
Agreed. She's gross to look at, and she'll never have a leading role again unless she loses about 200 pounds.
If I want to see fat ugly people, I'll go to Wal-Mart. I don't need to pay $10 to see them in a movie.
Pamela, girl.....You hit the nail on the head...I black too..I know for a fact she ain't gon' be on anything else..UNLESS somebody black is puttin' her in their movies.. Like I told my mother and sister HOLLYWOOD isn't for people like Gabby.. She gon' have to LIGHTEN her skin, loose some weight and get plastic surgery for touch ups.......When BERNIE MAC first came out on DEF COMEDY JAM that man was too black...When HOLLYWOOD got a hold of em' YALL TELL ME HIS SKIN DID GET A LIL' BIT LIGHTER.....It is what it is...
He speaks the truth, something most of you are afraid to hear and think is "mean". Stern says is like it is and is a very smart man, you should listen to him.
Stern is a total cretin, but he gave good advice. A chick her size has no future in Hollyweird, and is facing serious health problems in the near future. Her next stop should be The Biggest Loser.
First of all, Sterns show is a pay service. It's not public radio so he can say whatever he wants. IF he had called a super skinny girl "too thin, and she's never gonna get another part unless she puts on some weight", he'd be touted as a forward thinker, speaking the truth.
Either way, why freak out on Stern.. the public should speak out on all the movie producers that are still going to hire the Jessica Biels of the world, even though Gabourey is probably a much better actress (no offense Jessica).
Chris Farley had a pretty good movie career being over weight....
Howard Stern has been saying stuff like this for YEARS people. How is this news?
She is just America's new darling, and because Oprah approves, everyone cares.
Is there anybody left on the planet that doesn't know that Howard Stern says controversial things? This is hardly the most controversial thing he's had to say and I find it hard to believe there's actually enough of a backlash to warrant this story (hence the fact there are only 10 comments over the last hour). More likely, the author/editor has some personal vendetta against Stern...which wouldn't be a new thing.
The appeal of Stern is his brutal honesty. That is why his ratings are through the roof despite so many people seriously hating him. Because the other half LOVE him. This world has gotten so PC and sensitive that few tell it like it is anymore. We turn to Howard for that to give us a break from all the BS. Sidibe isn't just plump or "non-Hollywood" thin. She isn't even a lady who needs to loose some weight. She is morbidly, seriously unhealthy obese. She is probably 3x the weight she should be and she is a terrible role model in a country where kids are getting fatter every day. You want to know why our health care system is so broke? Because people eat crap all day, every day. And Sidibe represents the worst of the worst. She needs a damn intervention is what she needs or her joints and bones will crumble under all the pressure. She can do it, but she needs to start NOW.
I listen to him everyday and I have to say I agree with him. Although she's just been cast in a showtime series. I don't agree with his delivery, but isn't that the beauty of free speech. He can say what he wants and we all get to agree or disagree as we so choose.
To those who hate Howard Stern, but posting comments. You are giving him the attention that makes him famous for. It's not all about what he says, but what others comment about what he says. Thanks for the support !! Stern only says it like it is. We just think it, but he says it for us.
Stern is the best, not afraid to say what he feels and what most Americans think. He is the only famous person that will truly tell it like it is and he is right 100% of the time.... Thank you Howard you are the best!!
I'm a devoted Howard fan, but also recognize that in mainstream print his comments come across as downright mean. So I understand non- Howard fans – I felt that way when I first heard him 25 years ago. You have to get him to find it hilarious. BTW – You think he's mean to her, he's 1000 x worse on himself so he's under no illusion that he's Brad Pitt. With all the "Idol" and Leno news he's making I guess his stuff is getting more attention. Bababooey to you all.
Well maybe she can go into radio like he did. If he thinks she doesn't have the looks for acting.....well neither does he. He is truly a loser. She is a highly educated young woman and she can do anything in show business she wants....acting isn't the only thing to do. What a jackass!!!!
Clearly Mr. Stern is not the sharpest tool in the shed. True, many of us might have been thinking the same as what was said by Stern but most of us have some level of tact and common sense to know that you just 'don't go there that way'. Let's face it; a real man doesn't digress into a 12 year old mean-spirted schoolyard bully.
This guy is an idiot. Who is he to criticize her? He should take a look in the mirror. One could say he needs to act his age or that he should eat something. Who are we to say what weight is unhealthy? If an obese person doesn't have weight related medical conditions or weight is preventing an obese person from being successful like Sidibe, then we can't say they are unhealthy. A person can be very healthy and still be overweight. It's called genetics. Society has a warped sense of what is healthy or beautiful. Society sees the stick think women as what is beautiful and that is not what beauty is. Beauty is so much more than whats on the outside as that's only window dressing. Stern needs to get a clue and learn what true beauty is.
I can't comment but I thought you'd find this funny.
Stern is the reason I do not have Sirius. What a jackass.
And this is the guy people want to replace Simon on American Idol? Give me a break.
He's saying it how it is no matter how un-comfortable it makes some of you.. its the truth whether you like it or not... I mean you can pretend shes beautiful and has a career if you want to.. but you know the truth..
Stern cares little about this woman's health ... his history doesn't support that excuse for making this comments.
As such we should not give him a pass. Most of his listeners will not condem him for this. However, anytime he reaches beyond his radio show on Sirrius, the rest of us should DENY him any perks, opportunities, etc. (no more hosting of award shows, etc.)
He is a Slimeball.
I'm surprise Howard could even see her with that big nose in the way. I'm sure his legions of fan (yes, singular) laughed his hiney off.
If she lost some weight, Stern wouldn't be making these remarks. Let's place the blame where it belongs, people. On her.
Stern has a point, but it could have been made much more kindly. As a healthcare provider, I cna tell you that shaming people does not help the situation. There are positive ways to get people to buy into improving their health. She did not need to be insulted.
I hate the way he said it and it was downright mean and he picked an easy target but I have to admit it – he is right. She isn't going to get mainstream roles ever....at her size even though she is young and has an amazing personality all people are going to see are her size and you don't want her to be doing these downtrodden poor roles all the time. For that she has to lose some weight to be mainstream. She doesn't have to be reed thin but given the fake standards of Hollywood anything beyond zero would be a big size.As an overweight woman I understand how hard it is in the normal world so for a movie star, its a death sentence. Even Monique for all her talk about being big and liking it lost a lot of her weight. So for us to get to really see Gabourey's true talent, she has to reduce....it may not be fair but its how the world is...especially the movie world...
Duh!!! She has already finished her second movie. Know what you are talking about before you shoot off at the lip.
These comments by Howard Stern is an insult to this young lady. How crude and heartless of him to have the audacity to say this publicly. How would he like it if someone publicly told him he looked liked a "gay, washed up, and worn out mop hanging on a thin and frail body"? Sure, Gabby needs to tone her weight down...couldn't agree with that more. But to insult this young lady and criticize her weight in the public limelight is down right crude. And to say that she will never get a role in another movie, well, no one knows that for sure. Because to me, doors are being open for her all because of her starring role in "Precious". But one thing Gabby said which made me comment on to myself was this: When she mentioned she was going to Chick-Fil-A during the red carpet interview, I made the comment to myself that she didn't need to go there but instead to a salad bar. Other than that, she had a memorable and unforgettable night, I'm sure, sitting amongst the biggest stars in Hollywood.
Who cares what scumbag Howard Stern thinks? I didn't even tead the article!
She already has roles lined up, guys. Do some fact checking.
Stern hit the nail on the head, especially with Oprah. She is an example of so many in this country, this planet, that when the "audience is listening," they act like the weight issue is simply not an issue. Why is it that if you are at a table with some friends and one or two out of six say "would you mind if I say grace" and most say "no, not at all." When in fact they do mind. I was one of them. Now I am saying "yes I do mind" thanks for asking. You should see the looks I get. Why? Same thing here, if you are this overweight why should anyone hide the obvious health issues as well as the reality that Hollywood does not support overweight people, only the stars act like they do. It is my belief that like the agnostic or the atheist, they too can be offended, why do most seem to think that they shouldn't? Along with that, Stern is only saying (like others here have already said) what everyone else is thinking, who cares how he says it, it's true isn't it? We have all heard this: "truth hurts sometimes." And with that, "don't blame the messenger."
Howard Stern is tremendous. If 99% of the people were as intelligent, straightforward, entertaining and honest as he was- we'd be in a much better place. Instead, the world is filled with scam artists, liars and corrupt morons. Good for you, Howard. I actually said to my girlfriend during that moment in the show- I bet in 3 years she'll be at 150 lbs and, if so, she will have a good acting career. But she has to get a trainer and a nutritionist– she should be able to afford it now.
If americans could be honest with themselves, we wouldn't need people like Howard Stern. I'm not a fan, and I don't typically agree with him, but at the moment Oprah said that about her, I looked at my wife and said "what the hell is she talking about? Exactly how many leading roles are there out there for a morbidly obese actress?" It was an enormously patronizing and self serving remark by Winfrey. What she was really saying was: look how wonderful I am to have found this person know one else would look twice at, and I made her a star!" She is well aware of how Hollywood works, and knows full well what awaits Sidibe in terms of her career.
I think the real villain in this case is Oprah, for encouraging this extremely unhealthy person to feel like, "a Cinderella" when she is a poster child for childhood obesity so rampant in America right now. If anything, perhaps Mr. Stern's harsh spotlight may shock her into saving her own life. While there may be gentler ways to have done it, Oprah's indulgences have not helped in the slightest. "Precious" wrapped MONTHS ago and she is larger, no smaller. I vote for a big slap over encouraging hugs based on that observation.
That said, what a terrific story it would be to watch this talented person take on obesity and win. Even were she to get to Mo'nique's size, it would be a fabulous achievement and then, yes, she would have a career.
anyone on this blog this is against howard on this topic is the real loser here. anyone with half a heart should agree that this chick is a few chicken wings away from a heart attack and she needs some serious help fast. she will never be in another movie, but congrats to her for her 15 mins of fame. howard has earned the right to speak his mind about anything. and all you people trying to be nice are thinking the same thing he said, you just voice your opinions against it because you think that makes you a good person. news flash, it doesnt. if there is a god, he knows your true thoughts on the matter.
As a person who is overweight myself, I know what she must be going through internally. But she is a very fine actress with a great education. She speaks clearly and articulates well. Will there be many more roles for her if she does not lose the weight? Probably not. But this role was made for her and it showed that heavy people have some of the same traumas skinny folks do. The movie was uplifting and ended on a positive note. Pray God it ends that way for Gabourey in real life. But what will Howard Stern do tomorrow and the rest of his days? He will still be just an ugly, overbearing and stereotypical jackass!
I think underneath Howard's mean spirited remark, the ugly truth lies. And I do agree with him that if Ms. Winfrey wanted to really help this young women, she would take her to the under her wing and introduce her to a trainer and nutritionist.
Wonder if fat is worse than ugly, fat can be lost, major plastic surgery would have to be done for that face Stern was cursed with. Hair too, looks like a mangy cave man. Guess you can see I don't like him, nasty , nasty, should be in jail as a pervert.
So Sean Penn wishing rectal cancer on people that he has issues with is Hollywood cool?
March 9th, 2010 3:08 pm ET
"This is why I don't listen to his show, never saw his movie and refuse to spend anymore gray matter on him."
apart from commenting on news articles about him, of course
Stern is just telling it like it is. Some people just cant face the truth.
If Stern had no outer issues I can maybe understand where he is coming from. He is not exactly a Brad Pitt look alike. Maybe some one needs to tell him to do something with that mop on his head, or get a nose job. And he could dress a lot better than he does. So there Howard baby how does that feel to you. No one has the right to judge another person not even him. That is God's job. If he were really sincere he would offer her support and help in losing weight.
its not like she doesnt know that she is fat......
we need to get more people to stop saying "you are beautiful on the inside" and more people saying "you can be beautiful if you get off your fat ass and do something"
this type of mentality for morbidly obese people is why our country is full of fat asses!
Stern is right.
Howard is always lazy until contract renewal time comes. Now he's in the news every week. He plays the media like chumps.
He's a genius at self promotion.
thank you, Pamela, you're right on the money.
Oprah is far more insulting to her by lying and patronizing that actress right to her face. Why doesn't Oprah just tell her that she thinks she's stupid enough to buy that garbage? I'm sick of the self righteously sympathetic patronizing tone of certain famous people like oprah. Give me a break. That girl is morbidly obese. It does her no good to just placate her and feel sorry for her. It's much more sincere and helpful to be straight with her. She IS talented, but she's also really fat, to the point of being a threat to her life. There's nothing mean about saying that!! If someone had a drug problem and you cared enough to speak up, most wouldn't consider that being mean, right?
There is plenty of room for human dignity in this discussion without denying the truth that is right in front of our faces.
Howard Stern = GOD
I agree with him 100-percent. Although I wouldn't have been so harsh. I do think she'll get another role or too, but she'll be extremely type-cast and once the buzz around her dies down, she won't be able to find anything else.
I really do hope she loses weight though. Not for her acting career but for her health. She seems like an extremely sweet, down to Earth girl and it would be a shame to see her life cut short, or have a life full of ailments due to her weight.
Hey Stern-now that you've got a little money in the bank, why don't you go and fix your beak? -see, I am sure everyone was thinking it......
even as correct (for once) as stern is in this instance, quit giving this low life press!
Stern rules, nobody else would have the ballz to say what he does. Thats why people like him so much.
Telling it like it is should never involve the lact of tact. Especially if you feel that you are "saying it for their own good". There is never an excuse for nastiness. Also, to attack her career??? She was great in the movie and she was also beautiful in the "W" magazine spread as well.
whoooo!
Ok – Yes she is overweight and yes this is not good for her health – but do you know if she hasn't been trying to lose weight? I have been fighting my weight all my life and I am very succesful, smart and recognized woman – It is NOT so easy for some of us – It is not matter of money or laziness or nonwilingness – Society should undestand that people come all sizes and shapes as flowers and animals do – and Hollywood should include people from all shapes and colors in their magazine pages or movies – Only then people like Stern would learn how to respect us – ANd BRAVO to Gabouree for doing a great job with this movie and I hope we see more from her
"A very beautiful, smart, Big, white woman "
Like him or not, he's right.
Is he wrong? What did he say that wasnt true.... and if she listens and gets help, she will be thanking him in 10-20 or more years. It took a person I respected to tell me I was fat...and I changed...and that one rude comment helped me get my life back. Thank you howard!!
Stern can be funny at times, but don't go to him for health or relationship counseling.
At least she can lose the weight. Stern can't lose ugly!
If you disagree, you:
A: dislike Mr. Stern
B: are overweight
C: cant handle the truth
D: are a combination of A,B,C
If you agree, you:
A: like Mr. Stern
B: are in relatively healthy shape
C: can handle the truth
D. are a comination of A,B,C
Stern is correct! Obesity equals premature death. Furthermore, being a celebrity requires at least a hint of attractiveness. This whale on the beach has none and the public should not have to be subjected to her oh beast ness.
Someone get Howard a mirror......quick!
Thank you Howard. She is a great actress and we want her around for a long time. Go on a diet and get some exercise. We don't buy the old crap "slow metabolism", the real issue is the speed at she feeds herself. Go see a dietitian, get a personal trainer, and show everyone what an outstanding, healthy person you are. Drop a hundred pounds. Save your life.
I agree with Howard. The whole Oscar show is filled with people saying what other people want to hear. She seems like a lovely person and may be a fine actress, but she should focus on her health before she focuses on trying to find her next movie.
We humans pretend too much. Instead of honestly saying the truth which could save her life people are telling her she is at the beginning of a brilliant career when really they know that if she does not lose weight that her life will be a lot shorter. Howard Stern may save her life if she will listen to him. If she loses weight down to 150lbs or less she definitely would be at the beginning of a brilliant career. If not she will be in bad health and die young. The world needs people that are politically incorrect to tell it like it really is in reality. It would be a terrible world if everyone robotically said only things people want to hear.
Gabourey Sidibe is to overweight what Stern is to ugly.
At least Gabourey Sidibe's is proportional. Can't say that about Stern's nose.
Gabourey Sidibe is to talent what Stern is to no talent.
Listened to his show once for 5 minutes about 20 years ago. Never listened again and never will. Stern is a nobody in the world of class. His name and $ come from trash.
Stern is right, also honest. Who is going hire this balloon for another role? Unless Free Willy 10 is being shot, nobody. Get real Oprah and her bag of s*^% about this one hit wonder.
I hope she does get healthier but I think Stern is a nasty man. Don't you think that poor girl is painfully aware of her size already? Don't you think her doctors are talking to her about this already? Who died and made you the ultimate messenger to save this girl, Mr. Stern. You know you only said it for the publicity and ratings. You may not be fat but you're certainly an ugly man and I'm not talking about your looks, I'm talking about your cold, black heart.
Good for you Howard! He is dead on with that assessment of her. Morbidly obese people need help just like he said. Obesity has become way to prevalent in our society. People should not be celebrated for being so large.
At least Gabourey Sidibe can lose weight Howard Stern will always be ugly!
He was only telling the truth....she is not plus size, she is morbidly obese!!!! She is only 26, if she doesn't do anything now, she will die young!!!
he is right but downright mean.. She knows how big she is but she thinks she's beautiful...so leave her alone. Wasn't necessary to hurt her.
Why doesn't he do something about his looks.
Look, anyone who thinks that that girl, as nice and as talented as she may be, will get another job in Hollywood, is kidding themselves. My first thought on seeing her was that she's not going to live very long. She must weigh 400 pounds, and anyone who thinks that isn't a problem probably also weighs 400 pounds. Stern just said what anyone with an ounce of common sense would think, she's young and she's enormous and she's going to be dead in a few years. Very sad, but true.
WHY do we continue to give this man an audience? He is so pathetically insecure that he has get everyone riled up just so he will be noticed. How pathetic!
Brenda- you must be kidding me. Because she is healthy now, (which you don't even know, by the way) there is nothing wrong with her being morbidly obese? So all of that research showing the long term effects of obesity- heart disease, diabetes, etc., is all wrong, and we should just leave fat people alone? This isn't a case of America worshiping skinny women (which they do) or what true beauty is. This isn't a case of a woman with a minor weight issue. This woman is seriously, chronically, morbidly obese, and statistics overwhelmingly show she will have health issues related to this problem sooner rather than later.
I don't know what country Stern and some readers here live in, but I live in the US where these days 65 percent of adults are overweight or obese and about 16 percent of all children and teens overweight. We live in a country where processed food, refined sugar and fast food is cheaper than healthy food. The fact of the matter is that many American's simply can not afford fresh fruits, vegetables and lean meats especially in this economy. Obesity (and related health problems) is a societal problem not a personal moral problem.
That being said, it is a shame that there are not more roles for larger people in movies and television. They reflect the true America. Not the skinny actors and models that look closer to people in starving third world countries.
Stern, you're a pig........go back into your trough
I'm fat, always have been. I'm also old. That is to say, I'm not dead and I've been fat a long time without getting the diabetes, heart attack or stroke. In fact, other than being an eyesore to people like Howard Stern and the readers here, I'm super-duper healthy. I would never, ever, ever go on T.V. or strive to be famous in any way because of people like Howard Stern who make fun of fat people because it's expected of them and it's fun and it's not against the law.
I hate Howard. I was so glad he went to Sirius so I don't have to listen to him anymore. I do have to agree though every time I look at her. I love her ...but worry that at that weight she won't be with us much longer. Hey there's always Dr Oz or she could hit the reality circuit, Celebrity Fit Club or create a her own reality show to lose weight like Kristie Ally or Ruby. I'd watch it. All the best to her. Shut up Howard.
People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones, Howard.
As for women of size, unless the role specifies a particular height/weight, what does it matter? Miss Hattie McFaniel had a long career, her roles limited not because of her size but color at the time. Do we even know if Ms Sidibe WANTS an acting career? IIRC she went to the audition on a lark. She seems to have her head screwed on right for now. Good for her
What he's saying kinda seems like the point of the movie. Because people like her are and have been discounted so much for their size, skin color, etc. He's just reinforcing the painful things that the movie was trying to defeat in my opinion. And the fact that someone like her could be a best actress nominee should tell you that she should not be discounted. Besides, for all we know she could be much healthier than Howard. He seems dangerously skinny and I doubt he's in the gym before his radio show on the stairmaster.
I could not agree with Stern more. I think she is a cool story and a down to earth person BUT she is morbidly obese and needs help. No one has the balls to call it like they see it.
The difference between Howard Stern (an asshole) and Gabourey Sidibe (obese) is that Ms. Sidibe can lose weight while Stern will always be a low class, rat faced, asshole. By the way, has he ever considered having his physical flaws corrected? Some teeth whitening, an eyebrow lift and a stylist perhaps?
Amen, Pamela!
Not a great big fan of Stern, but I have to agree with this....... He is not picking on a easy target PLEASE....... He is just telling it the way it is....and do you really think that woman looked beautiful?? come-on ...She did a good job in that movie...end of it... and lose the beauty people...................
While Howard said this in a brutally honest, harsh manner, that doesn't change the fact that he is correct about being overweight or obese. It is not healthy and if you love yourself, you need to change it.
Love him or hate him, you know the man is right. Even if it sickens you deep down.
What all of you fail to realize..is that Howard Stern makes these comments to get publicity. May I remind you he really has not been in the news for a while so...boom; he see an op. to get press and we follow up with indignation which leads to more press.
1- she already has completed another film, and another is in post production and 2- had she been thin, she would have never been considered for the role of Precious.
Stern is a hyocritical idiot. Why does he pick on the young girl? There are overweight young actors as well. He picks on her because he is a punk! He is no genius. He is a vile and pathetic person.
Who cares if you agree she if is large. its none of your business. Everyone is different . Who cares about anyone's opinion if she want to she will take it up with her doctor and I do agree though that your head is shaped like a knuckle....
Sorry, that's Hattie McDANIEL.
I am not too fussy about Stern either but when someone is right, even if he is not SWEET while he is telling it the way it is, this young person will not live to see another ten years of life if she does not do something about her excessive weight. Maybe if Oprah, instead of telling her a pack of lies, told her the truth and offered to pay for some weight loss help for her, she could save her life!!!!!
Mary
Howard Stern is a completely tactless person. He's also a pretty horribly rude, and unhealthy person as well, at least in terms of the way he goes about expressing whats on his mind and the way he looks at life. If I had to choose between a young girl, who walked down the red carpet on a televised event (broadcast to millions), after giving her absolute best in a film with a performance that was nominated for an oscar, or him – I would pretty much ask her what she thinks about her future, her career and her weight. He's a dumbass. Never had any interest in what he has to say, and still don't.
Accountability in American Society, you obviously have never listened to the show.
He has encouraged his staff time and time again to diet and get in proper shape. He screams from the towers about Coke and McDonald's and how terrible these foods are that we put in our bodies.
He tells women who objectify themselves that they are likely only doing it because of a troubled childhood or some sort of embalance (even though he then has them take their clothes off).
The fact is that he is 100% correct about this young woman and, although it was a little harsh, hopefully she takes his advice and tries to take care of herself a little more.
Several points: (1) Why, why does anyone bother to report anything said by the totally irrelevant Howard Stern? (2) He's a small-minded, big-mouth jerk who likes to say negative things about people, (3) Yes, it's true that this young lady would benefit health-wise, and in Hollywood career-wise, by weight loss, but the Howard Stern show is not the proper format to address that issue. I'm quite sure that the people who are close to, and love, Miss Sidibe are quite capable of speaking with her about those issues. Howard could have chosen to take the high road and congratulate this young woman on a job well done, but as usual he couldn't drag himself out of the gutter!
Howard is a jerk and always has been. So he's not fat, let's get some of HIS skeletons out and look at them. As for the LADY that won the OSCAR......I'm sure she's a fine person and sweet as hell, but I have to admit....I'm sick and tired of seeing more and more women in this county with fat asses. It's no wonder the kids are fat....what do most of them have for an example.
Obesity is the last legitimate form of descrimination. You make fun or comment on someone's skin colour, sex, disability, sexual orientation and you are crucified and told how horrible and politically incorrect you are for having an opinion on or making inappropriate comments on the issue. And yet it is okay for anyone to make fun of someone who is overweight – a physical attribute that, believe it or not, not everyone can control. Over 32% of Americans are obese...another 30% are defined as being 'overweight'. Until we realize that Big Food and the farming methods of our so-called 'advanced' civilization are a large part of this downfall – Americans (and peoples all over the world) will see obesity continue to rise. And sadly, our children will now be the first generation to have a shorter life expectancy than their parents.
IF you don't agree with what Howard has to say, then reply to the news posting... and post your height and weight... I am a fat person at 6' 2" and 300 pounds... but I agree with him.
Really? Seems to me that Jorge Garcia has a career. Chris Farley had a career. Heck, Oprah herself is not a small woman half the time and she's the richest woman in America. Seth Rogen. Roseanne Barr. Queen Latifah. Dom DeLuise. John Candy. I could go on. We get it, Howard. You're married to a skinny, blonde model. But most of the world isn't that and Hollywood has shown that there is room for people who aren't.
Stern is right and yes he's a shock jock people....Duh. He's paid to entertain and say things about other celebs in an uncomplimentry way...Just like Oprah says nice things even if they arent true or ever going to happen... Oprah is the real villian...
Stern is a truth teller and he told the truth and the truth does hurt some people sometimes. But he told his listeners who pay for it..
So if you dont like it. Shut up and dont pay for hearing it...
The media is going to try and spin it like another Don Imus comment. The facts are facts...she is fat and unhealthy and probally wont get another roll in hollywood so Oprah what movie are you going to put her in next. Really we all want to know since you layed it out there in front of millions watching the Oscars...Where is her career going to next...Maybe a talk show in Chicago....sure why not they gave you one oprah when you wheeled out meat on a wagon to show how much weight you lost...
i agree with howard stern. people always like to say bad things about him but he is the ONE person who speaks the truth no matter how much of a taboo it is to say the things. he was on point about these comments. the girl is grossly overweight and if she doesnt get some help she wont be around for too much longer.
as far as her acting career..i dont really see her as much of a film presence. quite frankly i am sick to my stomach of hearing oprah winfrey always try to push her opinions on everyone else. of course there is a certain joy to see an african-american woman being nominated but he talent compared to the other nominees was like comparing a professional athlete to a little league player. GET IT together oprah!
Garbage in...garbage out...I really do not understand why people listen to this person...
Howard Stern doesn't say things just because they are true, or to be mean, or to be nice, or to be politically correct or incorrect. He says whatever he thinks will get HIS NAME in the news, thereby increasing his ratings and his paycheck. It works, doesn't it? If he bothers to read these postings at all, he'll probably laugh all the way to the bank (or to the bank's Web site in this day and age).
I love how people are making fun of Howard Stern's looks considering he is the first one to rip himself apart for being so ugly. Keep on ignoring how truthful he was if it makes you feel better.
He needs to take a look at himself.
It's the truth. I love you Howard.
Howard Stern is right, absolutely right. He is saying what we are all thinking. She has no future in show business, at least not in a leading role.
Quit eating like crap, start walking and get skinny.
Also what the hell was Oprah doing there? She isnt in the movies but they let her on there, but they dont have Farrah Fawcett in the Memoriam.
Can you say racism against whites?
If your performance review every year is filled up with what you did well, then you are likely to make no progress throughout your career.
Everybody loves to listen to the pretty and nice stuff. However, when was that stuff ever useful to anyone? Only the ugly stuff such as constructive criticism that will help people move in the positive direction.
Stern – you are an idiot.
Howard speaks the truth.
Sour grapes sir. I call sour grapes on you.
I have a further comment about Howard. He's as ugly as s--. He should have plastic surgery but instead he uses his hair to hide his face. He said years ago that he too scare to go under the knife. So just look in the mirror Howard...though who live in glass houses should not throw stones.
Stern is spot on. Do you think he cares one bit if he offended anyone with that comment. His 30 year career has been based on exactly that, speaking the truth.
This is why I pay $13.99 for Howard TV on demand....
or she can play in "Hairspay" if she can sing/dance... I love that play...
"Against Haters" – you're right, how could we have been so stupid.
My grandfather smoked his life and didn't die of cancer- so therefore cigarettes aren't really dangerous.
My Uncle was an alcoholic and didn't die of liver disease- therefore alcoholism isn't really dangerous.
My friend got plastered the other night and drove home without killing anyone- therefore it is safe to drink and drive.
Just because every single fat person doesn't get diabetes, heart disease, or have a stroke, doesn't mean you aren't at risk. All you are is an exception to the rule.
This is typical Howard Stern. So what!?!?!? He is thee shock jock!
Certainly it is easy to say that Stern could have put more thought into his words before he said them, but that is not how he works. He is very impulsive and he does not take the time to sugar-coat any thought that pops into his head. Obviously, there is a market for his method and anyone who criticizes it does not need to pay for the privilege of hearing him speak.
Also, anyone who chooses to complain about what he says on his PRIVATE radio station is simply boosting his ratings even higher than they already are.
he's right, she needs someone to tell it to her straight, god knows everyone around her are enablers
Well of all the Radio Clowns on the radio dial, Howard Stern at least has the decency to stay out of government and focus on his industry of entertainment. Radio Clowns who disrupt the govenment and incite murder and violence among their listeners are treasonous, hurting our country in the name of entertainment.
You have to agree with Stern on the facts...Ol' Girl is going to die in 3 years. She most likely has diabetes and doesn't even know it.
She needs a surgeon to cut her up and remove the excess. They can then take the excess and sell it to the Dolphin hunters from "The Cove" and potentially spare a few dolphins lives.
Hmmmm, she has so far outlived others including Heath Ledger and other young actors/actressess. So to hear about her dying in 3 years makes me laugh. I think prescription drug abuse is more unhealthy than weight. My money is on her.
Whether or not Sidibe's weight is healthy or not is irrelevant. The movie's popularity can all be attributed to the fact that her character's appearance reflects some aspect of what we see in ourselves...so if you ask me, it looks like we enjoyed seeing a movie that portrayed someone's reality regardless of how fat, ugly or crude it was. I doubt there won't be another role out there for an actress who's movie grossed 1.8 million opening weekend...I'm just saying Howard
well, for me the beauty, size and color doesn't really matter for an actress. are those beautiful girls only have the right to act? well, she is gifted with the talent. you cannot do anything about that. she's an actress, not a model. stern is an idiot.
As much as i dislike that man, he is telling the truth, health wise. I hope and pray that someone helps her lose that unhealthy weight. I am an African American woman with some health issues. Some have been brought on by weight. I hope she doesn't do as I did and wait until she has these issues to change her life to be healthy. Could he have been kinder, sure, but that is not who he is.
Howard Stern looks like Rodney Alcala, the murderer. I did a double take.
Howard Stern is a shock jockey, he's going to say rude things for attention, so please don't take too much offense when he says something completely vile and hateful. That being said, he forgot to mention how she may not want to work her way down to the unhealthy weight of many of the actresses there at the Oscars. There's severely overweight and there's severely underweight. People's health is affected negatively on both sides of the spectrum and actresses are typically far too underweight to be considered truly healthy. A healthy BMI is 18-25, and many of those women have BMIs under 15. That's not healthy, that's scary and we should be worried about how long they have to live as well. So if he wants to pick on one side of the issue, maybe he should focus a bit on the other side as well.
Howard Stupid, is just that!!..... judge not and you shall not be judged, for the same way you judge someone , is the same way you will be judged. And I don't care who believes this or who doesn't... our judgement day is coming....ready or not Howard!!
Stern makes his money being a confrontational, big mouthed talk show host just like some others do, so he's never going to be nice. But the truth is Ms Sibide will have to consider loosing a few pounds in order to work in Tinsel Town. Not saying that she wouldn't find work. She just won't get the parts like Zoe Saldana , Halle Berry or some of the other itsy bitsies. But she's young. Five years from now we might see a different Gabby.
OKay ... fine, but tell me, who is talking about who here? She has definitely worked her physical appearance to her advantage and gotten the best actress nomination. Even Howard is talking about here to advance his career. And the rest of you, keep on trash talking while she builds her empire.
Stern is a hyocritical idiot. Why does he pick on the young girl? There are overweight young actors as well. He picks on her because he is a punk! He is no genius. He is a vile and pathetic person. While it is easy to play the race card, I think this idiot would have said the same thing if she was white.
Okay - gotta agree with Howard Stern. She is too big. I noticed that when she was on Leno and Conan. She should really lose weight. It is not healthy. I think what Oprah should do is help this young lady get healthy. Its not about being skinny or a size 00, but it is about her health and she can't possibly be healthy looking like that. Next role - The Biggest Loser!
Everybody is jumping all over her for her obesity which is unhealthy yet nobody has said anything about how practical skeletal James Cameron's wife was. I certainly didn't enjoy the view of bones above the top of her nonexistent breasts. Her dress was ill fitting and did not flatter but made her look like an upside down, deflated balloon. So thin people don't always look "amazing" in what they are wearing.
Miss Sidibe would have looked much better in something that hid the top of her arms. Other than that, the dress draped her shape appropriately and de-emphasized her abdomen area.
Most of those TV personalities interviewing celebrities on the red carpet generally are kissing butt anyway. (For what? I don't know.)
I don't see how an ugly loser like Howard Stern has any room to criticize ANYONE. Have you looked in a mirror lately Howie? At least this heavy black woman has talent. The only reason anyone ever watched your show was just to see the boobs (the ones on the womens' chests, not you).
Wow.. he speaks the truth and gets hammered..
She'll be a burden on the medical system ..
stern...look in the mirror !!!!!!!!!!
She's like Oprah, Hot in any weight division!
Erin-
Jorge Garcia has had one good role. Let's wait and see how his career goes from here.
Seth Rogen and Queen Latifah? Not morbidly obese, just large.
Yes, I am sure Oprah meant that Sidibe was going to have a career as great as Roseanne Barr. *eyes rolling*
So your list doesn't have many really good examples, and the fact that these were the few names you came up with out of thousands of actors and actresses proves Howard's point more than it disproves it.
That poor girl – of course, she needs to use her money from her picture to get something done about her weight. However, kindness costs nothing and Mr. Stern could have tempered his remarks a lot and still gotten the point across. She's a pretty girl and has a boat load of talent but her health and heart are suffering badly here.
Unfortunately, women in movies, TV and commercials are all expected to be paper thin and beautiful or at least cute. Look at the next 'couple's commercial. The man can be dumpy, and comfortable-looking but the woman has to be thin and pretty no matter who she's paired with. Yes, this pretty overweight girl is not going to have many parts if she chooses to keep her weight the way it is and serious health problems down the road. But be kind about it, Mr. Stern – you can certainly afford to!
While Stern's approach to the subject is crass, he is absolutely correct. I think Sidibe is beautiful but she does need to loose weight. She like even myself need to get professional help with this process. While I am not nearly as large as Sidibe.....it is a problem.
Sidibe can lose weight, but Stern will never be anything but ugly.
What's worse, Howard saying it or CNN reporting it?
From the way Stern treats and talks about women on his own show, to the shallow, rude comments about this actress, is just the ongoing rhetoric by him exposing his intense hatred of women. It would be interesting to know more about his upbringing and his relationship with his mother.
Another woman at the Oscars, whose health comes into question, is Sarah Jessica Parker. She looked gaunt and ill and old. And her husband seemed quiet and passive, too. There was no excitement or pleasure reflected in their conversation. We focus on overweight people frequently, but I wonder if Ms. Parker will have health issues later for her eating habits today?
Wendy- Actually she is younger than Heath Ledger was when he died. And what the hell would that have to do with this anyway?
Howard stern is an ugly, angry, sexually fraustrated middle aged Jewish gay woman trying to prove she is a man by shocking her listeners, hoping to keep her radio job. If she really wanted to show us all some real balls, she would talk about ideas, not this mindless superficial gossip and judgement about people's appearance.
She could say something intelliigent and that would really SHOCK her audience.
The truth hurts.
The truth hurts sometime and sometimes it has to – get over it.
Obviously, Sidibe's weight contributed to her getting the part in the movie. Let's wait and see how she looks in a year or so. Maybe she saw the Oscar's replay and is thinking the samething thing. As for Howard Stern, I admit, I like his show and I'm a dedicated listener. His audience doesn't have to agree with him, but he does say what is on his mind and says a lot of things that people are thinking. That is probably why he as over 2 million listers.
Her weight is completely unhealthy, and I don't see a problem with pointing that out to America's youth. She shouldn't be a role model. Howard Stern is an ass, but what do people expect when they listen to his show?
What a whole lot of people in here are forgetting, when attacking Howard for being honest, is no one stood on a stage introducing Howard as the new Mr Universe....
The girl needs serious care to handle her health, not fake comments and wishes.
I am sure she is well aware that she is obese and does not need this jerk to point it out to her and everyone else. What a rude idiot!
I don't think we need to be politically correct about the clinically obese. People in this category have been proven to be a strain on our commodities and the environment. Like smokers, they also contribute to the skyrocketing cost of healthcare, and we all pay for it.
Just to be clear, if she were a man, there wouldn't likely be a question as to whether she'd get another part as an actor. John Goodman, hello? He's just as overweight, and yet he gets parts in Cohen Brothers films, etc. There are a number of men like that. There are few, if any women who can get parts being over weight, but they do exist, i.e. Kathy Bates. Just because there is gender discrimination on whether you can be a successful overweight actor doesn't mean we should just demand that all female actresses lose weight. No one would ever suggest a male actor to do so.
Sometimes it takes comments that strong to make an impact and for the young actress to take notice. Hand holding is not always the best way to go. This from someone who despises Stern.
Stern nailed it.. unfortunately for most people he did it in a way that isn't too friendly. Lesson learned here.. it's ok to speak the truth and clearly Howard did, but if you don't like his comments or his show just tune out.
I wish Gabourey Sidibe the best luck with her career and her life and with that said, I hope she gets help with her weight or she won't have the full career later in life like she deserves.
Howard Stern does have even half the intellegence that miss Sidibe has in one of her toe nails
Aww, Stern's comments are mean.
Aww, Stern's comments are unnecessary.
Give me a break. Americans always looking for an excuse. Sure, prop this woman up and praise her to millions of Americans. She is exactly what is wrong with America. Lazy and fat people who always feel entitled to their "break." Lucky for this one she got it, but as Stern correctly points out, she may not be around long enough to make something of it.
I don't necessarily like Howard Stern, but he's right. Why are we afraid to say it when someone is fat? Fat is killing Americans!! It's time for all of us to stop denying and start living healthy.
Remarks like this may enpower plus-sized women to change, but they also enstill an sexist and sizist attitude that is rarely applied to the male race. Stern's attitude that implies not only a sort of "perfection" but shows his state of immaturity, is superfluous in this world of eating disorders, world hunger, and excessive bullying. When talent emerges from the woodwork and out of places unknown, it should be praised and met with respect. Such talent, and ANY one for that matter should NEVER be told to conform or die. Instead, the "plus" will be dropped on the woman's own terms, and not according to the words and rants of a spineless, talentless sicko. He spoke "the truth" when the truth is right infront of our faces. There is a line between stating the obvious and OVERSTATING the obvious, and Skidmark-Stern crossed it, big time.
Howard is who he is, she can come back and say negative about him if she wants or she can be a "different" person and not be rude. Howard does what he does for money.....we can cry all we want about how much of a pig people think he is but it wont change a dollar bill into a million. Ok now the important thing I want to happen...Im a big fan of biggest loser, I say lets vote her to be the next contestant. Instead of cutting her down find a way to help.
I think Oprah should wheel out another wagon update of how much weight she gained instead of lying to the public with fake airbrushed pictures on the cover of O magazine...Cmon Oprah wheel out an updated meat wagon TELL THE TRUTH....
very sad but true. i would say the majority of people watching the Oscars were thinking the same thing. how about her comment on her dress. "if her dress was a porno movie. it would be the money shot? what the hell are you saying you are on the red carpet. i do give credit to Howard stern since the beginning he always said how ugly he is. he he said it on air and in his movie.
He is so funny. "...a woman the size of a planet" If I were drinking milk, it would be coming out of my nose by now. Ha ha ha ha ha.
Ugly comments by stern, for sure. But that's to be expected. She is very unhealthy, tho. She can be an excellent actor.
I find it sad that most people are so shallow. I believe Sidibe is a BEAUTIFUL woman and she is only limited if she lets the the narrow mindedness of others dictate how much she can accomplish. There are other large women who have been extremely successful in the movie industry (Oprah among them. Anyone remember the Color Purple?) The good news for Sidibe is that she already has several other contracts and has completed filming on one of them. Time will tell how successful she is, not Howard Stern.
Howard, Howard, Howard you never cease to amaze me with your sour disposition! At least Gabby can lose weight you are just plain UGLY and there is NO amount of money to change that! You are looking more and more like Big Bird everyday!
he speaks the truth!
Oprah...fake we shouuld do a show about that. Oprah is about as fake and judgmental of others as it gets. If you watch her show there is a moment when she will turn to the guest and say, for example if it was a show about drugs, "you're a addict" well duh that's why they are there. Oprah's brand of journalism is all about her being the holyer than now judge of morality. Oprah sucks.
Who gives a rat's patoot what Howard Stern says. This is not news. This is why I gave up on watching CNN. This is why I am giving up on CNN.com.
Some people grow up that way and change look at monique who played her mom. Stern is a POS I guess its okay to do blow cheat on your wives numerous time and promote STD and all but because you are new to the Industry and of a certain weight you are going to die sooner please. Howard if not for modern medicine your penis would have eroded and you would have died sooner than this woman could. Heck if not for modern medicine half the people in Hollywood would not be there.
Seems like Howard Stern got it right to me. Do you guys honestly think movie producers will be choosing her over Jolie, Kate Winslet, Cameron Diaz...etc. Lets be honest here.
Howard Stern is a schmuck!!!
Stop the PC...he is right.
Yeah, she is big, but how many thin actors and actresses have died, and they where thin! Therefore, do not say she is at an unhealthy size, when smaller people are dying for the same heart related problems as plus size people. Think sometimes people!
Everyone was cooing at her, saying how fantastic she looks, etc. He told the truth. Obesity is a problem in the US and should be faced, not glossed over. She should not be encouraged to keep that weight. It will be fatal.
I think she's lovely and refreshing. This will open doors for her no matter what she chooses to do with her life. At least she won't be limited to just radio like Stern because she's just to hideous to look at. I'd much rather look at her than him. Yuck! My message to Stern is, no matter how many people you put down, to make yourself feel better and unless you pull a Heidi Montag you'll always be ugly, inside and out. How does it feel?
You know what I'm always amazed at? It's that individuals think that obese people don't already realize their state. News flash! You don't need to inform someone they are too heavy or at risk of health issues directly connected with that fact. They know! I imagine Gabby was very self conscious being at those award, on camera, walking the red carpet, the only one of her "kind" there. Good for her. She's positive. I'm ashamed of adults that have no excuse. Shame shame, Howard.
Howard Stern should be the first to tell you a little talent in Hollywood can counteract being born ugly as a duck. No woman has this guy's poster on their wall, but he's doing alright. She's an easy target, and this is obvious and obnoxious comedy. Right down the middle of the road...the freeway inundated with grunts and the lowest common denominator.
I hate excuse, "he's just saying what everybody's thinking." Perhaps there's a reason people are thinking it rather than voicing it aloud.
Is he going to rip on Senator Roy Ashburn for being a hypocrite? Or possibly something about how Betty White is gonna have a hard time on SNL because of her age? That seems to be Stern material. The voice of the obvious with a hint of jerk for the morons of America.
i agree – i usually hate this man; but he's 100% correct. how can America say they embrace this woman and then NOT be concerned for her health? if she's such a great actress that she won an award, then she should be willing to make herself healthy enough to earn some more.
Howard likes being a jerk, it's his schtick, plain and simple. There was definitely a nicer way to say it. Despite her fame, I do feel sorry for her, plain and simple she is not healthy and hopefully now she has the resources to help her health. She does have a great self-image as she is proud of who she is which is awesome, not to let jerks like Stern effect your pscyhy, however, being proud should not get in the way of being healthy. I'm all for curves in hollywood, some women like Cameron's wife I believe looked absolutely anorexic. Being too skinny is not attractive, healthy curves are good, most women are a size 8 or 10, it's about time for hollywood to realize that.
Stern is a Jew with super first amendment powers. He is awesome and its no biggie thats he's also crude, mean, and attacking on his show on others.....beware a society where his voice is muffled and we all start to look like silly puddy or jello and sound like the teacher from Charlie Brown
if he woulda said this 20 years ago it woulda been hysterical but all the activist losers pushing for sencitivity for certain subjects so they can get some tv time (PETA is the worst) this world is to politically correct has anyone heard the phrase THE TRUTH HURTS? im not meaning to mention the actresses weight but the fact no one can say anything that isnt watered down anymore the movies we watch are watered down our music is sooo bland its scary and our tv personalities dont have any anymore ryan secrest is the most vanilla person ever sure he looks good on tv but he dosent have a signature voice he dresses like everyone else and hes as exciting as melba toast
what Stern said was mean but hes one of the last people left on the air that has personality
I am just glad she didn't win best actress, being morbidly obese and lacking talent shouldn't get a sympathy oscar. I am glad Howard at least has the courage to say what the majority of people are thinking.
She didnt win so why did the tag to the story say Oscar Winner?
Howard Stern makes money for being a shock-jock: no intelligence or education needed to have verbal diarrhea. So you can't put too much stock in anything he says.
Take her for her talent, not for her weight. If she wants to lose it–that's her business. She can give an impressive performance–give her credit for it.
Don't demean her because she isn't anorexic or light-skinned enough. Ugly, worthless, unsuccessful and cruel people make nasty comments about others to make themselves feel better.
You need some self-esteem–read a self-help book. She's rocking hers and has far, far more class than most.
I think of the actress Nell Carter when I see Miss Sidibe. Ms. Carter was also a woman of size. I don't think her weight will interfere in Miss Sidibe's ability to get parts, just in her ability to be healthy to perform. Mo'nique is also a woman of size and her career has been very good but she has had health problems.
But it's Howard and what do you expect? At least, he is trying to keep it real. What did Robin say?
I too thought that she might not get another part because of he weight. She was asked by ET what she was going to do after the Oscars and she said that Chic Falet was 14 miles away from her hotel & she would go there on Monday. Sounds like she has bad eating habits and she does need help. I couldn't help but stare at those huge arms. I too am over weight but nothing like she is. Her arms are bigger than my legs and I fear if she doesn't get her weight down she will die. I wouldn't be surprised if she doesn't already have highblood pressure & high cholesterol. How could a mother let their own daughter get so big? She doesn't need to be rail thin but at a weight that isn't life threating. Fast food is the worst thing to eat. Maybe Mrs. Obama can talk to her and show her that fresh veggies and fruit and fish is the way to go & get out and walk and walk and walk.
I agree with Howard. I thought Oprah's comments were out of line–an exaggeration.
Howard gets paid to be an a$$hole – I see we have some amateurs here. How many roles is she going to get in Hollwood even if she becomes a size2?
Howard's right.... but he is a bit too harsh...
Stern is a jerk. Plain and simple. He is the rudest person I have ever had the displeasure of experiencing. Regardless of her size she is still a human being with feelings and for someone like him to go off on her........ what a complete ass. I am sure that thru her life she has heard from many that for health reasons she should lose weight. Maybe she has, like many of us, tried and has not found the right diet. She deserves to be treated like a person like any one else with a problem whether it be weight, height, speech or anything, besides he is nothing to look at, at all!
Even though he sounds like he's being mean, I have to agree with the man, he's right. Though I don't think he should of made the comments, I think someone should be whoever they want to be and live the life they want to have. I don't think its Stern's business to say "oh go lose weight". No, it should be Sidibe's choice whether she wants to lose the weight or not.
I see Mr. Howard Stern running in Central Park most weekends. He is in a way an inspiration for his fans and those that are not.
He is very well known and make an effort to keep in shape and healthy.
I do believe he means good to this young woman despite of his harsh words. Facts are facts!
He's right. Just because it's not politically correct TO BE HONEST, doesn't make it wrong. Rude, yes ...insensitive, yes. SHE'S PHYSICALLY HUGE! How much does that young girl weigh? 375? 400? My God! Lose the weight honey or it's just a matter of time before cholesterol, diabetes, and heart issues catch up to you.
You know what I'm always amazed at? It's that individuals think that obese people don't already realize their state. News flash! You don't need to inform someone they are too heavy or at risk of health issues directly connected with that fact. They know! I imagine Gabby was very self conscious being at those awards, on camera, walking the red carpet, the only one of her "kind" there. Good for her. She's positive. I'm ashamed of adults that have no excuse. Shame shame, Howard.
my father was killed when i was 17 but he did teach me not to ever hurt a woman by hitting or being verbally abusive. i really think this would be a better place if dads would teach their children this one thing which has stuck with me for 60 years. women experience too much violence at the hands of alot of men. i think Howard is saying it's ok to slap this woman with his words. Let's make a pack with all men that it is not ok to hit or verbally abuse a woman......period!
Only addressing one thing –
To those who think she will never have another role.....she is involved in two projects that are in post-production.
Rick,
There is far more to the argument of health verses apperance of health than you are taking into account, for instance to see an NFL linebacker that weighs in at 325lbs and looks Obese and has a BMI rating in the 40's is usually ten times healthier than the average person. I know that this is a relatively rare occurance however it should be pointed out that there are people out there that are very large, that would appear to be in terrible health and shape that are the opposite.
Well, She did get the role in Precious...didn't she?
Why can't she get a role in Hollywood as a talented woman and not as a fat woman.Come on people, shed your prejudices.
First off I am a devoted Howard Stern fanatic and Im african american......I know too well about Stern's antics about overweight people in general....hell he's worked or is working with a few and he doesn't let them off the hook either. His comments, though a bit harsh, was right on the mark. This young, gifted rising star has such potential but if she doesn't take care of herself she might be in grave danger. I myslef am overweight, at 33, and its a struggle but imagine for her at just the young age she is having to deal with this issue. Suffice it to say Mr. Stern is only being honest and making a point that Hollywood can be just as vicious....he's only one person who can rant on his radio show that we pay for.....but mainstream media can really put a hurting on her just as quickly. Its a bit brutal but its honest and she has to know that it can become a serious problem if it already hasn't.
Wow. He's picking on a fat, successful girl.
Because she apparently doesn't know she's fat? Because its his business? Because she isn't an easy target for him to get some ratings off of?
She'll be fine, and if she isn't she'll still have this success on her resume. Good for her, and screw him.
There's a point where mean is just mean.
Does anyone think for even one minute that Gabourney Sidibe does not know already that she is morbidly obese? Howard simply just states the obvious; no new idea, no new insight, nothing that would be positive or beneficial to anyone. Just dramatic, nasty commentary.
By the way, Howard, get a haircut – your hair is gross and unkempt and will not help you in your career. Now, you too can experience how it feels to have someone else tell you how to look and what to do with your body?
i am beyond words with this gentleman. At what point did society put so much creed into what comes out of the mouth of this individual? Has he ever looked in the mirror......he apparently has forgotten what he himself looks like since he can find fault with so many.
The funny thing is, if she weren't in the movie that was successful, no one would have really thought about it. But we know that Hollywood is all about thin, or thin-ish, but not to thin or anorexic or manorexic. The fact is, Howard Stern, rude or not, dide put it out there. And rude or not, its Howard Stern, of course it's going to be in a mean way.... Have you really never heard him speak or open his mouth. She's not the easiest target, just the biggest, and he's pointing that out for everyone, not just trying to make her feel bad.
I'm thinking a "Free Gabourey" frannchise
I know some of you think what Howard said was mean... but when you REALLY listen to what he's saying, I think it's fantastic he was honest and powerful enough to be able to say it without fear of hurting his career... unlike so many in the "industry" who are on perpetual PR watch.
Let's be real. What he said may have NOTHING to do, necessarily, with his personal views on physical attractiveness... rather... his experience with the realities of Hollywood and commercial success. He has been part of it, and knows more than 99.999% of you out there forming an opinion on this post, about it. It's Brutally competitive... with an emphasis on utter perfection. If you aren't competitive, you are out of the game.
For all the women on the post, you would rather drool over a magazine cover of Brad Pitt or Taylor Lautner with their six pack abs bared in all their sculpted perfection, as opposed to Kevin James or Jack Black pushing their twelve packs abs over their belts. It's harsh... and it's just the truth, and you know it.
I think it's great Oprah encourages her because it's important to remain optimistic no matter who you are, but Howard is telling it like it is... and I don't even listen to Howard.
Well... Stern has a right to say that...
It's not friendly, it's remarkably rude and disrespectful...
But, it's true. It is true.
Lara said: "Obesity (and related health problems) is a societal problem not a personal moral problem."
No it is a personal problem no one forces you to eat. Once again its never the person fault it is due to someone else. People have to take responsibility for themselves and stop making excuses and blaming others for their problems and short comings.
End of story.
I thought we had to pay to hear from Stern. I did not pay and do not care what he thinks.
The young woman is aware of her weight Howard, but thanks for your insensative comments. Nothing has changed with him.
If Howard Stern is holding himself up as what a "healthy" person looks like, he is the one who needs to get help. I can't stand him. He never says anything of substance and he's only throwing out his comments for this actress to get ratings for his failing show. Sad.
Howard Stern is the funnies dude EVER. I miss his show on 'regular' radio. I haven't laughed this hard in a long time.
If she decides to lose weight, it will be for her health reasons, not because an idiot saw fit to ridicule her.
The reality is Gabourey Sidibe is extremely over weight, and needs to get healthy and fit so we can continue to see her in movies. She is very talented, but there are not many movie rolls in Hollywood for someone of her current size. I think she should ask her co-star and Oscar winner Mo'Nique for advice in this department. Mo'Nique has had her fair share of battles with weight but the woman looked fabulous and much thinner than I have seen her in years on Oscar night. As for Gabourey, you are in the spot light now honey and there are ton of talented young ladies who are going to be looking up to you, please get healthy and fit. So the world will be able to see you give another Oscar performance.
For someone as homely as he is, he really has his nerve. She can lose the weight, but even with plastic surgery, he'll stay homely. He's not so wonderful himself. Poor thing, lifts up his self-esteem by knocking others.
Howard Stern shouldn't comment. He looks dirty and unwashed. His hair looks greasy and uncombed.
Doesn't feel good, does it Howard?
Stern is a schmuck – anything to get attention. He is unnecessary and sort of like a plague. This type of comment is the reason why I don't listen to him, won't pay for his book(s) or movie(s), and in general think he needs to just go away.
Stern is a douche, but I agree.
Okay, Mr. Stern! You want to pick on somebody's physical "flaws"? Then how about we point the ugly gun at YOU? While you may not be overweight, you have a LOT of other things that are truly UGLY! One is YOU, and your mouth. Two is YOU and your ugly FACE! Three is your ugliness in general. To say "look who's calling the kettle black" is pretty much "right on". Yes. Gabby CAN help how she looks, but so can you by controlling your ugly, hurtful, unnecessary mean-spirited words at anybody you feel you want to, no matter how much it hurts them. You are one of the most insensitive, cruel evil people on this planet. You need to be tossed out of EVERY public business on this earth where nobody can hear your voice ever again. You are despicable. How ANY woman can lay down with you and your trashy mouth is beyond me. They must be your equal.
One day, Mr. Stern. One day, you will get your "Just Desserts". Just wait. Because what goes around, comes around.
Lynn
Once heard the moron put down a woman who was 120 lbs at 5'6" because that was too heavy, so this has nothing to do with his concern about her health. Stern is trash. His karma is coming, one sweet day.
Howard Stern is perfect at stirring up trouble. He does this best.
Okay... give him a break. Yes, Howard is blunt but true. Home girl needs to drop the weight and it's like Michael Jackson, no one wants to upset the star and get cut off of the money. But again, look at the history of people THAT big and go from there.
fat or skinny, pretty or ugly....she is beautiful.
stern has yellow teeth and a nose the size of texas, no wonder he is on radio, no one has to see his sorry ass face and how in God's green earth did he ever convince that women to marry him?
Howard Stern is a "Shock Jock". He makes a living at trying to figure out what the most offensive things he could possibly say are. That's what makes him money, and makes money for anyone who carries his show. I would be more upset with the people that continue to broadcast people of his ilk than the person himself. What does it say about any organization willing to broadcast him, or Mancow, or Rush Limbaugh?
Everyone should just ignore him, as well as the rest of that bunch, Rush Limbaugh included. When they don't get anymore ratings then they'll shut their mouths (or at least we won't have news stories about them anymore).
This is what I say to HSTERN–
"I may be fat but you're ugly and I can lose weight"
HAHAHAH... Stern rules... not even the tards at the FCC can touch him... He's doing his best radio now...
Stern's remarks were crude, but accurate. Nicki Bronsky & Ricki Lake, stars of "Hairspray" featuring white, heavy-set woman in the lead role, haven't been able to parlay their fame into anything as noteworthy. One can only surmise that their weight is an issue. Ricki Lake got this message & lost her weight (again). They & Gabourey are talented actresses but we live in a VERY superficial world where the public makes snap decisions on people based on their appearance & the film industry IS A VISUAL COMMUNICATION VEHICLE. The casting agents & directors have little time to tell whatever story they want to convey, thus rely on the audiences' tendency to make snap judgements to tell the story. This is the sorry reality we live in...
I have to agree....there is nothing that cuts short a life than that of morbid obesity.
Stern is just another jerk of the Limbaugh-ilk that makes his living by being as loud and obnoxious as possible in front of as many people as possible. So the woman has a weight problem. My girlfriend was at 290 lbs a few years ago but has lost over 120 lbs and her weight is still dropping. She looks very good now. Gabourey Sidibe can lose weight, but if Stern wants to keep making a living, he will always be a jerk. That's his profession.
How can Oprah, Stern or anyone predict someones career? Thank God the film screens (tv and movies) is not full of skinny and vanity hype! It has a lot of that, but look at actors... Look at people like Tommy Lee Jones, Queen Latifa and other actors... there are roles for this girl... theater, tv, movies... it is not the looks, it is the talent and whether the person fits the role... I'm skinny genetically just as people are overweight... so..? But I do agree with the health issue, she does not have to be thin or skinny but healthy!!! Her current weight just does not seem healthy, that's it! Hey, Stern is Stern. I don't listen to him, but he doesn't offend me... know what to expect from him... this actress, well she'll handle it... Her career...? We'll see? As with anyone...
howard stern is by far the ugliest man ive ever seen . hey
howard take some of your money and get that faced fixed god you would give someone a heart attack if you come out at night...
If she doesn't get any acting jobs in Hollywood she can always do McDonalds commercials.
It was one of the funniest Stern shows ever. Howard is the best!
Why would we expect anything less from Stern? He is a controversial person and has built his empire on just that. His comments are conveying what most are already thinking, however I am sure that Gabourey is already aware of her weight problem. Does he really think he's telling her something she doesn't already know? It must have been difficult for her to go through the motions of a dress fitting and walking the red carpet amongst women who are stick thin. Why must Stern be so rude to an obviously intelligent women who would probably like nothing more than to be a size 0. However, if she were there is no way she would have had the opportunities and recognition she's received from her involvement in the film, a sad irony. Stern should keep his ugly mouth shut!
Its sad but I agree with Stern. Gabourey Sidibe Im sure did a great job in Precious. I dont see her steaing roles from Halle Berry, Beyonce, Angleina Jolie, Nicole Kidman or Sandra Bullock, Maybe Tyler Perry can use her for something but even then all of his lead actresses he uses are attractive.
When Oprah gave her speech about Gabourey, my heart sank a little because I felt like she was publically setting this poor girl up for failure. While I don't wish that upon her, no one should be declaring that this girl or anyone else is going to have a brillant career. We're not f-ing psyhics! Gabourey could be a one-hit wonder like so many. Howard was saying what others were thinking, but as usual, he need a serious filter on how he says stuff. But then he wouldn't be Howard, would he?
It's funny reading all these peoples' responses, going to bat for the woman, just because she's the underdog here. Two days ago they wouldn't have cared.
Honestly, he's right. I'm overweight and am doing something about it. I....AM....FAT! Not like that, tho'. I don't think my body could take it.
Bottom line – if she wants to have a long career in acting, she better start peeling that weight off. Howard Stern is very frank, and that doesn't appeal to everyone, but thank GOD you still have the freedom to be who you are in this country!
Going to watch Precious tonight....
I doubt Howard Stern has any concern for Gabourey Sidibe's health and his using his usual 'shock jock' mentality to get people (like you and me) to talk about him and what he has to say. I don't understand why people listen to him or pay any attention to him unless they find these types of unkind comments to be a form of 'entertainment'. Someone needs to pull the plug on this jerk!
Oh my God! How can anyone, ANYONE, be surprised by this?! This is Howard Stern we are talking about. How can you listen to this man and then complain about anything that he says? C'mon. If you don't like what the man says, for goodness sake, stop listening to him speak. "Damn, it really hurts when I keep stabbing myself with this pencil."
That comment coming from the ugliest man in radio.
the ONLY reason he has a decent looking, skinny white chick on his arm is because of all his money!!! sorry, just telling the truth..
otherwise he'd just be an ugly radio guy !!
This comming from a guy who looks like he has avoided a shower for a number of years.
Hmmm? A fat, black chick not being successful? I think Oprah was the perfect person to introduce her because they said the same thing about Oprah 25 years ago. How's that for the truth, Howard?
You have to love truth-hate.
Yeah, he's right! So what?? Grow up!
Oprah DID lie, right through her teeth. Either that, or she's just ignorant (doubtful). What other roles is she going to be cast in?? Are there writers out there who are suddenly going to pen stories about an enormous black woman??
Like Stern said, what 'Blind Side 2'?? Seriously. What's Still Eating Gilbert Grape???
It's simply called reality. We know about her because of this niche role, which she just so happened to ALREADY BE PERFECT FOR. It's not a miracle.
I am sure this women thinks about being overwieght every single minute of the day, no she does not enjoy it either. She does not need an Ass like this to put it out on national radio, like she would listin to him anyway. I hope she does use her money to get help. I know she would like to lose the weight. Nobody wants to be over weight!! Folks who are not over weight just do not get that.They really don't. But one thing is for sure if she loses the weight she will be stunning, but nothing will help ugly Stern no matter how much money he has. He is just ugly! Both inside and our UGLY!!
Well if Hollywood is not ready for less than pleasing eye candy, there is always radio. Howard faired okay with a face only a mother could love.
An accurate desciption if there ever was. Stern admits that he his not a good looking guy and that he has a small penis. At least he knows his faults and can accept them. What I'm reading here is that its better to lie to this young lady. Putting a $10000 dress on a pig stilll makes it a well dressed pig.
Okay. I think that Howard could use a little tact lesson. BUT with that being said.. He is correct. She is a morbidly obese woman (whether she is black or white shouldn't be the issue at all). I am sure that she is more than likely already diabetic or at least borderline diabetic. Not to mention she probably is starting to (if she hasn't already) have problems with blood pressure and back pain. These are the reasons everyone should be worried about. Not whether she is going to make it in Hollywood. What should be the concern is whether she is going to make it to her next birthday!!
Someone mentioned previously that Chris Farley had a great career.. Let's look at that statement... HAD a great career...
Let's look at John Candy... He had an awesome career, better than Chris Farley and most thin actors could dream of having but again he HAD a great career..
Both men had great promising careers that were cut short due to issues related to their sizes. Eventually playing roles in their deaths..
She is a great actress with a lot of talent. I would like to see her continue to succeed with that if she wants to. But she has got to lose some weight or our next stupid conversation is going to include her in the HAD a great career paragraph...
Everyone is always preaching saying that Britney, Miley, Lindsay, etc should be correcting their behaviors because young girls are watching them.. Well the same needs to be said to Gabby.. young girls are watching you......
I read a comment on another site that hit the nail on the head perfectly.........Gabby is Oprah Winfrey without the billion dollar makeover.
Someone should remind Mr. Stern that you can take an overweight pretty girl and she can lose weight when she finds a man that temps her more then a piece of chocolate cake, but you cannot take a face like his and make it pretty!!!
Why does he not pick on the anorexic bimbos and thin rake models that flood Hollywood? They are killing themselves too.
Fat is bad..thin is in?
Not all cultures are built like thin, flat white folks. African, Southeast Asians, island folk are built differently genetically. Weight that is detrimental to health is bad. But if she is 300lbs and can about her day without depending on others and is happy ...why should it be an issue?
her size is only proportionate to your nose. dude, you are an arrogant tool and i have never liked you and now i wish you were vapor.
How does he get off talking about her weight when he is so fracking ugly?? Put a bag over your head Stern!
What's wrong with Howard's face? I think he needs help, it looks like he has a serious medical condition.
It's a good thing ugly ain't fatal. Old Howard would be on his deathbed.
Howard Stern is the ugliest, white dude I’ve ever seen.
While I think Howard Stern is a royally crude a$$, he has a point. I don't particularly care how he made his point, but he's correct. I am a health care provider, and I see more and more women becoming more and more obese at a very young age. It's not about political correctness and acceptance...if anything, we have become too accepting of people being overweight. He was telling the truth...it IS unhealthy, it IS associated with health problems ranging from fertility to cardiac disease, to orthopedic problems. It seems you can tell someone they need to stop smoking, that they need to not drink as much, but if you tell someone the truth that they are FAT and that it will shorten their life, you have all of a sudden insulted a person.
I fight my weight every day, so this is not something with which I have no experience. It's not as if I am unsympathetic...I most certainly understand how hard it is to get enough exercise, and to watch everything you put in your mouth. But I do it. EVERY DAY. I go to the gym or get outside and get some exercise 5-6 days per week, I have an active job where I am always on my feet, and I plan my meals a week ahead of time. It's not impossible.
While I think Stern is a vile creature...he hit the nail on the head on this one.
I have absolutely no doubt that caring friends and observers have offered Sidibe frank, practical, and well-intentioned advice about her weight and her health. Off camera.
But Oprah's very public on-stage address wasn't the place for that kind of advice or "call-out". It was the proper occasion for only one kind of comment, and that's exactly what Oprah delivered: a warm, encouraging acknowledgement of the thespian achievement that earned Sidibe a nomination.
People have to stop being so sensitive when someone uses words. He said what every body was thinking. Do you think she was in the end seat in her row by accident? Can someone tell me the last time a woman of real size starred in a major motion picture. IS her weight a health issue? Yes. If you listen to his show his bigger problem was with Oprah who by next year will not even remember her name but touts her as she is the next Meryl Streep or Halle Berry.
Actually I think he is right and Oprah always lies. In a country where how good you look and how skinny you are defines your career path in Hollywood and real world America I'd say she had her 15 minutes already.Certainly she is not the biggest woman Howard has ever seen I am sure,nor will she be the last but he always is con traversal thats his gig. We should not expect anything less from him As Chelsea handler would say Suck it!
All I can say is this WHAT A JERCK!! She won becuase she did an amazing job as the abusive mother (ok I admit havent seen it yet) and the actors/actress thought so also.
I'm a big fat tub of lard myself, but I am in complete agreement with Stern–unless she doesn't mind being type cast as "young fat black woman" in every film, she won't have a career. Her size will overpower any attempt to avoid type-casting.
i think she should take the next logical step: get on Dancing with the Stars.
God i love you howard.
"ooo i dont "get" him" I shouldnt comment if i don't watch his show? NO! I don't care if he's right or wrong, the way he said it is just mean and rude. If Imus got in trouble for what he said so should Stern
Many Americans are way too fat. Even a little pudge is not good for you. Hundreds of pounds of fat is fatal. You don't see many 300 lb 60 year old people. They die young. They are unhappy about their health and their weight every day of their lives. Lack of "will power" (an imaginary concept) is not the answer.
We need to restore PE to our schools. Every kid needs a hard workout every day.
Also, every restaurant and food producing corporation is spending millions on persuading Americans to shove more and more food into a grapefruit sized stomach. Does this advertising work? Many of you say, "You just have to ignore that advertising." What would you think if every commercial on TV advertised cocaine instead of food? Would you say to your child, "Just ignore those commercials, honey. Have a little will power."
To all of you who say "he's just being honest", since when does honesty excuse rudeness and downright cruelty? Just because we have freedom of speech doesn't mean we should exercise it without thinking about who we might hurt in the process.
I guarantee that Gabourey Sidibe - no matter how confident she seems - is well aware of her weight, her health concerns and the social stigma attached to it. She doesn't need other people pointing it out in such a mean-spirited manner under the guise of being concerned for her well-being. Howard Stern doesn't give a rat's ass about her well-being.
The recent focus on the "obesity epidemic" is just making the last acceptable prejudice even worse. For fat people, instead of just worrying about cruel teenagers laughing at you in public, now you have to worry about the adults on the street who should know better. They're sizing you up, wondering how much you're contributing to their health care premiums going up or how big your carbon footprint is.
The saddest part is that morbid obesity is as much an emotional problem as anything else. People don't eat like that just because they don't know better. The food is filling a void in their life. And the more you get ridiculed and humiliated, the more you turn to food for comfort. It's a vicious cycle that "normal" people will never understand.
hehehe –
How can you even compare her to Elvis or Kathy or god even Oprah. Those people are overweight, not disgustingly obese.
To be proud of being that big is disgusting. If she said I know I am fat and I want to do something about. fine I would respect her. This girl actually thought Justin Timberlake would be her date.
Shes a prime example of one of the 7 deadly sins. Howard was right.
Live your dreams no matter who you are and how much you weigh. Gabourey can always lose weight but Howard will always be ugly and rich.
I'm not exactly a fan of Stern's but I do agree with him. Hollywood has it's standards and there aren't too many roles for extremely overweight actresses, not to mention BLACK, overweight actresses. She does need to get fit now that she has the money to support a healthy diet and hire a personal trainer. I'm sure she will, as most of them do.
So why is it that Stern's comments have given many of you the right to call (him) ugly?... Regardless if this is the case aren't you all just a bunch of hypocrites?
Stern is not a politically correct guy, and perhaps he should keep his comments to himself. Sadly this PC phoney attitude is at the root of what America has become: a nation of phonies that (in many cases) will say one thing while privately thinking something completely different because you're so affraid to offend...
Hmm... reminds me of a certain soldier that went bolistic and shot and killed his fellow comrads some months ago, a tragedy that could well have been avoided had people questioned the rather obvious signs and called attention to this – instead of taking a PC stand of being afraid to offend...
Well, Howard Stern managed to find work in Hollywood looking like he does. He is grossly physically unattractive even if he is not overweight. His face is ugly and his mind, mouth and heart are even uglier.
sometimes the truth hurts. Gabby did a fantastic job in "Prescious"...she bascially played the role of herself. a fat girl with a tough childhood
The Truth Hurts
And Stern is a foul mouthed, evil minded, no talent, ugly old man with a big nose. He has little room to talk.
Flattery kills. The girl, from all accounts I've heard, truly is "beautiful" on the inside. But, to lie to her and act like she can maintain a long-healthy career at that weight just isn't right. Beauty can't be judged by someone's appearance, but health can. She's not healthy.
It's ridiculous how so many are jumping on the bandwagon to say that Sidibe is "talented". The truth is that she is no more talented than any other run-of-the-mill actress, and probably less so. She was cast and later nominated for PC reasons... so certain people could demonstrate to the world how good and noble they are. And in any case, whatever acting "talent" Sidibe has is hidden behind that face so bloated that it can scarcely convey any expression at all.
Stern is dead-on – we were saying the same thing: what other role will she ever be able to play? I guess whatever role calls for an enormously obese girl . . .
PS – This comes from someone who had to lose 100 pounds for health reasons, so I know where she's coming from, and she needs to lose the weight *now* before it seriously impacts the rest of her life.
Is anyone really surpised? A coward is always going to pick the least intimidating target to pick on. If precious starred Michael Clarke Duncan, we wouldn't have heard any comments out of Stern. What a Chickens$#%!!!!
I congradulate Gabie, I look at her accomplishments, and think I wish it where me. I look at her weight and look past it as it is the obvious imperfection that we all have. The doors are open to her in the industry as she is very smart and young. i will guarantee she will loose weight as a busy schedule in hollywood will do I hope she does not desire to be a skinney white girl who turns to cigeretts drugs alchohol and and pharmcutical drugs, along with bulimic and other unhealthy issues that keeps those perfect little bodies skinney in hollywood. We know of many satrs who are on drugs to keep their body thin whose life expectancy is no better than a 450 women.
It may be harsh but they said all the same things about the chick form hairspray bright future ahead of her well where is she now any one seen her sorry to say howard is right on so many lvls I dont like him at all but in one year we will be saying what happened to that big girl form that movie
Well, there are some roles. Look at Hurley from Lost.
She has a problem and needs help. If she were a meth addict and Stern told her to get herself cleaned up before she dies, would people be mad at him? You are all delusional if you think shes fine the way she is.
The awards ceremony is about acting, not the actors personal attributes, just the acting. The attack Howard made was an assault on a person who has a personal issue. She was nominated for an acting award, not a beauty pageant.
So she has a weight problem. She was also nominated for an Oscar. Let her enjoy the moment and tell Howard to stop being such a d–k.
He might have been awful the way he said it but it is 100% the truth. That girl is obese and needs help. And can anyone honestly think of another role that girl would play unless she dropped hundreds of pounds? No, there won't be one.
It is time to stop celebrating being fat. Bench the salt, eat a salad, and stop frying everything. Oh and salads shouldn't include a pound of ranch, crutons and bacon bits.
I saw that others mentioned the likes of Chris Farley, John Candy, Dom DeLuise, Marlon Brando, Elvis...they seemed to miss one glaringly obvious thing:
They're all dead.
hes 100% right, blunt, but right. nobody eles has the balls to say what he said, cause nobody wants to "hurt her feelings". like that would even budge her, shes a beast. and shes gross. as much as no one wants to admit it, you need to be pretty and likeable to be a celebrity in hollywood, most of the time. she is neither. she needs to get help becuase its gross and very unhealthy. i dont want to see her in any movies. what other kinda movies would she be fit for anyways? none
I don't even want to touch the subject re Gabi's weight. It is none of my business, and nobody asked for my opinion.
I just have this for Howard: Who bore you?
Has Howard Stern ever thought about plastic surgery..is this why he has the face for radio??? Shut the f up!!
Regardless of what you think of Stern, he stated what most people were thinking. I had not seen the movie or her before, but my first thought after seeing her was about what role she could ever play again. Regadless of age or race, she is a morbidly obese woman. What roles will she have? She needs to first save her life and then think about a career.
First Amendment is what it is. Don't like it? Don't listen. Simple as that. People say stupid things all the time why must you all freak out about it?
Besides...Sounds like he's venting some frustration. Robyn Givens left him for the same reason Sibide wouldn't date him in the first place. You guys are smart. Figure it out:)
Howard and the rest of ya'll should do your damn homework. She has already filmed two additional movies since she shot Precious. I think that would constitute "WORKING AGAIN." Hollywood is not kind to any woman that doesn't look white, blond haired, blued and anorexic. Gabby is beautiful both inside and out. The weight issues should be her issue to own not the rest of us.
Sadly...he IS saying what everybody I know was thinking. I mean, that poor girl is one of the largest people I've ever seen. What possible roles can she be up for in the future? How is she ever going to have this "cinderella" career that people are talking about? No chance. Howard lacks sensitivity in his choice of words, but what he said is true.
What I failed to add to the bottom of my statement is this..
"Gabby, young girls are watching you.. So show them and let them hear how you are trying to be healthy.. NOT that when you leave the Oscars that you are "hitting the Chik-Fil-A HARD when the Oscars are over" ..
How is that a responsible thing to say??? What is that showing other young girls who are struggling with their weight?? Forget your health? Just eat all you want?
One thing ALL actors and actresses or public figures need to remember is this... Quit your whining.. You asked for this. You wanted to a "movie star", " a model", "a singer", etc. So you asked for the public attention in my opinion. So we are going to look to you and worry about the ones we care about.. You are going to be scrutinized down to the color of your toenail polish.. If you didn't want the attention then you should have picked a different line of work...
Yes what Howard said is mean, but it IS his job to be mean... right? He also said the truth.
And by the way, tho all those who make comments about him, but have never listened to his show, Howard makes fun of everyone – overweight, skinny, white, black, stupid, etc. but most of all he has made a career of making fun of himself. He always makes fun of his nose, and his gawkiness, and the size of manhood. So for those that think he can dish it out, but not take it, or that he doesn't make fun of his closest friends, listen to him for a while before you make assumptions!
She could call and thank Howard. She is as big as a house. What movies is she going to be in "The Grape Ape?"
I am a black but thought of the young lady as being over weight
Colour does not play into this as some people are thinking
The lady needs to do something about her weight given that she even has some money.
I am overweight and at over 55 I ma struggling to get it off.
The dress she wore would have been even more flateering had she been a wee bit lighter in weight and that is the honest truth.
Howard might have been blunt but maybe there is no other way to say it for this to create an awareness.
H. Stern is right. That woman is so fat the only movies she will be able to apperar will be made for Imax theaters...
YAWN...Stern is no different from Rush....all about getting ratings and attention....get a real job Stern!
Howard is the man! He says what everyone thinks but is too afraid to say because they don't want to get fried in the media. I listen to him every day and will continue to do so. He spoke the truth. This young woman needs help and everyone that tells her she looks beautiful is becoming an acomplice to her near term death. She needs to seek help from a nutrionist and an exercise trainer. Her life is at risk forget movie parts she will not be able to get on a plane with out having to pay for that extra seat. You go Howard !
Howard Stern is a piece of garbage. Why is he on the air to begin with? No one should care what he says!
Howard Stern's remarks are just plain rude. Do you not think that this young lady see's her size when she looks in the mirror or everytime she has to buy clothes, sit in a seat, etc. I'm sure she will work on getting the weight off. What she doesn't need is his thoughtless comments. Also, what does her color have to do with her size?
Where's the mystery? Stern talks about EVERYONE. She is morbidly obeise. I don't see anyone trying to help her. It's not like there are a lot of roles for morbidly obeise women of any color. And there are no roles for dead women.
Its called being brutally honest,but when it comes to Stern that means clubbing baby seals honest. Let look at what said and not his delivery.She wont get any more part in hollywood unless it has to do with obesity.She is morbidly obese.About 822 people a day, 300,000 a year die from obesity.
For all of you out there bashing Stern, the purpose of his comments was to point out the FRAUD that Oprah is, not to bash an overweight girl, and that was more true than any of his other comments. Anyone who actually listens to his show understands his point, which he always has one. Just so you know Howard cares more about that girl than Oprah ever will.
Stern really is UGLY inside and out. Please CNN, don't draw attention to Stern and his vile behavior by mentioning him at all!
It would be great if she could use this opportunity to lose some weight and get healthy as an inspiration to other people who struggle with obesity. Celebrities can have a tremendous influence on society.
totally agree w/ stern. I don't care what skin color she has. That deg. of overweight is disgusting. Out of 100K actors/actresses, is this all hollywood can find to play a role? Where does this thing come from anyway?
Well people, I hate to say it but this is why our health care system is in such a mess. Healthy eating is my household's health care reform.
I really don't put a lot of value into what he says. If appearances really mattered, wouldn't he do something about his own look? Didn't his look go out of style about 30 years ago?
I wish somebody would remind HIM of why he made it in Radio and not on movies and television.
Mr.Stern is not very nice on the eyes.
For those of you who say Gabourey won't be doing another movie – she just finished filming another movie titled "Yelling To The Sky." As for her size, yes she is a really big woman and yes she does need to mind her weight and health to which I am hoping she does, but I find many of the comments here inappropriate, based in ignorance and silliness, and just mean-spirited. I'm happy for her and she's a role model for women who are usually looked at with disdain – usually from people that have low self-esteem issues themselves. I wish her continued success and a long life. And yes, she is bright, articulate, and has a sense of humor. I sense that she will be losing weight and will have a good career, whether it be in movies, television, or what have you.
Let's give her a chance. She's young is very much aware of her size which she noted is a problem in her family history. Maybe this acclaim will give her the opportunity to begin a healthier lifestyle. Stern's comments were way below the belt but let's not forget what he gets paid to do. When this young lady opens her mouth I forget all about her size. I hope that she doesn't let Stern's comments cause her to lose any sleep. I wonder what his daughters' and wife's reactions were to these comments. Enough said. He gets paid to make comments like this.
Go Stern! Somebody needs to be telling the truth about these morons.
Maybe it's glandular?
That is what everyone else used to say years ago about enormous people. The best role model she could be would be to go on a medically supervised diet and keep up the good acting.
She cannot be happy with herself with her size. Doesn't mean she has to be a size 4, but just get the weight way down! Then she could go on Oprah or whatever talk show and that would be an inspiration to many people with similar weight problems.
To the person who asked why Stern feels the need to speak every thought he has: it's his freakin job! A job that pays him millions of dollars. Having this article and publicity of the matter will bring more awareness to both Gabourey Sidibe's situation and the situation of other obese people than could have gotten otherwise.
If he hadn't said these things, it would have been a non-story. But with his comments, some good may come of it, for Gabourey Sidibe or possibly someone else.
550+ comments on Stern ripping a fat chick.....hilarious!
I don't get it. 75% of you don't like what Howard says or how he says it, yet you read it all and take the time to comment.
If you haven't figured him out by now, you aren't paying attention. The fact is, he's right much of the time, and he makes you think all of the time.
That is a lot more than you can say about the other loudmouth on radio, Rush, who is almost never right and doesn't want you to think.
Who cares what this pig has to say. Howard, your 15 minutes of fame are over.
...coming from the ugliest man in show biz.. There's no need to talk about her size, it's her talent that got her nominated.
Does he own a mirror???????
I hate Stern, but in this case I completely agree with what he's saying.
While watching I couldn't help but think the same thing. Look, I'm 6'3 300 pounds....by all accounts overweight. But, at her size it would be ridiculous for Gaby to think, or to be told by Oprah, that she will have an amazing career after this movie. Rom coms....their out. Action flicks....I don't think so. I have listened to Stern for years. People hate him for speaking bluntly...and perhaps this is warranted. But the truth of his words, however harsh, is undeniable.
Interesting all the rude comments about Howard – obviously, people who don't watch or listen to his (very successful) radio show. Howard is one of the nicest, warmest people you could ever meet. His claim to fame is being able to turn off the filter that *all* of us have in-place between our brain and our mouth. Even very nice, warm people have rude, mean thoughts we filter out before they get to our mouth – Howard doesn't
That's the secret of his success – he's no monster, just an ordinary (but nice) person who's learned to turn off his internal filter.
This is why I despise Howard Stern.....he was the little geek that nobody liked when was a child I'm guessing and he is still ANGRY AT THE ENTIRE WORLD....I wonder about the people that listen to him on a regular basis....I guess to get there daily dose of " yeah lets put someone down so I won't feel so bad about myself"
By the way, these are Gabourey's own words regarding her weight:
"It's something I've had to work at. My first diet started when I was 6 years old," Sidibe said. "I've never been a small girl. One day I had to sit down with myself and decide that I loved myself no matter what my body looked like and what other people thought about my body."
She said she made peace with her body in her early 20s (the actress is 26). "I got tired of feeling bad all the time. I got tired of hating myself."
Howard has always been STERN when it comes to his comments,this is why he has to be listened to on SIRUS radio. I think that the show the BIGGEST LOOSER would be good for her as she would show the world how much her carrer does mean to her and how bad she may wants to be a star. As she could be a role model for others with everyone knowing already who she is. But i have to agree it was not a pretty site as the OSCAR'S are to be about the GLITZ AND GLAMOUR!!!
Im starting to believe that Rush Limbaugh, Pat Robertson and Howard Stern are the offspring of cow dung! Then Howard uses concern for her weight as a way to get by with what he said about her. If his sidekick Robin doesn't quit his show, we certainly know who pays who for what. Howard you just proved that you are a racist, maniacal jackass who just proved that everything about him is small. Everything!!!!! Its a wonder you have children. Hey Robin, I wonder what he says about you when you aren't around!
P.S. Howard...you are Butt UGLY
Howard Stern – Acting credits:
Fartman
Nominated for:
People that live in glass houses should not throw stones. Has he looked in a mirror lately, he shouldn't be commenting on other peoples' appearances.
big shocker – Stern is insensitive. Don't like him, so I don't listen to him. Society, right or wrong, has changed our collective perception of beauty – but thank goodness for wiser heads (like Oprah) who still see the beauty within and talent even if dolts can't. That being said, this overweight nurse agrees that being closer to normal ht/wt is far healthier.
Those comments were harsh and he could have said them nicer. But, I love Howard, listen to him everyday. I'm not thin by any means. I think only because he said it – everyone gets all worked up. Those upset by it, do not listen to Howard on a regular basis – because there is alot more to him that this. Everything is always taken out of context and he's always protrayed as this evil, horrible person who does nothing but look at naked women.
Unless you listen you don't know how many people he actually lends a hand to ...get over yourselves everyone.
I think it was just as big a shot at Oprah in Howards subtle little ways!
Isn't wonderful that we live in a country where you don't have to listen Howard Stern if you don't want to? So don't listen to, or read articles on, what he has to say. Take it one step farther and don't comment on it either. If you choose to inform yourself on the humor and rhetoric of Howard Stern, then you would need to listen to the whole show in order to understand the sarcasm and truth behind the things he says.
It's also very unhealthy to live alone, without any friends, admirers, anyone to love, or anyone who loves you. Based upon this fact, Howard Stern will predecease her by many years.
Wow. Most of you who are turned off by this need to realize something. While he was extremely rude in what he was saying, he was speaking the truth. Hollywood is a medium that you are almost required to be AT very least normal looking to acheive enough rolls to establish a career. It's a sad statment, but the fact is nobody really wants to pay 10 plus dollars to see a super morbidly obeise man OR woman on screen unsless its in a degrating roll. She will maybe get 2 or 3 more rolls handed to her by Tyler Perry and then when his star fades, so will she, and it;ll e all down hill from there. Also, all of you who have been ripping on Sterns looks, he's on radio, that not a visual medium, were it's not required to look even half way good. I'm sure this young woman is very sweet, smart, and talented, but her out of control eating will be the end of her. Terriably sad.
She is not at healthy weight i agree but nor is his way way way too skiny wife. Please stop judging people and reflect on your own life. Loser
Howard doesn't smoke, I can't figure out why some people on here made comments about him dying from cancer from smoking. He has a super-healthy lifestyle. As for his comments, they were all true and just what I was thinking when I saw her. Pluto may be too small to be a planet, but not that girl!
Howard Stern is ignorant. He does not know what Gabourey's future holds for her. ANOREXIA isn't healthy either but you see a hell of alot of women walking around looking that way. So what is Stern's point. Oprah's comments about Gabourey was based on her internal person, not her external and if we all started looking at people from this perspective the world would be a better place.
Truth Hurts....Howard Stern always gets flack or ridicule for saying/writing/and speaking the truth. If the actress was white...everyone would have come out and said the same things Howard Stern said without thinking of backlash. But the actress is African-American and everyone is scared to say anything derogatory. Howard is telling the truth...he is concerned about her weight and he is not afraid to say it.
yes, she is at an unhealthy size, but so are the waifs on his show. one extreme vs. the other
The first time I heard Howard Stern was many years ago visting my friend in NYC , and I said "you wake up to this?" Several years went by and I had the misfortune of seeing one of his specials on TV on New Years Eve at my cousin's, upstate. Howard, you are a disgusting pos who makes fun of the retarded and the obese. You have no talent, no skill, and no class.
Hate him...but he is correct.
Howard ALWAYS makes fun of his own looks, so those calling him a hypocrite are wrong. hypocrites all over this thread though, saying negative things about him while lambasting him for saying negative things about someone else. Come on, Sidibe is enourmous. it's sad, she seems like a sweet girl. He expressed concern for her health and is talking about her long term career prospects as well (which are not good). it's hard enough for women of color to get good roles in hollywood, even harder for someone who is morbidly obese. people have been discussing her weight since the movie came out, not sure why this is news. and hollywood is the most vapid place in the world, also not news to anyone. she needs to take care of herself first and foremost and those around her should help, which is what howard is saying.
Flattery kills. The girl, from all accounts I've heard, truly is "beautiful" on the inside. But, to lie to her and act like she can maintain a long-healthy career at that weight just isn't right. Beauty can't be judged by physical appearance alone, but health can. She's not healthy.
Howard Stern is a shock jock. He's simply doing his job. Are the hurtful words necessary? No. Is he right? Yes. How many legit roles can you seriously land at that weight? She just did the perfect role, so that one's out. People want to relate the actors they see on screen which is why average sized people will be selected for 80% of movie roles. How many actors (especially female) do you see winning oscars who are anywhere close to that size? But beyond her career, her life is at stake at that weight.
Oh give me a break...stop making this a racial thing. Pamela almost had it, but then wrecked it with her last few sentences. Who cares if this actress is green, blue or purple? The woman is vastly overweight, it's dangerous to her health, and unless she can find a part for a hugely overweight person (very much a niche part I'll add...), she's going to have a huge problem finding more work in Hollywood. Why does this ALWAYS have to be a black/white thing...??? Focus on the point here people...it's a weight thing, not a race thing!!
Kris said : Everyone is always preaching saying that Britney, Miley, Lindsay, etc should be correcting their behaviors because young girls are watching them.. Well the same needs to be said to Gabby.. young girls are watching you......
I hope young girls are watching her and thinking I might not be skinny but I can do great things.
Look, we all know she needs to lose weight for health reasons. And yes, Hollywood does not cater to women of her size, and it does not (for the most part) cater to women of her color unless they are drop-dead gorgeous and weigh 90 pounds.
But let's not forget that we rarely hear others harping on how UNDERWEIGHT much of Hollywood is. And this is also extremely unhealthy. So Stern, if you're gonna make it a point to blast an overweight person, why don't we ever hear you saying the same about all these underweight, malnourished individuals walking the red carpet?
One thing I did notice about the Oscar's this year, though, (very different from past years) is that a lot of the female actresses actually looked pretty healthy for the first time in a while. I didn't see anyone and think 'Wow, she's gonna disappear.' Maybe Hollywood is waking up to the reality that being too thin can kill you (Brittany Murphy is a good example, she was skin and bones).
Its not about getting parts in a movie or whatever your looking for in a career. I look at her and the first thing that comes to my mind is this: Dont you even care enough or respect yourself enough to take care of yourself. It is just a straight health issue. Its like any other thing done in excess....everyone says leave her alone as long as she is .... blah blah blah.
She is obese BUT there is a time and a place for every thing. You do not go on an award show and tell someone who you are supposed to honor that he or she is fat. It is quite tacky and impolite. Others have also accussed some of being too PC, sure it might be true in some cases but I feel that the reaction is born more out of the feeling that what Howard Stern said, albeit true, was NOT NICE. It was rude.
Was he lying? No. Not at all, she is morbidly obese and No one in their right mnd would insure her. Make 12 months at the gym and 12 months out of McDonalds your career.
This shows the hypocritical nature of Hollywood that they are critical of someone overweight but never remark about someone who carries an unhealthy lack of weight.
Anyone who is "shocked" by Howard's comments obviously has been living in a cave for the last 25 years...this is newsworthy?
Everyone is right! But hey...she gave an amazing performance, so she has talent. And like Howard said now that she's got a little money she probably will do something. It's just too bad that we, as a culture feel free to bash people like this. What, Howard, you don't think she already knows she has a probem? What about your nose! Dude, you don't even need a finger to pick it...you can use your tongue! And that hair! Remember...we all live in glass houses!
I can't stand howard stern however I do agree with him. I was disgusted on Oscar night every time the camera showed this woman; like a big, obese black woman is the new Ava Gardner or something. Like a freak show, her pictured along side all of Hollywood's glamour queens like she was one of them. Yuk.
We all agree that she needs to do something for her health, but I am sure there are people close to her who will work with her on this. However, this does not mean that anyone, including Mr. Stern, who has the right morally to single her out and that the obvious in such a harsh manner. I do not listen to him because it is my choice to not waste my time with his tirades. His followers must derive some satisfaction from his twisted ways, but I cannot for the life of me think why.
This young lady will find her way and I wish her well. Hattie McDaniel was mentioned and she also was large. I loved her dearly and felt she was talented and much loved.
while the performance in Precious was difficult and portrayed well. I do not think we should be labeling "americas cinderella" as someone who is the snapshot of what childhood obesity leads to in this country.
If someone is lucky enough to land a major role in a movie with the success of Precious they should they make a commitment to take some of their earnings and get healthy. Obesity is an epidemic in this country and not in any way healthy. Type II diabetes and high blood pressure are almost confirmed by just looking at her.
Congrats on your performance, and success. But now, Gabourey get yourself healthy and be a true example for so many kids who look up to you to tell their story.
I like Stern. He's pretty funny. I don't think he was doing this for a joke, he genuinely meant what he said, in my mind. He may just have a point, as well. She is most likely shortening her life.
At the same time, that's what landed her this role, and she shouldn't change for anybody besides herself.
He touched on some valid stuff, though. Now that she has some money, she could devote herself to becoming slender, and that will get her tons of noteriety, as well.
Obesity is a disease like alcoholism. It needs treatment. It is time we recognize it for what it is. These people need help.
Of course Stern is right. No matter how unpleasant.
Poor girl has no future in Hollywood or anywhere else if she remains that overweight. Obviously she will die of obesity related complications.
Stern is an a$$, but he is also right on this one.
What is funny is his show is on a paid service and directed to people who choose to "opt in" to the experience. Why his remarks need to be relayed to the rest of society who obviously dislike him or don't find his show entertaining is beyond understanding. The only people that hear him choose to do so. Get over it....
I love how the man with a 'face for radio' is casting stones about how people need to look to do well in showbiz. What a loser. Stern...hope you're healthy. Skinny people suffer from diseases and heart attacks, too. I doub't you will ever appear in the IN MEMORIUM montage for you "amazing" revelation of a film PRIVATE PARTS *insert your mind as one of your parts that is small*
People, love him or hate him he is speaking the truth. I am a 400 pound man and WISH someone would have kicked me in the rump 20 years ago on this issue. All on me for doing this to myself but does not hurt when someone confronts you with it so you open your eyes.
He, according to the article, did not once say she was not a good person WHICH IS WHAT COUNTS. Howard was not always skinny. He gets it. He KNOWS he is not attractive so the people above harping on that GET OVER IT. Has nothing to do with anything here.
He also did not create the "Hollywood mentality" people. Do you realize who created that? ALL OF US THAT WATCH OR READ ABOUT OR CRAVE NEWS OR PICTURES OF THE "PRETTY PEOPLE". She may be an incredible actress but nobody cares because she it not the "ideal". Love Howard or hate him he is speaking the truth and in his up-front way he is doing her a favor and actually seems to care if you people will simply see him as someone OTHER than who he is. Quit being so holier-than-though folks. Not ONE of you who have commented has never had a similar thought as was expressed by Howard above. Howard is not to blame for SAYING it, we are ALL to blame for causing the problem in the first place.
Everyone complaining that what he said may be true, but "mean" is stupid.
I'm sorry, but there is no "nice" way to tell someone that they are too fat, and should shed the pounds.
And on another note, the way he said it wasnt even really mean... it was very matter-of-fact and true. You should listen before you start assuming that he probably said it in a mean way due to his abrasive reputation.
If the movies are supposed to depict reality, at least to some degree, then there are probably at least a few roles available for obese people. Especially in the US of Big A.
Sorry Pollyannas, Stern rules and like it or not he tells the truth. Everyone complaining on here needs to grow a pair and realize that he called it the way it is.
Once again,Stern is correct!!I really dont think this is the time to get PC !! And as we all know,now that shes popular,none of her stooges that surround her wont say a thing,mainly to save their jobs !!
Just because something is true doesn't mean it should be said. We'd all be better off if we practiced simple rules of kindness and courtesy rather than flaunting our super clever wit and cool ability to put others down. Save the criticism for things that matter. Start a movement. Kindness rules! Pass it on.
I did not know that being a young, obese black woman has anything to do with being nominated for an Oscar, and having probably the best night of your life that a young woman could have possibly ever dreamed of, whether you weigh 95 pounds or 500 pounds. Five minutes later.......in comes good old Howard....prick..the balloon burst. I mean, come on, why are people so obsessed with other people's imperfections. Do you think they don’t know? Duh! Obesity is a personal issue between yourself and the reason why you got that way, but does that mean you are, forget about capable, but not allowed to achieve, be seen in a beautiful way, have a great mind, and have aspirations that goes against the thin~white~rice grain. Hmmm.....I hope Gabourey Sidibe achieves in any aspirations she has just like anyone else. The nice thing about Gabourey is she is young, and she can do something about it if it is a problem for her, however, poor Howard, look at him, and that’s probably after plastic surgery. Making a comment like that from someone in his position can potentially be a career killer for anyone but him. Yes it is all about ratings for Howard, but if you dig deep enough, you have to ask yourself, what happened to Howard to make him the way he is: Just great acting (me thinks not), or he’s actually a world renowned philanthropist who dedicates all his free time and money to the bariatric clinic of his choice because he is so worried about obesity in America? Was he treated so poorly as a child, picked on by school bullies, or whatever, or was he a totally spoiled child that insulted people and they gave him everything he wanted just to shut him up?
Also, it is not a given that an obese person will have obesity related health problems of any sort, or "die of" them. They are made more likely, but they're not a foregone conclusion.
this is sterns job, to make waves. and hes not wrong, she is overweight and its not healthy.. and if oprah was referring to her acting talent then she may not be wrong, but fact is the roles for an overweight woman in hollywood are slim (no pun intended). she should make an investment in herself to become healthy.. anyone saying stern is just bein mean doesnt know stern.. hes just being him. and speaking the truth as he does it.
Yes she should drop some weight and I'm sure she doesn't need HS to tell her that.She's a smart girl...she knows already.He needs to focus on his own ugly self,inside and out.She may be fat but he's butt ugly and she can lose weight!!
AMEN howard . You said exactly what I was thinking. That fat cow took up 2 seats at the oscars and is hideous to look at. Shee needs to drop 200 pounds, stop eating fried chicken and get some plastic surgery.
To Gretchen who raised the comparison to Hattie McDonald: Ms McDonald was an established screen actress before she got the GWTW part and did relatively few on screen roles afterwards. A lot of her later career was in radio- a non visual medium(thankfully, or we would have to look at Howard Stern, too).
Gabourey may be beautiful on the inside, but acting is what you project externally
Stern is tactless , but there is a reason it is called morbid obesity.
All of you who see "truth" in what Howard Stern says must have issues yourself. Was John Candy famous? Is Oprah herself not overweight from time to time? Why exactly is Sidibe incapable of overcoming stereotypes perpetuated by the masses? Other people have done it. Anyone can become famous if they believe in themselves, are true to themselves, and have talent, and she has more of any of that than Howard Stern has ever exhibited. Anyone who even remotely agrees with him is a blind sheep and should try a ltitle openness.
does any1 remember nikki blonski from hairspray? the overweight white girl star? seen her in anything lately? just DWTS, dont like howard but he does speak the truth. just sad that ppl still go black vs white still.
She already knows she is overweight, she is the only one that can change the outside. Something is bothering her on the inside that she needs to work on first.
Who is Howard Stern – and why would any one with an IQ even slightly above that of your average junior high school student – care what he has to say?
Our fascination with a rude potty mouth armed with a micrphone, is what's helping to lead America right down the porcelain convenience (toilet).
It true....why is everyone so sensitive about the truth. She is what she is. She will not play another part in the movies unless the character is geared towards her size....she drops some LBs and she will open up a new door for her.
Oh, c'mon you know all know what he's doing...
He's managed to manipulate the situation into something which would obviously generate controversy. He touched a nerve and now Stern has, once again, whipped up a frenzied mob- it's the only way to capture the attention of all the desensitized zombies who fax us invoices, pitch meaningless sales offers, look at our credit score...
Stern represents honest communication. Here's mine:
End Times believing-Right Wing-Neo-Conservative-Iraq war loving-purity-ring wearing-censorship embracing-homongenized lifestyle-mo'fos- – - you all can go to hell!
I worked technical support in a call center. I was only one of 4 women who did this sort of work. The rest of the techs were men between the ages of 19-28. Of the entire staff I was perhaps one of 3 people who were normal weight or thin. There were so many young men who were huge and couldn't fit into chairs and such. It's not just Hollywood, it's America. This poor gal is, like it or not, a poster child for the morbidly obese. Did her weight make her less of a talent? no. Will her weight, as Stern pointed out eventually effect her career in that she may actually die of her weight? Yes. Does it hurt when Stern calls people out? yes. Does it sort of seem like Stern just like Hooters models? yes. But let's not lose the core message. Being morbidly obese is not healthy. See Food Revolution on ABC, March 26, 2010
Couldn't care less about Stern but his concern about her obesity is on target.
I love Howard generally, but instead of criticizing her for her size, criticize the food companies who prey upon poor, lower class people by putting addictive additives in their inexpensive (but good tasting) foods so that not only are they horribly bad for you, but also are highly addictive (on the level of many class 1 drugs). obesity is a huge problem among low income people directly because they have no other option but to purchase the most inexpensive food options, which end up destroying their health. Message to the health care reformists: try to reform the food industry to disallow the use of such ingredients in our food to try to improve the quality of everyone's health, particularly the low income wage earners who are largely uninsured and thus who's consumption of health care directly impacts the rates of those who are insured. but I don't expect that Howard would ever get this deep on his largely superficial radio program
Head Diva in Charge: I think the point is that she is not healthy. And in a country struggling to deal with healthcare, the costs people like Gabourey put an unacceptable strain on our resources.
What happened to manners? My Mom always taught me that if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all.
I agree with howard stern,he is only saying things that alot of people are afraid to to say without being criticized,this is what is wrong with our country, too many followers and no leaders. Political correctness is BS
What was said could have been said better but lets face it people that both sides of this are wrong. no one has lied because the future is not set on what we think now. yes it may influence it but nothing is for certain. for all we know this woman could turn out to be the woman version of Chris Farley. As for Howard i know its what SOME were thinking but that's why we don't say it out loud, cause its rude.
I always find it funny when Stern passes judgment on others- he's so ugly! I think "face for radio" was coined just for him. He should really just worry about paying for his daughters' plastic surgery and not about this poor girl.
Fire his sorry ass NOW!!!
He's crude, and rude, but the little person inside of each of us, is saying the same thing Howard is saying. I listen to his show and he often reads or plays on the air what people say about him, and not all of it is positive. He's the first to make fun of his appearance, and takes it with a grain of salt. Love him, or hate him, his opinions are his and if you don't like him, he'll be the first to say, "change the dial".
Baba Booey !!!
Mr. Stern of all people should know that it's not always about superficial beauty earning one success in Hollywood. All he has to do is take a good look in the mirror.
He said it in a way that a lot of people need to hear it: brutal and honest. Perhaps it'll wake her up and get herself into rehab. People may not like the way that Howard stated it, but he just said it in a way that most people want to say it.
Perhaps it'll shock not only her, but the rest of the obese community into adopting a healthier body weight and as such, a healthier lifestyle. It's people like Gab that set a bad example for other women out there.
Either put down the cheeseburger or end up dead by 30. Perhaps by then, the weight of the medical system in the US will be lifted... by about a megaton.
Well, if Stern can be so unfeeling, so uncaring, then so can I. Yes, let the truth be known that he's just a homely looking, scroungy looking old man, so, Howard, please, since you have a lot of money in the bank, why don't you get that ugly bee's nest on top of you head cut!
Yes, she is very overweight, but that doesn't give anyone the right to call her names or speculate of what she may or may not become. I just read where she has landed a role on a show on Showtime. I do think she is on her way to being a great asset to Hollywood. This was her first film role and she was nominated for an Oscar. That's saying something. I wish this girl all the luck in the world. I really hope she makes it.
Obesity is a disease that needs to be dealt with, but who are we to judge others? It's none of our business how this girl or others live their lives. I don't have to pay for her medical bills, so I really don't care. Some of you really need to get over yourselves.
to hehehe,
Are you trying to compare ELVIS to this black girl? Even Kathy Bates or Dom Deluise? You put all three together and they barely make one Gabourey Sidibe. That's not being mean, that's being real. Dom and Kathy may be big, but Gabourey Sidibe is morbidly obese
Lucia C
Hit the nail right on the head. I would like him with amnesia in a room with no mirrors. And comment on his own show and see how flatering he would be about himself. People like him make this whole world a little darker. Howard grow thw (F) up.
Well... there is some validity in his comments. Being overweight is almost certainly not a good thing for one's health, and of course it won't help her career. Prejudice against those who are overweight is the one "OK" prejudice now- and this is doubly so in Hollywood. We know this. But to be rude about it? That's not going to do any good. And if she is as good an actress as she must be to have gotten to this point, it is a shame that he can't find something positive to say about her, rather than insult her over something like that. Perhaps a private comment to her if he is truly concerned about her health- but not something publicly derogatory.
How could anyone think Howard Stern was right to criticize her for her weight and color combination? As a fat person myself, I can honestly say that EVERYONE feels the need to tell me I'm fat and that I should lose wieght. I KNOW!!! I eat salads, I exercise. Not every fat person is an overeating couch potato with poor moral values and lack of self-control. I personally blame my fat mother and my fat father. You people with normal-sized parents are clueless and say stupid, hurtful things without knowing what you're talking about. There are a lot of stupid people making comments today.
People who complain about Howard don't listen to his show. He's blunt, honest and truthful. What he said about her was the truth. She's huge and is a heart attack waiting to happen which is tragic. Her going on about Chic Filet was disgusting. I was at a gym when she was on tv and all of us listening to her were grossed out. In fact I said, "Yea, that's what she needs...fast food"
Keep it real Howard. Love you!
Howard Stern is the most disgusting, grotesque person in show business. 99% of the stuff that leaves his mouth is profane. So she is overweight. What gives you the right to judge her. Thats a personal issue for her, it doesnt affect you and your everyday life. I find your to be a horrific looking man, your hair is nasty and your face, well, I am not even going there. I dont see you running out trying to do anything about it. But guess what, I could care less because it doesnt affect my life. Your badgering of her size is what is wrong with this world, its why everyone is so fake and plastic. Its garbage like this that has the young girls today thinking they all have to go under the knife.
LOL. I am a black woman and I was totally not offended by his statements. in fact, i just died laughing. it's mean, but it's true. this is why we are the fattest nation on earth! because everyone wants to be politically correct and say she looks fine, but we all know that she is a walking heart attack waiting to happen. not a good image for young black women and men who are suffering the most from complications related to obesity...
I guess it's ok to say things like this if the person is fat. God forbid if it's about race, religion, or any other matter. Nice double standard there!
Instead of being a complete jerk about it, how about you do something to help? I guess public humiliation is the only way you know how to help. Get new material you low grade scum.
I love Howard, yea he's New York Brash and thank god he is not pc but lets face it, the poor kid if not already is on her way to diabetes and heart conditions. Hope she does get help AND she probably took no offence anyway, she's quite light hearted, funny and probably a Stern fan...
Perhaps she can play Monique in the inevitable Monique biopic?
Maybe there is a career for her. She already has another gig with Showtime.
http://movies.msn.com/movies/article.aspx?news=487168>1=28101
Howard, you are so ugly. Now that you have a little money in the bank, go get yourself better looking with plastic surgery so we don't have to look at your ugly face!
To you Stern haters, the truth hurts. This woman is morbidly obese and Stern used his show as a platform to tell her what everyone else is afraid to say.
He said what he said on his show and not to this woman's face. There is a big difference. This is the place he goes to speak his mind and the people that listen to his show know what to expect. It is not his fault that the news media took what he said and spread it to those who would take offense. And I'm sure he would make no apologies.
For those that say he is one to talk, he isn't as egotistical as you would think. Stern knows he isn't good looking and jokes about it just about daily. If you listened to the show a few times you would probably find that his true gifts are his interviewing and storytelling skills, albeit a lot of you would probably take offense to the direction he takes. His show is a mix of low-brow and crude content, but done in a way that is at times extremely entertaining on a long daily commute. For those that want serious content, stick with CNN or Rush Limbaugh. If you want some "adult" humor in the morning, Stern is probably the best there is. Listeners beware.
Yes, she needs to lose weight. However, Howard, ugly can't be fixed! Honestly does he think that women would give him the time of day had he not been famous. Really.....
What he says is true but the way he says it (intentionally) manages to alienate everyone. It's as if he's shouting, "Your house is on fire, you dumba@@!"
This is not a moral issue this is the facts, aside from Howard, the problem is she is a severe food addict and not healthy. She will die young due to this problem and she is not a role model as far as her health goes. Americans have enabled fat people for too long. We have no problem saying terrible things about alcoholics and drug addicts and the mentally impaired but food addiction is right up there with all of that. We have to stop coddling people who eat too much. It is NOT HEALTHY!!!!! it is not fair to those who love you, it is not fair with the impact it has on our medical needs, they will soon start to charge more to over eaters just like they do to smokers and this is fair. People who have a problem with eating need help and need to be told to get it. Not snow jobbed into believing this is beautiful and healthy. She is a wonderful actress and very smart and she now has the means to do something about it and yes we need to tell her just like we told Robert Downey to get sober. Other countries do not allow their children to get to be this size. Our first lady has just announced her fight for childhood obesity. We all need to be participants and stop allowing our kids to explode in front of our eyes due to lack of exercise and too much sedentary crap in our lives like video games instead of playing outdoors and eating such horrible food at home and outside of home and people are soooo scared to say anything like, oh that child is too fat, its ridiculous. Her mom is big too and you can see where she got her food education from. We have to stop this NOW and take responsibility and stop killing our children with food and bad information and lies. FOOD KILLS!!!!
I am a liberal Democrat and about the same age as Howard Stern. I should be in his camp. However, I never have been. I have never gone for his act. He is basically a stupid uncivilized person who appeals to the worst in others. He is one reason for the culture deteriorating.
He could have said so much more ... this is extremely tame for Stern. For instance, he could have said she can now afford to pay for the extra two airplane seats and strengthened suspension in her vehicles and someone to tie her shoes for her and someone tor wipe the places she can't reach and someone to roll her in flour to look for the wet spots etc. So give him the man a break folks. AND stop trying to justify being a huge fat person by saying some skinny people are unhealthy too. Aks yourself and answer honestly ... How many morbidly obese OLD people have you seen in your life? Right, that's because they die before they get old. So, while she's hitting the fast food hard, keep admiring her suicidal tendencies and sit on your pedestal touting the virtues of obesity ... keep lying to yourself because no-one with any sense is listening.
Howard Stern is an uncouth, foul-mouthed pig who probably gets his jollies stealing candy from babies! Waste of DNA.
i'm sure he is not the oly one commenting about her huge behind.it maybe harsh,but its what alot of people are thinking....get real.
Oprah's not a skinny white chick either but she seems to do okay. Just sayin'.
artrain March 9th, 2010 3:08 pm ET
This is why I don't listen to his show, never saw his movie and refuse to spend anymore gray matter on him.
But I will still read an entire article about him and then post a comment...Sounds like an awesome boycott.
Looks like she will be working again...
http://www.accessatlanta.com/celebrities-tv/etonline-headlines/precious-star-gabourey-sidibe-357806.html?cxntlid=thbz_hm
Good for her.
She doesn't need anyone to tell her she's overweight. She'll do what she can when she's ready. That's how it works.
Orahs job is to make fat women feel loved and important, when in the history of human nature has being fat , not plump but really overweight a healty thing, now because some no name actress gets nominated for a crappy award its ok to be fat, give me a break. And besides the oscars are one of the crapest awards there is, the taste for the movies that win are just horrible, hurt locker hahahaha please Pee Wees play house is better than that.
Gaby is a smart, talented actress. That's obvious to anyone who has seen Precious. Unfortunately, Stern is right. She should lose weight and start a healthier lifestyle. She should do this not only for her career but all aspects of her life.
If you don't like it, turn the channel, or drop your subscription. This is why when we bought our new car and got XM free for three months, we had no interest in renewing. putting on CNN only gives him the attention he desires.
Howard is just telling the truth, this woman is so fat and unattractive she has no shot at a career.
People may forget WHAT you say, but they will never forget HOW you say it.
Howard Stern is right. His statements were not mean, they were honest. Hollywood makes stars out of young, good-looking THIN people. She needs to save some money and do what she can to lose weight and live a healthy lifestyle. She needs to address her serious weight issue NOW, or she will soon start taking medications for diabetes, blood pressure, cholesterol, etc. Anyone who disagrees, or thinks he was being a jerk, is in complete denial.
I am a Black woman and while what he said about her weight being unhealthy is true, the way he said it was immature. But then again Howard Stern is really immature soooo...
Howard Stern is an ass AND he is the ugliest man I have ever seen... Maybe he can play a monster in a movie.....
oh he's right. get over it.
You know we need to sweep around our own back doors before we start poking at someone else's. We all have 'imperfections' that others don't like. So why don't we just zip it and stop meddling?
First, we don't know anything about her health because it isn't our business. It could be thyroid problem which is really genetic which still NOT OUR BUSINESS.
We need to stop judging people. Some of us don't know if we'll have a job or the decent health we do have the next hour, let alone next week. So how does he or anyone know if she'll be in another movie or not? So not our business.
Stern is right on and everyone knows it but they're too afraid to say it because its not politically correct. STERN RULES!
i will not sit in judgment of howard stern because my comments will make me no better than he is. however, it needs to be said that size does not always equate health. i am 105lbs. 5' 3" and have more health issues than that of friends who are considered "overweight". i assure you that when i look at them i do not see a large body. health does not consist of just weight, but of a sound self-esteem, mind, and emotions. in this country we have starved our bodies into submission and in the process have caused more damage than good. dieting does NOT work. it just furthers damages your body's metabolism and will guarantee you struggle with weight for the rest of your life. weight should not be the focus over health and wholeness. over the past weeks i have watched gabourey sidibe handle herself with a grace and confidence i could only hope to attain. i spent years under the stronghold of an eating disorder in pursuit of being thin and "in". it serves no one but the companies who seek to profit off our insecurities and make us feel that we will never be enough. the history of modeling proves the dysfunction of the need for thinness. models today were and are still called "hangers". the goal is to make them look like hangers so the attention is drawn to the clothes not the woman. if you research its history you will find that the industry got its start in a sanitarium where woman were dying of tuberculosis were photographed. gabourey is beautiful, bright and strong. i hope that howard stern can take his gaze and judgment off of others and pursue the betterment of himself.
And PS Howard, Ms. Sidibe is a Psychology major. She's not looking for a career in movies.
Well put Stern. Howard says what everybody thinks but doesn't talk about. You won't hear it on main stream media shows due to their family friendly attutude but you can bet when the cameras are off the hosts and crew are laughing about it. Sometimes people need to hear the raw truth instead of some sugar coated advice, The truth may hurt but its what people "should" hear .
That's Stern the shock jock. If ppl don't like him then sue him. Good luck!
He's a very good courtroom defense lawyer how he phrases his controversial comedy but he's no show business liar. I'll give him that and a few more chuckles.
Here's what is TRULY disgusting:
I watched TONS of pre-Oscar shows...didn't we all? Not ONE of them questioned her weight, didn't bring it up, didn't even act like it was an issue. They had her sitting on a couch next to the smallest waif-like chick up for best female, and she took the entire couch.
Some of you will say "I'm sure she's conscious of her weight and what she looks like"....that's not necessarily true. We have a million overweight people in this country who say "be proud of who you are, be fat and be proud"...but yet these people are the same people that drop dead of a heart attack and then their family sues McDonalds for serving unhealthy food.
Why is it SO wrong to tell people – "hey, have a salad."
There comes a point where everyone needs to make a choice between having a salad or going after one more Twinkie. This girl OBVIOUSLY missed that choice a couple thousand times.
Sorry, but she's SO huge that she's disturbing to even look at. It's more cartoonish than Pam Anderson's breasts! Stern may have been harsh in his criticism, but he's hit this one dead on the head.
Sometimes it's hard to hear, but it's also things like this that might penetrate all of that fat and get in her head a little.....and motivate her to get herself in a more healthy position in life.
Stern is crass. Stern is mean. Stern is also correct with his comments. This woman does not need more we love you's. She needs some direct help otherwise she is not be long on this earth. Stern could have been a bit nicer but come on, this is Howard Stern and not the tooth fairy.
Yes, I'm not a fan of Howard Stern. However, As an African American woman who has lost over 40lbs I can honestly say Gabby is morbidly obese! Also, she blood pressure, She better have health insurance because she's going to need it. High blood pressure, diabetes, heart attack and stroke. So, you were right on this one. Her mother was just as big. What made matters even worse is when she stated on the E network that she going to hit Chik Fil A. like no body's business. Please get gastric bypass ASAP.300+ pounds is not healthy and no we will not defend her on this.
Telling a fat person they're fat is like telling a blind person they're blind. yeah, no kidding, they know they're fat and they don't need you telling them about it, trust me. She will work on her weight only if she wants too, in the meantime you're just heckling her. i find this ironic coming from a frizzy haired, long nosed, scarecrow of a man like howard stern. how many roles are there for loud mouthed jews?
Mr. Stern. I hope this girl is not suicidal because your comments are painful even for me, a skinny girl... If we label people as you do, we could say you just can have a carrer on radio, because you are so ugly. You are a tool!
People keep saying "he has no right to criticize because he is butt ugly" like he would even care... he knows hes not an attractive guy, hes an awkward looking jew.
All you overly politicly correct people are what's holding the world back. Stop worrying about what other people will think about what you say and just speak your mind.
I'm not a lover of either Stern or Oscar nominee, but Stern was right and rude. Let's get real. The girl needs to shape her at least a little to keep alive and keep up her good work. I like to see her in more movies with her talented acting.
Look, Howard Stern is the KING ! He has the b*lls to say what you people are scared too. Listen to his show and your will get a huge dose of reality. BTW , he made the comments on "HIS" show... he didnt go on The View or Regis or Opra, he said it on HIS own radio show. I love the fact that Howard speaks the truth no matter who is insulted by it, we need more people like Howard and less phoney people!!
Stern is just saying what most people are thinking... don't hate the player.
Stomping all over someone because they get a little bit of success typically reserved just for "the beautiful people," that's the sport of low lifes. Good for her, for accomplishing things that lots of people with stellar BMIs can only dream of.
Seriously, has that idiot looked in the mirror lately? I think he has no room to judge. At least she could lose weight....he will still be freakin' ugly!!
HS is tactless and mean, but what he says is not untrue. Since when did Hollywood lose it's vanity? What roles are out there for obese black women? The love interest in a romantic comedy? Puhlease. Her ride in the spotlight was great for her, but lets all snap back to reality.
He only said what everyone else was thinking! Insensitive well ya BUT unfortunately true. Black or white she needs to lose weight for her LIFE not even for her movie career. Oprah pisses me off these days, I guess I'm not drinking enough of her koolaid anymore?
Wouldn't it be interesting if, two years from now, when she lost over 100 lbs., that her reason for losing all that weight was because of the fact that "I heard Howard Stern say the truth about how I was."?
Fascinating.
two words for you = Nikki Blonsky.
Seen her in any good movies since hairspray?
PS: this actress was just signed to do a comedy for Showtime tv.
Why does everyone have to fit into Your Image of What they should be. There have been many heavy women in the movies...You do not know if she has a thyriod problem or some other coontributing factor to her body type. We need to stop trying to make everyone clones...this would be a boring world if we all looked alike.
Everyone keeps saying her weight is gonna kill her. So what? Smoking will kill ya. Drinking will kill ya. For Pete's sake, just breathing and eating veggies will kill ya eventually.
She can walk, and act and go to school. She isn't whining about not getting a job in Hollywood (she already has a film in post-production). No taxes are paying for her lifestyle.
It's her body she gets to do what were she wants with it.
She is going to appear in a second movie in 2010. She has a part in 'Yelling to the Sky' an indie which was workshopped at Sundance.
Most of the time the truth hurts. I work in the operating room everyday. Most of the patients now are 250 pds and more. Most of the surgeries are directly and indirectly related to obesity which causes diabetes and sleep apnea and hypertension. We are buying newer operating tables to handle 500 pd patients, extra long operating instruments, extra wide wheel chairs, commercial scales to weigh patients. I see nurses getting hurt frequently moving extra heavy surgical patients. Health care cost is skyrocketing and one of the major reason is overeating. No one dares to bring this up because it is politically incorrect. This is a enormous problem that needs to be addressed immediately.
Stern made very valid, TRUE points. He gets paid all that money from Sirius for being a shock jock. Would you expect anything else? Most of you are in disgust about what he said. So, I guess she's not fat and she's very healthy, and she'll be a star!
If she were a young thin beauty, she wouldn't be a world class actress and oscar nominee.
Howie 0
Gabourey 1
Howard, you are like the pot calling the kettlle black!
Atleast Gabourey can do something about her weight should she chose to do so; but your face that is a whole different story. Your are stuck with it! And in the words of Mr. T. "I pity the person" who has to wake up every morning next you and look at that face.
So the next time you go pass a mirror or a window take a good look at yourself and ask yourself who are you to pass judgement on someone else when you aren't antthing to write home about. You are a mean-spirited person who has no respect for anyone's feelings (true or not). It takes all kinds to make the world go round and I hope that anyone close to you never has to hear someone say negative things about them because I am sure that they would be very hurtful to them.
My suggestion to you is to 'get over it" and find someone who is your equal when it comes to bringing people down and take them own.
Leave Gabourney alone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
this si why American Idol needs Howard Stern. Never a dull moment with that one.
Of course this coming from Howard Stern the embodiment of healthy living the man always looks like a scarecrow addicted to crystal meth
Stern is a "shock jock" for a reason. He says things to shock and appall but above all to get reactions, he's built his career on it.
Howard Stern spoke as the most enormous ignoramus that he often exemplifies himself to be. What a jac__ss!!!
I can almost guarantee you that you will see her in Tyler Perry movie soon, so Stern will be wrong. But, other than that, Hollywood will snub her. Stern calls himself ugly all the time, and he is part tongue in cheek with his delivery so take his words for what they are worth. Don't forget this article doesn't transcript his whole conversation or tone. He's both wrong and right at the same time, and sometimes two things can be equally valid.
It's nobody's business, except her doctors, what her health issues are. She didn't make a movie so that she could have her health judged. Fat animations make great movies too and Stern never disrespects them. I say judge her for the character she played and not for her health., sexuality, race, etc etc. Some people are so disgustingly stupid. She is a human being who also happens to be a good actress.
Networks pay for idiots. Case in point: Howard Stern continues to get jobs. If he can find a job - anyone can. What he said was ugly and hurtful. Why cut someone down, because you don't like the way they look? Concerned about her health? That is a bunch of BS. He hates fat people, that's obvious.
First of all, unless she's a family member that you are worried about, mind your own business. She can always lose weight ~ Howard Stern, however, cannot lose his ugly face or his ugly personality.
Stern knew EXACTLY the kind of result he would get for making those cutting comments. When you're an aging "HAS-BEEN" and nobody cares about you, sometimes you have to take out an easy, helpless, young target to draw attention to yourself and boost your ego.
Way to go.
Truth hurts...Oprah couldn't say it because she's been in the same boat for 20+ years.
Stern's a clown, but he's being candid. We need more candid discussions in this country, without everyone having 10000 reasons on why they are offended this time....He talked about fat, he talked about sex, he talked about blacks, he talked about hollywood, he talked about this, he talked about that....Pseudo-Outrage is worse than the offense.
Like Howard Stern is one to talk about somebody else's body/appearance. He looks like a skinny, underweight crack smoker. And did anyone ever see his "Fartman" superhero routine? I never knew such a skinny man could have such a flabby, disgusting pair of buttcheeks. His a$$ looked like a flesh-colored balloon stuffed with jello and cottage cheese. And while we're discussing Howard Stern's body, he's openly admitted that he is hung like a mosquito. So hey Howard.... you're faaaarrrr from perfect too, buddy.
These type of comments are what keep Stern's job security! This is what he is good at.. being an ass and proud of it!! People listen because he is entertaining just like Rush limberger or Hannity or any FOX news show host. Its like watching some get really hurt.. funny and exciting because its not you on the end of the stick!!
I'm no fan of Howard Stern either, but I was thinking exactly the same thing! What new "project" is weight-obsessed Hollywood ever likely to offer her and why is Oprah of all people telling Gabourey that she is on the verge of a brilliant new career when in all likelihood she will just fade into oblivion. Having said that, Oprah was spot on when she pointed out that here was this completely unknown first-time actor in the same category as Meryl Streep! I hope she enjoyed the moment because it's unlikely she will ever be there again!
She is a horrible role model, just let herself go and I doubt she will ever be in another movie. Can't she see herself..
Howard, if you can have a career in entertainment then ANYONE can. I'd much rather look at her than look at you. You've made your career out of being an offensive bully. I, like most people, am tired of hearing your nasty voice. I guess you'll make a buck any way you can.
Well, she's much less offensive to look at overall than just his face is.
Are you kidding me? She is a nominee for her convincing portrayal of the character that she was cast to play in a very dramatic movie. I give her props for doing her thing despite what anyone may have ever told her to the contrary about her "chances" in Hollywood. I enjoy movies with good actors. I have seen movies ruined by horrible casting and bad acting by "pretty" people who were cast because they were the flavor of the moment. This girl is young and has time to correct any health issues that her physician and family recognize. Other than that everyone else can worry about thier own health issues, drug issues, anger issues, family issues, relationship issues, financial issues and leave this young lady alone. How many times has Howard Stern been married? How many push-ups can he do? How many laps can he run? What is is BFI? Does he really care that this girl does well or doesn't do well unless it somehow affects his career? Why does he think that Oprah and the young lady have not had a discussion about her health in private? Oprah has managed to be very successful and still be different than what most consider "camera-ready". Why does Howard Stern feel it is OK to call anyone a Fat-black anything? Inflammatory is not informative. My take on opinions is this:
Children get away with it
Movie critics get paid for it
Everyone else is just being an
Howard,
You have money in the bank.
Get your teeth fixed, fix your hair and do something with your nose.
How does it feel?
this is called freedom of speech people. he always says things that people think about but are too afraid to say it. She really does need to lose weight, who cares if he makes fun of fat people. if you dont like it, don't listen to him its that simple.
Truth or not, if you think for a second that Stern was commenting on her wait because he cares at all about her health, then you're just as brainless as he is.
I think Howard is great. He may not appeal to everyone but he calls it as it is. And for those who criticize his looks– he does that himself! He does not claim to ever be that which he is not. But he is honest and direct and a very moral person–don't believe everything you hear about him until you have listened. He is a performer and you need to separate that on-air persona from who he actually is–a good friend, boss, father, husband and someone who has always supported minorities of every kind. Equal opportunity truth.
Millions of fans (and believe it or not a lot of us are educated and successful contrary to what some people opined here) really like what he has to say! You would be surprised who enjoys listening to him.
He called it as it is-she is unattractive and fat– so, unless she has some great voice or skill that cannot be found elsewhere in a more attractive package, I say she will be forgotten shortly.
I listen to Howard, and this was much longer than the few lines sited here. It was also more of a dig at Oprah than this actress, whom he may have insulted, but he also showed concern for her health.
As for the comments about this woman, he is right, and she has put herself in the public eye, and is fair game to the scruitany that comes with it.
Not that it matters to him or anyone else either. I can't stand the man and I don't find him entertaining. I guess he enjoys being nasty & vulgar & hurting people. I agree that she is an unhealthy size, but being crude and nasty is not going to help her lose weight. I thought the dress she wore looked very nice on her, it was very classy. Her dress was better than Lopez and some of the other women. Many had, what were you thinking moments.
Regardless of what we think, at least she had the confidence to take this moment and shine. Beauty comes in all sizes and if hollywood would stop making those skinny girls into drug addicts some of them would be obese too. We can't have it both ways you are either addicted, drunk, or fat or you can be skinny, with drug problems the fact is they both need help.
What will happen if, God forbid, Howard's words do come to pass, and the poor woman dies and early, weight related death? I'm sure that the media would be full of touchy, feely stories about the dangers and plague of obesity, What Howard says is true, and those of you who damn him are obviously not listeners. These are the words of a man who is, in an admittedly unorthodox way, quite caring and compassionate.
Sad to see how many shallow americans there are in this world, what he said may be true, but the way he said it was to cause pain , in order for him to get attention which equals more Money for him. His mother must not not have given him what he needed, while he was growing up.!! Nobody has a right to talk about someone that way, unless your going to help. Speaking from experience, it's up to you to wake up and start eating healthy. Who are WE to judge when millions of americans are obese!! Including those of us commenting on this. So unless your willing to pay for her to get help, Howard Coward!!!
Keep your BIG MOUTH SHUT!!!!! Sad to see what people will do to get Money and Attention.
Howard who?? Oh yeah. Well, since Stern is quite possibly the ugliest man alive, who cares what he says about other people's weight? It has long been a trick of unattractive middle aged men to pick on women's flaws, so no one pays attention to their own flaws. Sad. Some people will do anything to get theselves back in the mainstream press.
Her costar monique used to walk around saying how women shouldnt be ashamed of being big and how they should not change. She said all that till she got diabetes and now she cares about taking care of herself. So lets not begrudge howard because he stood back and told it like it is. Someone needs to sit her down and have a real conversation with her about what she needs to do. I am not sayign she needs to get kate moss (not healthy) skinny but she needs to be healthy.
harshly stated, but the truth. Like it or not.
And, what do his looks have to do with this? He can't help the fact that he's ugly. He was born that way. She wasn't born morbidly obese. Huge difference. I highly doubt her obesity is due to a medical condition; rather, lack of discipline, control, a combination of factors SHE has control over.
Stern has a style. He also is expressing something that is true. He gets paid BIG money to express himself In His Style! Why in the heck should he suddenly change the way he's expressing himself just because the subject matter is "touchy." He does this every day. I'm not crazy about Howard Stern and I don't listen to him. But he's right about the actress being grossly overweight and that's that. I don't have a problem with what he said at all. You could listen to his show and find something to complain about Every Hour if you wanted to. Leave him alone and worry about the actress. She's in trouble.
Is Howard Stern still on the air? I thought he retired. Isn't he as old as larry King by now, and did he marry that girl who is younger then his kids? Why??
Howard Stern no body talk about your un-kept hair and homosexual appetite, you should get some help in respecting the human race.
Gabby can always lose the weight, but Howard will always be ugly, inside and out.
No one has mentioned the lady who looked anorexic (spc). Another example of unhealthy weight which was pretty skeletal. Even though I don't like Stern, he was telling the truth. It's not all about being a star if you're health is bad and you won't live to enjoy your accomplishments.
And again, for those of you blind to read that ........
Gabourey just finished a new movie titled ..........
"Yelling To The Sky: .................
The Academy Award-nominated actress for "Precious" ..........
will have a recurring role in the Laura Linney series "The Big C" after guest starring in the Bill Condon-directed pilot.
Linney plays a wife, mother and teacher in the Showtime skein who is given a terminal cancer diagnosis and Sidibe will portray a smart-alecky student in Linney's class. Oliver Platt also co-stars.
Sidibe also toplines indie pic "Yelling to the Sky," co-starring with Tim Blake Nelson, but no release date has been set.
Shooting for "The Big C" is set to begin in May for a late summer premiere. Skein is exec produced by Darlene Hunt, Neal Moritz, Vivian Cannon and Linney and produced Original Film and Sony Pictures Television.
This man needs to look at himself instead of commenting on other people. Why are we seeing this story. Why do any of us listen to this aweful person. For me he ranks right up there with Osama BenLauden. His opinions are always hateful. Howard, don't you have anything better to do? Oh thats right you don't because there are stupid people in the world that pay you to be the pain in the neck that you are.
as an obese white man i find this racist and uncalled for! it is a disease that only speed or crack can help! and with the economy burtal like it is whos going to afford that!! i blame my obesity on the govment with the free cheese and food stamps and no job what the hell am i going the do but EAT!!
You nailed it Howard. If some loser came in with needles stick in thier arms the same thing would be said. GET HELP!!!!
Thank you Howard for being the voice of truth and reason. Maybe she can try racing after Toyotas
she can play so many roles, eg. such as a girl next door, or HEB cashier, easy man! fat ppl all over the place in this country, truth and the difference is she is talented! instead of just fat
Howard Stern for PRESIDENT!
Stern may have a way with words but he spoke the truth and lets face it, we all thought it. She was an eye sore to look. Every time they cut to her I was like oh my god she is huge! She is unhealthy and could not even hold her eyes open. Take the money and invest in gastric bypass.
Stern rocks!! I'm a lifer!! Baba Booey!!
Obviously one does not have to be thin to have talent. And the girl probably will get some help. Hollywood may use her quite alot, but only in certain roles, such as in comedy. Losing weight will ultimately open more doors for her. Stern has made many inappropriate comments on many subjects. We all just need to "consider the source." More power to the up and coming new talent.
A. EVerything he said was correct, although, I'll concede, harsh. I doubt Ms. Sidibe is losing any sleep over this, as she can see herself in the mirror. I'm pretty sure she realizes she is morbidly obese. And, anyone with half a brain knows that you very rarely see exceptionally large women in movies. The men can get away with it because Hollywood is sexist when it comes to age and weight.
B. FYI – to those of you saying Howard is ugly and shouldn't throw stones...glass houses...yada, yada, yada...He, himself has said he's unattractive and it's a good thing he's in radio. He's self deprecating and self critical.
C. He has every right to comment on what he wants to on HIS show. He was discussing the academy awards and she was a big (no pun intended) part of the awards. What's he supposed to talk about? I highly doubt that he made these comments for publicity since they were made on his radio show, which people have to pay to hear. Others took it and reposted it to other places, not Howard.
D. He is hardly a racist or a bigot. Howard will discuss anyone and state his opinion on anything that comes up during the show. What, because he described her as 'black', he's racist? News flash...she's black.
Let's face it, as long as people continue to listen to Howard Stern, he will continue to trash people no matter what. Nothing seems to be sacred with him, and that's what he is paid for.
As for Gabby, I wish her continued success, and hopefully she will start to take better care of herself. Certainly she can hire a personal trainer.
When I watched the Oscars, I thought how sad it was that this talented, college educated Woman is going to have serious health issues.
Stern is a jerk who has his own OCD and Mental problems because Daddy and Mommy did not hugging him enough. Stern goes to a Therapist 3x a week. Gabourey Sidibe does not, she goes to school.
Gabourey Sidibe does not live in a ghetto with no good food choices like many others. Gabourey Sidibe has a weight problem that stems from other phycological issues that we don't know about. She's a sweet and talented young lady who I hope will get help. The change is needed for her generation. M onique and Oprah are NOT good role models. Monique talked about getting some greasy B-B-Cue with her Hubby to celebrate her Win. Oprah talks about food 24/7 and has battled weight for years.
When will Oprah ever set things straight, continuously touting the latest Diet on her show . Teddy P died from all this Yo-yo dieting because diets just don't work! They tax your heart and kill you eventually. It's about life style and behavior.
So I agree with Stern on the Health issue, not being Mean is more my style. Stern is mean because he hates himself.
Sorry for any mispellings, I'm in a hurry to go to the gym. LOL
Coming from someone who is an absolute disgusting PIG with Yellow Teeth – enough said.
I say "YOU GO GIRL"
I am glad somebody had guts to speak out. It's better than hearing countless lies from presenters and the like that a girl that size is beautiful and is on a verge of a having a major career in show business. If we don’t have a sequel to Precious (which we won't, because this "unique" story happens in every second household in the Bronx), I doubt there is another role for her. I am glad she had her moment. God bless. But please, not only this is unhealthy, and painful to look at, it sends the wrong message of hope. The only message it should send is to use the newfound fame and wealth to finally take control of your life and lose some weight.
I have to agree with him. If we were alll to look at how unhealhty we are, we would tackle this healthcare issue at the same time. Unfortunately, she's the prime example. She is going to need extensive medical care, pills, etc. to keep her alive. Draining the system. This isn't an incurable disease. Weight can be controlled...unlike cancer or somehting of that nature which should be tkaing up our healthcare time, not overweight people that are too lazy to do something about. Obesity is quickly becoming the #1 killer (if it isn't already).
Prevention is the best medicine. STOP EATING SO MUCH AND TAKE A WALK!
It's sad that all the women have to attack Stern just because he had the nerve to point out how morbidly obese this woman is. How dare any man say a woman is fat! Newsflash... To the women of America, you're fat too.
I hope everyone realizes HE'S RIGHT. Being that obese is unhealthy. Howard Stern's appearance is irrelevant. Being ugly is not hazardous to your health.
I don't listen to Stern so can't comment on whether he's a racist or not. However, what he said regarding this young woman did NOT sound racist to me. The truth of the matter is that if you all were absolutely honest you would admit to feeling a wee bit disgusted when the camera panned to her. White, black, yellow, that big is not pretty and I'm not going to pretend it is just to be pc. Stern is a complete jerk – but don't kill the messenger just because you don't like the message. As for Ms. Sidibe, if she's happy the way she is, so be it but I can't believe that having to struggle every day can be making her happy.
I think most of us try to be understanding about most things, but obesity is a topic that seems to garner much outrage and anger. You may not think it's right to make an obese person pay double for a seat in a plane, but if you had to sit in the seat right next to someone that size perhaps your views would differ. I feel sorry for her that she has this weight issue and would hope that at some point she'll make an effort to lose some weight, if not for vanity, then just to be able to walk more easily and do everyday things more easily. It seems such a shame because she's so young and has a whole life ahead of her.
The truth hurts. Sugar coating this message would only encourage them to try eating it.
People complain that Stern is too harsh, however, this wouldn't be a story, and most importantly – nobody would listen – if his remarks weren't over-the-top on the subject.
Complaining about Howard Stern in this case is like saying Simon Cowell's advice can't be good because he's "mean".
Now she's more likely to listen.
No matter what one says about her size, ALL women and pansy
men will be called racist or insensitive. She's fat, fat, fat. Lying about
it by calling it anything else is very American though. There's nothing
in our Constitution that says I have to lie in order to make someone
feel good. For those who don't like Howard, you will find nothing good
to say about him.....he, at least, is telling the truth. Now for all you
cows out there, start sobbing and crying.
I saw a talented young girl. Then again, I do not judge a book by it's cover because I am old and wise enough to know better. There are so many ills in this world we could resolve if we would stop 'seeing" each other and start working toward common goals. If only we spent as much time on improtant matters as we do on these boards running other human beings down. God help us all!
My problem is not with his tone, it's with the fact that he is stating the obvious. It's more of an insult that he thinks she hasn't realized all that by now. She knows she needs to lose weight. I respect her for keeping her personal life personal. None of us need to know about her weight loss practices or future goals.
You know, I occasionally listen to Howard's show on Sirius when I get the chance, but when anyone, not just Howard, says cruel things about another when they don't KNOW them, like REALLY know them, it's a vile act. Whether she is black & heavy, that's not his concern OR his problem nor is it Robin's problem... Geez, Robin you were FAT yourself too until not too long ago, look at yourself in the mirror for a second. If Howard Stern or Robin Quivers don't like her as an actress, fine... But attacking someone based on physicality ONLY is truly STUPID & IGNORANT. Howard & Robin, get a grip on reality. No one is always going to look how YOU want them to look & face it, she's making a name for herself in a city that is always used to the thin, beautiful, plastic surgery look.... I commend Gabourey & I praise her courage for going after what she wants. Stick to radio, you guys....
Did he walk up and tell her to her face that she was big as a planet? No he didn't. I don't like the guy either but let's get real, when most actresses are considered fat if they are size 10 just where does this plus size woman think she's going to get any jobs? He's right on the money and he's saying exactly what everyone else knows and most are thinking. She can't possibly believe that great parts are going to be handed to her and her size overlooked. So as much as I don't like Mr. Stern, his statements are right on the money.
Stern told it like it is....he never says anything in a politically correct way, but I agree with his sentiments. This young woman needs to wake up and get healthy – lose that weight now. Howard's right, she won't be around long, unless she wakes up. All the makeup, hair and gowns in the world can't hide the fact that she is grossly obese. Please, regardless of your career, get help to lose weight – NOW
Couldn't have said it better myself Howard. So very true. A caller said she could play the marshmellow man in Ghostbusters. HAHA
Ok.. so curiosity killed the cat and I had to google search images of Gabourey Sidibe. All I can say is this...Kelly Price, Remember her? The music industry frowned on her for her size too and she went and had the Gastric Bypass surgery and lost a lot of weight but where is she? You See, it dosent matter if your heavy or thin.If the audience likes you then you will have a career no matter what it is in. However, sadly you only see the heavy ones doing comedy in Hollywood movies never taken seriously. I was reading an article where Gabourey Sidibe was quoted as saying "I love myself not exercise". So no matter what anyone says or thinks is best for this girl she has her mind set. She wants to be just the way she is...and honestly as long as she knows the negatives of obesity (which obviously she knows because you can't avoid it) then why does anyone think it's their place to say anything to this girl?? She has heard all of these cruel judgemental comments through life noone on this message board is saying anything she has not heard before. Yes the truth hurts in life and can be down right cruel, let alone in Hollywood. I wish her well..
Not only is Howard Stern a rude jerk but he is wrong. Gabourey Sidibe has already been hired and appeared in two movies this past year that are both currently in post production.
That lady is humongous. Stern tells it like it is and if you can't deal with it, that's your problem.
Stern unfortunately makes a living making sexual inuendoes (which are not funny, only remotely shocking) and making fun of people. Wow, that is real talent. What an embarrassement.
Stern is absolutely right, he is saying what most of us are thinking.
Stern is 100% correct. Why would anyone dispute what he said.
I have never like howard stern never listen to his radio broadcasts only heard of him thru controversy, but he really said a mouthful when i saw her the cover of ebony that whole body shot the girl is enormous and she needs to get some serious help she is too young for that when u cant see the facial and bone structures its out of hand, her performance was outstanding someone needs to get her on some kind of program
He always makes outlandish comments to get attention. The best thing to do is just ignore him.
America needs more of Howard Stern. He is right – so lets not pretend to disagree. The women is fat. He was not suggesting she isnt a good actress, or her success wasnt earned – but only that she is obese. And we scratch our heads and wonder why there is a health crisis in the US.
Whatever Stern has said is what I was thinking in my mind. But I am sure people have told her she will be criticized harshly due to her weight once she is in the public eye. I think he is outright blatant but the bottom line and at the end of the day what he is saying is what most of us are thinking about her weight. Perhaps the harshness will motivate her enough to show us all that she can loose the weight. She is morbidly obese and that is a fact! Saying mean things and not in a constructive way is what gets Howard the attention and success he has gained. Of course, if you don't like it, as I don't then just don't listen. I quit listening to him but do understand how some people like him. It is all about peoples opinions, likes and dislikes and you gotta respect others but not always join in.
Stern is right! He's also funnier than he is ugly. Long live the KOAM!!!
i think she realizes she is overweight and doesnt need people to point it out to her. i believe this girl does own a mirror! this girl may not get another movie opportunity so why do people have to burst her bubble, her 15 minutes of fame...because they have nothing better going on in their lives so they put down others
Stearn says what everyone doesn't have the courage to voice. If people would listen to Stern instead of picking out sound bites, they would realize he is one of the smartest, funniest, charming family man who has very high standards and morals. F Jackie!
Someone said that Stern is no looker him self. Someone else said he's a loser.... But those are opinions. He may not be a looker, but he's also a RADIO BROADCASTER. At least he knows he doesn't belong on the big screen (sans Private Parts). And I wish i was a loser who made 100 million a year for 5 years doing something I love. How pathetic!
The fact is that most people who hate him barely, if at all, listen to him. He has the right to say whatever he wants, however mean he wants.
That's the problem with this country these days. People are so sensitive and easily offended by other peoples OPINIONS that instead of just moving on and living their own lives, they have to try to make everyone think like them or criticize those who think differently.
Everyone thinks their special and everyone wants special treatment.
Howard was stating a plain fact: She's fat as hell and is going to have health problems if she doesn't change something. And she's never going to have a career unless the Goodyear blimp needs a stand in.
Well grow up people! There is nothing wrong with calling a fat person fat. It is what it is. Do you think she doesn't know she's fat? Should we tiptoe around an elephant and pretend it's a cute little butterfly?
I think not! I'm willing to bet that people have tiptoed around her weight all her life and that's why she looks like a blob of chocolate pudding at this point. She needs some good firm truth injected into her, not more snack cakes and compliments about what a bright future she has ahead of her.
At this point the only way she'll have a bright future is if someone installs a light in her big fat piano case coffin.
Lighten up people. By criticizing Stern, you're being just like him! If you want to be better than him then keep your negative comments to yourself. Especially when most of you don't even listen enough to have a clue about him.
Who cares what he said he is right though and funny how oprah had to talk for her. Cant stand oprah. What is it with some of these Holywood Stars. Always wanting to send money or adopt in other countries. What about all of the homeless and kids that need to be adopted here in the U.S
Truth Hurts. Stern Rules
Love Stern...listen to him everyday. He's very direct and yes, it can be incredibly rude, but he speaks the truth on this one. She is obese, more obese than many that you see on "The Biggest Loser". I'm not downplaying the fact that she did an amazing job in Precious, but really...she needs to lose alot of weight for the sake of her health!
what I dont understand is all the uproar, he has the right to say what he thinks. Does it matter? it seems to here on CNN, We all make comments when we see an over obese person and if you say you dont YOUR FLAT OUT LYING TO YOURSELF. PC has gone terrible wrong in this country. I think she was terrible in the movie personally. I have the right to say I thought that the entire cast and movie were crap. Does that make me a racist, bigot, sexest.
She does need to lose weight and if she does then Howard will be commended for helping the girl. If she dies because of her obesity then Howard will be commended for trying to help her, You cant have it both ways CNN World. It is his opinion and if you dont like it.SO WHAT
Howard Stern has a face that is made for radio.
For all u haters, remember all of us will never be the same, God made us all to his liking. Howard you need some worm medicine. For
those of you who are saying nasty things about the Gabby , I am sureshe is10 times more healthy than you and you are all going to eat
your words as she is going to soars to the sky. Bad mind isa helleva thing.Haters go and "REPENT".
Howard Stern is the greatest thing to happen to radio since Tesla invented it! He spoke the truth as always but in this PC world that we live in nobody can handle the truth.Most of you who don't have any kind words for Howard have never heard his show.You shouldn't have an opinion because you have no idea what you're talking about.Sure she has talent but she she will be dead soon unless she does something to get her weight under control...she probably sweats gravy.That's not healthy...see Chris Farley...John Candy etc etc..
I just read that Ms Siddibe has accepted a role in a Showtime comedy so I guest his prediction has already been proven to be false. She is overweight and guess... what she knows it, but unlike so many people she believes in herself and her talent enough to persue her dreams. Imagine if we all did that and stopped being so concerned about other people's weight, height, intellect, sexuality, etc.
We'd probably actually accomplish some of our own goals. YOU GO GABBY and if the world does'nt like it tell them to KISS OFF.
I'm appalled. Let's start with the difference between "thin" and healthy. Stern needs to get his foot out of his mouth.
I have seen the movie "Precious" and all the way through it, all I could think was, "That is one very unhealthy young woman". Her excess weight was pivotal to the role, and in that regard she was somewhat exploited. It's very sad. Stern is a blithering idiot, and very rude, but unfortunately what he speaks is the truth. The only roles that young woman is ever going to get are roles calling for an unhealthy overweight woman. She is amazingly talented, and now she needs to get healthy.
While uncouth, Mr. Stern's comments toward Mrs. Sidibe's weight and the health risks it carries are absolutely correct. It is extremely difficult to tell someone that they are obese, yet sometimes the painful truth is necessary. At her current weight, Mrs. Sidibe's can expect to live roughly 20 years less than a woman of normal proportions. I encourage everyone to speak tactfully with those that they love about their weight (and all issues related to health, but aside from smoking, being obese is the worst preventable issue we see.)
A personal anecdote I can relate occured last summer when I was at a relative's wedding. I saw my cousin and his 22 year old overweight daughter (she is approximately 5'5 and 140-150lbs) and struck up a conversation. Years ago, we were close, but with the passage of time, we have drifted apart, and this was our first meeting in 4 or 5 years. When I had a chance to speak to the daughter privately, I asked if she had a wedding in her future. She replied that she was single, so I politely let her know that with those who exercise frequently are much more likely to marry, live longer and happier lives, and less likely to develop an array of diseases such as heart disease. I asked if she wanted any information on nutrition and/or dieting advice, but she did not seem too receptive. A shame, but I feel good knowing I did my part to offer help.
I am not a fan of Stern, but what he says is true. We are too politically correct. If you are fat, you are fat! Not "big boned". And this gal is FAT. Get some help, lose some weight, or we will all be paying for your medical bills. Not fair for the rest of us who exercise and watch what we eat.
Thank god someone said it! Its true. I think it's worse that people are lying to her than Howard saying the truth. We make excuses and say it's okay to be fat now when it is just plain and simply not healthy and not attractive. Period.
Can anyone, honestly, imagine all of Hollywood fawning over a morbidly obese white woman? The answer is no. Never in a million years...
I love that everyone keeps saying how ugly he is and he has no room to talk. He is more critical of himself than anyone out there. He know's he isn't very good looking and fully admits it. He is a radio show host and comments on what is current. It's truly one of the only radio shows out there that is even listenable. I don't agree with everything he says, but he is right in this case. Many of his listeners are some of the biggest celebrities and richest people in the world from actors to CEO's of fortune 500 companies. He makes money for advertisers and is probably close to a billionaire himself, like Oprah. Like the man or not, he evokes controversy and conversation, which still makes him one of the biggest influences in pop culture.
oooooooooooooo – so controversial! Stern wants to make money.
Talk Bad = $$$$$$$
Mr. Sterns is correct, she is heavy, but he is ugly – you just can't fix ugly
Wow, there are ALOT of fat people with issues on this board. Howard Stern told the truth, why is everybody so mad?? Hey if you bunch of slobs cared so much about that fat hefer Sidibe then you should tell her to drop the weight. Don't shoot the messenger Howard. He only says what people are really thinking. The REAL DISGRACE is OPRAH for lying to ole fatty.
Although I disagree with the way he said it I agree with what he said about her weight only I said she'd be dead in 5 years.
No one should comment! This sick, insensitive fool deserves NO ATTENTION WHAT SO EVER!! Who died and made him King! His opinion is insignificant!
What an a hole. Sure she is big but you don't riducule a person because of thier physical apperance she done nothing to you howard. Thats why no one cares about your show you long nose idiot
Ok... So Howard Stern was finally able to get his name in the news again. *ho hum* Can't he do anything new? He's been doing the same schtick for over a quarter of a century. Isn't he learning that he's grandma and grandpa's shock jock?
I'd rather listen to PhillyD.
shocking the howard would say anything shocking. its just his opinion people, doesn't mean he is right!
Everyone acts like the fact that he points out that she is fat and black that he gives a rats tushy if she's healthy. Reality is when Lindsey and Ashley and Mary Kate snort themselves into oblivion noone says a word because they're petite white chics, and I mean how healthy is that. Lets just be real. Lets not pretend we're concerned with Ms Sidibe's health and call a spade a black, fat a$$ spade... Mainstream America will never let ANOTHER fat black woman get ahead... you guys already said it... how can there possibly be room for her when Monique and Oprah's fat a$$es are taking up all the shine... RIGHT?
Wow, Howard, like every woman struggling with weight issues needs the creepy likes of you to point it out to her, as if she doesn't deal with it EVERY FREAKIN' DAY OF HER LIFE! Has anyone told you lately that you need a face transplant? You've got enough money, get on with it, for crying out loud.
This being reprinted is my only issue with it. This is not only an unnecessary article, but it just brings more attention to comments that were obviously unnecessary to begin with.
I'm sorry, but Howard Stern is a pig.. with a capital P.
Gabby may be a bigger girl, but where is it written that if you have a weight problem, whether it be heavier or thinner, that you can't act?
My only guess is that he (Stern) must not have had a very positive childhood, nor loved very much!!
You know, it amazes me when someone puts someone else down and then they go back home and look at themselves in the mirror. I really wonder what Stern sees when he looks in the mirror? It's no wonder why he's on radio, this guy looks like Tiny Tim's illegitimate child with some skanky crack addict.
I'm really loving the idiots who throw the word racist and bigot around.
***FYI people, criticize an african-american and you're a racist. Even if the person has legitimate issues.***
Remember this in about 3 years when your president gets voted out for inaction and trying to push through healthcare that over 50% of people don't want but he keeps lying and saying the majority do want
People listen to his to hear the harsh, off the cuff banter... Not to listen to an overly PC news person gloss over the fact that she's 350+.
And all the accusations come from people who have probably never spent much time listening to the show. The man is obviously nothing close to a racist.
Stern is an ass. But when he is right, he is right!!
Stern is dead-on. His job is to SHOCK people, therefore it is obvious he pulls no punches on purpose. He is an entertainer. However he is accurate and everyone knows this, despite the bluntness. We provide a forum for him because he is famous, so he will use that forum in a shocking way.
BaBa Booey to you all....
I feel the same way as Howard Stern, but I wouldn't put it the way he did. I took one look at her talking to Kathy Ireland & said oh boy. I didn't see the movie, but I saw her. She's kind of hard to miss. The first thing is "who dressed her?" . She is short, very heavy and she should have been in an entirely different outfit. Needless to say, very heavy people have to dress differently from thin people. Blame Hollywood, and make them look in a mirror.
That's funny coming from someone who looks like a cocaine addict...
Well Howard is entitled to his opinion but in my eyes a talented woman was recognized for a job well done. As for what he said about her weight and hollywood may be true. However he's been in the media for a long time and hardly anyone would call him attractive. I think the BBW actress is way better looking than him by a long shot but hey that's my opinion.
Anyone who says Howard Stern has no talent is a complete moron and has no idea what they are talking about!
Howard hit it right on the nose, she's a good actor obviously but she's the size of a ship...with talent.
You people who agree have no consideration for being human. Do you know her personally? She might be working on her health, she might have a health problem causing her to be overweight but people like Howard say hurtful things about her. Grow up and be adults it was wrong what he said. Another thing if she was normal sized she would not have gotten the part. so what is Stern talking about?
Howard Stern's black sidekick Robin Quivers made much more controversial statements equating this girl to the killer whale that recently killed it's trainer and how she's Shamu.
but of course that won't get reported. Since black insulting another black is 100% fine.
he called a fat black girl a fat black girl and that is all it takes to make you a racist please his number two is a black woman stupid
Does she get health insurance from the Academy? If not, we all be paying for her choice of lifestyle.
In Indian epic "Ramayan", there are characters called Rakhsasis. The physical description of the Rakhsasis matches uniquely to this woman Sidibe and half-Rakshasis match Oprah.
I don't like Howard Stern but he has a point. Obesity is the new smoking and these people should be pressured by public opinion to change their habits just like smokers. It eventually works. There are far fewer people that smoke nowadays and hopefully we will have fewer gluttons in a few years.
Stern speaks the truth whether people want to hear it or not. Time will only tell whether he is right, but my guess is that he will be.
It's not about looks so much as health. It's time people began taking obesity seriously- #1 cause of death in our country. We can't keep pretending that it's "o.k." to look how you want. Obesity is affecting all of us with a rise in health care costs, insurance premiums, etc. People may have to be harsh to make an impact.
i can not stand that man.......we need to verbally attack him and his family.......lets see how he would like it........
Thank You Howard Stern. All that Hollywood is doing by giving this girl a role is sending a message to young people that it is o.k. to be overweight and unhealthy. I am sure that there are people who disagree. Overweight people were probably inspired to see someone that unhealthy and unattractive reach this level of acclaim, but they should really understand why she is so famous; for being the most enormous actress ever. It sends the message that it's ok to sit on your butt and eat KFC for your whole life and be the next fat actress instead of working hard and being healthy. I wish this story were about her going to Weight Watchers. That would be inspirational...
If she never gets another role in a movie it says more about the stereotypes movies put forward, because there are a lot of fat women in real life. Women who go ahead and fall in love and get married and go to work every day and have families, whether or not other people think they "deserve" it or not. I find it hard to believe there are no interesting stories about any of them.
I do wish that people would stop insisting that they are just worried about her health. The truth is that fat is always portrayed as ugly, and people don't want to see ugly, but it's not PC to say this, so we hear all the noble concern for her health. I don't see anyone worrying about Charlie Sheen's health, and he's at least as likely to O.D. as she is to die of a heart attack.
He is rude but he is right. There are so many more actresses out there why did they pick this one to be nominated for an oscar. She is so obese. It is so ridiculous that our society tries to cover up obesity with "love myself for who i am " crap. She is morbidly obese. How on earth did she get that part??
He is so right. Everyone should stop acting like they don't notice how obese she is. He will be the first one to tell you how ugly he is. Stop being so politically correct.
How can you not simply agree with him on this? He says in his show that he like the movie, that she played a good role. He is not saying anything bad about her, just that she needs to lose weight, which he is right! And it IS wrong for Oprah to go up there and lie to her by saying that she is starting a brilliant new career. Unless she is going to play the part of the whale that killed that woman as Seaworld she will not be in another movie.
Yeah yeah, Stern speaks the truth, blah blah, blah, and there is also something called tact. Stern has none of that. Sad that he has to go the easy route of his radio personality to say it. Oh well, Karma is alive and well, everyone gets their dose of it eventually.
This is a new low for Ster – which is saying a lot for him! But that's what a 'shock jock' is all about. Ones appearance is a personal matter. I'm sure Sidibe knows about her appearance, and even about the possible consequences, but that's HER decision. We should all pay more attention to people's characters rather than their looks. it be a better world!
"Waaaaaahh Waaaah Waaaaah! He's so mean, boo hoo!" PLEASE! Cry us all a river! Howard Stern built his entire career on being honest and not holding anything back. The truth isn't always wrapped up in a pretty pink bow.
Howard Stern is a cruel, useless human being.
Look at every post here: All the girls here say I am rude and a waste, and all guys say its the truth = all the girls on this post are fat. Only someone who is fat is going to get upset when someone tells the truth. Hit home, huh ladies? Go do some chinups, and take that donut out of your mouth and quit worrying what I say.
well Howard Know-it-All she got THIS part didn't she? Leave her alone.
I disagree with Stern – I think this young woman has a promsing career ahead of her. Think of her range as an actress: she could play a marathon runner... I mean... she could play an inspirational bike messenger... I mean... she could play someone who doesn't live on the ground floor of her building... I mean... OK Howard may have hit the nail on the head with that one.
She was not worthy to be in the company of the others. Fortunately she did not win up against real journeywoman actors. The limit of her range will probably reveal itself. And she will disappear for health related problems in the near future unless she acts now to get control of her weight.
It is not insensitive to be honest to someone about the way their weight affects health.
How you delivery the message is the key point.
It is a health issue. Any doctor would – and should – tell her the same thing. She is not a healthy young woman. Her figure is not "curvy" – it is obese. And I hope she can get healthy. Not "skinny". HEALTHY.
Sidibe should be offended by what Howard Stern says. It's an opinion and Howard was just being Howard. I believe what he said, to a certain extent, was true...She is a big girl and she should try to loose weight only to be healthier and yes, Hollywood wouldn't extend extra roles to her because she is not a marketable actress as talented as she is. But it was HOW Stern made the comment that came off as being offensive and down right rude. But seriously, did you really expect more from a shock jock? If you don't like Stern, dont listen to the douche...just like I dont listen to Limbaugh or Hannity.
Stern's comments were extremely harsh. The only problem is that he is 100% on point. The girl will never have a career and she is a one hit wonder unless she does something drastic. Her weight is disgusting and she needs to take control of her life. It is a HUGE health concern and needs to be addressed extremely fast before it is too late. Hopefully she does something about it. I pray she doesn't take the lazy way out like most of the overweight American's in this country with surgery. She needs a lifestyle change.
I don't like Stern, but the truth is the truth regardless of the source.
The fact that you would report on this and repeat Howard Stern's remarks just rubs more salt into Gabourey Sidibe's wounds, and frankly, makes you just as ignorant as him. What is happening CNN? Is there nothing better to report?
Freedom of speech is fine within reason. But to say what he did was extremely out of line. The man ? is a low-class OAF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Howard is 100% correct. Facts are facts. Is she obese? Yes. People that are obese and overweight are at more risk to have heart disease, strokes, cancer, etc. If you are in movies and or a celeberity, you are gonna have people talk about you publicly and be critical of you. It comes with the territory. And by the way Howard jokes all the time how he is ugly......so he even makes fun of himself about his looks. If Howard would have said this about a man.....most of the women on here wouldnt be ripping him.
STERN RULES.............BABA BOOEY!
She looks horrible. This is not about a few curves-this is obesity at its worse. She needs help .And I thought Oprah remarks were very patronzing and mean .She is not my Cinderella story .I am not impressed by lazy people who lack control over their lives. So if she is happy with her 350 pounds fine- but I do not wish to look at her. There are a lot of fine actors of normal weight who have survived tough situations to make it into the business. Why aren't they Cinderella stories?
I can see Gabourey in a reoccuring role on SNL were she talks to parents with troublesome kids and tells them what it's like to live in the van "down by the river" and then she falls on the coffee table. That would be funny. Sometimes you have to laugh instead of cry.
Damn! The number of enablers here is unreal. I just hope all you people that are crying "Foul!" will be just as vocal when this woman dies of a massive heart attack or stroke.
Howard Stern is speaking of his own rejection from Hollywood because he is considered ugly.....on the outside as well inside. He has tried for years to leave radio and move onto TV or movies...no one wants to look at him or hear him unless they are porn stars. His beautiful wife would not even be with him only for his money.....VERY bitter and hateful man.
Gabourey is talented as well as intelligent and well make more movies hopeful she will lose weight for health reasons along the way.
These messages boards terrify me. Are there really this many people living around me with their heads this far in the sand? The inability for most American to use reasoned, rational thought and judgment is why we re all going to die of over-population, war, disease, or pollution one day soon. Too many idiots among us. To spell it out for you, here are four main things you need to come to grips with as being right:
A) Howard is right. How many obese (not just a little chunky, I mean OBESE) working actors are out there? None. Seriously, name one. And not giant overweight comedians who we all laugh at (John Candy, Chris Farley, etc.) They all died before they were forty anyway – of poor health!! I'm talking about actors. There are none, and that is a fact.
B) Howard wasn't being mean. He wasn't making fun of her weight, or laughing at the fact that she will never work again. He is telling her to take advantage of the fact that she has had a little success and a little money, and go get yourself healthy. That is called honest tough love, folks. Smiling at her and saying "you are beautiful and great just the way you are" is NOT honest, nor does it help her. It only helps the image of the person saying it (Oprah), because she wants to be perceived as a NICE person! It's all about stroking her own ego!
C) Howard knows he is one ugly bastard more than anyone. That's why he went into radio, dumb asses! He KNOWS that his unfortunate Big Bird looks precluded him from ever being a successful on-screen personality. He knows that looks matter and that he does not have them! And that is what he was telling Gabourey!! So why do people keep harping about his looks? The difference is, no matter how healthy and fit Howard is, he will still be ugly, and he knows this. Buy Gabourey, well there is a good chance there is a pretty face under all that fat, so if she can get to a healthy weight, she might still have a career, and he is saying that he hopes she does something about it.
and lastly,
D) Howard can say whatever the hell he wants! Constitutional Amendment #1 – Freedom of Speech. If you don't like what he has to say, exercise your right to NOT listen to him. Let's not waste our time talking about what he should or should not say. You have a choice, make it.
Howard Stern is a shallow, hateful scumbag. He has zero talent and his messed up opinions count for nothing. I cannot believe that there are people here who agree with this piece of crap.
Seriously folks, Stern is an entertainer who serves a specific audience. He makes comments like this because his audience accepts and gets a kick out of them. With that said, he is absolutely correct. Hopefully the only role she gets in the near future is a spot on Celebrity Biggest Loser! Jillian would whip that tush into shape!
I said the exact same thing to my wife as Oprah was introducing her. We live in Orange County, CA, and Hollywood is not now, nor ever will be able to shift gears and sell the idea that a larger size woman/man is bankable. People don't aspire to be fat. Stern took the words out of my mouth.
People need to realize that Hollywood is not reality, its Hollywood, you don't like the rules, go the the Jersey Shore.
In true Stern fashion, he can't say anything delicately, but the message is right on. Oprah needs to check herself too. This is in that same vein of Jennifer Hudson getting an Oscar on her first acting job. It's totally ridiculous. YOu don't have acting chops worthy of an Oscar on your first movie. It's just more of the HOllywood machine running out of control, playing to what they think will be politically correct. It's all completely bogus. Hollywood is bogus, big-time.
I feel the same way each time I see Stern. Pal, you're an
uncommonly ugly and obnoxious guy and you seriously
need to consider a face-lift.
Howard Stern is an idiot. The bottem line is he has no one else to talk about and he just needs to get a ratings increase so h
No matter how big this actress is, no one's life can be more miserable than the life of someone who goes around speaking to people like Stern does. In a career decades shorter than Sterns, this actress has shown more grace than many of those at the Oscars.
Stern you are a low class dumb ass. Why do you think it is ok to make fun because of the way they look? Have you looked in the Mirror lately? You are truly a sad sad person, I feel sorry for you. It isn't entertainment when you have to belittle someone to make a living. I guess it just shows what a no talent you are..... Grow up, You are just a Bully.
You have no room to talk, Howard, about what "Hollywood" should look like! This coming from a man who looks like an old horse with a wig!
I don't agree with Howard, but I understand some of what he has to say. Hollywood is full of phoneys, I would bet a million that most of the "beautiful" people mocked her in private. This is the same people that busted on the woman from "mad men" for being "curvey". I hope she goes on makes a differance, but I wouldn't bet on it.
Stern looks like an ugly Ichabod Crane, form "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" story. He has no room to talk he is not prince charming.
Howard says what we are all too afraid to say, and is always the truth.
This is what makes him the greatest interviewer on the planet! I love
you Howard.
I hold the same amount of contempt for Stern as I do for Imus, Limbaugh and Beck.
They are all gutless, classless punks.
Every one want all ethnic groups to look like WHITE skinny girls. Gabie is more real than most.
Why is anyone shocked by what he said. He should be reminded however that fat people can lose weight, ugly is ugly forever.....
Look at the number of responses. Whether you love or hate him everyone seems to have something to say. Stern Rules! Baba Booey!!!!
Stern is still on the radio!?!?!? Who knew! More importantly, WHO CARES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i totally agree with Howard. She needs to get on celebrity fit club then on to the biggest loser and then try jenny craig.she might get down to atleast being obese.there are 20 million black women that could have played that role.oprah should kinow this. how many diets has she been on herself? oh and for a future role, E.T. 2010, the 2010 being her weight.
Well if they ever decided to remake Gilbert Grape she could play the mom. Hehe
And while I don't agree that Stern should have added the extra comments of her as a planet, I do think he has a very solid point. I know that when I first saw her all I felt was pity. Maybe she will read what Stern said and make some changes. No one else seems willing to give her a wake-up call.
I listen to Stern and he is always talking about how ugly, skinny , lanky, insecure he is , and yes he comments on other people's short comings but you do not have to listen or agree with him it's America freedom of speech, I really dislike Rush L, but do not listen to him anymore & do not bash the people that do. If you do not like Stern so what just move on with your life.
Someone should tell Howie that there is a reason why he is on the radio. He's a mutt. And with a face like that he should not say anything bad about anyone. He looks like "Lurch" with bad dentures. But usually people that are not mentally stable and have issues with their own looks will put others down to bring themselves up. Its his thing, it's the moron that ever put him on the air and the rejects that listen to him that need to have thier heads examined.
Howie, although you make a very valid point, albeit in a low class kind of way, the girl deserves your respect for having the courage to reach for a goal and achieving it. And even if she never plays in anything else, she will always have her shining moment, when we saw her for what she was, and not for what she looked like....
I was disappointed that such a grossly obese person would get an award. Howard Stern is getting nagative comments from other obese people no doubt. The world should not award obese people with any type of award no matter what it is. Make them know that they are over eating, food that could go to someone whom is severly under fed. I thank H
Yeah, Stern..and you are ugly.
Just an FYI, Gabourey has already finished her second film and is about to start another... And as someone who's also overweight, I find that the topic of her size is ridiculous when you see her talent – why are we still judging people by appearance? Yes, a healthy lifestyle would be a good choice, for myself as well, but slashing her future is not a helpful means of communicating a hope for her to change her eating habits.
Did the man lie? I think he is the ONLY one who said the truth. Big fat Oprah is the liar here and I might add she is not helping that fat girl at all by telling her a bunch of lies like she was cinderella. Wasn't cinderella white? I mean come on! stop with the lies Oprah. It's bad enough that starlets have all these "yes" people around them that they don't know what reality is anymore.
Thanks Howard for setting everyone straight again, like always and baba bouy to you all!
He sees it, he says it, he's right about it. Deal with it. My line of work requires me to tell people the truth about their situation, and 85% of them are in denial about the truth. 75% of that 85% come back later and say I had their situation right and are now glad they were told. Over sensitive public needs a life lesson in the truth. Most just love to hear what they want to hear, and if someone is 'direct' with them, then that person is the wrong. Deal with the truth and move on.
uh whoo whoo... Frrrrrrrrrrrrrrrunkis!!! Howard blows.
It was very interesting to read the various comments posted. Personally, since I have a life-I could care less about whether or not someone else is fat or skinny, black or white, ugly or pretty, is rich or poor. We have become so consumed about other people's faults we forget we have our own. Maybe that's why 'Shock Jocks' get the attention they crave. People harp on their every word in order to not look at their own realities. If Ms. Sidibe gets another role or not, the world will continue. If she dies from obesity, the world will continue. My only question is, what are you doing to make life better? If your thoughts revolve around someone else's lifestyle, then you need to check yourself.
Stern – look in a mirror – not only are you one of the most ugly people on the outside, but you just let the world know how ugly you are on the inside as well. You have become popular by making a total ass of yourself and you will never attain the dignity required to be a real star.
That guy is a complete idiot. I don't understand the mentality it would take to be a fan of his.
Interesting. Stern says she will never be in another movie and yet her next film "Yelling to the Sky" is in post production.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1504508/
He needs to check his facts before he goes mouthing off.
If only Howard could be this honest to the enormous fat black chick that sits in his studio
One thing about it.......Sidibe is big and can lose weight if she chooses. Stern on the other hand is grossly ugly and you can't do a darn thing about ugly!!!
There is a 750 pound white women Ruby with her own show.
She is a lovely women with a beautiful sprit, she has friends
and a good life. Howard is sad he has no friend no life and
he must feel pretty small to attack someone he doesn't even
know in such a voilent way. I think that he sounds like a man
with a small pe pe and probably need to take a whole bottle
of the little bills to make himself feel like half a man. He wish
he had her life and success only god can judge her on only
will decide who successful she will be. Howard your not
god
Diane
i agree with stern, she is huge and fat and morbidly obese. but i do disagree with stern on one point. she probably will be in other movies. of course, once she loses weight (if she does, and hopefully she does), she will no longer be a second thought to any one. it's like the fat version of reverse racism. think i'm wrong? there have been several actors in recent memory of ....super size proportions..who, once they lost weight, also lost the interest of hollywood. the same could easily happen here.
She's plenty qualified for other roles
Big Momma's House
She could be a Klump in Nutty Professor
The world is her oyster
Howard Stern rules. Sorry the truth hurts. Ba Ba Booey to you all.
If he really cared for her health he could have invited her to lunch and had a private conversation with her. Instead he thinks publicly embarassing her is the way to go.
He is and always has been a pig. Just a disgusting pig who deserves no ones time.
he is only saying what people are thinking
being fat is a burden on other people. not only do you cram our spaces, but you drive our health care costs up because we have to pay for your illnesses
health care companies should drop people if the are obese
People need to start losing weight
its pathetic how up in arms some ppl get. yeah he coulda said it nicer, but why would he? he hates how pc america has become and i agree. pluto would orbit around that woman. its a disgrace u can have oscar, have money and still slob out and be a fat pig. its gross.
Many years ago, while living n Southern California, I was driving home from work at 3:00AM. One of the LA radio station would live feed Howard's morning show from the east coast, where it was 6:00AM.. His show began with a disrespectful bit on Karen Carpenter, the deceased sister of the Carpenter's duo.
Miss Carpenter did nothing in her life to deserve being treated that way. She did bring us some great music!
I changed channels on the radio, and have tuned him out ever since.
Gabourey Sidibe is the hottest girl that I've ever seen. Shame on you, Howard.
The chick is morbidly obese. Stern has a radio show that talks about anything and everything. She's 90% of anything and everything.
Howard may be crass, but he is compassionate. Through his show, he analyzes and pulverizes society and manges to be entertaining as hell in the process. The girl from Precious is not a casualty of Sterns. She simply is a topic of discussion that leads to his opinions of public health and Oprah's malarkey.
I hope Precious makes an appearance on the Stern Show. He would be very gracious and kind to her and if she played her cards right, might get the chance at the sybian.
Moon628 and everyone else who honestly believes Gabi reads this tripe and would look to these bloggers as her intervention 'family', get real. First, the comments are inspired by that egomaniacal slob who looks like a child predator and truly has the perfect face for radio. Trust me, I'm sure she's fully aware of her size. She doesn't need us to tell her. Go cure someone you actually know.
That is too funny! Howard Stern is entertainment he makes people laugh. Those who are appalled guess what? Dont tune in! This guy tells it like it is and that is hilarious! May not be right or nice but that is something he has to sleep on not us. But at the end of the day I am still laughing!
Stern is a genious at what he does, aside from his crude comments he is most likely one of the best interviewers of our time.
The people who drove him off terrestrial radio are the same ones waving a communist flag.
All I can think about when reading Stern's remarks is how blatantly accused Gabourey is for her weight when there are hundreds of thousands of obese men and women in America. But how many of them have defied all odds in hollywood – Just Gabourey. I haven't seen any truly overweight people in movies in ages. And the actors who are fat? Are all men! Her success should be seen as a form of overcoming the show biz's usual shallow expectation for women in the public eye to be thin. While she should be aware of her weight and the health of her future, Stern should be ashamed of himself for seeing a young woman as valueless because of her weight and having absolutely no respect for her talent or her humanity.
The King of All Media called it as he sees it – and added another example of why he could be the greatest judge on American Idol – he knows what it takes to be a star and tells people if they got it, or not.
This story presents it in a bad light. He actually showed sympathy. Howard is a great guy.
Many have complained about how ugly Stern is. That is true. But you can't control ugly, you can control fat. Gabby is the size of a small continent. You can't even see her eyes over all that face fat. It looks like someone chopped the legs off the Michelin Man, and made him eat 500 donuts a day for 10 years, then wrapped him in 50,000 yards of blue cloth and pushed him onto the red carpet. Nasty
Go Howard. You may not like him, but he makes a lot of sense.
Please, people... get real... Stern is a realist. He is saying what everyone thinks. She is FAT. She is OBESE and unhealthy. Shall we call it the "elephant in the room?" Who cares. Let's all grow up and stop getting offended every time someone tells the truth.
One previous poster, an African American woman, referred to her as a "300 pound black woman." Not so. Whereas she is hardly planet-sized, she could top 600 pounds. There is some serious pathology going on with anybody that hefty, no matter what the acting talent. Stern is an ass, but at least he is not a hypocrite like Oprah. Tough love may save her life.
Listen this is how we talk when we are with friends. The whole lot of you are but a bunch of hypocrites. You are thinking what howard says.
Howard thinks what I am thinking. Enough with the political correctness. No one wants to see a hairy legged black fat woman.
enough with the pretentios stuff.
Howard stern is a regular average guy.
enough
I listen to Stern occasionally. I enjoy him. But I can almost guarantee this was a from a bit about the Oscars. He probably wasn't picking on the easy target, he was probably getting his say on the entire topic and this was just pulled from it.
Regardless, he speaks and the truth and isn't afraid to say anything. He isn't for everyone. I just happen to like him.
I believe Howard loves this because for every post put up on this makes him richer. Howard does not get paid to be Mr. Nice Guy and any target that enhances his role is fair game. Be honest, if someone paid you a million dollars to insult a fat black chick would you do it? I would and buy her a date with Richard Simmons. LOL
I'd rather look like her than him any day!!
weight is a sensitive subject, so some tact is needed (and Stern is famous for his lack of tact), but when I saw her performance I thought, great actress, but her weight was very concerning. If Oprah or anyone that praised Gabby cared about her at all, they would encourage her to get involved in some type of healthy weight loss program. It is extremely unhealthy to be at such a weight, and also at such a young age, & her career will be shortlived or plagued by diabetes and sooooo many other problems. She is a cinderella story, and has become an example and role model for girls who are different, but she needs to also be a good example by being healthy.
You people are something. Society comes down on all unhealthy aspects of life and those who practice it – drug addicts – smokers – alcoholics. So why should obesity get a pass?
Stern called it like he saw it. So what if he's no Tony Curtis – is there some rule that says only people can have opinions on "unattractiveness".
As for racism – he's picked on overweight white women as well, so just shove opinions where the sun don't shine – probably under your own overweight butts.
You A-hole....look at yourself! You need to clean up your act! Who are you to judge what other people look like or need? You are disgusting human being and need to shut your mouth!!! You might want to think about cutting that mop that you wear on your head. It looks grimy and come on now...how old are you? Act your age moron!
I saw the movie and it was okay..dark – not too in line. However, as much as I like her...I feel that Hollywood seems to see her as the actress that she played, and feel sorry for her – I'm not trying to be ugly, I just feel that they are not seeing the real person...they're seeing Precious....
OK......I must say...I don't think I have seen another woman this large!! This is really something that she needs to conker....as it HAS conkered her.....now if she did a film based on the obesity in this Country where the obesity rate is 60%......lost all the weight and then formed a reality cooking show where she tells everybody how she did it.....this would be a very uplifting moment for some!!
Who REALLY pays attention to what Howard Stern has to say? They know he is a crude, egotistical, talentless imitation of a man. I do agree, however, that 'someone' should offer help to Gabie in a kind and friendly way. No one PLANS to weigh 300 pounds. The young woman should not be lied to about her weight or her chances in Tinseltown. I think Oprah should add to her little Cinderella speech and offer to take Gabie under her wing.
Have to agree with Howard....she has an issue........
She can work hard, lose weight and get healthy. Howard will be an ass until he gets a lobotomy.
To Howard. Yeah, well beauty is only skin deep but ugly goes clear to the bone!
Okay, she's big. We don't need Howard Stern to point this out. But my problem is that so many people really give a crap about what this loser has to say. He's an idiot! If we quit reacting to his little quips, he will no longer be controversial and will fade away into oblivion.
The one's that don't think his comments are dead on are the fat broads who eat all day. The USA is disgusting, fast food all day, no excercise. Hit the gym once and awhile, stop complaining on the point of view of Howard, you all should try to look like his wife!!
She is a visual emetic. Nobody wants to looks at something that inhumanly morbid and ghastly.
You go Howard..keep telling it like you see it. This girl is obese. She is no difference than a heroin, sex, or alohol addict. Here addiction happens to be food. You don't get to look like she does without having a twisted relationship with food. It's bad people, it's OK to admit that. She also has the right to not listen, develop diabetes and die of a heart attack. Freedom for all. I love America.
The point is whether person is famous or not ....We as a society need to get back to respecting people ...My grandmother once said if you have nothing good to say shut the Hell up......Do u not know she is fat she lives the life ...it is not for us to point it out an disrepect her ...WE ALL HAVE FEELING ...WHY MUST PEOPLE CONTINUE TO HURT PEOPLE ....IT IS SO VERY SAD THE WORLD WE LIVE IN CURRENTLY IS SO EVIL AND HURTFUL
List of some very famous obese people:
Marlon Brando (as an adult)
Orson Welles
W. C. Fields
Roseanne Barr
Cass Elliott
Raymond Burr
Luther Vandross
Wm. "Refrigerator" Perry
President Grover Cleveland
President William Taft
Eleanor Roosevelt
Barbara Bush the first
Buddha
Michael Moore
Winston Churchill
Kirsty Alley
Tom Arnold
James Gandolfini
Dr. John
Oprah Winfrey
Jackie Gleason
John Candy
Fatty Arbuckle
John Goodman
Carnie Wilson
Aretha Franklin
Hattie McDaniels
Dom DeLouise
Louie Anderson
Rosie O'Donnell
Luciano Pavarotti
Placido Domingo
Chris Farley
Quuen Latifah
Ruben Studdard
Randy Jackson
goes to show you that you can be fat and still become famous!
Lighten up on this 26 y/o young lady, Gabourey. She will make the necessary changes when SHE is ready, not when Stern or anybody else tells her to.
Why do people have such a thing against Stern? First of all, it's called entertainment-you don't have to listen to him if you don't find him entertaining. But if the press brings him to YOU, and you really read an article like this and think he's ONLY trying to rag on her, you're pretty ignorant. Of course he's going to bash her-he bashes everyone including himself on a daily basis! But the biggest portion of his words were ones of concern and truth-that people are enabling her and should be trying to help her. She's not just a chubby chick, she's grossly obese and WILL die if she doesn't get help. Kudos to him for actually making a valid point in the midst of his nonsense.
I'm concerned for her too and Oprah calling her a "Cinderella" is only playing into this young woman's denial that there is something seriously wrong with her weight.
Her upper arms are bigger than many of the other actresses waists for heavens sake.
This has got to be an enormous strain on her heart to have to pump blood throughout such volume. Plus, as she weighs close to 400 pounds, the damage to her bones, tendons and ligaments has already begun. Yes, maybe she is supposd to be a big person, but 225 pounds would be a heck of a lot better than 400 for her life expectancy. She seems so nice a person, it would be a shame to lose her.
BUT WAIT, every time I've listened to Stern I've wanted to cry and vomit at the same time too! And I haven't even had to look at him. I think he is jealous that with his bufugly a** he couldn't nominated for an Oscar, let alone get a movie role. He's King of all ugly retarded perverted jack a**es (actually, he's their pimp, but hey, he wears lots of hats), he should be saying, "Hey, I made it and I can't even act (like anything other than a person who can't look himself in the mirror literally and figuratively), why can't she?".
I wonder if Howard and Simon Cowell are related.
if she had an addiction to cocaine – she would have won
if she had an addiction to cigs – they would have smoked with her
if she had an addiction to sex – she would have "seeked help"
if she was anorexic – she would have been worshiped
if she was a he – she would be loved (john candy ring a bell?)
but she is black, she is a woman, she is made fun of, ridiculed and just hated.
Why is it so hard to understand – she has a problem and needs help not hate!
Why does America hate honesty?
I am not much of a movie-goer but I did watch the Oscars... Stern has the name and the courage to have voiced my thoughts as I watched in amazement.. I must admit I am not an Opry Fan. I always thought of her as a hypocrite, sucking up tons of US money, whilst spending what dribbles she does spend, on South Africans, rather than much needy African Americans in the deep South...
The point is whether person is famous or not ....We as a society need to get back to respecting people ...My grandmother once said if you have nothing good to say shut the Hell up......Do u not know she is fat she lives the life ...it is not for us to point it out an disrepect her ...WE ALL HAVE FEELING ...WHY MUST PEOPLE CONTINUE TO HURT PEOPLE ....IT IS SO VERY SAD THE WORLD WE LIVE IN CURRENTLY IS SO EVIL AND HURTFUL
When Oprah said what she said during the Oscars about a brilliant new career for an American Cinderella, she wasn't saying "you're thin and beautiful". She was saying "I want to live in a world where a large woman can be appreciated for who she is, and for what she does. I want to help create a world where we can see the beauty in any body." Good for her.
There are people who cannot loose the weight, it is just the way they are as there are very thin people who can eat all they like & never gain an ounce. Gabouray is an amazing young lady with an incredible personality, she will succeed in anything she wishes, already she has a contract to be in a made for TV movie. Why does everybody assume her overweight is because of overeating? Does it really matter? She is beautiful as she is, Howard Stern is a very ugly ridiculous thin man & there is nothing he can do about it. Who would you rather be?
Why not also comment on the size 0 actresses? Is this healthy? sexy? It is strange that he is only focused on the overweight and not the under weight....but that's Stern lopsided and small balled.
at least she doesn't look like a rat, stern.
Of course she will lose the weight. And just like Monique, she get an oscar one day and look great doing it.
and she is STILL BEAUTIFUL!
People the man speaks to blue collar Americans. He talk's to his fan's like 90% of us (blue collar) would talk to each other. GET OVER IT...go listen to your messiah Rush L. if you don't like what he says. By the way, even Jennifer Hudson understands what she has to do to make it in Hollywood.
Howard is right. The people who are ripping on him for being brutally honest are the same ones that embrace Simon Cowell for doing the same thing. What's worse for Howard to say that she should take her money and use it wisely or for Oprah to lead this girl to believe she's on the road to the land of milk and honey. He's simply saying ( in his own way) that it may be wise to use your money and invest it something like say maybe your "life" She's in what is probably lower middle to low income bracket. Possibly no health care what so ever. She should think about getting herself headed in a healthier direction.
Not be misled by Ms. Winfrey into believing that "Sugah ya'll ship has finally come in" I admire this young lady for having the courage and the motivation to get herself to a tryout for a part in a movie that she landed and went on to become a nominee for "best supporting actress" But honestly Oprah don't try to exploit this young lady and
lead her in a direction that will only bring her heartache. You stood up there that night and asked where'd that comee from. I'll tell you where because I've experienced it all too many times myself. She was putting her life into her character. The hurt the lonliness. Cuz kids tease her they way they do. Because unfortunately children can be very mean and very cruel. Whether you're too heavy or too thin, too short, handicapped mentally or physically. Or maybe you just don't wear the brand of jeans the others wear.kids will always find something to humiliate you about. If nothing else well this young lady showed them and I say she should have been given the Oscar based on just that. I congratulate her for her courage. I hail her for her accomplishment. I pray for her to do the right thing and consider taking a long hard look at herself and not the outside but what's inside. Consider your health. Hopefully this experience was a self esteem booster for her cuz I know how a group of cruel children can suck that right out of a child like a vacuum.
Howard is 100% correct. Period.
This is a prime example of why so many women and little girls have such low self-esteem. This ignorant, obnoxious, insensitive, freak that's supposedly college educated couldn't articulate his feelings and thoughts in a more diplomatic way than that? How sad! Not everyone is made to be "skinny". For all he knows, this could be a long arduous battle (like so many other people) that she's been dealing with all or most of her life! Howard Stern....start acting your age and put your money where your mouth is. Get out there and help develop programs to fight obesity (just like our First Lady).
he just said what everyone else is thinking.....glad he spoke out. too many people are whimps and concerned about "being insensitive".....get over it.
hey howard you are ugly both inside and out.....whats with that hair.....
Has anyone noticed that since having cosmetic surgery on his face Howard Stern looks like a young Annie Leibovitz? Was that what he set out to accomplish?
The way he spoke the truth was rude. OF COURSE IT WAS! It's Howard Stern! He is a millionaire BECAUSE he is rude. If he was polite with his comments he'd be poor and working late night at some AM station. Don't like it? Don't listen to it.
i usually dont agreen with him at all/but Howard Stern is right every which way
there is a diff between being overweight and being obese
Just looked at Stern's posted photo. The guy is ugly in the worst way, looks like an old woman. How dare he criticize anybody! His wife is in ln love with him why? He is so handsome or he is so rich?
You are all so full of yourselves. Anyone who says that Stern is a pig never really listens to his show. Besides, she may be nice. but she is a morbidly obese human.
haha! Since when does anybody give a crap what Howard Stern says.
Stern has to be the most obnoxious and one of the nastiest ever to be allowed to broadcast any kind of show to the public.....intellectually he is a pygmy and with a mouth like his.......even hoof-and-mouth disease is overshadowed........he makes a great deal of income because the public is easily bilked by "germs" like him. Simply put.........Stern is a moron.
What do you expect from Stern? He has a face for radio, a voice for silent movies and the intellect of gravel.
The world has Bigger things to worry about like Global Warming!..I love her CONFIDENCE she is a star in the making....Quit speaking death on her ..none of you on here can give her life or take it away...in three years she'll still be telling everyone to kiss her azz....
You go girl...the haters will come....keep your head up and do your thing!!!!!! People are just jealous....no one gives a damn if you're healthy or not ...just using that as a tool to be racist....Your'e not the first or the last woman who has been over weight...If you feel good in your skin...tell the haters to kiss your chocolate azz!
Dope King!!!!!!!!! comes with dopey stuff. Why can't he look at the mirror and get a plastic surgery done. Low-life scoundrel nothing else to do but make idiotic statements about others. An insipid, an insane, airhead, dim-wit and a light bulb. If this guy is taken a judge in the American Idol. Bet the show will go off the air within one year. He needs brain surgery, a face-lift and an external hard drive to boot up his whole system. Finally the award goes................dope king of the year Howard the Rowdy Stern
The truth hurts sometimes. Ever wonder why you never see any old people her size? It is because it literally kills you to be that fat. Please lose weight and don't eat yourself to death.
Stern is an intelligent and honest person. Most people can't deal with that. This isn't a girl. She's a 26 yr old woman and for some reason everyone treats her like a child because she played a child in the movie. When I watched the broadcast she could barely clap her hands. She is obease, and obesity leads to death everytime.
The King of all Media, Howard Stern Rules!
stern – you are the King.
Oprah is retiring, who beter than this young lady to replace her? She has the mojo!
Sometimes, the truth stings. Sometimes the truth makes us uncomfortable... but its still the truth. You may not like it, but what Stern said, albeit cruel, is the stone cold truth. Mr. Stern's comments were worlds more honest in this case than those of Mrs. Winfrey.
What did he say? That, being morbidly obese, she is likely to not live long. – TRUE That there are very few acting roles (right or wrong) that will come to the morbidly obese? – TRUE
Stern wasn't "picking on an easy target", he was pointing out the obvious that everyone else was thinking (and you know you were), but kept to themselves. In a candid moment, even Mrs. Winfrey would agree....
As distasteful and blunt as his words were, it is impossible to challenge the truth in them. You are a liar if you deny the truth simply because it makes you uncomfortable and you wish to ignore it.
i agree with Howard, do i like him NO, but america has to face the fact that we have become a nation of obese people, which affects me and the cost of my health care. i am very thin not because i dont eat i do, a lot, but a co-worker thought nothing of asking me if i had an eating disorder, what do you think the response would be if i said to an obese person, why dont you stop eating!!!!!!!!! your fat. i am sick and tired of people wearing their fat like a badge of honor, hip hugger jeans low cut blouses, midriff with all their flab showing, disgusting, i dont want to look at your fat, and take some pride in your appearance and quit the fast food and the 55oz drinks you guzzle all day. i am glad howard has the guts to tell it like it is.
Gabby can lose weight, but Howard will remain ugly and ignorant.
what a ass he's so pathetic, he has nothing better to do but judge people, how sad!
Stren has never impressed me. But he is allowed to say the things that he said, regardless of what you and I think. What these comments really tell me is that "political correctness" has swarmed our country to the point that no one can legally say what is on their minds because of it. Don't tell the HS student he is failing school, say the school is failing him. Don't tell the guy that makes money at the poverty level that he can improve himself and get better opportunities. Tell him he is a victim of society and entitled as a result. Don't tell the yound lady that she is fat and that she really cannot sustain life being that overweight. Tell her she is going to have a great career in Hollywood, no worries.
who cares what he has to say. He has enough bad habits that haven't killed him off in 3 years that there is hope for anyone. He's rude, disgusting and obnoxious and thats the only reason anyone listens to him. You dont think that girl knows about her size or how other people view it, that some lame shock jock needs to point it out, and show that he has no class on top of it.
Bwana: Tony Curtis?
I guess Stern is really for GREAT grandma and grandpa...
Wjhats up with Sterns teeth? They are so yellow he may want to see a cosmetic dentist about the age related discoloration. Something can be done about that.
Well, she is morbidly obese after all. Can't blame Stern for pointing out the obvious.
Stern appeals to lowbrow, low class part of society? Funny, I guess my Masters in Engineering doesn't count for much then because i listen every day. Like it or not, he is right.
If you are one of those that says "Never listen and never do", how can you judge him on what he does? And aren't you doing the same thing he did to this fat chick by calling him ugly? Stop breeding because this world has enough dummies. But then again, in the immortal words of Ted Knight in Caddy Shack: "The world needs ditch diggers too"!
Get OVER it people. All he sais is what he is thinking. She is fat and needs to lose weight. Period!!
I am obese, and have tried for decades to lose weight. I walked up to five miles every day for a year and lost two pounds. I joined one of those women only gyms and lost 15 pounds in 4 months, then not another ounce in four years. Last winter I had a foot problem and had to help my daughter-in-law who was on bed rest with a two year old, so I spent 5 hours a day with them, and had no time to work out. So I gained about 10 pounds more. I am 57, and really don't know what to do. I do not eat badly, and I try to be active. I hate what I look like, but at what point do you just accept your body? I have skinny sisters, a skinny son, and an obese daughter Gabby's age. I love her, but I can't make her lose weight, any more than my husband can force me (and he has tried for decades.)
Her and Mo Nique both need to lose a lot of weight, people need to stop acting as though nothing is wrong with these big birds. This Sidibe chick could die she's just too fat. Someone please let her know. I see a pretty girl under all that fat.
I thought she was awesome. Once in a lifetime opportunity, and she pulled it off with grace and style. If only Howard could do the same.
Sidibe: HAS a BIG FAT ASS
Stern: IS a BIG FAT ASS
Stern says things to get attention. He's a very very small man and when he dies only suckers will miss him. He's just as bad (if not worse) than IMUS.
Gabourey's weight is her own business and Stern is rude and unkind to make personal remarks about her. She is beautiful as she is, leave her alone. If she wants to lose weight, she will, it's her business.
Oh yes, Howard Stern is the epitome of all that is good and healthy in this country. We know he likes his pubescently thin, blonde and with enormous breasts. Preferably with as little on as possible. Yes, sure, he's a spokesman for clean living.
She should tell him 'I can lose weight but you're always going to be ugly inside and out'.
Stern rules!! Baba Booey!!
Ummm, I must agree with Stern, though he certainly could have been less cold-hearted about the way he said it. I do, however, question why James Cameron's wife did not come under the same scrutiny for her anorexic frame. Perhaps we all need to realize there can be unhealthy weights at both ends of the spectrum.
thats how these kind of people earn their living by being controversial and rude...like glen beck, sean hannity and other illiterate idiots
Bababooey
Seriously...who gives a fuch what that piece of waste has to say. Besides, he seems to have done well for himself despite his obvious physical short comings.
Oprah is fat and she does okay.
Gaby Sidibe does not need Stern to tell her anything. She knows that she is too overweight, and she knows that she needs to loose all that weight, for her health, her career, and as a role model. She said this quite clearly in a recent interview herself. In fact she did say that she has started on her weghtloss plan. So for Stern to go shooting his mouth off as if he has uncovered a well kept secret is, to say the least, really mean. But from what I hear, being mean is his only claim to fame.
How are all these people saying Howard Stern is not talented? SERIOUSLY?!?! The guy has created the most popular radio show in HISTORY. I never listened to Stern because everyone always said what a lot of you people are saying (he's an awful person, disgusting, etc.), but I started listening a few years back and have realized that is all a LIE. Stern is just a very entertaining, smart individual who is not afraid to speak his mind. This is what makes him interesting. As far as this actress goes....she IS fat, it is HER fault, why is it so wrong to say it? Stern is right, and he made his point in an entertaining way. Get a grip people....
He is right, she will never act again at that size....she's been typecast by that role and nobody will take a look at her, except for a role that calls for an overweight person to be cast, who is of color. Further, it will only ever be in a supporting role. She outta go back to what she did before she got there, she'll have a much easier life than dealing with the pressures of hollywood
You all need to get over yourselves. Howard Stern speaks his mind, if that's offensive to you, don't listen, or read this. The fact that you clicked the link that has his comments in it tells everyone that you actually DO care what he says, despite your fake protests otherwise. boo hoo, I despise Howard, he's gross, and creepy, and yucky, and eats children. 680 comments before mine tell me every single person on here cares what he has to say. And you naysayers obviously don't listen to the show. Seriously, get over yourselves...
Has Howard Stern looked in the mirror lately?
Howard has been calling it as it is since he came into the airwaves. It really should not come as a shock or surprise to anyone. It also should not come as a surprise to anyone that she is enormous and not the picture of health. When people are in a show that is going to broadcast their image all around the world, people will talk... problem is that many think of things to say but they filter them out and play it safe. Howard speaks what many are holding back, for that, I am glad that he is around because he is saying what many others are afraid to say.
Thanks Howard for being like you are, and I sure hope that you continue to amuse us as well as challenge us to be politically correct.
A big Baba Boey to you and can't wait for the Miss Tiger Woods beauty pageant on 3/10/10!!! I am sure that people will sound off on that one too, and that all media will want a piece of any of the bits! You rock and crack me up!
Howard – you rock! I miss the KRock days. Before I even read this I already had an opinion of her – she's a one-hit wonder. This was a part for an overweight black gal, played by an overweight black gal. Those other actressees worked their whole career trying to get an Oscar nod, she got nominated because she did a hell of a job playing herself, plain and simple. More than the weight, Howard made the right call on the career, and at least he has the stones to say it.
Stern Rules Baba Booey!
What does her skin color have to do with anything? It's disgusting how many of you, including Howard Stern, have referred to the color of her skin. Her skin color is a gift from God; her weight is a different issue altogether. Yes, she needs to lose weight, but her color has nothing to do with it. How quickly some of you look for a reason or excuse to make race and color a part of your criticism.
If Sirus and Fox had any decency they'd fire that retched vile man.
If you don't like Howard, you obviously haven't listened to him long enough to get him. Most of the people commenting on here need to relax. The chick is a huge mess who needs to get control of herself. She obviously needs to lose weight for several reasons. Howard shouldn't be deemed offensive for speaking the truth. It's more offensive to lie.
If I recall many felt the same way about Ricki Lake after her marverlous performance in HAIRSPRAY. Although at times I find Howard Stern provocative and funny, in this instance I feel it was a cheap and cruel shot. I would imagine this young girl knows what her issues are and hopefully the Academy Award nomnation will be motivate her to do what she can to become healthy. I didn't see PRECIOUS, but have to assume that she provided one hell of a performance and I expect we will see her again as an actress. As for Howard Stern, perhaps a little humility and an apology would go a long way as he has attacked a child.
Wow, Howard Stern told a fat woman she's fat. Boooring. Unoriginal. Stupid.
Yes, Stern is a shock-jock, but he was right on this one.
Gabi made me uncomfortable. She had to have a special seat because she could not fit in the theater seats. Since when did Marquesa become Omar the Tent Maker??? That was a first. And Oprah... God only knows she can use some good therapy too. She has gained and lost more pounds in the past 10 years than most football players weigh. She is disgusting and so is Gabi. I cringe when I look at them. Neither one of them is healthy and Dr. Oz should give them both a good verbal scolding. They both need physical and mental help.
This was NOT about race. It was about health.
Love Howard. He is honest, says what is on his mind (and likely most everyone else's, but everyone is too PC to say anything).
And for all of you who think he's an ugly ass and shouldn't talk – you obviously have never listened to him. He is completely self-deprecating and spends a lot of time making fun of himself, his looks, and his penis size. He does not even give himself a free pass.
And those of you who think he is a pig... every single person willingly goes onto his show knowing exactly what they are in for. I have no sympathy for those woman who you feel sorry for. They want to be on his show and be treated like an object.
By the way... I'm a female fan, and Sirius subscriber ONLY because of Howard.
Stern is a hugely entertaining, intelligent man whose show has little to do with the nightmare that people who have never heard it think it is. And much of his audience, myself included, are college educated, upper level bracket individuals. It is refreshing to hear someone so honest, and yes, he said what many of us think about this girl's weight.
Stern = pointless.
All haters out there have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to Howard Stern. He is a radio genius and even the fact that there is this much commenting on him makes who he is. The entire night all my wife and I could talk about is how ugly she was and how she was one cheeseburger away from a heart attack, which is sad. If Oprah wants to propogate this situation that is on her, but Howard was just telling the truth...GET OVER IT, and if you don't like it, don't listen....
Also for those who have to point out the obvious, please just close shut up. HE ADMITS THAT HE IS UGLY!!!!!!!!!!! I say we put a website together ...wwww.SAVEPRECISOUS.com....everyone can provide low calorie recipes
He's totally right! She AND Oprah both look like silverbacks. If you listen to his show, he makes fun of EVERYONE ... if you don't listen then you don't get it. It's a comedy show. He calls himself a flamingo at least 3 times a day on his show. For you idiots that are quick to criticize him, give him two weeks of your time, really listen to him, and I promise you'll become a fan. My wife couldn't stand him and now she doesn't go a day with out listening. 35 million subscribers can't be wrong.
One day everyone will wake up and realize that we Americans have a terrible weight problem. We're dying from it on a daily basis. How many people do you know have "bad knees" or "weak ankles", etc? Come on people! Their fat and they need to be told so by society in general. We have no problem condeming smokers. What's the difference? Fat guys and gals eat too much. Period. Accept it and let's move on. Look at all the diabetics. Look at all the people using wheelchairs/carts in the supermarkets. Look at the average guy/gal going into a restaurant. What more evidence do you need? Sure some of the aforementioned people have a true medical condition both most are just fat because they eat/drink to much.
Comment concerning the engineering degree of Mike Dywat.............Mike........we ARE impressed,,,,,,,,perhaps you should change your name to match your writing ability........you could perhaps change your name to Bate Masters...this will help to flaunt your very important degree.
The truth hurts, and Howard Stern's probably right. What other role could they cast her in that would push her career further and make people say, I want her? Granted Monique won, and she is pretty good sized, but the hollywood industry (not the critics) prize thin women. Not to mention she is probably going to be the poster child for obesity. Where she takes it from here who knows? She could stay fat and be the idol for all fat people to embrace their fatness–Or she could get skinny and be the voice of a generation of people who say "I want to get rid of my fat. It's unhealthy and not for me."
Howard Stern is the ugliest man I've ever seen, inside and out!
It's no accident that obesity has become the norm in American society.
Please listen up: HIGH FUCTOSE CORN SYRUP is a MAJOR contributor to obesity, and it is a main ingredient in some 85 THOUSAND products (virtually ALL packaged food) sold in this country. (Granted, some people could care less about too much body mass, but the majority would prefer to be slimmer, for a lot of reasons; that's common sense).
Why is it in virtually all packaged foods? Because it makes big buck for the corn/sugar mega-industries who don't give a Flyin' Fk about YOU. And it ain't gonna change until American consumers demand that it stop. Google the subject and let those arrogant S.O.B.'s hear from you. Yeah; that really cuts into your 'down time' but if ya don't, you lose your right to bitch about how they're taking advantage of your trust in them. That old saying: "Nobody can take advantage of you without your permission" is true.
She knows that she is overweight. She knows that people are accustomed to seeing pencil thin actresses. However, she is a great actress.
why does his opinion matter? Frankly to me it DOES NOT... this space could have been used better I think than for something he had to say.... He's so low class it's not even funny... he's a wart on society in MY opinion
I suspect that within 18 months we'll be reading that she's on welfare.
cant say i disagree. fat people dont make it in hollywood anymore unless youre sweaty and loud, like john belushi or chris farley. she will need to lose weight if she wants her career to continue. i think theres nothing worse than telling an obese person theyre beautiful just to try and be 'nice'. these people will never face the truth and that is deadly for them.
Wow, people pulling the racist card. If you need to pull that card in this case then you should look in the mirror.
As for her weight, she looks at least 250 pounds overweight. She will probably die soon if she doesn't do anything about it. That id the truth. Watch "The Biggest Loser" and see what those people have to deal with, and most of the women are nowhere near the size of Gabourey. Sleep apnea, diabetes, high blood pressure, the list goes on and on. This is the kind of crap that needs to be taken care of!
As for how Stern put it, he's a d#&%. I have never liked him, but that doesn't mean he is wrong.
And to add on to another post, to he[[ with being PC, we as a nation are a bunch of d**m crybabies! Grow up people!!!!
I'm not a Stern fan at all, he's really shallow. I can't recall ever saying this before, but he was right. Rude, but that's his job, and right. Hollywood tries, but rarely succeeds, to make heroes of those with addiction problems. You can't justify alcoholism, drug addiction, smoking, obesity, and make it stick. I do hope she gets help; she's too talented to lose.
I do think that she is a lovely and lively girl and that she should lose weight so that we can see her again and again in newer roles. That's the way a civilized person would approach it. Even if he doesn't think she's a lovely girl. She is lucky enough to be a success and should lead a healthier lifestyle in order to capitalize on that. TA DA.
Anyway, what does it really matter I never really understood Howard Stern I remember seeing him on late night TV getting beautiful girls that he could never in million years have a chance with to take off their clothes/talk about their sexual experiences. I hate it when ugly people slam other people's outer appearances.
HOWARD RULES – BABA BOOEY!!!!!
Love or hate Stern, how can anyone disagree with that comment? She IS enormous. She is likely to have a short life unless she changes. The people that only point to her and call her a princess are people who care more about looking good than helping someone who obviously needs it.
Howard has been for 30+ years absolutely honest and even though he disgusts most people, his millions of listeners will follow him wherever he goes.
hey, the truth hurts.
Holywine, I second your notion, excellent point!
Way to Go STERN! She indeed needs some help!
Not a big Howard fan, but, have to admit the girl is waaaaay too big.
He just said what most of us were thinking. Its not PC but he isn't lying. Obama should take a cue from Stern.
Howard is the king. Look at all of this reaction.Only the king of all media can get this kind of reaction. Love him or hate him you know who he is. She is a fatty like Oprah. ba ba boooey to you all.
He is an idiot. I am quite sure that Gaby is aware of her weight and the health issues that it can cause. She comes across confident, and happy which is what I love about her, because society, mainly people like Stern makes it so difficult to be comfortable in your own skin. However, who knows how she feels when she is alone and looks in the mirror. She may feel really badly about how she looks and doesn't need some ass like Stern spewing negative comments about her. Get a life Stern.
The only people who hate Howard Stern are the ones who have not listened to his show. He may be abrasive for some people but the truth is he is very intelligent and he tells it like it is. If she becomes upset from the uproar and loses weight Howard will be the man who helped put her on track to save her life.
Howard will be a hero!!!!
BA-BA-BOOEHHH!!!!
The funny thing about the folks who are countering by pointing out that Howard Stern is quite unattractive is that he works in RADIO – a decidedly non-visual medium!!
Ugly, morbidly obese, or both works fine for radio, but it very rarely results in a long career in movies. Its just the truth.
Stern went to satellite so he could say anything he wants. Yes he makes himself appear quite shallow at times. I have not seen the movie, do not know this actress. What I do know that Oprah looks for every opportunity to appear charitable, self-righteous, "saintly", etc. and this really feels like another attempt to seize the moment and wow the audience with some historical insignificance in the hope of summoning another standing ovation. Overweight and homely people are cast all the time in character roles – often the most developed roles in film and TV, so I wouldn't count this actress out, but I do agree with Stern. At the very least, it will be interesting to see if this actress secures a job at HARPO or O Magazine as a result of Oprah opening her mouth and the actress pounding on the studio doors. That will be funny. Notice I use "will" instead of "would". Watch.
I wouldn't have watched this movie if you had paid me! She is fat and gross and absolutely disgusting!
I notice most of the comments here are from women, and are largely anti-Stern. I wonder how many of you are "fat, black chicks?" Stern is no hero of mine, but he speaks his mind and stands by it, even if unpopular.
Howard Stern better get a haircut so we can see his face. Further, if he ever finds himself out on the street, he will never get past an interview until he improves his appearance.
Some lame comment from Stern, what else is new? POS no talent moron has no business saying anything about anyone. His whole act is degrading women. I'm surprised no one has broken all of his teeth.
A Baba-Booey chant?
Baba-Booey!
Howard Stern disgusts me! How dare he insult and ridicule this young lady. Is he saying this because he cares about her health? No, he's saying this to be cruel and to put her down. He thinks it's funny to hurt the feelings of a young woman. He's a disgrace and a sick idiot!!!
Typical Stern. He needs someone to humiliate when he is taking a break from telling sophomoric genitalia jokes. How this man makes a living at what he does defies logic. The only person I can think of that's a bigger loser than this guy is ANYONE who would tune in to his vulgar toilet humor. He is truly a dreg and a complete drain on decent society. Stern, when your time on this earth is done, be sure to place plenty of sun tan lotion in your casket....perhaps SPF one zillion. If anyone will need that, it is you!
STERN RULES BABABOOYE- Talk for 5 hours a day and I promise you will offend someone too.
why can't a fat person have a career in the movies? most of america is fat and they reflect the average person more so than those skinny actresses in the movies. plus, howard stern is the last person to comment on anyone's looks. while he may be thin, he is by no means an attractive man. being thin doesn't make you attractive, smart or a decent human being. stern is physically repulsive, he is vocally vile and spews venom. sadly, he gets women because he has money. does he really think that these women he is involved with are involved with him for any reason other than the fame and the money. stern is the one to be pitied here, because if he lost the money and the tide turned on him, he couldn't get away with saying the stuff that he does. someone should tell stern that 80's are over, perhaps a new hairstyle would be something he could invest his time in.
It does not matter if Stern speaks the truth or not. Being that nothing he says is EVER said in a constructive or helpful manner, nothing positive will ever come of it. Don't waste your time listening to him. The world would be far better off without the ugliness that spews forth from his mouth every time it is open.
Howard Stern's comments were blunt & cruel, but he was correct. Americans, including this young Oscar nominee, are too overweight which causes an army of health problems. It is especially disturbing since she is so young to be so overweight. Please diet and exercise and keep a healthy regime for the rest of your life.
You know what? Here's a guy that fights convention. He has thrown PC to the curb. If someone's heavy, let 'er rip. You don't like what you hear, lose weight. If you find it offensive, don't consider the source, consider the object of the comment. The truth hurts. This whole society is as a result of molly coddling the sensitive ears of self and over indulged whiners. Too bad. Let's take a quote by Shakespeare..."she doth protest too much." Lady McBeth was professing her innocence to the extent that no one believed her. The accusations were too close to the truth. In this instance, obesity is rampant, and all we do is sell more Coleman tents. If these self serving, over stuffed behemoths can't take the heat of the words, either lose weight, get out of the limelight or opt out of any form of government healthcare. If you have to step into the back yard to fit into the mirror, don't replace the mirror, deal with reality...you're as big as an asteroid.
How many Olympic athletes did you see that were anywhere close to having a roll, let alone there own zip code.
BTW, not to enter into an hypocritical zone here, we're drinking beer (light) and eating pizza...HA.
Her weight is an issue, but because of health. It's a shame how American's hold celebrities in such high regard and esteem but only if they are thin. Celebs think they own the world and I don't support them in any way-I always wait for the movie to come out on comcast or the computer. This young lady should lose weight for herself and her health, not to get a part in a movie. She is a psychology student I believe and I'm sure this experience will give her insight to the neurosis of Hollywood.
To those saying stern has a popular show:
Have you seen his numbers this decade? he was cool in the '90's, but come one! He's just regurgitating his material year after year with nothing new. 20 years ago he did the same thing to oprah. *yawn*
Can't he get any new material??? Can't he hire new writers if he has to use 20 year old scripts?
She is FAT!!! She needs to lose a few pounds, and then some. ANYONE who says different is either blind, stupid, or just as fat. I would NEVER go see a movie with her in it ... PERIOD. She is disgusting. And if it is a medical problem then take some of your new found money and get it fixed.
I love when everyone says "who is Stern to talk," "he's just trying to get noticed" and so on. If anyone has listened to the show, they would understand that Stern is his own worst critic, and he certainly is the first to point out that he is NO BEAUTY!!! He is relevant, and he is a broadcasting GENIUS. Certainly his ridiculous salary for jumping on to Sirius indicates some type of worth. I respect Howard, even the harsh way he says things. He is NO BIGOT, and really is not afraid to point out the hypocrisy of life, Hollywood, and yes, even his own show! Howard is not afraid to speak boldly, honestly, and not in the water down way that America has become accustomed to, and demands....remember everyone, you all get prizes, you're all special, and we always say nice things...even if they are total lies!
Unfortunately, like it or not, Stern's comments are right on. Morbid obesity is deadly and dysfunctional.
The political correctness that dictates that we must accept everyone's condition unreservedly, even if they are destroying or limiting themselves, has got to stop.
Eat right, exercise, adopt healthy habits, do not do drugs, limit alcohol, stay in shape in body and mind. The kind of eating that leads to this level of obesity is a medical problem that needs to be cured, not encouraged.
Not sure what's more pathetic, you picking on her during the biggest night of her life or the fact that your own life is so pathetic that you feel that you have to.
Sternum....get some sun!!!!! You're too pasty white and unhealthy looking! eek! And maybe try some teeth whitening! You can afford it dude!
Well said Howard!!! She is HUGE!! This woman should be NOT be idolized, especially not by our nation's youth. Obesity is the biggest challenge facing our society today, and is the #1 cause health problems. Too many of us are taking in more than we burn. Get off of your fat asses!! That includes you, Sidibe!!
Howard has a good career and he is dog ugly so therefore he needs to look at the man in the mirror.
Howard Stern said something controversial? No way, that NEVER happens! This isn't news, but thanks for the free advertising. BabaBooeyBabaBooey!
Pick on somebody your own size Howard!
Stern critizes someone because of their size?
Thats because he cant see past the end of his enormous nose !
Howard is right, She is a good actress BUT what roles will she get? He was rude in his delivery but she has to loose weight. Monique aint small either and she made it but she was not as big as her.
YOU mite hate him but Stern is just saying what all of us thaught. Stern has a VALID POINT
Just like everyone else, I do not usually care for Stern, nor do I listen to him. However, in this particular situation, he is right on target. It is not a matter of meanness - it is a matter of health! Obesity is one of America's biggest health concerns, and COSTS! Obese people require much more medical care than those who are of appropriate weight. Guess who pays? We all do!
As long as we act like its okay for obese people to be that way, America will keep getting bigger. Maybe if more people said "Dang man, you are really, really overweight" we wouldnt need shows like "Biggest Loser". How about some social responsibility?
just to inform some of the dimwitted posters who continue to associate howard with smoking, he hasn't smoked in over 25 years and continually preaches the dangers of smoking. seems like an awful lot of folk keep saying things about howard when they have little knowledge of the man.
Sure, she should definitely lose weight or she will not live long at all.
But in regards to having a career, Howard Stern's one of the ugliest men I've ever seen. If he can get a job, she can.
The great part is she can lose weight and get healthier. He though will remain ugly. Inside and out!
Howard, you have the beautiful trophy wife. You need to look at yourself in the mirror - cut that nasty ass hair and let's see what your face really looks like - it's as bad as being heavy - covering up what you don't want others to see. Lighten up on the big girl and bring Greaseman back! He had such a way better show than you will ever have. And he's not mean.
I think he's just an idiot with a microphone. I don't listen to Howard Stern because he's crude and obnoxious. But I have to agree with him. I loved the movie, and I like her as an actress. Sometimes for the message to get through you have to say it like it is. Otherwise the message won't get through.
he was ruthless, but he's right. She is way to big. She should take her time, maybe a year or so and lose the weight, or she won't last long.
She will have a wonderful career. She can play Fat Albert in the movie version of the classic TV show. She can play Re-Run in the move version of "What's Happening". The sky is the limit for this girl. Heck, if she drops 20 pounds she could play Oprah!
This country is so screwed up. It's amazing. Getting thin at all costs is just as dangerous as being morbidly obese. There is a great possibility that Gabby is totally healthy despite her size. And if you think about it, if being thin were the answer, no woman who weighed less than 125 or man who weighed less 175 would die before the age of 90 or so. It's about health people and weight is not the measure of that.
Sure, pointing out the elephant in the room is his job, his personna, and you may or may not like him for the tactless style, but Stern is absolutely right. And who knows, his tactlessness maybe be a rude awakening to Sidibe, and will do her much more good than all the facetious hollywood BS she's being served by fakes stepping over themselves to prove they can accept and embrace the token "ugly duckling".
Howard, you have the beautiful trophy wife. You need to look at yourself in the mirror - cut that nasty ass hair and let's see what your face really looks like - it's as bad as being heavy - covering up what you don't want others to see. Lighten up on the big girl and bring Greaseman back! He had such a way better show than you will ever have. And he's not mean. And I am a personal trainer.
The truth hurts and Howard is 100% right. She will probably get a few more roles here and there but later disappear unless she does something about her weight.
Hey Howard,
Have you looked in a mirror lately? You're not exactly the answer to God's gift to women in the Looks Dept. Before you judge her, at least go and have your face lifted with your mouth sewn shut!! Maybe then "your appearance" would improve!!
So, let me get this straight. Some of you are mad at Stern for being honest and no one is mad at Oprah for lying? If someone chooses to be in the spotlight, they should be prepared for the comments.
Being morbidly overweight is extremly unhealthy. If any well known actor or actress had put on,or lost, large amounts of weight the size comments would be flying. Because Gabourey Sidrie entered into the spotlight extremely overweight and possiblytalented are we
supposed to pretend that she has a future ahead of her inHollywood. Getreal people!!! We watch celebrities because we are intrigued.
Theyare what we all want to be. Like it or not! It's what makes the world go around, the have nots, strive for better, the losers want to become winners, and it is what makes most of us buy magazines in the grocery store isle. Seriously folks, get a grip on reality!!
You may not like the way he said it but its very hard to disagree with the core of his message.
I would never wish anyone the burden of being overweight. I have struggled with it my whole life. After reading the comments above from alot of self rightous people, no wonder Stern feels like it is ok to make nasty comments. Are some of you even aware of what you are saying?.
I almost..... wish some of you the burden of being overweight. I did say almost. I wouldn't do that to my worst ememy.
You know just because you or someone you love, doesn't have a weight problem now, doesn't mean you will never have that problem. I pray you don't and I pray you find compassion in your life. There are worse things in life than being overweight, but it is the last discrimination left in our society. Isnt that sad!!!!!!
There are two issues at play here. Firstly, Howard Stern. You either love him or hate him. Me, I love him. He speaks like I think. His perspective and ability to convey it is perfect. This society is far from Victorian in nature now, but needs the polarity of Stern's insights to contrast the norms of acceptance.
Secondly, obesity. Here you have someone who is admittedly large. Too large. I personally don't care what someone does or looks like. Not my issue or concern. She's a house waiting for her plumbing to explode. Can she act? Again, I don't know nor care. But, she's huge and Howard spoke the truth. The object of the sandwich is not the bread. It's time to look at the accepted social norms of today. We sit around, do nothing, piggy size everything and when one of our bodily systems fails, we sue McDonalds. We are an over indulged, self serving, egotistical, irresponsible, illiterate, litigious, bleeding heart liberal society.
It's a shame that the truth has to be tempered with the method of delivery. Devine what's true. How it's said is irrelevant.
Stern is right. You can't make a logical argument against what he is saying. You can say it's mean which it is but it's true. Oprah is lying when she says she will be a star. She wont do anything again. Look at every other woman at that show. No one looks like her. Might not be nice but it's honest.
I think it is unnessarsary to take time and complain about someone who is new to the industry. How do you know she may already started losing weight? She might just fool use all and all the roles she wants never say never you haters of he world. I see you did not nothing about Moniquie
because she would have come to Howard's studio and kicked his ass.
Another way to be raciest.
Howard make a lot of mony for his style of humor, that can't be argued. Doesn't this in itself mean that he is a very talented entertainer? His Sirius XM contract is WAY over half a billion dollars.
I see this actress and feel physically uncomfortable. I imagine that it's tough for her to walk distances without getting breathless, to pick up something from the floor, to wear comfortable clothes or to tie her shoes, because that's how I feel. I'm an obese woman, and the fault for that is both mine and the manipulation of food content by the food industry. But the responsibility for losing this weight is mine alone, and that's just the fact.
Stern is right, and whomever made the analogy to Simon Cowell is spot on. There's no reason why he can't say what most of us are thinking, especially if it's truthful, and it's for her own good if she chooses to listen to him. The fairytale is that her condition, whatever its cause, is anything but a path to early death. And she really is talented - to die young would be the tragedy here.
I listen to Howard Stern every day, and have for 15 years. He has his schtick, and I don't always agree with him, but he's really good at what he does, and he paved the way for just about all innovation in radio programming since the 1970s. Those who diss him across the board clearly don't listen to him or get what he does or understand his job.
Does Stern have a point? Yes. But this is a man whose audience is long-gone because what he wanted most was his morbidly obese paycheck, the right to be vulgar 24/7 and teeny-tiny 'audience'. He wants it both ways, but he chose what was important.
And to think there was talk about howard judging Ameican Idol!
Our society is in the toilet if they let this clown
have a public voice. Howard is gutter.Get out of my face little
Howie and just GO AWAY!
Have any of you actually noticed that she HAS lost weight? Look at pictures from a year ago and you can see a difference.
Howard Stern can be vulgar and probing and disregards people's feelings. There is some validity in his points. What other roles will she get, other than "fat black chick'? Oprah called her "an American Cinderella" ... no executive would spend a dime putting her in a Cinderella story, because no one would believe it. She can;t be a romantic lead ... an action heroine ... all she can be is a joke, or the poor large black girl who is shunned by her peers, but learn to rise above the fray to succeed. How many times will America pay to see her "rise above" and show the world for a big girl can do? Not enough to make a career. She is talented and charming ... that an a dollar will get ya a cup of coffee.
Of course Howard is right! What was the last role for someone that big? I love ya Howard! Keep tellin' like it is! BA-BA-BOOEY
I thought the same thing about her career....what would be her next role with her looking like that? Next I thought that she needs to make a life change now, not in a few weeks. All the bleeding hearts know it's true. Can we stop killing people for talking out loud? Free country right?
Howard is actually speaking the truth...in his way. Not all will agree, but it's his way. But I have to agree, where was her mother while she was getting this large? I'm not a small women either, but I know if I was that large, I would be going to a Dr. to get help if I couldn't. She won't have a long career as Oprah say's she will, because if she continues staying this size, she won't live to see 30. Has anyone notice, it's an epidemic in this GREAT COUNTRY of ours...this is how the good USA is getting!!!!!
Laugh, Clown, Laugh! I wonder if Stern has taken a good look in his mirror lately.
Jesse in Texas
You gotta be kidding me. You think Howard Stern is the only person who thinks this? He says what he thinks! What alot of people think, but no one will say....in public! Howard is only guilty of being REAL! If you dont like it, you dont have to listen. period.
Look, Stern is a guy who puts things bluntly, and it may not be politically correct, per say, but he definitely has a point here.. Oh yeah...Hey Now! Baba Booey, and Howard Stern's penis!
whatever howard, you just didn't have to be such a douche about it.
He has a point and is entitled to his opinion. While I think he might have been a little rough on her, but he is hosting a comedy radio show, not preaching in a church.
All in all, she is the size of a Buick. Notice he didn't attack her acting only her size. He didn't say she was ugly, just that she was big.
The one thing you have control over in your life is your weight.
Maybe she will drop some weight and continue her acting career.
Other then that, HOWARD RULES!
Baba Booey
he is an unsaved man, who does not believe in God. I hope he enjoys his life here because, where he's going won't be so funny. We are here to esteem each other higher than we esteem ourselves-says Jesus. He needs to look in the mirror. Girls only want him for his money.
Despite what you think of him, in this instance, he is spot on. She is morbidly obese (defined as greater than twice the ideal body weight) and a poster child for cardiac disease, hypertension, back/knee problems, diabetes. She definitely needs help and is not at all the type of person we need out there as an example to our youth.
Can we stop acting like being fat is OK? Its NOT OK. Being fat is one of the greatest health problems in this country and people want to say politically correct things like "JUST BEING THEM" or "THEYRE HAPPY, THEYRE NOT HURTING ANYONE". Truth is, obesity is unnatural, and they ARE hurting millions of others because they can't control themselves. Healthcare costs in this country are out of control, due in large part to the obesity of 30% of the United States. So, everyone, lets stop trying to make fat people feel better about themselves (aside from those who actually have disorders, such as thyroid conditions) and tell them they need to get healthy or they will no longer be allowed to recieve health care at taxpayer expense.
I have not seen the movie, but I am sure it was a powerful, compelling story, and she undoubtedly delivered a stunning performance. Stern is Stern. I don't listen to him, but he speaks his mind. It's unfortunate that she has to be exposed to that sort of public criticism, in such a crass manner, BUT it goes with the job – you are on the Academy Awards for the whole world to see. That is what being in the public eye is all about.
If Britney Spears shows up fat the press is all over that. SO accolades also attract criticism. Do I like Stern. No. Do I agree with his comments? Yes.
I guess the nomination was about talent. There are many skinny celebrities that die at the young age due to drug addiction, suicide, depression, the list go on...
As an overweight African American woman I dont care if I so big that I'm about to pop. No one–absolutely no one has the right to tell me what I should do with my body... Unlike these skinny-to-the-bones Hollywood girls that only drink diet coke and have a cigarette, at least Gabourey Sidibe is proud of her body and is accepecting it. It's her life and let her be happy!
Why is he married to a beatiful girl? he has money. He bought her.
Sorry, I don't listen Howard anymore since he went to satalite.
His show was not worth the jump to pay radio.
As far as his comments though, ALL obese people should either come to terms and attempt to loose the weight or just simply die. End of story.
Get off the Tax Payers payrole and upcomming FREE HEALTHCARE for those who destroyed their quality of life and are now begging for a second chance.
Stop eating that second pizza, walk more then start jogging when they are able.
If by chance they are just too obese to function anymore then, sorry...the hell with them.
Have them raise enough money for gastric bypass from some outside donation program but it should not come from unwilling taxpayers through our upcomming Social Medicine.
Howard is right, she'll be dead in three years and remembered as the fat girl in that poor fat girl movie. Didn't see it. Don't care to see it. No into watching big fat people.
What Howard Stern thinks is beautiful is having blonde hair, being thin and having big breasts. Give me a break! He should talk about grooming himself...he's ugly and has NO sense of humor. Just degrading in my opinion.
Why anyone would listen to HS is the biggest mystery. Untalented, insensitive, obnoxious, crude, rude, Not funny, and a blabbering idiot... et all.
Her talent is quite clear and her performance was outstanding. I am sure parts are being written for her right now. If you listened to her in any of her interviews it's obvious she is very articulate and intelligent.
She was both charming and adorable. If she decides to loose weight it's her decision.
For those who feign concern for her weight and view That as her problem, they only need to look within. Compassion? Hardly. Love to know what lies behind their great need for brutal derision. Got anything You need to take care of about You? (No, you're probably so busy being Perfect!) Please!!
Oh, Howard, Great Caring Wise One: “You just want to say to her, listen, honey, now that you’ve got a little money in the bank go get yourself thin, because you’re going to die in three years,” he said.
I don't buy it for a nano second. I would rather listen and watch Gabourey Sidibe any time over Scum-bucket Stern, the king of derision and oppression of valuable, good people.
stern wins again... all this buzz is about him
A lot of health care problems are caused by obesity. People need to start taking care of themselves to reduce healthcare costs for everyone. More overweight people in the US need to face reality wake up. She should use her money to get her stomach (or mouth) stapled. It will lower healthcare expenses in the future. It's not fair to those who go out of their way to stay healthy.
I'm glad he said it. It's time to have an open, honest discussion about reducing health care costs and it's starts with obesity.
Howard Stern was a jackass at DC 101 when I was in high school and he's a jackass now. Yes, Ms. Sidibe is a large girl. Yes, her weight can be a detriment to her health and career. But who in the hell his HE to make comment on it and in that manner? Howard Stern has never had any decorum. He's trailer trash with a microphone. Will he NEVER go away?
I don't get why all you commentators are saying he called her ugly...i didn't listen to his whole schpiel, so maybe he did, but from what i read in this article he simply says she is SUPER fat...which isn't in the eye of the beholder, it's true...she is really obese. people that overweight can keep telling themselves how beautiful they are on the inside as much as they want, the fact is they WILL die sooner because of it...and the one comment about not crapping on Chris Farley, the man did take some flack for being overweight and he did die young...though it wasn't from being a fatty...moral of the story...stop crapping on Howard because he's ugly and 'has no room to talk' and 'shouldn't call her ugly'...that has nothing to do with what he said...
Stern is right, he just says it in a way that is harsh... but it does not make it untrue. Acting roles in Hollywood for morbidly obese people are few and far between. She needs to lose some weight for her career and her life.
Stern is just stern.
PLEASE...another proud to be fat person. Stern was dead on. We are not talking a couple of pounds. You would stop someone from putting a plastic bag over their head....so tell them to put down the BIG MAC!
Ah yes....uhh...Mr. Stern, that woman can always lose weight. But you are a has been who is extremely unattractive AND WEARS A WIG. Let's see how you really look without your store bought hair. I cannot wait until somebody is able to grab a photo of you minus your carpet and posts it for all of us to see. Perhaps then there will be some OTHER @sshole who will point out how embarrassing you are and are unmarketable!
Since when is "you're fat" the only thing you're allowed to say to an overweight person? And furthermore, just because she's not saying it on stage at the Oscars doesn't mean Oprah's not advising this young woman on the pitfalls of obesity–something about which Oprah knows all too well.
The fact is, Oprah has been fat on and off for most of her adult life, but she is the most charismatic and powerful woman in America. She is trying to nurture the potential in this young woman and show her that she is more than just fat. Maybe if she sees great things up ahead, this kid can find the inspiration she needs to lose weight and get healthy.
well, who would have thought that a guy that looks like howard stern would be in entertainment? plus he has a mouth that matches that not so attractive face. i just think the guy is disgusting. i feel that the actress he discussed will probably strive to improve herself in every way in the future. congratulations to her or her accomplishments to date.
This is such a sad world. There is NO bigger a$$hole than stern. Did anyone even see the movie? That girl is a wonderfull actress, and for her first role at just seventeen, I'm impressed. Your already condeming her to no career for being heavy. There are many things she could do, and knowing the public (you) she will be forced to lose to be accepted. I wish I had her attitude towards myself. Such self confidence, she doesn't let judgemental, perfect, people police get to her.
Consider the source. This is actually rather sensitive approach for him – but I'm not convinced he really cares, he just couldn't keep quiet with such a target like her getting attention.
However, I think we can all see Gabourey is a beautiful, talented, happy girl and she should feel good about herself, but it doesn't help her if she and everyone around her just sweeps her weight issue under the rug. I hope she looks after herself a little better, not for Hollywood or a future career but for herself. We can love her as she is but she needs to be healthy too.
Not that I like Stern, but he does have a point. She is morbidly obese and if she stays this way much longer she won't see 40. This is an immensely talented young woman, smart and very articulate, with that said watch her in about a year, you won't recognize her., I really believe she will lose the weight, mainly because if she wants an acting career it's the only way to go. If she doesn't she will have had her 15 minutes of fame.
This comment was really off color but it is true,but in no way is it accepatable, shock jock or not.I can not stand this guy. Do a movie where you are nominated for something so i can go on air and say well i hate how the people are lying to you,you need plastic surgery. The best saying goes beauty is only skin deep but ugly is to the bone.
How like society and Howards the Cowards, to have a B-fest over a plus size woman and assume she won't get any roles in Hollywood, but if it was a man, there would not be all this crap.
I have to admit I like Howard Stern for his honesty a lot, but he is mis-informed in this respect, as a professional film and TV actor who has had my hand in producing, everyone gets typecast into how they look, but that does NOT mean you can't get regular work in both film and (more likely) TV. Directors and Casting Directors need to fill roles and cast you the way you look, but most importantly they need you to be a good actor on set so not to embarrass yourself. She has PROVEN herself a good actor. If the role is calling for a hot white girl, guess what... she isn't getting the part, but then again neither is Halle Berry or Brad Pitt. She will have plenty of work, and probably much more interesting and challenging roles than most of the cookie cutter hot white chicks in LA. At the same time I agree that anyone with too much weight should do what is best for their health and gets exercise and eat healthy, just like people should stop smoking, drink less, and drive less stupid...which are all things America is well known for.
Oprah was "fat, black, and ugly" when she first started as well but now all of you people loving to say all of the negative things about Gabby would damn near kill yourselves to be in Oprah's presence! Yes, for health reasons she should lose some weight, did you ever think that maybe, just maybe, this attention (and $$) may be her motivation and method for doing so now!?!?! Just like you all like to point out, she's YOUNG so it won't take much for her to slim down some and by slimming down some I DO NOT mean trying to make herself a darker version of the super thin, anorexic looking white actresses (not that all of them are like that, just a majority).
Sparking intense controversy, seems to be exactly what Mr. Stern meant by, "...she could play a football player..." in a hypothetical "Blindside II."
In his remarks, did he mean a position on the defensive line, or perhaps an offensive tackle or guard, where the bulk, power, and lateral movement of this talented young actress would be a huge advantage?
Or was Mr. Stern referring to a position such as defensive back, wide receiver, or even quarterback, were agility, not brute strength, would be an advantage? If this is what he meant, I too would have to agree with most of the posters here – his comments were way out of line.
Do the people that keep calling Stern ugly believe that he thinks otherwise? He is the first person to call himself ugly! Being ugly does not make one unhealthy, or lessen one's ability to comment on another's health. Howard was not trying to being controversial, but rather was just saying what everyone else was thinking. I hope the actress gets some help...
Ms. Sidibe is a lovely, talented actress, but the fact is, if she is going to have a range of diverse film roles, she is going to have to lose weight. At this point, she can only be seen as the character of Precious. Howard Stern can be brutally honest, but he's right.
Stern is crass, but it's true that this young woman desperately needs to lose weight soon. She surely weighs 400 pounds. Given that even our President's wife is encouraging healthy eating, that children are obese at alarmingly high rates, and that obesity is a major health problem in the U.S., she is hardly a role model for young women to aspire to.
Now, if some how his comment some how lead her to become healthier, then one may argue that it's the nicest thing anyone has done to her.
It's easy to say nice things to people because it makes one feel better. It's like giving candies to kids.
What the hell is going on with people's minds? I've read all of the posts on the subject and there are some key elements that people fail to realize. Of course Ms.Sidibe has a weight issue, but 75 % of American are overweight and obese. Address that issue. Most people either didn't get what the movie was truly about or the truth about how people are is just to sensitive for people. Millons of people are abused every year but people don't address the issue until it hits there home. Number two people fail to realize that Oprah is a powerhouse. And everything she endorses turns gold. So there will be plenty of movie roles for her. The average women is a size 8, so this issue with weight in Hollywood is insane. I'm not saying Gabourey should be the coveted size 2, but the size she is right now is working for her. to be continued
Sidibe, just might have he last laugh, stop and think about it, with a friend like Oprah Winfrey!!! She already has better connections than most of us, and she already has another movid in the works. The one problem with thinking something, is that sometimes our mouths let our thoughts come out, and that can be a bad thing. Sidibe has a right to a career, just as ugly Howard Stern has!!!!
People forget. Oprah herself used to be plus-sized, but she made herself into a great American success story, and with success, apparently, came greater health.
Coming from a guy that is terribly odd looking (to put it nicely) and he makes a comment about an overweight girl. What is the reason he is married to a young beatiful girl? His money possibly???
Who knows what the future will hold for this young lady? I think we need to consider her youth and imminent maturity. Perhaps she will make the right decisions regarding her health and weight in the future. She really should NOT be judged on her very first (and very successful, by the way) on-screen appearance.
I like Howard Stern. He simply says what everyone else is thinking,
But due to political correctness, We dare not say it. Howard can be open and honest, and make millions doing it. I only wish I had his job.
One of my pet peaves is Hollywood picking the less attractive people to be the minority actors. With all the beautiful and talented black women, it is sad to see these unattractive people chosen to be actors.
Did anyone learn fron Don Imus' comments? This is just the same. Is Sirius paying Howard Stern that much money that he can say whatever he wants and get away with it? And I'm throughly irritated with Robin's ass. Who is she the virtue of weight loss? And does Robin has to co-sign everything Howard says. Does she not have her own opinion. Sometimes Robin you really need to know when to shut the hell up. Really.. Neither Howard or Robin are gorgeous. How are they to say what pretty is. Truth be told, if Howard wasn't rich that wife of his wouldn't give his ass the time of day. And with all the money Stern is making he could pay Robin enough to improve her look. Or is that stripper turned housewife getting part of Robin's cut. Is that not what she was? Everbody's commented on Gabbie's weight. He and Robin's life is fair game. He needs to hang it up for he causes harm to the wrong somebody. People aren't as forgiving nowadays.
Sorry, but I have to give Howard props for saying what was on many of our minds. This women is morbidly obese, and definately has type two diabetes.. The only career options she is going to have in the future are a cameo appearance on "The Biggest Loser" .. Call Howard what you want, but the man is more successful and famous than this woman will ever be.. Why? Because the man says what other people want to say. Then again, is she going to find another a role as a thin girl? Probably not.. But, she will not live much longer in the condition she is currently in.. No one should be that FAT. I know some of you apologists will make excuses for her, but IMO no one should look in the mirror, see that and not get themselves in shape, especially not at a young age.
Comments like this have been Stern's gig for 30 years. Why is there even a discussion?
Why is it that You Tube can get away with putting Howard's content on without his permission and then some blogger feels the need to write a story about what he says – just to grab headlines for themselves. Howard wasn't talking to you people on the open airwaves – which means he's NOT looking for ratings. He was talking to the millions of subscribers who pay each month to hear his opinion – myself included – a white, married, college educated professional female. If you listen to Howard, you know that he says what everyone else is only thinking. That takes courage in today's society!
Gabbie loves herself genuinely; this is something the majority of us self loathing, antagonistic, dissatisfied until we've obliterated someone else's hope, robbed them of their joy and sold it the highest bidder, people will never understand.
Ugh! What a terrible excuse for a man!
You know what? Who gives a crap if she is the way she is.
It doesn't matter if she is the most horrible looking human being or the most gorgeous woman ever, She was there Sunday night. She was nominated for Best Actress for the Academy Awards. That has to say something.
It is no wonder that this world is going to hell.
People like Mr. Stern think they have the right to judge someone like that. And then the people who agree with him or excuse it are just as horrible.
This is disgusting.
She is a bad role model. Being that obese is unethical and negatively affects others.
Stern wants everyone to look perfect-like him.
Nicole and Chris,
I couldn't agree more! With Oprah in her corner, and as her sage-guide and mentor, and most powerful woman in America, Gabriel will outshine the likes of Stern And all the bashers (and may I ask, what have they done lately to remotely compare with her powerful performance!!) Anyway, she will be Fine. I Can't Wait to see her next jewel!
I never cease to be amazed by "what everyone is thinking–" and how it's always some mean spirited thing. I wasn't looking at this actress and thinking "She's too fat and has no show business future." I was thinking, "Good job– that's awesome." Some people are very overweight, so what? Like she doesn't know that that's a hazard to her health? Everyone knows that. Losing weight is pretty hard for a lot of people, just like quitting drugs or alcohol is for others. And what's this about there being no future roles for her? Every woman in every film is not some super beautiful chick. Stern's just mistaking his own taste for that of everyone else in the world.
Stern is a mean bastard but he is right. She is a very intelligent and talented girl but she is waaay too big. She should go on the Biggest Loser.
why is it that when Howard Stern says racist, rude comments, they seem to be in the back of the news but when Imus or someone else says things, its front page news and everybody is talking about it. Imus loses his job and Stern will get a 10 million dollar bonus. Don't get it.
I think it's sad that Mr. Stern would not allow this young woman to enjoy her moment without his cruel comments. She and her mother are both undoubtedly aware of the dangers of her obesity, both to her health and future career, without hearing it broadcast on the radio.
While I was concerned to see that she apparently has not lost any weight since this movie was filmed (and hope she makes an effort to do so in the future), it is still important to remember that she was the one walking the red carpet last Sunday, and she was the one taking home the Oscar, not any of her vocal detractors.
Also, without the excess weight she is fairly attractive. Howard, on the other hand ...
Right or wrong, Stern speaks his mind. I personally find him entertaining and incredibly intelligent. Most of the people commenting on him as a personality are simply ignorant. They are commenting about what they have heard about him and not what he is saying. What his said about the actress is rude, but true. And definitely funny.
He has always been a dirt bag to make his money. thats his thing
He is an idiot. Gabourey is more of a star/celebrity than he will ever be. Howard Stern needs controversy to be a celebrity, while Gabourey has pure talent. Howard Stern is a looser.
LIghten Up you god-fearing, sad-life living losers. He is an entertainer. Look how much buzz he caused. Keep commenting. Haaahaa! He's been laughing all the way to the bank for years and years! You people say worse to your friends, don't front! (Excuse the aforementioned lame metaphor).
How is being obese unethical? That's completely ridiculous. At the end of the day, she's only hurting herself and frankly she seems to be more comfortable in her own skin than most people a fraction of her size, so more power to her.
Howard is right that someone that size doesn't have a long life expectancy and hopefully she will use some of the money she has made to get healthy so that she can continue to share her talent with the world.
If only there were 1,147 comments following some of the things our former President Dubbya had done instead of focusing on the unhealthy size of an actress and a guy who has made speaking his mind his living.
Now that would be real change.
All I have to say is that if all the female best actress nominies were trapped on an island who do you think would be the first to be eaten?
You can say what you want but he is 100% correct. Oprah is another obese person who makes money by writing a diet book and then putting the weight back on and losing it and writing another book. For her to say that to her was just terrible and a lie. Like him or hate him Howard speaks the truth. Others are just afraid to say it.
i thought the exact same thing when i saw her at the Oscars. But, i'm sure she knows it, and for someone who is probably miserable about her appearance 99.99% of her time on this planet, a little happiness and praise, may make her happy for a moment or two. Why not let her have that? Worse yet, why take it away from someone? We all deserve to be happy once in a while. Isn't that what we all want? Deserve? As much as I love Howard, It saddens me that he would have a need to take that moment away from her, and it would make me not to want him as a friend. There are those out there who cannot take any pleasure in the happiness or success of others. He is clearly one of them.
Stern is certainly crude and rude but he tells the truth. G. Sidibe seems like a sweet girl, I hope Oprah and Dr. M. Oz will help her lose weigh and be healthier.
It's amazing the hateful things people say under the cloak of anonymity! Here's my take on the situation: (1) Howard Stern is an ass, but we already knew that; (2) Gabby Sidibe is overweight, but we already knew that; (3) Oprah was not lying to her - there are some people who see her as an American Cinderella story. She's a talented young actress. (4) It's up to Gabby if she wants to lose weight. If she wants to be eligible for more roles in Hollywood, she probably will have to do that, but it's really not anyone else's business. (5) Being fat doesn't make her lazy. (6) This is precisely what the director was talking about when he made this movie: all this ruckus about her fatness and blackness speaks to our biases against both. I say leave the girl alone. She's comfortable in her own skin, which obviously rattles a whole bunch of people on this page. God has the final say on who dies and when. Howard Stern may check out before she does!
I'm in the NYC area, about the same age as Stern & I've listened to him since he was at WNBC doing afternoon drive in the early 1980s, but I haven't listened to him since he went to Sirius (I'm not buying a subscription to Sirius, that's why). I didn't think he was still relevant anymore. Well, I guess I'm wrong by this article and the big response to it. That's funny in itself. Meanwhile, if anyone thinks Howard does this stuff for anything other than comedic value & ratings, there's a bridge I'd like to sell you. This is Howard's shtick.
As for exactly what he said– I had no idea who Ms.Sidibe is, so I clicked on the link above. When I saw her, I heard the sound of a ship's fog horn in my head (don't ask me why). Lady, you are ugly and fat (and a little self-absorbed too)!! I mean, I'm glad for her that she's having some success and all, but you all know Howard is right. He may be insensitive, but he's right.
Hey Howard– when are you gonna buy some radio stations and put The Best of Stern into 'free radio' again? You'd have marketing revenue, low overhead..... it could work.
I watched the awards and when they showed this actress, I was mortified at her size, she looked disgusting to me, one french fry away from a heart attack. Howard Stern is ugly, but ugly doesn't equal unhealthy. He is not the most tactful person, but he's honest. There are so many health problems linked to obesity and it has been a growing problem with young people for years now. We should not sugarcoat her morbid obesity, she is only 26 yrs. old and unhealthly hands down. Howard just tells it like it is and that's what most people can't do.
Word-up Howard.! By praising these Large Ones We're sending the wrong message. She eats enough for 5 obviously, If she wants to grow old and watch her grand children grow, She needs to get help, It's really not easy to look at, the tent she was wearing could have been made into three dresses. The other problem I had was with her co-star Monique who did win. She has an open marriage and only shaved her legs once in her Life. If she shaved more often her marriage might close again. Who did that lady think she was standing up there talking smack to the academy. Howard hit me back so we can talk of this travesty. Oscar has lost it's Luster, Oprah's Large again too... tell her to start running another marathon and don't stop til christmas.
He is 100% correct. Not fun to hear, but he is spot on.
I am obese. While I do not like it and exercise and try to eat right, I accept that I am obese. During my annual checkups, my doctor always remarks that I have clear lungs and no other major ailments for someone of my size. I can go on the stair machine for 60 minutes and more.
My point – Even if you are obese, you can still enjoy good health. All the men in my family are fat and we live to an average of in our 80s.
What a waste of comment space....Howard Stern is right.....as for Ms. Sidibe ....this time next year she will be forgotten......Just because Oprah thinks she will have a career doesn't make it so.....Oprah says what she says because she wants attention.....and she'll do what ever it takes to draw it to herself......you talk about Sterns ego....Oprahs is beyond anyones...ever. Howard is rude....at times....but truthful and funny as hell.......I wonder how many young African American girls are going to look up to Ms. Sidibe and say...."bring on the junk food" because Oprah supports it and maybe I too will be a star.......
Anyone remember Darlene Cates? She was the 500 lbs actress that starred in What's Eating Gilbert Grape. She recieved critical acclaim for her work & there was buzz that she would change Hollywood; that finally Hollywood would see that obese people, specifically women, are just as great as average to thin people. Well she didn't change anything. When was the last time she got a part? Honestly being morbidly obese is not only unhealthy but something most of us find unappealing/unattractive. If Sidibi wants to suffer from diabetes, high blood pressure, heart failure, and liver problems, then all the power to her. But she's not getting anymore parts in Hollywood. She needs to get down to a healthy size, like Queen Latifa, Katy Bates, even Mo'nique. They're bigger size women but are on the healthier side of things. Howard Stern maybe an ass for saying it out loud but he's speaking the truth and we all know it.
You ALL – and yes, I'm looking at you, CNN, most of all – are missing the point here. I'll put it in caps so you can hear me over all the crap being shoveled around in here:
SHE JUST GOT HIRED FOR THREE MORE ROLES.
So NO, he was NOT "telling the truth!"
Stern is right. He is saying what most people in Hollywood wont say because it isnt "PC". When i saw her i was thinking the same thing. Most people in Hollywood are fake. There is a Middle America out there too. Its not all glitz and glamour like the people in Cali think it is. Very arrogant of them to think so.
Ok Here's my question , this ass has been offending people for DECADES. why now just because he has an insulted a heavy black women do people FINALLY speak up. He needs to be removed from all media . I even heard a rumor of him joining american idol... I can hear it now, oh i think you can sing but you are fat and black so no you are not going to holywood. I have never watched or listened to ANYTHING he has done and will continue to BAN anything he is involved in.. why is hate so profitable to him?
With Howard Stern, it's all about publicity ($$). Period.
He's an "attention whore". And he gets attention, any way he can..
Even if it mean picking on a morbidly obese Black woman.
It's not what you say, it's how you say it. Tact. Decorum. Taste.
I know Stern is a jerk. But this time he went to far.
I've been listening to Stern for 20 years. It ends today.
So long Stern, have a nice life.....
He's right...but a bit rude on the presentation.
i believe Stern to a person who is entitled to his opinion just as I am mine, as someone else pointed out he is obnoxious and the last time I looked, I didn't see an MD behind his name so who the heck is to predict her demise. If he can be excepted while walking around look like a big wreck of old slob then there is hope for Sidibe as an actress, the pig.
Ummm, He's a shock jock. You're all giving him the attention he wants.
That woman is the size of a planet. It's disgusting..
OK...why doesn't Howard Stern take his own advice and use some of his money to better himself. Lord knows he has many flaws...he is ugly as sin, he is an ass, he could use some lessons in manners and he is ugly as sin.
If you understand Stern's talk format you should know by know this is what he does and we expect his observations.
But Howard: was Oprah supposed to be honest to Gabourey Sidibe
during the Oscars on TV in front of millions worldwide?
Furthermore Howard's disparagement of Gabourey's size and film future is ironic being that the Oscar winner for best Supporting Actress, Mo'Nique, also a very large Black woman, prior to "Precious" has 8 feature films she's acted in, in her body of film work, plus two more counting "Precious" and "Steppin...The Movie" also released in 2009, which are 9 more than Howard's one movie, "Private Parts".
Finally Gagourey Sidibe at her young tender age, has already achieved what middle aged Howard Stern hasn't and probably never will....An Oscar Nomination For Acting.
Here's another thought, when was the last time Oprah was seen standing next to a white person... she is the real racist here. Don't get me wrong I HATE Stern and do NOT listen to him and I am a subscriber, but Oprah is nothing but a black female version of a racist!!!!!
Stern rubs people the wrong way because of how he expresses himself but he's absolutely right. This girl is young and extremely overweight. Forget about getting other roles, she needs to get healthy.
I'm not condoning what Howard did, but what Oprah did was a thousand times worse. If she truly cared about this girl, she'd have taken her aside and said, "Look. You're morbidly obese. If you want to live to see 35, here's where you can go to get some help." Instead, she does the total opposite and *encourages* this girl's appallingly unhealthy lifestyle!
All of you Stern haters are just jealous of him and his $500 million dollar payday and his beautiful wife. 'Nuff said......
Did he comment on Rosanne Barr before she lost her weight? Lets not forget Oprah was overweight and she is very successful. Everyone who agreeds with him are just as bad as he is. We have people starving themselves to be skinny for who? What she looks like and how heavy she is shouldn't matter to anyone but her. Its not up to us to judge her. As far the "fat black girl" thats just another way to be racist. What is the focus being fat or black. If the is issue is about being fat then why does "black" have to come before fat. We are a racist sociey period and everyone that responded on his side are ignorant. Let me ask all you people that said being fat is unhealthy, do you drink or smoke? That causes health issues as well lung cancer, heart disease etc. We can't say that someone has a short life spand because they are overweight, its not up to us to make that call. All you who said that are simply dumb.
has anyone told howard that he has a big as white nose?
This is why his show didnt do well in Montreal. He thinks he's funny, but the truth is he is just PLAIN boring and sounds like a broken record.
Never could stand howard...hes cruel and hes a disgusting pig.
Howard is usually rude, but he's absolutely right. Everyone else is just afraid to say it. All these people here are upset because he says a really fat chick is too fat, but the first thing out of all your mouths is Howard is an ass, or Howard is ugly, etc. You all need to get over yourselves because you're no better than he is.
Strong, gutsy women just scare him. He is showing his impotence by attacking her. If he wanted to make a valid comment, there are other ways of doing it.
Howard tells it the way it is! He is like Simon Cowell – You don't always like what he says but, he does get it right 99% of the time... With respect to Miss Sidibie – How can you argue that she will not have a challenging career? This world is about the Pretty People and she does not fit in. She will more than likely be forgotten or her career will be relegated to small cameo appearances. For those of you that knock Howards delivery, you're missing the bigger picture – He is willing to be controversial in order to bring attention to Sirius Radio... Howard is a genius!
I am LMAO that this is actually on CNN. #1: He's right. She is morbidly obese, beyond 'could stand to lose a few pounds' and straight to circus oddity. #2: Stern has been saying stuff like this for YEARS and NOW it's controversial? #3: Reading over all of these comments, I believe that the consensus is that he is 'just saying what we're all thinking'. #4: All you blusterers and huffers need to take a pill. If you haven't listened to the show, you have NO IDEA that this is totally NON-controversial. Wait til he picks on some starlet who has put a few ounces of cheese on her ass for your righteous outrage.
Who is this Howard Stern Character? Linger Longer.
Is Stern an ass? Well...of course he is. I really don't like his choice of words in this case as he was quite cruel. But, I do agree with the message he is trying to send.
When Howard Stern was born, the Dr slapped his Mama instead of him for producing such an ugly man! What gives you the right to make fun of someone because they are overweight? You are a pig! The only reason why your wife married you was because you had money...no other reason...
Ok, Howard Stern if you are going to rip someone b/c of how they look then maybe you haven't looked in the mirror lately. You know there is a solution it's called plastic surgery. We all know the money isn't the reason you haven't done it. So what's your excuse? Everyone has flaws and some peoples are more prevalent than others but there is no reason to rip someone because they actually made something of themselves. If you haven't noticed but over half this country is obese. Instead of ridaculing someone b/c of thier size why don't you take your money and do something useful with it. Just remember you're ugly inside and out nothings going to change that.
Howard Stern is not only an ass, he is an ugly ass. There is a reason why he is on the radio and not on TV or movies. He is only picking on this poor girl because she is an easy target and he will get attention. And, it is jealousy. The only movie he has ever been in is his own movie and it sucked!! These comments were unnecessary and flat out rude. Go look in the mirror, Stern! Why don't you worry about fixing yourself instead of picking on others?!
Will someone please tell my how Howard's statement is racist? I want someone to explain this too me. Is it because he said something negative about an overweight black woman? So if i'm critical of a black person, that's racist? Saying he's a racist proves that you not only know nothing about Howard Stern other than what a bias article has told you, and you also have a very skewed perception of reality. To compare these comments to Don Imus' is so much of a jump you'd have a better chance of jumping over the Grand Canyon on a tricycle. Howard, in a very blunt way, said she was overweight and unhealthy. Imus made a racist comment about an all black basketball team.
One of the comments mentioned how they were a "long time listener" and because of these comments you were no longer listening. I would venture to bet that you never were a listener if THIS made you stop listening.
To those of you who said her Oscar nomination shows that she's more talented, successful than Howard....no. One film does not a career make. And plus, she was only nominated because she's Hollywoods latest "charity case". Oh look at us, we're being nice to the fat girl. Hollywood also gave Roman Polanski a standing ovation...
Let's stack up Howards accomplisments against Gabby's. Howard = 30+ year career. #1 movie, 2 #1 books, #1 cable show on the E!, every radio station he came to became #1. Took a failing satellite company, and in his tenure brought in over 10 million subscribers and last quarter they turned a profit for the first time. Lets not mention the almost billion dollars he's earned in his career. Now...Gabby = 1 movie, 1 Oscar nomination...hard to compare.
wahhhhhhh.... Howard called a fat chick fat. wahhhhhhhhhh
Are we really surprised at Howard Stern's comments. My issue is with that "Uncle/Aunt Tom" of a cohost who echoes everything he says. YOU could be that fat black (did you forget that you were black) woman who can't get a job anywhere else. What size are you? Be careful who you slam.
I agree totally with Sterns statement. I was getting annoyed at all the camera angles of her. She should have wiped her neck off a few times. I'm sorry, what neck ? I do have sympathy for her life. How in the world was she ever considered for an Oscar ?
Oh please. All of you Stern co signing, d ck riders, who keep saying we don't "understand" him and he's "right", get a life. No, I don't understand anyone that freakin' ugly having the audacity to talk about ANYONE. His face looks like ground zero. Thats why hes on the radio and not tv. If I looked like that, I wouldn't give people a reason to call out my flaws by picking on someone else.
It's not what you say, it's how you say it, and the was he talked about her was horrible, maybe that's the only way he can get good ratings, is by being mean.
Okay first of all – if anyone is going to criticize what Stern said about Gabourey, they need to also criticize him for all the millions of horrific things he has said about tons and tons of other people throughout the course of his career. Why is this controversial? It's HOWARD STERN. It's like saying Hugh Hefner was seen with a young naked blonde.
God, I love Howard! Tell it like it is kind of guy. He's honest. I hope she does get many more roles but the fact of the matter here is, yes she is overweight. Oprah is the one that should be ashamed not Howard.
Sadly Stern is right about her size being Unhealthy. He may have been rude but his message is very truth full. When I saw her I was thinking her next roll will be as a contestant on "The Biggest Loser."
Just because something is obviously true doesn't mean one has to say it. Let the young woman have her moment!
Howard Stern is a classless and moronic asshole.
He should take a good long look in the mirror.
I agree with the person who said he is UGLY on the inside and out!
For everyone complaining that he's right but he didn't have to be so mean about it, here's a wake-up call: If Stern didn't say things the way he said them, he wouldn't have a show... period.
oh common people...Howard Stern is just saying what everyone is thinking. He is absolutely correct she does need to lose weight, so she can continue her career as an actress. Now that she got a little money she should improve her lifestyle and become healthier individual and there is nothing wrong with being healthy.
Howard is the man!
Sidibe is beautiful inside and out. She maybe the healthier than any of the bloggers on this site-skinny people have health issues-she auditioned for a role and got the part she didn't think she would get-on the first try. I'm pretty sure she is aware that she is a big girl and that Holloywood thrives on outer beauty. I know she reads the blogs and see what people say about her-but who cares about what people say
she is being recognized and I applaud her for taking the courage and the confidence to take a life changing step-she wasn't planning to make a career out of acting, but when roles are introduce to her, she is taking them. No, Sidibe, you are not the "cookie cutter" actress that everyone is so use to, but you continue to do what God planned for you and don't worry about the haters.
Stern appeals to a certain demographic and he's shrewd enough to keep doing his schtick because he knows that demographic will eat it up and keep his pockets lined. The interesting question here is this. Stern has been offending people of all races, genders, socio-economic tiers, sexual orientations, etc. for years. Why now is there such a backlash about Sibide? It seems much deeper than just the PC police continuing their incessant whining. How and with whom did Stern hit way too close to home so that they're launching into over-reactive tirades? P.S. I don't like Stern, so I'm not defending him. I'm just very curious as to why the huge reaction NOW for this particular actress vs. the all the years that's he's been crudely disparaging others in a similar manner.
The people posting here are reacting to Gabourey for the same reason Stern did - ignorance and hypocrisy. Statistically, the fattest woman will outlive the thinnest man. Obesity is NOT the serious health risk it has been made out to be, especially for women. Fat senior citizens, in fact, outlive thin senior citizens. The reason fat is "medicalized" is the same reason that gay sex is in some circles - bigotry. People react instinctively and try to dress their reactionary ignorance up in logic.
You know who IS sickly? Those pencil thin, anorexic women that Stern has on his show. They are the ones at risk and yet he says nothing. THEY have a much higher risk of death than the most morbidly obese person. YOU people are the ones in denial. Go speak with a genuine obesity doctor who has been educated in the last twenty years.
Stern is just a bigot - and a cruel one at that. How he ever had a TV career with that face is the mystery.
Thank God there is someone out there with the guts to speak the truth. Imagine being in Show Business and not being afraid to call Oprah a liar and public suck-up artist, which she – despite all her wonderful qualities – without a doubt, is.
Stern gives good advice. You have money and fame now Miss ; hire the best nutritionist and personal trainer in Hollywood and go for it.
The message should NOT be: Ok all you over eaters it's OK ; you CAN be fat and successful.
is it my imagination or separated at birth? howard stern and bachelor no. 1, rodney alcala.
anyone ripping on stern has done nothing but 'sink' to his level. unfortunately many of you missed his point (probably b/c of his delivery, sure). she is morbidly obese, and all of these people that are so accepting of her weight are doing nothing but sentencing her to an early death.
hopefully she hears this story, and thinks, "well, he's right. i am fat". and then does something about it.
a true friend, or true fan, does not sit idly by and watch someone die.
HEy Lou, in case you haven't noticed, Stern is a radio star; he goals are not related to acting in Movies and winning acting awards.
Everyone is so busy pointing the finger at others when they should really look at their own unhealthy life style. Yes, she is over weight, but that does not give stern any right to use her and destroy her happiness just for lousy ratings. if he is "concerned" (which I doubt he is) then why doesn't he try to help her? Furthermore, who knows she might have a medical condition that makes it hard for her to lose the weight? She may not be sitting around eating twinkies like everyone thinks obese people do.
Oh Howard, if only you were relevant.
I happen to like Howard Stern for his honesty. There aren't many roles she could take. Like he said, take your money and go exercise for your job or just lose that weight. And she isn't the only one he picks on.
Regardless of the debate about the individual Stern targeted ... clearly this is about him. He is using someone else's moment in the spotlight to garner publicity for himself. Stern is really no different than Rush Limbaugh or other jerks in the media who constantly make inflammatory remarks to gain publicity. This would be a much better debate if a softer media figure were to raise the question based on medical concerns, etc. Since Stern is the one making the statements ... its clear what his motive is.
I saw Precious and for 2 hours got lost in the story of this young girl who was dealing with the life that she didn't choose. What I love about a true actor is that they are fearless, and no matter what people think, they are willing to show the ugly side of themselves to give a GREAT performance.
I'm proud of this young lady who knows she is not America's standard of beauty! She is an inspiration because she is not hiding until she looks the part! She is standing before all of you, who would rather that she hate herself and just disappear, and she is living her young life to the fullest!
No matter what anyone says... She is Oscar nominated Gabby!
So Howard said what everyone is thinking. Come on, honestly, what roles is she qualified for? I can't wait to see her in a romantic comedy with Gerard Butler. 'The Crush of Love'. I'm sure it will break all sorts of box office records. (or chairs)
We did not know anything about the movie and we walked in and saw her and walked right out. She should be called enormous not precious.
Stern is right she will have a massive heart attack if she does not get help.
Stern maybe you should get a nose job. That is the ugliest big peice of crap I have ever seen on a face! I hope they keep you in a back room so we don't have to look at you.
I think it's hilarious that the people who hate Stern and talk about how he shouldn't harp on Gaborey for her weight – and how looks aren't as important as whats on the inside – try to insult him by saying how ugly he is.
Stern has had an enormous career in radio for like 30 years – the man is talented... you certainly can't argue that. Because of her weight issues, Gaborey is a one-hit wonder. She might be very talented, but we'll never see any evidence of it beyond 'Precious' because she'll likely never get cast another role of that magnitude again. Hollywood likes good-looking, skinny people – and moviegoers like watching them.
And let's please stop the 'its ok to be fat' myth. It's not. It's unhealthy, dangerous, and socially limiting. And Gaborey isn't even 'just' fat – she's morbidly obese. Someone needs to give this girl a wake-up call to lose some weight... otherwise, Stern's prediction will unfortunately become true.
Howard Stern don't you think she knows she's overweight?
She can get skinny but you can't get handsome!
Wow. Howard Stern.....you look like a sheep dog.
I agree with Stern. That heffer needs to mix in a salad. No dressing.
You all hate him because 9 times out of 10 he says EXACTLY what you all wish you could say. sad but true...he has a point. he may just go about it wrong.
The other day they had a hot or not on yahoo or something, with what people wore to the Oscars. She was on the hot side... I think I had a Howard moment... thinking seriously, there is no outfit she could wear that would make me think she looks hot... Are the fashion judges just pandering to the need to be PC?
Well, I'm not going to pretend to have read every post. OMG he must have hit a nerve!
But what I will say is Howard Stern gets paid an unGodly amount of money saying the things he does about people who hardly are equiped to defend themselves. He'll say it in rude and unflatering ways most of us couldn't image saying. He's called a "Shockjock" for a reason, so knowing that shouldn't surprise you in the least.
It's all for ratings, and apparently irate "comment post". If Howard really cared about the Sidibe's health, he would approach her in private and offer her assistance, rather than try to tear someone down in such a public forum, during what can only be the highlight of her young life.
The Oscars was not the time to address Sidibes obvious problem. But Oprah saw it as a time to express pride and joy for someone's job well done. Mr. Stern apparently has had so much smoke blown up his bum. That the smoke rings circling his head has clouded any memory of what it's like to have someone truly and honestly be happy for him and his accomplishments.
Who knows what motivates someone to over eat. Lazy, Stress, Genetics or maybe it's hearing an overpaid shock jock publicly humiliate them on a national stage for ratings.
Just a thought!
Ok! When Howard was still on sindicated radio, he had women on his show performing anal ring-toss (even the name is so nasty that this post will probably be edited). So now he is going to get negative press because of his typical fat and black jokes?...give me a break! The people who listen to his trash pay for it and so who really cares? At least there is little chance my kids can hear him anymore...
I'm actually quite proud of Howard for his words. I haven't listened to him for years, but the Howard I remember would have called her a fat pig and left it at that. The fact that he expressed concern for her well-being truly impressed me. And he's right.
He's still alive?
Imagine, Howard Stern spouting off without knowing the facts...
You can be fat and healthy. I know, the medical and obesity community says you can't.....but, there are a LOT of studies out there that refute what is being touted by the medical community. The research of the diet/obesity community – well, you need to follow the money. If being fat isn't dangerous, they don't make money.
Size isn't the issue, the issue is whether or not a person is taking care of their body. You can be fat and fit and skinny and unhealthy. Here's the bottom line, not everyone is fat because of life style choices and not everyone is skinny because they are taking good care of themselves. Unfortunately, many people are fat because in their pursuit of the "social norm" they dieted, meaning they restricted their food intake. The body, in its pursuit to keep you alive, takes any type of food restriction seriously and changes your metabolism so that you retain more weight, because it wants to make sure you never die. So, as experienced by most dieters (around 85-95%), you may lose weight, but then you regain the weight (usually within a year, most by 5 years) and a few pounds more. The hard part is, you will never lose the weight and keep it off...mother nature is more powerful than any diet in the world. Then there is the gene factor – some people are just naturally fatter than the norm...nothing is ever going to change that. However, no matter what a person's size, they can have a healthy eating relationship and enjoy pleasurable movement (even sex Howard!). Any person can be healthy – even if they are fat – meaning their blood pressure, cholesterol, lipids, glucose, etc. are normal. Exercise and healthy eating are the key – not weight!
And just for fun – at the turn of the century, the truly beautiful people of this country were fat. It was a goal. Being fat meant you were wealthy and had more of everything, especially food (a huge issue after the Civil War!) Beauty truly is in the eye of the beholder. I find it interesting...for all the marketing around skinny women...my boys, husband of many of our male friends are really not all that attracted to really skinny women. As my youngest son would say...they need to eat a sandwich then get back to me. Howard is one opinion out of 7 billion...and not a well informed opinion, at least not about fat people.
The best way to deal with negativity is to ignore it – giving it attention only feeds the fire.
Well, I'm not going to pretend to have read every post. OMG he must have hit a nerve!
But what I will say is Howard Stern gets paid an unGodly amount of money saying the things he does about people who hardly are equipped to defend themselves. He'll say it in rude and unflatering ways most of us couldn't image saying. He's called a "Shock jock" for a reason, so knowing that shouldn't surprise you in the least.
It's all for ratings, and apparently irate "comment post". If Howard really cared about Sidibe's health, he would approach her in private and offer her assistance, rather than try to tear her down in such a public forum, during what can only be the highlight of her young life.
The Oscars was not the time to address Sidibes obvious problem. But Oprah saw it as a time to express pride and joy for someone's job well done. Mr. Stern apparently has had so much smoke blown up his bum. That the smoke rings circling his head has clouded any memory of what it's like to have someone truly and honestly be happy for him and his accomplishments.
Who knows what motivates someone to over eat. Laziness, Stress, Genetics or maybe it's hearing an overpaid shock jock publicly humiliate them on a national stage for ratings.
Just a thought!
THANK YOU!!! I didn't watch the movie because I can't stand to look at her. It looks like her face is going to explode. She will NEVER be in another movie unless she is playing another character like she did in Precious. She needs to lose weight if she wants to be in anything else. SERIOUSLY!! She is not Cinderella..she is not beautiful. Come on people.
Never liked Stern. But sadly this time I found some validity in his points.
Stern is of course correct. This Columbia graduate who revolutionized media is the only guy on the air that cuts through the PC crap and calls it like it is. His $500 million contract was for a lot more than just T & A.
Howard speaks the truth.. The world tore into Jessica Simpson for gaining 10 pounds... but because this chick is black its different???
Howard for Pres!
Howard can be too blunt, but he's right about the girl's weight.
She now has some money and prospects of working again.
However, if she doesn't lose weight, she's going to die. It's
as simple as that. If she doesn't have the stength to change
her life, she needs someone to help her.
how is Howard Stern any different? i mean, let's face it- she may be grotesquely obese for someone so young- but if it wasn't for his constantly "over the line" remarks- he'd just be some ugly jack ass that no one listened to as well. It was his outrageously lewd tongue which made him a name and if she hadn't fit the bill of the Precious character- no one would know who she was either.
GS is an AMAZINGLY gifted actress and what happens at this point is up to her. Why does the world believe they can sculpt and mold her into yet another miserable anorexic like every other young starlet?
To mer; I love your blog.
The truth hurts.........doesn't it!!!!!! Don't shoot the messenger.
sroo: and yet, hollywood is filled with drug addicts and anorexics. Those people will probably die a hell of a lot faster than Gabby will and THEY aren't being raked through the coals in the name of "true friends" and "true fans." this isn't being debated out of concern, it's being debated out of judgement. that is the honest to God truth and it's time someone said it. It makes people uncomfortable because either they don't understand it, or it isn't normal. That's it.
He's blunt. Not everyone in Hollywood can be blunt but he can, and he can get away with it. I would go crazy if I was always being told what to say. I respect him for being honest, however yes, it was a rude statement, but hey it's true! If noone ever says anything- she'll keep on going the way she is, and eventually parish.
Howard Stern is Howard Stern. Yes, he is an ass, but this is true. She really is an un-healthy size. I was thinking the same thing in the sense that she will get pigeon-holded into the same roles because of her weight. Precious was perfect for her because she phsyically played the character as well. She is young and successful. It wouldn't hurt to lose weight. For her health, not for cosmetic reasons. This would benefit her "long career" that Oprah is talking about, as well. It will open more doors for her. I'd like to see her do well despite her size, but it's honestly not realistic in the business she's in, and when it comes to this, Howard Stern is 100% right.
For all the pretentious idiots out there like Stern who think just because you don't smoke, don't drink, your not over weight, you have never done drugs, nor have made any unhealthy mistakes in your life; you're still not going to live forever...Surprise!!!! As long as people don't assassinate your spirit, it is possible to be a fat person and live a happy life (even if preceived by YOU as potentially a shorter one). Like most Americans, I am so tired of seeing only the beautiful, rich and stupid do "great things"....
Stern caters to the weak and the powerless.
All the people complaining about Stern being "rude" or "disrespectful" have obviously never listened to his show. That's his entire shtick.
Having said that, I found that I got tired of his act after a while. It's like a bracing shock to the system at first, because you're used to people having an internal filter on what they say, and he appears to have none. But after the shock wears off, he just starts to sound arrogant and annoying after a while.
Having said that, he's 100% right about Gabby. Everyone is pretending she has a glowing future ahead of her, and that is by no means guaranteed. Tatum O'Neal actually WON an Academy Award at the age of 10 and everyone thought she had a huge career ahead of her, but it never materialized. She got bit parts and never did become one of Hollywood's top leading ladies. This despite being very attractive, unlike Gabby who is (let's face it) not very attractive because of her morbid obesity.
two words....Jenny Craig
now let's address those who said "Howard should look in the mirror, he's ugly, he shouldn't be critical for looks".
Ok...if you weren't so ignorant to Howard, you'd know that he's critical of everyone for everything...including himself. He knows he's ugly, he even said he looks like a pelican. He's overly conscious of weight and health because he used to smoke, eat unhealthy and be over weight. He was so unhealthy that his parents sat him down and said "look, you need to make a change for your own good". He now eats healthy and runs 4 or 5 miles daily.
Howard l being an ugly man won't effect his health. Howard being ugly won't give him heart disease, diabetes or liver and kidney problems. Howard being ugly won't put unneeded stress on his heart and skeleton.
Lastly, for those of you who are throwing the racist word around. Listen to the clip, you can easily find it. His BLACK co-host Robin agrees that Gabby needs help. Let me say one more time...Howard Stern's BLACK FEMALE co-host Robin agrees with him. Robin's battle with weight has also been very well documented throughout the history of the show.
Stern is awesome, he is truthful and funny. He's not fake like most of the entertainment industry and from what I've read most of the people that have commented on this story. There are a whole bunch of sheeple in this country being who can't think for and be honest with themselves.
I really envy Howard Stern. I whish I had a job that allowed me to express how I really feel about everything and get paid for it.
It may have been rude, but he is a shock jock, he makes fun of everyone, that's what he does. This only hit a cord for the same reasons why (and he is actually correct) Oprah made her remarks... because under the surface, everyone feels bad for her ,and is rooting for her, and wishing her the best.. BECAUSE OF HER SIZE! And all that comes with it...
Like many other commenters, I don't care much for Howard Stern, but I have to agree with him here.
When I retired from teaching in 2006, a fellow science teacher of mine said he had two or three years left and his dream was to retire with his nice pension, move to Las Vegas, and become a dealer in a casino. He loved gambling.
But he was nearly as big as Sidibe. The year after I retired he had a massive heart attack and died. He was out of shape but in otherwise good health. No diabetes, hypertension, etc.
For years some people had warned him about his weight but too many kept quiet. A seven years before he died I told him he could get some exercise being an assistant cross country coach for me and all the walking would do him good – and he'd make an extra $1200 for the 16 weeks to boot. He declined.
Unless Sidibe gets and listens to such advice, she has a good chance of meeting a similar fate.
How sad it is that folks feel the need to make such negative comments about Gabouray. Precious is the story of a young Black girl who is victimized and bullied because she is an overweight, dark skin girl; who should play this role Halle Berry? Rather than allowing her to enjoy her moment, her day, people enjoy making negative and nasty remarks about her skin color, her weight and overall apperance. What difference does it make if she never does another movie, it's still one more movie than any of us have done.
Some of the remarks on this post are just down right mean and nasty; only small people feel big by making others feel bad.
While some might not find Gabouray pleasing to the eye, she may very well be pleasing to the heart and soul which is much more important. It took great courage to walk that Red Carpet knowing that folks will joke and make remarks about her, but she did it anyway. I applaud her.
So to all you folks who enjoy making her feel bad, if it makes you feel good about yourself to make others feel bad, continue to make your jokes, cause Gabouray will still be a better person than you are.
First of all I congradulate Ms. Sidibe for her performance and nomination. However, I find many of these comments to be very disturbing. I do feel that she needs to lose weight for obvious health concerns. For those of you who feel she will not be in any future films because of her weight, my question for you is; how do you know she won't lose the weight? If she loses weight will you reconsider you assumptions regarding her acting career, or is there another reason you feel that would keep her from realizing any future acting endeavors.
Remember her "size" may have nothing to do with over-eating, etc. It may just be "her" biology. None of us know her medical history. So criticisms are out of order.
As for Stern, the world will be best improved by just "ignoring" him. He "survives" off "shock" statements. Simply ignoring him is the best payback.
Stern is a low life. No one has the right to criticize someone else. Especially in the public way he did it.
Yes, Gabi, is overweight, yes, it is a dangerous situation, but telling her in public only adds pain.
How hypocritical of Stern, who is a former addict to shame Gabi on air! Would those of you be so supportive of Stern if he was shaming a drug addict? Or an alcoholic?! Millions of Americans are addicts in one form or other, the thing is......... when your drug of choice is food, its hard to hide!
Stern is disgusting, to shame a young woman on his show is as low as it gets! Careful Stern.......... karma is a bitch!
IT was infact her SIZE that got her the part as Precious in the first place!!!!!
Why is everyone making such a big deal about what Howard Stern said? His job is to comment on our society. People listen to his radio show for just that. They want his insights on pop culture. What he said was true. The girl is the size of a blimp. Should we lie to her and let her go down this path to an early death?
Actually, nobody will say this but it's immoral to be grossly obese, so people should stop talking about how someone can be "attractive on the inside".
Morbid obesity means gluttony, which is one of the Seven Deadly Sins that have been vilified for centuries. It is only recently, in the Age of Consumerism, that we have stopped regarding gluttony and greed as bad things. Also, morbid obesity means a lack of discipline, and an undisciplined mind is nothing to be proud of either.
Also, morbidly obese people are bad for the environment. They eat two or three times as much as regular people, which means they have twice or three times the environmental footprint, because so much of our pollution is a result of the agriculture required to make and transport and package the food that we eat. That means two or three times as much pollution.
Amen, Howard.....Amen!!
I don't care for Howard Stern, and think he's a crass old windbag who takes enjoyment off other's misery (which is exactly what people do who don't like theirself).
However, he IS only saying what everyone else IS thinking. And one fluke movie does NOT make a career. Ms. Sidibe is obese and is not setting a healthy example for young people in America. No one is saying she needs to look like the rest of those lollypop head, skinny women in Hollywood, but she is risking her life.
We should take pity on poor Howard Stern. He hasn't had any new material since the 90s.
Well don't you all realize, Oprah is the new messiah.. what she says goes or gets put into motion. See Gabby already has a new TV role lined up on Cable, as it was announced yesterday. If people want to get on Oprah's good side the will hire Gaby or even write rolls for her to play in. Imagine a screenwriter going to Oprah saying ... " I have a movie, I want to star Gaby in".. I just don't have the funding.. "Cha-Ching".. Oprah will produce it. Oprah is so predictable & if Hollywood is smart. they need to jump on the bandwagon.. oh my bad the Oprah gravy train.. she won't live forever. as for the other issues... Yes Gabby needs to loose weight, Yes Vanity Fair should have been sued for Racism, Yes I am a black woman.
well, i have quite obviously made just as much, if not more, of an ass of myself than stern did when the controversial comments were made. that being said, i cant really say too much on the issue without pissing any more people off. i will say however, that i disagree with MOST of the things he said.
for example: Stern disagreed. “She told an enormous woman the size of a planet that she’s going to have a career,” he said during his broadcast. “Oprah should’ve said, ‘you need to get help, we don’t want to lose you.’ "
for once in my lifetime (or at least since i've grown up a little) people are not being so shallow. i've come to realize that it doesnt really matter what the hell somebody looks like doing something if they cant do it. i honestly believe people should look at personality and talent before looks in most cases. granted, if someone were to try to cast her as a swimsuit model, he may not meet as much resistance. however she was the right pick for the job (and a walk on off the street basically), and she did a great job. she is an actor, and a damn good one at that. she is not trying to be a supermodel. let the girl do her.
Howard Stern is someone we could definitely do without. I heard rumors that he would be taking over for Simon Cowell on "Idol" next season. That would result in my petition to discontinue the show. I hate everything he stands for. He truly is a Jack of all asses. But I guess America is great because idiots like Howard Stern and Michael Moore can have a voice too.
There are many things that are could kill you, a texting motorist, a thin person with high blood pressure or pressure from society to fit into an expected norm. How many kids do we hear about that commit suicide from comments about their looks? Yes, being overweight is bad for your health, but this is Gabourey's moment, not Stern's. She should have the right to enjoy it to the fullest, regardless of the color of her skin or her weight. I understand his shtick is making fun of people to the point of causing huge controversies and that keeps him in business, but the way he has chosen to find fault where there is none is getting tiresome.
Stern is correct! Instead of giving her (Gabby) all of the glory, people should be telling her to go on a good diet plan! She is the candidate for a heart attack, high blood pressure and diabetes.
Would Oprah have empathically tried to inspire and help launch the career of an obese caucasian woman, abused in a trailer-home in West Virginia? No. Winfrey is a racist with a very thin veil.
He's a flat out jerk. I don't care if it's the truth. You just don't say it like that. It's harsh and rude. No wonder the world is so messed up – if you admire and support this guy, then something is wrong with you.
Howard's right about everything he has said,her next role is to be the meteorite that hit the earth and wiped out the dinosaurs.
As long as Oprah and Tyler Perry are behind Gabby it doesn't matter what Howard Stern thinks. He is nothing to look at either. Maybe Gabby can work with Oprah on her radio show. Don't count her out. She is a very well spoken young lady.
Thanks Howard... I thought the same thing. Nobody should encourage her. Her drug is food.Not healthy.
I'm with Howard Stern...I think that people who are her size make excuses for their excessive weight gain and try to blame the media for putting pressure on women to be thin. Well, there is a reason why thin is encouraged – it's healthy. Being over weight should never be the norm, nor should it ever be acceptable. Lose the excuses, lose the weight – that simple.
It doesn't matter if Howard Stern was right there's a way to say certain things. So he's being truthful okay I see that, but when you're dealing with the truth there's a mature way to approach it! You do not handle the truth like it's one of your bad jokes Stern, and you most certainly do not say it in a way that'll have everyone who hear it point and laugh at this sweet girl behind her back, to her face, on the internet, or anywhere. It's about time you get some class and know when it's time to joke and when it's time to act like an adult. You never joke about anyone's health, at all, and it doesn't make you the more popular for doing it!
Just because she' s large it doesn't mean she's stupid. She's not a child. I'm sure she's well aware of the statistics of careers for large women in Hollywood as well as for being over-weight. What I'd like to know is why is this anyone's business?
Stern is the man...Sorry if he is a little harsh, but that is the beauty of stern. He says what he thinks and most of the time he is correct, sorry he doesn't sugar coat everything. Get over it, the fact that there are this many post about what stern says on his radio show that you must subscribe to to hear just emphasizes what a bad ass the man is. Love him or hate him you will always listen to what he has to say.
Love him or hate him, you all know darn well that on this subject, he is spot on with the truth.
Howard, you got my vote if you ever want to run for President of the USA.......You others should open your eyes.
You people can be so cruel... she could find another gig... weren't they working on a Fat Albert remake?
He didn't say anything untrue. People can't stand when others speak their mind. He doesn't censor what he says, and good for him.
more likely... perhaps she can team up with Dustin Diamond and Britney's ex on the next Celebrity Fit Club
Stern and Robin were 100% percent correct. That lady is not fat, she's OBESE! If any of you were Siruis/XM subscribers who listen to Stern you would know that today he said he wasn't trying to pick on her so much as make a point that this lady is heading down a road of no return. She'll be dead in a few years if she continues to "hit Chik-Fil-A and hit it hard" as she put it. So him saying she won't have a career is just a fact of nature. She won't have a career because her heart will pump sludge blood around her gigantic body until it gives out. Everybody complains about healthcare premiums, do you think people like her drive them up? Of course they do because they're at risk for so many health related problems, and America is so fat that the healthcare industry can drive up premium prices and not feel to bad about it. These people put themselves in that position, and our feeling bad for them, or worse, being accepting of it, is absolutely ridiculous. Bravo Howard and Robin. You're just voicing what so many of us already know and believe.
There is only one difference between Howard and Oprah because both of them are entertainers, nothing more: regardless if you hate Howard, I can at least appreciate his blunt and direct approach as opposed to Oprah's sugar-coated b.s. designed to make everyone feel warm and fuzzy. As an educated woman I find Oprah to be far more offensive than Howard; not because she's black, but she gives the most ridiculous advice to people with the premise that it's legimate while manipulating her minions to follow her mindless drivel. Sure, Howard can be crass and tactless but I thought the same thing when I saw Ms. Gabourey: she's too young to be so overweight!!
I don't like Stern's show (although I loved the movie), but I have to agree with him. He is saying the exact same thing I was saying to my wife on Oscar night.
Stern is has it all right. If the lady doesn't lose weight she will die! And if the puiblic wants to beleive that is not true we are doing her more harm then good.
I'm curious if the majority of the comments going against Howard would be the same if he described someone who did something vile and evil, in the same manner.
He shouldn't have stated his opinion publicly, it was not appropriate and I'm sure she's aware of her own situation.
What a jerk!!! Howard Stern you are a puke
Wanda...maybe you can shed some light.
Could you explain to me how Howard Stern's comments were racist?
It's sadly true. It's hard enough for a female black actress to get work in hollywood, being large is just another obstacle. She's just not "fat" she is obese and needs help. She is very talented and can really make strides, but Stern is right, the weight will hold her back. She'll be typcasted, or worst she'll be in a stupid Tyler Perry movie.
As difficult as it may be to hear what Howard said we all know that it's true. Holly Wood is EXTREMEMLY superficial. Brutal Honesty is sometimes the best HONESTY.
I don't think Oprah meant any harm. It is like a Cinderella story because who would have thought to hire someone that size in a movie. Who can say whether her career is over. I think she has made a name for herself and will move forward. Also, she should not have said on camera that she likes Chick fil A. We know you like to eat but don't say out loud that you like to eat. Have some pride. She will get herself together. I have faith. If she wants to continue in her career, the producers will get on her about weight.
Whether you like Stern or not he was speaking his mind, and what were either thinking and would'nt say themeselves. As far as criticizing Stern's looks, He's a Radio DJ. Have you heard the expression he has a face for radio. He is not trying to make money off of his appearance.
True there are others who are large who have made a career, Dom Deluise & Monique were mentioned....they are both comedians. Being large and funny is more marketable than being large and dramatic.
John Favreau was very stocky when he made "Rudy", he asked for Sean Astin's advice on getting more work and Sean told him against the advice of others "To lose weight". Others on the project said he could be "The big funny guy".
If she wants to work as an actress she needs to not kid herself and lose the weight.
Monique is fat, she was always fat, and she managed to be on TV for years....and she got an Oscar! So, there's hope for Precious lady, too.
However, yes, she should lose a lot of weight, for her own good.
I think Howard is telling the pure truth regarding her weight and the how fake Oprah is. His harshness is testament to the true feeling of many of us, whether we want to admit it or not. American Idol would be LUCKY to get him as a guest, he would save the show which would certainly fail once Simon leaves.
I think Howard had the right idea, but his presentation was wrong. He's right because she should really try and lose some weight, just for her health. Not for roles or anything, but for her to live a long, happy life.
I don't agree with Oprah's comment. Especially in an age where childhood obesity is a growing problem.
Hello. She is the size of a house. She should use her new found fame to promote a diet or exercise program. I wish her luck and courage.
PLEASE – everyone get over it – Howard is off terrestrial radio, and on Sirius – no one has to listen, we pay to listen – if not for this news article only Howard's fans would have knowledge of this anyways – he says this kind of stuff about ALL famous people which is what makes Howard great, no one and nothing is sacred – he is going to speak his mind and he's in the perfect outlet (Sirius Radio) to do so – and lets not forget, his show is an ENTERTAINMENT show – its comedy! – since when are we not allowed to make fun of people?? – say what you will about him, he's still the King of all Media
Everyone keeps getting on Howard for his looks. If you listened to his show you would know that he thinks he is one of the ugliest people he's ever seen. He has extreme self image issues as well as low self esteem. While I agree with what he said, like most of you, I do not necessarily agree with the delivery.
I do have a question...since when is someone not allowed to voice an opinion whether it be done tastefully or not?
Howard Stern is kind of a jerk, we all know this. It's why he's popular.
Miss Gabourey is more than likely overweight because her family could not afford super healthy food all of the time. I may be completely wrong because I am not familiar with her background, but hopefully now that she has a good chunk of money it will help her to be more healthy.
Stern gets paid millions to be rude, obscene, and filthy.
I guess that qualifies him to identify faults!!!!!!!
What a jerk!
He looks like he has been hit on his blindside. Has he ever thought about his looks and that is why his is on RADIO. Ithink he would be prettier if he shut his mouth. and when you see a pretty women with him fat or skinney... It must be the MONEY because it sure isn't looks
He isn't wrong, and people need to realize that being that overweight is not OK. While I want my children to know that outward appearance doesn't mean anything, I also want them to know that unhealthy is not acceptable by any means. If you are as large as Gabourey, then you have a very serious problem.
This is why I'm glad he is no longer on public radio. He has the right to say what he wants ans we have the right not to listen to him. I wonder how he would react if someone told him his nose was way too big and he should get it fixed? He is a sad, insensitive and pathetic man.
While crass, he is essentially correct. This is a bright woman with many career opportunities who is quickly killing herself. If she was a junkie his comments that she should 'get some help' would have been applauded.
My mother was 'proud' of being a large woman and despite all of our begging to take better care of herself, she ignored our requests. When she developed diabetes and had her foot amputated, her pride gave way to terror and depression. I wouldnt wish that on anyone.
Stern does a 'comedy' show. So while his sarcasm was a little harsh, I wish more people would give some 'tough love' and a little less Politically Correct pats on the back.
Howard Stern is the man. Not everyone has to like him. He makes a very valid point. Oprah lied to this poor girl, and she should lose some weight or she will probably end up dying. Thats howards style. He tells it like he is. Best radio show on the planet!!!!!
I don't like Stern at all. I think he's a douche for the most part. However the guy is honest and is intelligent and above all a realist. People can sugar coat the issue of this girl's image and weight all they want but the fact of the matter is that she's morbidly obese and has a vary high chance of death in the years to come. If she doesn't come to terms with this then it's bye bye to her movie career. She's an amazing actress and it would suck if she weren't able to perform. Besides Hollywood has its image of "beauty" and she doesn't fit that description unfortunately so if she wants to act it means she needs to slim down.
Howard Stern is a shock jock my friends and as such he cannot sugar coat anything he says. Love him or hate him it's this trait that has him banking millions. That said he is correct in his assessment – IT IS NOT HEALTHY TO BE 300+ POUNDS! It is also pure shenags when someone who has difficulty walking up a flight of stairs claims to be irreverently happy being obese (yes I'm talking to you too Monique!). This chic needs to take her money, hire a trainer and nutritionist and live to see 30!
I had to agree with Stern in something. When Oprah called her a Cinderella case, I thought: she might die young if she doesn't take care of herself. I heard her saying that she was ok with the way she was (good for her), but that doesn't make her healthy. She is going to have problems breathing if she has to do some action on the next movie. Also, everyday the media mentions somebody that got fat and now looks horrible, posting the worst pictures about that person. Usually when an actress gains weight, she doesn't do too many movies.
So... lets wait and see how many movies come on Precious way in the future.
Still waiting on someone to explain to me how his comments were racist....
Howard Stern is the man!!! Not everyone has to like him. He makes a very valid point. Oprah lied to this poor girl, and she should lose some weight or she will probably end up dying. Thats howards style. He tells it like he is. Best radio show on the planet!!!!!
Mr. Wong:
Please do not lump all morbidly obese people into an easy category. I am currently in this category and by no means am I a glutton, in fact the strict diet (which does require discipline) I am currently under through my Doctor, is working to reduce my weight to a healthier level. The actual pounds however is not what is to be measured. It is the Body Mass Index or BMI. This level as most reputable fitness magazine will attest to is the best way to ensure someone is in a healthy weight range. If this was not being used, all of your sports heroes would be considered obese, as well as the fitness models (both men and women) as the weight guides distributed by the US Government show a small weight range for "normal" and do not look at muscle mass. I can also tell you that I probably eat much less than you do as I do not snack between meals and currently have a calorie intake of 1400 calories a day with only 20 grams of fat allowed. Take a look at the labels on the foods you eat and see if you can make the same claim.
I believe Bibically the statement "Let he who lives without sin cast the first stone" applies here and certainly should in your case as you make a generalization which is not only unfair but rude.
minne said ...."She has more talent in her little finger than he has in his entire ugly body."
Well, her little finger is the SIZE of Howard body! Howard is right on with his comments. I've listened to Howard for many years. He is what he is and is making lots of money doing it. Minnie, the last acceptable prejudice isnt fat but calling people ugly. Shame on you!
Howard Ugly Stern is now, and always has been a bafoon. Legions of people, for some reason, find him entertaining. He is like a puppet on a Serius string. He has no talent to speak of, no personality that means much, and has certainly not stepped out of the pages of GQ at any time, nor will he. Gabby is big, and for reasons that SHE may choose, can change. She is young and has much to learn. I predict we will see her career blossom and do her well. She is bright, funny, and has a whole life ahead of her. I also predict she changes some lifestyle choices. All of this aside, Howard Stern is an ugly man, inside and out. THAT he cannot change. She can lose weight, he will always be ugly and despicable.
I think Howard Stern is a complete jerk but I have to agree with him on this. She will never be a great actress. Hollywood is fawning all over her but what other roles can she possibly play when she is that big?
She's a blimp!
yes it's harsh but Stern has a point. I don't always agree with Stern but he spoke an inconvenient truth here. She's morbidly obese.
while it may be partially "the truth", it was rude to say...at least in that way.
Why do so many people care what Howard says, It is a COMEDY SHOW, it might be true not true, rude, not rude, its a COMEDY SHOW. He loved the movie just made jokes because he is trying to get a laugh.
I don't know why Howard Stern chose to dive into this dialogue. He chose to personally attack someone who gave the world a brilliant performance - something that Howard Stern will never do. I am so glad that he is no longer on television - if you want to hear him you have to pay. My guess is that less people are listening to his garbage these days and he is getting less expsoure. Probably why he chose to enter into this dialogue. Some day Howard Stern will pay for his mean, rude, obnoxious behavior and comments.
She already has a contract to work on another movie, so suck it Stern jerk.
Love him or hate him the man is right.
Karen I agreed with you. Just because he is thin don't make everyone want the wind to blow them away. Honey take a look in the mirror and what do you see. A Ghost who wants to be beautiful.
He's mean but he's right. Anyone who thinks the star of Precious really has a career after this is insane. Hollywood doesn't have constant roles for Ginormous Women. And most importantly she's not going to live long in that condition. Sidibe should staple her stomach or get the lapband do anything other than stay at that weight.
I think we are focusing on the wrong thing in all that posted commentary – don't shoot the messenger. While I am not a "following fan" of H. Stern, I do appreciate his willingness to push the envelope and state the facts. The nominee is too big and Hollywood tends to focus on those who weight less – let's get real and to make her think that she has an aspiring career is a mistake. At this point, it is a health issue and she needs to focus on her health. Where is her mother and father? What about her friends? I am not happy with the delivery of H. Stern's message, but it needed to be said...in fact, he only articulated what we've been thinking before the Oscars, during the Oscars, and after.
why everyone on howard stern, she is fat shes freaking huge, she needs to work on her diet, she can die within 2 years from a heart attack if she stays the same or get fatter, all of a sudden you can be called fat and its offensive? she only got that role because shes fat!!!!! Its true she might not be in another film unless they need a role for a huge person, quit being so uptight, i like how these FAT people have to choose sides lol the unhealthy side.
Interesting how people somehow see Stern as God, with the ability to predict another human being's future...
Stern's silly, attention-hungry antics aside, he cannot predict the future of Sidibe's acting career. In fact, she's already been tapped to co-star in a TV show on Showtime...so already Stern's foolishness is becoming exposed for what it is...
@Ina,..your example of Monique is dead on!
As for stern's fake concern for her weight...it's the spirit behind what he said that reveals his diseased soul. Facts can be stated for many different purposes. His purpose was not to benefit her health, but to mock and denigrate her.
My prayer is that Sidibe subscribes to God's definition of beauty and His alone.
How easy it is to hide behind the internet and critize. I'm guessing a bunch of these posts are being written by beautify queens and fitness champions.
Stern concerned about her health? B.S. Stern is concerned about ratings and notoriety. Did anybody actually ask his opinion of her?
Does it make him and other posters feel better about themselves to bash somebody they don't even know? How can anybody say she won't get any other movies roles? Plenty of actors have had roles written specifically for them-regardless of their looks. Speaking of which, Stern isn't exactly a picture of health.
Dom Delouise worked for YEARS!!!! Even after Brando became the size of a small car, he got work. Drew Carey doesn't seem to be hurting for work. Oprah is gainfully employed as is Aretha Franklin
I'd venture to say more 'young skinny' people die from smoking, drinking, &/or drugs than obesity. There are probably more young skinny sick people than anybody wants to admit.
Sadly, I thought the same thing Stern did. Hollywood is just lying to that woman by pretending to suggest she has an acting future in movies. It's more than cruel, it's villainous.
Howard you may be right about her weight but you could have been a
little nicer .Yes i agree she should lose weight but that up to her.Stop
judging people you not perfect yourself, please look in the mirror that
all i have to say.
This coming from a disgusting man who looks like a retarded billy goat.....
I disagree with Howard and everyone saying there are no roles for her. I heard they are remaking the Speed movies and they are looking for well known actors/actresses. Hey thats it she could play the bus!!!!!! or maybe if shes lucky the entire freeway!
Look, Oprah, Monique and Queen Latifah are very talented and they are HEAVY. So what? They can find roles and other stuff to do. If he is concerned about her weight he should tell HER, not humilliate her in his program. Remember Stern:what goes around comes around. Someday you will be very humilliated and you will know how it feels to be in the other side. I will be smiling that day...
Gabourey is fat; Stern is ugly. Gabourey can lose weight, but Stern will always be ugly - inside and out.
Right they are fat not morbidly obese!
I wonder if they will feature her in the "In Memoriam" segment when she dies in a few years?
These remarks seem fairly tame by Stern's standards.
They will feature Blue before they feature her. We will miss ya Blue (not the dog)
It's true. She is Huuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuge!
So, Stern points out something that is true and all you people have to do is insult him? Well, you've just about fallen to "his level" haven't you? I personally agree with him, she is WAY over weight and glorification of a person of such a size certainly isn't healthy for society. "Hey everyone! There is nothing wrong with being morbidly obese! Hooray!" This is bad, mmmmmk.
I dunno, there could be a 'that's my momma' movie in the future.
Yes, she may be overweight and it's not healthy for her, BUT, if you look at pictures of her before the awards show, and look at her now, she has lost some weight...More than likely she had to gain alot of weight for that particular role...I noticed she has lost a considerable amount of weight when she appeared on the NAACP awards a few weeks back...Trust me, SHE will work again in Hollywood!
pardon me, A "What's happening" movie could be in the works, too.
That is insulting to football players and planets everywhere!!!!! By the paco she couldn't play the bus.... her ankles would snap if she were to run more than 3 mph. And its not like they could put her on a rascal unless of course they were pulling it with 4 bulldozer, 20 strongmen, 2 747s, and everyone that show precious. But they could remake weekends at berneys when she dies in a few years. They could have her being supported by whales. Shazam!
Stopjocknmyswag: Dom Deluise, Marlon Brando and Drew Carey? How can you compare the acting success of obese Caucasian men to Gabourey? That's worse than apples to oranges – you know television shows from the Honeymooners to the King of Queens promote that it's acceptable for a Caucasian man to be fat, and he can still pull a slim, beautiful wife. Be honest Camille: Oprah, Monique, and Latifah are major exceptions to the rule. Speaking as a Black woman, I'll put it out there and say honestly that Gabourey's challenge is greater than those three women (and Aretha) because her skin is darker. Painful or not, I'd rather she hear the negative while she's young, so she can take the steps necessary to live long.
Howard Stern – I don't look or listen at anything this glamour louser produce. Howard Sterns glory days are forever gone. Please realize out there that you don't have a be a comedian and arabesque size to be an accomplish actor. You don't have to be a no talent Jennifer Aniston any more to stay on the front page of any magazine. You don't have to be a SIZE ZERO to achieve a grammy, emmy or OSCAR any more. Diversity has also come to weight and height. Get over yourself Stern. This the 21st Century and global warming is not all you have to wake up to everyday. Ms. Silbe was glamourous, loving and talented and Oprah did not lie. Ms. Silbe will be around when you are no longer an ICON or are you still an ICON! That's to be seen!
You know, it stinks in Hollywood that if you're not a size 2 or less you're considered too fat. I agree that she should start taking care of herself for health reasons so maybe parts can come to her easier and quicker. But you don't need to be a size 0 to be a role model. She may be a beautiful person inside because she surely is one on the outside. Who are we to judge? As far as Howard Stern goes-he's just a pig!!
I find it funny how people are making remarks about Howard's looks and then defending Gabourey Sidibe weight.
Howard stated he was worried about her Health and she needs to think about how she is going to continue her life. I mean she mentioned in a interview she was going to get alot of fast food after the interview is over.
If Gabourey Sidibe was a drug addict or drunk and she made jokes about getting high or drinking still she passes out wouldn't you be concerned about her?
She can lose weight, but he can't gain brains!
You are wrong on so many levels what makes you think that you can just unleash on someone and it's okay??? Besides have you taken a close look at yourself ? you may be thin but !!!your far from handsome.In fact you look as if your in the finale stages of AIDS so maybe you should go and have yourself checked .
Stern is a mean & nasty man. Must be related to Limbaugh. I would listen to either of them if they paid me.
I've never been able to stand Howard Stern b/c he's rude, crude and over the top. But I have to admit that what he said is completely true. I thought the same thing he did when Oprah said what she said. I thought, is she for freakin' real, what a complete lie. There just aren't parts for a woman that size. For god's sake, look how long it took for Halle Berry to get real parts, and she's drop dead gorgeous with an enormous amount of talent. Even after winning the Oscar – how many hit movies has she been in since then? It's hard enough for any African woman to get good parts in Hollywood, let alone one as morbidly obese as Sidibe.
This is just more proof that a large percentage of Americans are just fine with hating people because they are fat. They believe no "fat" person can ever "really" be successful. Stern and many commenters here believe that Gabourey Sidibie not only will never be heard of again but should never be heard of again. Roseanne got a damn long running TV series even though she was heavy. Why? Because talent typically outs. This woman had enough talent to get an Academy Award nomination, why must she be limited by Mr. Stern's prejudices or by the prejudices I read in these comments? Given the hate I'm reading here and the hate I read when Kevin Smith & the other passenger Natali were treated so rudely by Southwest, you'd think all of America was svelte and not growing fatter each year.
Actually, Howard may be wrong. Think of it this way. How many skinny talented actresses are in Hollywood? Yea...a lot. Let's face it she'll never be 105 pounds, but there are roles for women of her size, and she will be at the top of the list for those roles with a lot less competition.
Howard needs to look in the mirror. Perhaps someone in his close circle who has the balls to do so should tell Howard that his stringy, long hair went out with big haired rock bands in the late 80's. He should get it cut, but that would only bring more attention to his enormously long, horse face.
Right, because there are no large black women in entertainment. So Oprah, Queen Latifa, and Mo'nique are all figments of our imaginations?
Stern is a very "UNattractive" man; his hair has no style, his face is not pleasant to look at; his nose is four times two big, and his mouth even bigger. Leading to an ego that is so large, but with nothing of substance to back it up. Money? well money cannot buy you a moral personality or true friends. But it can give you a fals sense of reality. His tactics area rude crude and unacceptable. He believes Money makes the man– well there has to be some sort of true substance; and with him it just MUCK!!
The chick is fricken HUGE. Whoever created us as species did not have this in mind. She needs to get on a treadmill and diet like the rest of us. Seriously it was fine for the role but now thats over get with it!! get the stomach stapled or something along those lines. its not healthy or correct to be this BIG. Stern is only telling the truth here.
Yes, Howard Stern is mean spirited and harsh with his comments, but he is so true. The real sad part about this is that no one who knows her and loves her has taught her how to take care of her health. She obviously has eating issues, where was the mother when she was eating so poorly or a friend to encourage exercise? Howard might have done her a huge favor by calling her out on her size like this. I like her, I think she is talented, but I can't stand to see her on magazines or on TV because of her size. My daughter wanted the new Ebony magazine she was on, but I said "no" because of her size, just like I have said "no" because of anorexic models on other magazines, it portrays poor body image and unhealthy lifestyles, obese or thin. I can care less what roles she wants in Hollywood or anywhere else, my problem is that she throws this BS out there about loving her size and so on. That's great for her, but when you are being looked up to by girls and women, you need to be accountable for your health and the impression it gives. Why be proud that the chances of you living into your 30's is nonexistent unless you lose weight? Why be proud that you are prone to diabetes, heart attack, stroke, and so much more? I wish her all the success in the world and pray that she is on Earth long enough to enjoy it.
Yeah well she's fat and you're ugly...but she can diet.
I have a question....why is it anyone's business, especially Stern's? Everyone should butt out of other people's lives (unless specifically invited) and focus on their own crap...'cause we've all got plenty.
I heard something interesting the other day..
When someone takes out a cigarette to smoke, many times people will say "you're an idiot, you are killing yourself" or something along those lines to point out that what they are doing is dumb
But yet if we saw an obsese person eating a hamburger, we would not say the same thing. And why not, this person is killing themselves
as well.
We need to stop being PC and stop advertising fast food to child (like we did cigarettes) and treat this like the epidemic it is.
Howard Stern is one of the most intelligent men in the world. He's so far ahead of most, the majority of people don't even understand him or why he does things. He's a strong force for good in the world, trying to break down barriers and show lies and nonsense for what they are. The first step to fixing something is recognizing there is a problem. No one else seemed to notice there was a problem. Thank you Howard for taking the first, perhaps most bold, step. If she listens, she may owe you her life.
After I wrote my comment above, the obvious dawned on me: Howard Stern is WHO he is only at the expense of others. And his most ardent fans are those who totally embrace tearing others down in order to feel better about themselves. The only difference between Howard being negative and his fans is that he gets paid Millions of $ to daily feed his negativos and they just get to continue on in their daily lives being negative. This is surely an exception to the rule of two negatives = a positive.
C'mon people...this is Howard. This is what he does. I mean...let's take a few steps back in history and remember some of Howard's greatest hits....
1. Wishing the head of the FCC get cancer and die...and even praying to God that it would happen.
2. Saying after the death of Selena that he wanted to have sex with her dead body.
3. Now this comment about Gaborey (however you spell her name).
The one thing about Howard compared to other jocks like Imus and the Greaseman...is that Howard will stand by his comments...he won't apologize about anything he says on the air.
Only problem is that Oprah decided to stick her nose in Howard's business...and she was blasted by Howard as well.
But give me a break people...Howard has been doing this type of radio for almost 40 years...should any of this shock us now?
Well, thank goodness Howard is on the radio so we don't have to see his hideous face!
He may have been insensitive but he was telling the truth. Why are so many people dancing around reality? Take a look at the pictures. Also, why don't we use truthful words such as gluttony and obesity? Are they not politically correct?
Howard rocks. He speaks the truth that everyone else is thinking but is afraid to say. And he'll be the first one to agree with those of you who say he's unattractive. For someone who has "no talent" and is "no longer relevant" he sure has sparked a whole lot of emotion here! There's a reason he has 30 million Sirius listeners.
Ever wonder what gives a person low self esteem well not being accepted for who they are is a start . Many of you say how talented she is but then say but she needs to unload 100 pounds. It is a shame that many of you seem to think that your comments are concern for her health when you are just as guilty as Howard Stern! You all are pointing a finger at her telling her how to fix herself! She needs to lose weight if she desires it . it is part of who she is. Just like those of you who are skinny and chose it are skinny! Just like those of you who smoke smoke and those you drink drink. Just because you say she needs to get healthy and drop some weight doesnt mean you are being kind it means you are not accepting her for who she is and you are doing what people have done for years. Trying to fix a fat person. A fat person has to have resolve and fix themselves and kind bullying doesnt work just like mean bullying doesnt work. People wake up! We all have an achillies tendon. Rave about her talent say a little prayer for her under your breath because you care but dont point a finger folks! It is ugly no matter how you say it!
Beth is a top model and married Howard because of his looks and personality. Oprah isn't the only blowing smoke.
Were this a person addicted to alcohol instead of food, we'd be celebrating her drunkeness and telling her she has a career going forward playing drunks? You don't get this large due to bad genes. This is a food addict. Obesity is a killer, and our nation, with its plentiful, cheap food, is one of the worst places to live if you have a food addiction. Howard, crass and inelegant as always, is right. You don't see any really old really fat people. And Oprah, of all people, with her legendary battles with food should be the most aware of this.
He's hilarious, nobody should get butt-hurt by this. He makes a lot of money saying what he thinks, and it his right to do so. If anything people should be mad he has such a huge following, it means people agree.
This is a lovely, lovely young woman. Americans are so blinded by television and movies and magazines telling us that all women must be blonde or White or a size 4. This happens to be a very pretty 26 year old articulate young African American woman who happens to be larger than some other people. So what? There are plenty of roles for her. For you folks writing from corners of the world who know nothing of Hollywood, here's the rub: studio libraries are filled with scripts that are waiting for certain personalities and talents. This lady has proven her mettle. Who the hell cares how much she weighs and why is it any of your business or that moron, Howard STern's business? His thing is to say something deroggatory about the person who gets the most press at the moment to keep the silly people who continue giving him attention talking. A couple of weeks ago, he was attacking Ellen DeGeneres. At the end of the day, perhaps we could do better and simply applaud people who are comfortable with themselves. I'm sure some of your posts calling this young person "fat" or "ugly" isn't the first time she's heard it, and I'm quite sure it won't be the last, however, it seems she's getting the last laugh. She was nominated for an Academy Award. She was there. And if she doesn't do anything ever again, this happened in her life and she should be proud.
The life expectancy of morbidly obese people is HALF the typical life expectancy. Sadly, Stern will outlive Sidibe.
I have to agree that though Stern's choice of words may not be pretty, he actually has a good point. This actress could have the workings to make a wonderful career but it'll be a short one if she doesn't work on getting as healthy as she can. It doesn't mean she needs to be a size zero but healthy. You can still have meat on your bones and be healthy and that is all he's saying.
I am sickened and some of the comments I am reading here. I have truly realized how ignorant some of my fellow Americans are. Gabourey has already been cast in two new movies ("more roles"), If Oprah says that she will have more roles then she will...Oprah makes her own movies and is very well connected...Oprah, Monique(oscar winner), Queen Latifah(oscar winner) and last but not least ROBIN QUIVERS OF THE HOWARD STERN SHOW, have all had weight issues...as you see by Ms. O's bank book, she became a billionaire...yep, fat and all! Monique and Queen, extremely successful...and o yeah..um I cant really say successful for you ROBIN QUIVERS unless I am referencing the gastric bypass surgery that you had. The tragic but true thing is all of america...there have been a number of suicides within the last few months with hollywood actors...not overweight! Maybe these people needed to turn to food for comfort..then they would not be dead today! Now that's honest but TRUE!
hey mer, if u don't consider stern to be relevant with his 19 million sirius xm subscribers thenn maybe u should stay out of the conversation. Bottom line, like most americans, especially black females, gabourey is extremely over weight and will have health problems if she doesn't do something about it, instead of being angry at stern for his comments, maybe all you retards that seem so upset should be honest about gabourey and people like her so they can get help b4 they drop dead..
Is Howard Stern an Ass, Yes most definitely. Does the star of "Precious" have an weight issue Yes, but that doesn't give him or anyone the right to take away from her moment. Just because a person is on the plus size doesn't mean their life is meaningless or they don't belong in the midst of American societal "norms". She's a beautiful girl and what God has in store for her no man can take away. Some of the people in this world are so hung up on what doesn't matter "looks". As for Howard, has he looked in the mirror lately, before you judge someone look in your own yard first. I find that people like Stern, only put others down because, they are empty inside and are not happy with who they are.
Anyone who is overweight should check out their options for slimming down. To stay healthy and fit is a priority. Many people do not realize it is due to a thyroid problem and many times not even the standard blood test indicates it. They should see an endrocrinologist for further testing. I did, and once I was placed on the right meds, the weight fell off. I"m happier, fit, slim and so happy that I can once again run and play with my family. Ok..now that the health tip is over.....Howard Stern is rude and what he said was blatantely cruel. The man obviously has no filter on his mouth, but he is one to talk – his career is in the toilet and oh my god – get a frickin hair cut.
I'm overweight and I know from experience it is not healthy or cute to be fat. I love myself and I have a great life, however I have made a conscious decision to do something about my weight. There is no way in hell that girl is as happy as she claims to be. Stress(my case), depressions, low self esteem or abuse of somekind are ALWAYS the case in adult obesity. This girl needs a wake up call and people need to stop lying to her and help her with what ever the issue is. And find out why she cant put a downa fork. I say this with compassion. It aint cute. Ask any fat person behind closed doors would they rather be fat or at a healthy weight and they will all say healthy weight, except for those in denial.
hey karen, you are THE ASS, keep on pretending like this girl insn't unhealthly, she needs help. you are part of the problem for people like Gabourey, you are dishonest and disgusting, you need to tell her the truth even if it hurts...............
Whether he is right or wrong I could truly care less. Whether or not she'll get another job... she already has. Whether or not the business is tough on any color woman over a size 2, we all know the answer to this. What I don't understand is why she should be ashame of herself. Not everyone on this planet is supposed to be a pixie stick. Maybe it is unhealthy, but what isn't unhealthy is being comfortable in your own skin, which some of us thin people don't even know how to do. And yes before those of you who have nothing better to do start with the nonsense, I am a size 3 AA female. And maybe, just maybe, if we stop treating people who are overweight like crap it may turn into something that helps them understand that perhaps their wieght is not healthy. And maybe, just maybe Gabby, big though she may be, is not unhealthy at all. I doubt that any of you know her, and neither do I, but please just let her enjoy this time and stop raining on her parade.
I think Stern meant well. He could have said it in a better way. He was right when he said they would never put her in any other movies. They wont unless Eddie Murphy makes another Klumps movie. Only Tyler Perry of Oprah would cast her in a role showing her talent because she is a great actress. Everyone else would put her in a stereotypical type movies where she is over eating and passing gas and no one wants her around. So Stern was right about that part. Everything else is just him being his self. I hope he never changes.
hey tim.... Stern = Loser= 100 million dollars per year contract and a model wife. Not bad for a loser, but im sure you make more.. stern is right, the girl is obese and needs help.......
Howard is telling it how it is. She is too fat and unhealthy, she is going to have medical issues that us taxpayers and insurance companies are going to have to pay for.
THOSE OF YOU SAYING HOWARD STERN IS UGLY KEEP IN MIND YOU ARE SINKING TO HIS LEVEL BY INSULTING SOMEONE ELSE. However Stern cant help being ugly, he is in good shape and takes care of himself. She is fat by choice eating all that crap food, the insults about her are well earned. If you insulted stern consider yourself worse than Howard Stern.
Keep the peace!
J
I do NOT like Howard Stern – refuse to listen to him – he is a rude and unfeeling man. I do understand the health concerns – there's a way to address that with respect. She if a confident young lady and should be applauded for not letting anything or anyone hold her back.
Ok...so Howard ticked a bunch of people off. Lets remember folks this is how he makes his living, and obviously he has done very well. I have listened to his show and while most of it is really crass, he does make some good points, however harsh they may be. This movie was specifically about an overweight girl/woman, therefore the actress was well picked and did a very good job. And as shallow as it is, Hollywood is just that. Unless a part is written specifically for this young woman, her career is over. Which in and of itself is sad, as she appears to be very talented.
Howard basically said what everyone else is afraid to say. However rude he is, it is the truth. There is a weight issue and she does need to take a good look at her life over the next few years; medically speaking (high blood pressure, diabetes, heart prolems...etc.) As for Howard picking on an "easy target", anyone who has listened to him knows that anyone and everyone is a potential target.
As for Oprah, she is not one of my favorite people anyway, so anything she says or does I disregard.
Stern is right on the money with this one. Yeah sometimes the tuth hurts but the truth may just save her life
If Howard Stern got this far with that face, then Gabourey should have not problems regarding her weight. Please thank Howard Gab for paving the way for all the fuglies in this world...
Look at the response he gets. I love his show and he speaks the truth but you people that hate him give him exaclty whayt he wants when you all respond like this. It is so hysterical how he can control this type of reaction. If she walked into the studio with him he would tell her what he thought in the way only he can and I bet she would end up loving him by the end of the interview. He is off puttingly charming.
you guys are funny
hello hehehee, its not about her talent, its her health. By the way Elvis and Dom both died before their time , you could have at least used better references........... Gabourey is unhealthly, stop being dishonest about her.......
Howard Stern makes controversial remarks? What next, a news article about how the sky was blue today?
The important question here is: Why does he care? Does her life affect his? He's dealing with something that really isn't any of his concern.
Who is Howard Stern? I have never heard of him.
Does it really matter about her weight. Who cares! im sure she quite aware. Every actor or actress began in a first movie. It called the beginning people and who is Howard Stern to have an opinion on something he knows nothing about. He knows nothing about the Oscars or acting. First he lashed out at Ellen and now this young girl. The guy is just hideous, i can believe people listen to his his penis looking ass.
All you people who say he is an ass are stupid. Stern speaks his mind... it's called FREEDOM OF SPEECH.
He's 100% correct. How many movies are based on an extremely large person? NOT MANY, typically movies are cast by fit individuals. Plus, her heart is screaming for help... Stern heard it and verbalized it. He's doing her a favor!
I have been a Stern fan for many years and can always depend on him to give his honest opinion on any subject whether I agree with it our not. Obesity is a huge problem in the US, it wastes millions of healthcare dollars and I found nothing inappropriate with his comments.
He is very funny, everyone even Black people are thinking what he said, and everyome know that this poor girl needs to lose weight, because what type of a life or career will she have moving forward?
She's morbidly obese. At that size, she's not going to get another role outside of one of the 5 movies Tyler Perry puts out in a year. Could she make a career out of Tyler Perry movies? Of course, he has. But what kind of roles will she get? Regardless of whether or not she gets more roles, she's a prime candidate for a heart attack, stroke, diabetes, high blood pressure, knee/hip replacement surgery, etc.
Is she a good actress? I have no idea, I didn't want and have not seen Precious, that's not the point. Let's presume that she is. For that role, she needed to be that size. But how many movies do you honestly think will actually be made and distributed about a morbidly obese Black woman? Unless Norbit 2 comes out, I'm guessing none.
If she is to have a long, diverse career (not just playing a downtrodden, morbidly obese Black woman) she needs to lose the weight.
Just because the truth hurts, doesn't make it not true.
Stern's method is EXACTLY what she needs to strike home that she MUST lose the weight .....or.....she........will.......die.
I thought he got canceled years ago. What a jackass he is.
Another old white man who makes alot of money and looks like the Grimm Reaper talking about another black woman! Good thing Sidibe has really thick skin to deal with his sad comments! Stay talking about the white women, we black women enjoy not being noticed.
Howard Stern is hardly one to judge anyone by their looks. He is one of the ugliest people I have ever seen. A lot of men get better looking as they get older but not Howard. He's scarey ugly. The only reason his wife married him is for his money and it's time this piece of garbage realized that.
Gabby Sidibe's spirituality cannot be understood by a man like Stern. Unfortunately, Howard Stern is so spiritually bereft that he will never know that Gabby Sidibe could not have made this movie had she not been who she is. The character is overweight, probably because of her father's repeated raping her as a child–many children gain weight to keep abusive men away from them. I cannot believe that Stern is concerned about Sidibe's health. He is making a statement to make money on his radio show.
Karen, I'm with you.
Howard Stern's spirituality could be put into Thumbelina's thimble.
Why is it okay for people to call out an Actor for Drinking too much but not eating too much. If George Cloney showed up smashed and got called out, no one would have a problem with it.
Hollywood is a nasty, caustic, unforgiving industry. This isn't the first nor will it be the last time Sidibe is criticized for her appearance by Stern or anyone else. People forget that Hollywood is not some corporate 9 to 5 accounts receivable office, where Stern could be fired or slapped with a harassment suit for saying these "mean" things to a colleague. Being told to lose weight or change your appearance is par for the course here, and the way Stern voiced his opinion is actually quite tame compared to how many agents, managers, or casting directors would have phrased it. I won't take anything away from Sidibe – god bless her, because the great thing about the industry is that ANYBODY can make it, they just have to trudge through the endless line of people who tell them they can't for whatever reason. But admittedly, the odds of her ever achieving success on this level again are slim to nonexistent. Oprah may be right – Sidibe may have a long career ahead of her – but it will most definitely be in projects that Oprah herself or Tyler Perry have a direct hand in producing, and not much else.
This talented actress can lose the weight anytime if she wishes.
Stern however will ALWAYS be ugly, inside and out.
It's tough for most of Americans to hear things like this, because everything is OK, everybody is doing well, just look around you are wrong...People here(in America) are not saying what they think,because it's unacceptable, Stern can so he does....
I am a woman and by Howard Stern's standards very overweight....however, I'm a long time fan of his. The man coined the term "shock jock" and to this day the core of his commentary is for shock value. It's kinda sad that he is the only one with the nerve to say what he did. Had Oprah or Ellen or Barbara Walter's said the same, there would be an outpouring of support for them and for Gabby to lose the weight and become the star she should. But because it came from the man everyone loves to hate and who is the easiest target of all...his brutally honest words are falling on deaf ears.
Sorry, Howard, you are wrong on this one. There is at least one more role she could play at this weight. She could play Oprah in her biography.
Did most of you just get hip to Howard Stern? This is what he does. He makes good money doing it. Why get all heated, he says shocking things to make a living. Was what he said wrong. Not as far as I can see. Hollywood is 98% glamor, 2% substance. Glamorous black women dont get parts in Hollywood, how far is this broad gonna go? Could he have said it better or nicer yeah, but thats not how he makes his money.
I don't see how anyone can disagree with Stern. She's dangerously overweight. I find it irresponsible for those around her to just play it off like she's beautiful – i mean she seems nice – but she could lose 100 pounds and still be fat...
Hey all of your truth speakers, Gabby just got another job in front on TV so now what do you have to say???? I say you shut up...how do you like that. Howard looks like the rear of a horse. If he had no money he would be lonely for life and we all know that too.
I love all the so-called Stern haters who made it a point to read this article about him and take the time to comment. Why do they follow him then? Clearly closet fans afraid of being politically incorrect. They are suce hypocrites – and yes – he comments on fat men and fat white women too! He just says what the rest of us think. Oprah was luck – not talent! So there!
Jeff's right – and Howards right – she needs to lose the weight, if its weight she gained for the role – time to shave it off. Otherwise, she and Kevin Smith will have to start chartering planes together
All the other actors, big men and big women, have either lost weight – Kevin James did lose weight – or are dead – Dom Delouise – Marlon Brando. The truth is the truth. She is morbidly obese. Oprah and Monique would not qualify in that category and are curiously continuing to lose weight for their health. It is sad because you can tell she is totally fine with her stature and being fed the garbage lines about her talent. She will continue to be typecast just as Dom Delouise and other actors before her were and will have little chance to be a versitile actress like Queen Latifah who by the way also lost weight for her health.
Howard Stern needs to shut up and go to hell. If losing weight was so easy I'm sure Gabby would not even be the topic of this discussion. What makes Gaby beautiful is what is on the inside of her not becuase she's thin. Howard is skinny as a stick and is ugly as hell because he is ugly on the inside. How dare him. If it wasn't for his money and all the plastic surgery and make up he can afford there is no telling what him and that wife of his would look like. I bet they are ugly as hell. Now his wife didn't make the comment, but she goes down with him cause she married that loser. What a douche lord! To beautiful Gabby: Keep doing your thing and shake all the haters off. You are beautiful no matter what size you are.
doug you think Gabby is going ot pay attention to what this inconsiderate pig says. Yah I don't think the words of Stern the pig will inspire her to lose weight.
Maybe he can inspire one of the women he constantly demeans on his show. Ugly PIG get a face transplant.
He is useless and losing his audience over the years. She will be seen on Showtime by more people than have ever listened to him on one day. He is insignificant. Only way he can get attention is act like a pig and insult someone. Look in the mirror and insult yourself. Uselss human being..
She could be in Norbit 2 so Eddie Murphy wouldn't have to get into the fat suit. Howard is right she needs to lose weight or deal with health problems. Personally I don't listen to Howard. I got enough of people like him in high school. She probably does not have a career in showbiz.
This article really shows the media’s propensity to believe that Stern will still somehow evolve into a more mainstream, yet edgy, satirist, like Simon Crowell or Andy Rooney. Gabourey Sidibe is America’s new Sweet Heart – who cares? She is really just experiencing 15 minutes of freakish fame and that’s all.
I'm not a raving Stern fan, but he's 100% right. Political correctness is killing this country.
I thought howard stern had died years ago. he certainly became irrelevant years ago. I hope Ms Sidibe's response to this will be as follows: "howard who? robin who?" I wish that had been CNN's response as well.
Hey Howard Stern. Why don't you take some of the overpaid millions you've earned and buy a new face? Let's face it. You're no Pitt, Cruise, Butler, etc. You've made enough to have an overhaul. Jerk
Howard Stern may not say what everyone thinks but he does say exactly what he thinks and he gets paid a lot of money because clearly, people like to listen to him and admire the fact that he does just that. You can like it or you don't have to but the bottom line is that Gabby Sidibe needs to lose about 100 lbs immediately – not so that she looks like a Hollywood prototype but so that she looks like someone that will live past the age of 35.
I agree–she is very big, but she is also very quick. I was talking to her once, and I turned my head for just a second-and dammit if she didnt steal my ham sandwich.
Why do people even listen to the likes of Stern and Limbaugh? Why, it's because they agree, that's why. Though not me. Birds of a feather...
Since when did it take balls to shoot fish in a barrel? I used to admire Howard's wit, but anymore he has the sophomoric humor of a 3rd grader. Sad – for him and for the targets of his "wit."
meb
The TRUTH is the TRUTH, people. I hate phonies who say what they WANT to believe and want others to believe. Why do you hate Stern?
I'd bet over 70% of those who say they hate him have NEVER listened to his show!
Yea....and Mo nique is thin? The only roles out there are for abusive fat black women.
As usual: Howard is crass but correct.
Sterns comments were not politically correct, he was just being mean and vicious because people will listen. If his first concern was for her health then he would have lead with that and geared his comments in that direction. He said what would get the most press and it worked. If Gabby is not your cup of tea then fine, but it does no one a service to be vicious because you think that you are being politically correct when you are actuall just being vicious.
What an a-hole
This is why he is called the "Shockjock' because he says what ever he thinks. It is the same with Ann Coulter, Michael Moore and others who like to provoke. It gets them attention, they get free air time and it makes them money and lots of it.
I just take what they say with grain of salt, they are just entertainers.
She's the size of a small hippo. Not many Hollywood roles call for that. Stern sounded like a jerk (Duh, he's Howard Stern) but he pretty much called it.
He has dirty teeth.
What movie is she going to be in? How about Gabourey Suffocates Stern. Opps she fell again.
Hey Howard Stern, ya should have been in the car with Kennedy!
No matter how much truth he may have been telling, Howard Stern could give less than two coppers about Gabourey Sidibe's health, much like the rest of people that make that comment. It's just something people can say so that they don't sound nasty when being critical.
Whatever your condition or habit, it's live or let live, unless you have HIV/AIDS, or you're fat. Then, it's your fault, and open season on you.
Stern is right. He's just saying what everyone is thinking but doesn't have the guts to say. She really needs to cut down on the twinkies...... but she is human and she has feelings. but she should really loose some weight because this is not only a beauty problem but is also a health issue.
Gabourey takes craps that are larger than Howard's head the morning after chili night. That's healthy, not to mention more attractive and better smelling Howard Stern's real head.
if any of you actually listened to howard stern instead of just reading articles twisted by the media, this wouldn't be a controversy. this article is an example of why i done with cnn. no better then fox news...
Stern you need to look in the mirror and change that haircut looking
like you are the wife of your marriage. lol Get a life u smuck
Thin people ALWAYS think that it's a matter of 'letting' oneself go. You have No idea, unless you've been that heavy, what that person is going through and has gone through. She said it herself, she was always called 'fat girl'. And then to add that she will have health problems is just as ignorant. Just shut up and let people think you're a nice person and stop trying to do other people any favors, because you don't.
There's a reason the guy's on satellite radio, so you have to PAY to hear him.
He's completely right in what he said, people in this country just aren't used to someone saying exactly what everyone's thinking.
Could have been a little more discerning with his choice of words but hey, men and women have DIED for his right to say what he did, and I'l back that 100%
Free speech, way to be Howard.
Howard Stern said it how it is and it is his show so why wouldn't he talk about it? There is a difference between being overweight, fat, and obese. In her case it would be SEVERE obesity. I sure as hell do not want to see her in a dress again. I was overweight by 60 pounds and my health was in danger by many different things, and I lost it all and at my ideal weight and have kept it off for years. That girl needs help if she doesn't think that how she looks is appealing or healthy. There needs to be a medium for these stars, not obese or anorexic but how about the ideal weight for your height, age and body type? Now she has money for a personal trainer-go be the next jared.
If she were a man would her appearance be an issue? What qualifies Stern to make this assessment of a young woman's career? There are successful actors in all shapes and sizes, dumbass. And her health is no one's business but her own.
Who has the right to say what a "healthy life" is or entails? It is the government, insurance agencies, doctor associations/societies that are funded through interest groups promoting their own agenda ? Yes, Sidibe is a "big" girl, but at the end of the day is she happy? Is she living a full life? Those should be the questions...if it were any of our business.
and Stern never said anything about him being attractive, hell he probably knows he's ugly-but he wasn't comparing himself to anyone and if anyone asked-he'd probably make fun of his looks
Howard Stern, 'shock jock' has a way of putting things. Doesn't mean its not true. I thought the same thing: We'll never see that woman in another film unless she's playing a sofa.
I saw 'Precious'. Acting angry is not a difficult thing to do. Scowling is not hard to do either, especially if you weigh 450 lbs either...in fact, it just happens.
And, finally, its unfortunate that the ONE time she was on the red carpet, she looked over at a "fellow actor" (my words) and said "I'd hit that" and then repeated it to him in front of everyone. So so tacky.
all in all I would rather listen to Kim Jong-Il than the juvenile rants of the always-irrelevant Stern.
Stern,
I have watched you degrade and humiliate women for your own financial gain for years. You are no prize yourself. At least she has talent and doesn't use stupid, vapid women for financial gain. Have always thought you were an ignorant piece of shitl Get over yourself
While it true that she is big, she can lose the weight, but Stern can't lose his ugliness. This idiot has the face only a Radio Mother could love. So you know women hang around him for only one reason.... Money.
Howard.. Go look in the mirrow and then go to the dentist and invest in a little teeth whitening for those horse teeth of yours...But first pull Robin nose out your A$$ so she can look in the mirror at herself.. Who told the two of you that you have the right to comment on how someone looks when the two of you look like 10 miles of a bad highway...SHUT-UP
HS's comments made me laughed until I cried! On a serious note, I hope this young woman listens to Howard. She is super morbidly obese and her life is in danger. Perhaps, Oprah can use some of her humanitarian zest to get her into rehab?
What else would you expect from him.....and hey he is only saying what a lot of people were probably thinking.
Hey, dum dum Howard...you've had a long time "career" with exactly Z E R O talent and look like a trash can overflowing with black weeds ....why can't a very large women with a beautiful smile , talent and inteligence work at what she's good at?!
one thing to remember–the young lady can loose weight-but stern can do nothing about being ulgy.
yes i guess he could have a face lift-but i do not think there is enough lift to make stern's face acceptable in public–
For those of you mocking Howard's looks you obviously don't listen to the show... he would be the first to admit that he's not attractive.
Regarding her weight, It's about time someone is honest in show biz. It's just not healthy
Stern – I wouldn't talk. You are one ugly MF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hey, Howard, take a long look into the mirror and tell us what you see – puke!!
For all of the bigots on this board, and Howard Stinch..uh, I mean Stern, who say Gabourey will never work in Hollywood again, well guess what? She just landed a recurring role on a new Showtime Series premiering in May called "The Big C". (And her Oscar isn't even cold yet, lol) Didn't take long for her to prove all of you bastards wrong.
You know some of the same thing people are saying about Gabourey's weight and looks are the same things people used to say about Monique, and Oprah, and Whoopie, and look at how successful they've become. They have more money and fame than all of us put together.
Gabourey, I wish you the best of luck. You can do ANYTHING you set your mind to.
All you idiots who are offended or upset by what Howard said are probably the same ones who believe there were/are WMD. Truth might "hurt", but a coronary before the age of 25 ain't real comfortable either. Who's being more "honest", Howard or Oprah? Oprah wouln't gush over any "Twiggy" actresses...she singles out Sidibe because Oprha feels "thin" by comparison.
And if ANY of you tools actually listened to Howard's show, you'd know that he is the most self-deprecating celebrity when it comes to his own physical appearance.
Outrage over telling an obvious truth? Ridiculous. She's a great actress, but let's see how much more work Hollywood throws her way.
How many people have actually listened to the audio rather than taking the media's word that he "slammed" her? Yeah, he wasn't eloquent about or nor did he sugar coat anything, but all he really said was 1) She needs to lose weight if she values her live and 2) Her chances of having a significant career in an industry that won't cast women who are 20 pounds overweight aren't particularly strong. She may get typecast but beyond cheap comedy roles morbidly obese people don't get cast in films. Simple as that. Yeah yeah, she's a role model for fat kids. Great. That doesn't change the fact that she needs to lose weight. What a bizarre society we live in: Jessica Simpson goes up a couple of dress sizes and its open season for the trash media. Someone points out, in no less offensive fashion than what was written on TMZ and Perez about Simpson, that an actress is dangerously overweight and he's crucified. I can understand why people think Stern goes too far sometimes, but this is not one of those times.
Stern has indeed built a career on saying whatever comes to mind regardless of how rude or hurtfull it may be-this is what a shock jock does. This is why I don't pad his pockets by listening to him.
Gabourey Sidibe may be obese but she is a lovely lady both inside and out as opposed to Stern who may be thin but is as butt ugly and truly obnoxious as they come.
The whole say anything that will shock and repulse people thing really wears thin after a while- just ask Howey's ex-wife.
Gabourey always has the possibility of getting fit, Stern will never have the option of being a decent human being.
Wow, so much hate, anger and name calling (of all things!) directed at someone who just made a simple observation! Gabourey just might be clinically "healthy" at this point in her life but her health will fail if she doesn't take action soon. Personally, I'm tired of seeing obese children standing in line at the grocery store with their obese mothers, and everything in their cart is full of sugar, carbs and fat. Don't be so mean to Howard – like it or not, he's RIGHT!
Stern is on another level of show business. There are lots of great musicians, lots of great actors, but he's the only one that can carry a 5-hr talk show 4 days a week (5 days a week for about 25 years) and consistently make it entertaining.
The truth stings. I don't care how wholesome thing they are, I'd be willing to bet both men and women were thinking something along the same lines. Maybe not as blunt. Maybe not as brash. But the notion that this woman is obsessively over-weight is a fact. A harsh reality that apparently society has a difficult time accepting. Sometimes it takes a bigger person to tell a person what they don't want to hear, rather than what they do.
Ta Ta Ta TooThie!!!
Howard you vile filthy creature love ya man!!!
Is it just me, or does it seem to be Howard Stern's objective to piss-off as many people as he possibly can in life. I, for one, am thoroughly tired of this trash-mouthed slob.
Almost everyone disagreeing with what Stern said is also making a comment about his vulgarity or that he is ugly or something similar.
I do not agree with his comments but most of you are just as bad making comments about him.
If you really dont care about what he says why are you reading the article and commenting about it.
BaBa Booey Rules
1. Stern who? Didn't he used to be on radio?
2. She knows she is is heavy. She knows she is different. She knows her limitations.
3. Stern makes his money being idiotic.
I know nothing about the actress, having no interest in the film in question, so the question has to be asked if her weight is due to a condition beyond her control (i.e. a glandular problem, etc). If so, then Stern was out of line. If her weight is from other factors, I don't know if he was necessarily off base. People who are too thin are becoming the target of criticism and concerns about health. We're now getting the same issue regarding people who are overweight. People who nod in agreement when someone like Stern goes after the Kate Moss's of the world (as I'm sure he has) can't really turn their nose up when he goes after people at the opposite end of the spectrum. The question has to also be asked - would there be such negative reaction had this comment come from someone who is more respected by the mainstream such as Oprah or Larry King?
Unfortunately, Howard is right. Regardless of his motivations, for discussing the issue, her weight is unhealthy, life threatening and certainly nothing to aspire to. Instead of denying it, we should join Howard in promoting a healthier lifestyle regardless of how uncomfortable this may be given his public views on other subjects,
Oh come on.... Howard is just drawing attention to himself by saying this crap so he can take over Simon's place. He SUXS.
Howard Stern for president!
Stern is right. The girl is a house and there are very few leading rolese in Holliwood for houses. She isn't pretty, and again she is huge. We are talking about the movie industry where beauty and fantasy is the product for sale.
It's great if you like yourself. It's great if you are comfortable with the way you look. But you must not like yourself that much if you are dying on purpose. She is fat . It will kill her. Hollywood does not care about her, and Hollywood will not care when she dies. A little bit of blunt honesty is a necessary thing once in awhile. It's just a shame that we have to wait for creeps like Stern and Beck to say what ought to be said because people like that are usually full of %^&$.
The actress is a one hit wonder with her weight she is either gonna lose the weight or die its simple fact stop trying sugar coat it by saying there are many plus size people in Hollywood she a walking hippo a ticking time bomb ready to explode. Howard is right and the way he said is perfectly fine some people need the harsh truth no matter how rude or horrible it is get over it. Its up to them to prove the critics wrong and her talent was really never being question by Howard just how is she gonna find another role in that condition.
I saw her on Kimmel Live recently. As Bill O'Reilly would say... what a bold, fresh piece of humanity! This girl is so delightful: she's a funny, fun-loving all-American girl having the time of her life and enjoying every minute of it. I'm disgusted by Stern's comments. He's not her physician. There have been no alarming news about her health in the media, so there's no reason to believe she's not healthy. Why? Why would anyone want to ruin such a nice kid's day? I don't get it.
If she never be in another movie again, it doesn't matter. She has done something few people her age has done. If she died tomorrow we'll remember her for the oscar nomination not her weight. How about Stern let her enjoy her moment. Congrats Gabourey Sidibe!
Howard I don't think you need to tell Gabby anything about her weight that she does'nt already know. Give her some credit, she is an intelligent young lady. The truth is... the only reason you have had pretty women in your arms is due to your money and remember... SHE CAN LOSE THE WEIGHT, but.....YOU CAN'T LOSE YOUR UGLY!!!!
Howard when in the HELL are you going to stop criticizing people. Your criticism is so damn old. When are you going to grow up cuz you sound like a whining broken record. Find something else to do with yourself. You have made enough money at the same ol' crap. Maybe you can move to the other side of the world where you can start out fresh in TV. Oh wait... your too ugly to make it on TV, that's why your on the radio, we don't have to see your ugly ass mug everday. Gabby is prettier on her worst day than you'll ever look like on you best.
He said it because none of the kiss asses orbiting around her, or the suckers living off her fat, will tell her to take care of herself.
hey fool's, he got you all talk'in .. LOL that is what he loves. Call him ugly but he is the one laughing to the bank.. Ha Ha Ha !! Keep talking...
Stern rules baba booey..
She was at the Oscars for her accomplishments as a actress – far from it – she was asked to portray a poor, fat black woman – I AM SURE IT WAS A DIFFICULT TASK. An actor or actress should be measured by their range of acting ability, she was not. She was there because of the color of her skin. Stern is right, she will only be in movies that she will portray fat, black women.
Keep up the good work Howard. You're right, unless Moby Oprah foots the bill for another ghetto sob story, she won't be back. The only reason she came off so good in the movie, is because she was reliving the travesties of her own life. She's far from being an actress.
The truth may hurt, but Howard stated nothing other than fact.
He's obviously not the most tactful, but in this case he's absolutely right. That poor girl needs an intervention. I hope she gets the help she so obviously needs.
Aren't his 15 minutes up yet? When will this buffoon finally go away?
Still, what he says is true. I cannot understand why anyone would applaud someone who is an obvious example of the American way of life – overindulgence, gluttony and lack of any kind of restraint.
Shame that Stern had to be the one to make the pertinent comments.
I really don't care what Howard Stern has to say he is an ugly person all the way around but what kills me is this: probably about half the people who commented on her weight are probably overweight themselves. Don't comment on someone elses imperfections if you are overweight your self. Its easy to point out someone who has a problem but you go to the store and purchase size 18-20 pants!!! Leave her alone, if she makes it in Hollywood thats her business, if she doesn't make it its still HER business. How about some of you get up off your butts take your overweight kids outside and play!!!
i hate to say it, but he is right. and as for the way he said it, remember that he's an entertainer. as they say, the best revenge is success: she should lose the extra weight and show everyone that her talent and weight are two different things.
all the best luck to her.
People are absolutely clueless when it comes to Stern. I see all these people saying "Has he looked in the mirror?" and "You are one ugly MF!"
Who do you think would be the first to agree with you? Stern himself!
Stern is as hard on himself as he is with everyone else. Sure he's rude, but that's the point! All these people who are offended and appalled by him are only feeding into what he does. And what he dos is great! We need his type of view in this PC media! YOU DA MAN STERN!
The man says these things the way he does to get attention, that's all. Take a look folks, it worked. He's like a rude little kid, it you'll ignore him, he'll go away.
You don't get it, Howard knows he is ugly and he will be the first one to admit it. Anyone who really listen's to Howard would know he is all about being healthy, and if he did not care about this girl he would not have said a word. I would say Howard cares more then Oprah- at least he is telling her the truth. It may not be nice, but the truth rarely is.
As harsh as he may be, Howard Stern does have a point, but he forgot about America Ferrare and how she started on "Real Women Have Curves" and is now a big star on Ugly Betty. Not everyone has to be thin as a rail to make it in Hollywood, but as far as her health is concerned, Gabby absolutely has to do something about the weight. Watching her on Precious was painful and it was supposed to be. But I don't want to have to deal with that type of sadness on every movie she's in. Who would?
Howard Stern is mean, rude, crass and laughing all the way to the bank because there are idiots out there that validate him. If she's big, she's big. It's her life. Let her live it. We all think in America that it's my responsibility to life everyone's life for them and give our opinions about stuff. People, shut up and let her be.
I for one, love Howard. I am a Black woman, 42 and have been listening to him for 20 years. Nothing he says offends me. That is Howard Stern as is! Why is anyone getting so angry? Your life will still go on everyday, same routine, same check. No one is forcing you to listen to his show nor no one asked you to read the story regarding his comments. Get over it and get on with ur lives..
She does have to lose weight and I'm sure she knows it. It's not what you say but how you say it. Monique and Oprah was just as big, do I need to say anymore!
Howard Stern for President!
Anyone who listens and supports this jackass is also a jackass....
Stern was a jerk on dinosaur radio, he's still a jerk now. Howard need to look in the mirror bcause he's no prize either. How is he still relavent? Not every woman has to be a size zero. As for Sidibe's career, she has three films coming up and has a TV pilot on Showtime. Does this sound like she's not going to have a career in Hollywood? Howard must be jealous since his movie career came and went in a flash. Howard needs to retire. His idea of comedy is wearing thin.
Howard tells it like it is and those who are offended are those who are so caught up in the 'politically correctness' of this country which is b.s. ...she's a big fat mess who needs help. She took up 2 chairs at the Academy Awards! I was hysterical when people on the red carpet were telling her how great she looked in the dress she was wearing b/c that dress was the size of a tent. More people need to loosen up and tell it how it is.
HAHA!!! Damn I love Howard! So true! I can't stand to even look at fatties. The level of gluttony required to get that big is disgusting. And all those Hollywood hypocrites are even more disgusting. They spend their money on liposuction, plastic surgery, face peels...you name it, in order to look "beautiful", but then patronize the fat black girl at the Oscars like they are accepting her. The truth is, they all left the theater and snickered behind her back. At least Howard tells it the way it is. "Girl, you are fat and disgusting, and you need to lose some weight." Does it hurt? Hell yes it hurts! Maybe it will hurt bad enough that she will get off her fat ass and do something about it.
@Jake Let everyone be? Problem is letting everyone be doesn't let everyone be. I'm healthy, but my health insurance keeps going up and up and up...
for everyone who states, they cant stand howard, he has no talent, he's ugly, you are the fools. it doesn't matter if you like him or not, he's 100% correct about her health and how she appears. the newscasters are making it sound like its ok for her to look that way. thats insane. she is very unhealthy, and i'm sure she will have a short life span. if you dont like howard, dont listen, if you think he has no talent, then your opinion is differant from his millions of fans, if you think he's ugly, look in the mirror. the fact is, he's healthy and he watches his diet. he has no control over how he looks, nor do we. we do have control over our food intake. i, for one, am a fan of the king of all media, if everyone else listens, you too will be a fan. howard, you are the king of all media
Oh my god. This guy needs to be a cohost of Palin's new show. What a piece of work. No one deserves this hacks attention. He should look to the real yuksters out there, not the quiet unassuming ones.
His words are so true. The problem is society is too politically correct to admit he is right. She is fat and disgusting and is not a role model for anyone. Well the medical profession loves her because she keeps them in business.
Also, you may hate Howard Stern but look at all the post his article generated. He is very intelligent and makes millions because of people who hate and love him.
Iwould never have known she was overweight until you mentioned it. (that's a joke Howard)The first black woman to win an Academy award was also overweight. It is because of you that this country is so infested with racism and unfortunately she may never have a chance to perform as brilliantly as she did in "Precious" not because of her size but because of people like you whose voice carries to those in power. Did you see the movie? If you did you would have seen a powerful voice for the voiceless "Precious'" of the world. i would think you would be more empathetic, considering you have a face that was made for the radio....and they say we have come a long way!
I love the fact that everyone is so concerned about Howard Stern's opinions and statements. He is one of the few in media that is not afraid to be honest and most of his controversial statements reflect the thoughts that many Americans are too politically correct to state. And I'll assume that most of the comments on here are from individuals who do not listen to his show since you would then know he is also one of the most self depricating individuals out there regarding his looks, among other things!
Gabourey Sidibe is a beautiful young lady inside and out. She is a blessing from God with a beautiful talent. Stern has a talent as well. Just think...because of his criticism...she will be more famous and he will be more criticized for his rude comments. I'm sure Ms. Sidibe is aware of her health and will make her own decisions on how to handle herself. That can not take away from who she really is...beautiful inside out and a blessing!!!!
By the way, Ms. Sidibe is already working an another movie!!! So Stern...kiss her whole ass!!!!! I may not agree with Stern's comments, but he is entitled to them...just as I am to mine.
You Go Ms. Sidibe!!!!!!
Howard, the planetoid-sized gasbag, should talk.
Howard Stern has always been a jerk with as big mouth. He gets off
using foul language and talking dirty and taking people down for whatever reason. He thinks the world revolves around him, maybe his world. There are ways to say things, especially to young impressionable young people, and he blew it. He needs to do something with his mouth, hair and face. There are alot of people still trying to figure out why his wife married him, I know I am.
LOOK WHO'S TALKING!!! omg – stern could scare the dead -
Howard says things that most people only think in the privacy of their head; things that are embarassing to admit publicly. Can anyone deny that Gabby has a serious weight issue? Now that she has the means, would it not be a good idea for her to lose weight? That's not saying she should drop to a size 2, but ANY weight loss would be helpful. His comments about her chances in Hollywood are based on Hollywood's track record. How many obese actors and actresses are on TV or in movies? Perhaps there will be a "funny fat friend", but most of the time, it's the thin "beautiful" people. She may be a great actor, but unless someone writes a part specifically for her, there aren't going to be a lot of opportunities for her in Hollywood. This movie gave her a great start, I can only hope that she doesn't feel she needs to stay big to retain recognition.
Stern said the harsh truth. Don't expect him to pull punches. If you listen to the entire segments (and his follow-ups), you'll know that he admits she has talent and that the comments weren't meant to be personal attacks.
It is way too easy to cherry-picks a few of Stern's lines to make him sound like an complete asshole. (He's an ass sometimes, but that's the show)
Also, it's funny how people are all up-in-arm about him calling Sidibe fat but yet call Stern "ugly" and "rat-faced".
I bet she knows she is fat. I bet she gets told this a hundred times a day. The people who are really ugly are those that feel the need to dump on fat people. Somehow this has become the politically correct thing to do these days. The human virus must consume.
Someone seriously needs to run this man down with a Mack truck.....
Once again stern says some stupid stuff & then you have some even more stupid comments on this board. Insensitive people ask your selves these questions...Who says she cant be in more movies? How do you know shes not working on one now? Why cant she be a role model? Who says she hasnt been working on losing weight?...and you wonder why so many out there in the world hate themselves for how they look?.....Keep doing you Gabby. Keep being a wonderful role model for people around the world:)
Howard is 100% correct. Name 1 (one) example of an actress her size having a long-successful movie career. Love Howard or hate him, you can't deny he is telling it like it is, even if it a little harsh.
I think that america has high expectations on how woman should look. If this young star feels comfortable in her own skin, then every on should respect that. I mean, She must be aware that she is over weight and it may make give people the o.k. to be obese. They may even gain confidence and self respect. Im not saying its healthy, but when the star is not being critisized she may realize there is a problem. Until then just enjoy her talent.
I got to agree with Howard on this one. As for the people who think he's mean or rude, if you sugar-cost something like this she'd probably eat it.
Hey, if the show "Half Ton Man" decides to come out with a movie, she'd be perfect for the part. She might have to pack on some more pounds for the roll though....oops I mean't role.
He's right.
The truth of the matter is that's it's none of anyone's business. That is the problem today everyone is in everyone elses business.
Wow! Is all I can say. I understand being candid however, when you do not know all of the facts then thats when it's out of place. Yes, she may be over weight but that does not mean that she is unhealthy. There are many people in the world who are under weight and just as unfit and unhealthy. And with regard to her acting skills I do believe that there will be more roles for her and in time we will see a different in society and how they view bigger people. All I can say is Gabby don't listen to the nay sayers there time will come and the only person who can judge is that higer power and Howard Stern surely is not.
That is what Stern does best tear people down. It's true that he says what other people are afraid to say.
For once, I do not think Howard was rude at all, he was right on the mark. People need to get their heads out the sand, she is no different than a drug addict, she is addicted to food.
There is a truth to these comments, at least from a health and role model perspective. While we as a society are always quick to condment the "anorexic" look to models and the bad influence they can have on our children, we must also condemn the glorification of the look of this actress. Such obesity is a rising epidemic among today's youth, and telling a woman such as this that being the way she is acceptable sends a completely wrong message to all of us.
I read these comments about all the people that hate Stern and it's getting silly. It's funny to me because there is no doubt that he will be considered one of the great icons of the 20th and 21st century. Over a million people out there listen to his show every morning religiously. He has been doing his show for over 30 years! He is the only celebrity out there to make celebrities and real people out of mentally challenged individuals, little people, homeless people, and many other physically or mentally challenged individuals. Over a million people spend over $12.00 a month to listen to one show. That does not include the cost of the radio. Instead of criticizing him, you should give the guy some credit for making people so happy.
Freedom of speech, he can say whatever he wants whether we agree or not. I can't stand the way the people in this country think they can stop people from speaking their mind because it might not be popular. I was thinking that, it was only natural, but I would never of said it outloud. That's why I love Howard. He should replace Simon Cowell it would be great!
Big girls do need to lose weight and be healthy.... but thinness is not synonymous with good health. Just like being overweight isn't a guarantee of health problems, (especially so for women!!!) But even saying "fat" now-a-days seems like such a nasty word. That and the fact that guys tend to use the word more often than women and toward women who are not even fat! Our culture is extremely unhealthy mentally, and I truly believe that losing weight and being healthier (again, not necessarily a pair) would be easier for a LOT of women in our country if we didn't vilify women who are chubby, have a few extra pounds, or hell... even if they are "fat!" Do you think women who are overweight are joyful about it? Have sympathy... and empathy. Christian nation, right? Act like it. "What movie is she going to be in? ‘Blind Side 2,’ she could be the football player.” - this statement alone is just cruel. I remember when I first gained weight in my early 20s (and i was NOT fat, mind you) – some guy was harassing my friend at a bar and when I told him to back the -ef- off, he laughed to his friends and said, "look guys, we have a linebacker for the 'skins here". I feel that men in the US treat women so disrespectfully... who says that to someone? Although I was not big, it still completely gave me a complex. And it was designed to. It was designed to be cruel, cutting, and hateful. And although I know it said more about that jack-ss that said it than it did about me... it was still wrong. And you know what? I bet that guy considers himself a gentleman! (like ALL american men).
Howard Stern has a lot of nerve considering his face looks like toilet paper after someone wiped their azz!!! For your information, Gabourey is already in a new made-for-HBO movie fool!!! Not everyone in Hollywood has to have bones sticking out.
To be honest, I love stern, and stern is up front about eveything. If so many of you do not like him, why even click on the article about him?
I'm sorry but no matter what her weight is, who the hell is Howard Stern to be telling her what to do about it? Is he her doctor now? It is absolutely none of his business! I guess Howard Stern's show is suffering and he needed some attention and he knew he'd get it this way.
People and the media are getting SO bent out of shape about what Stern said, and while it's uncomfortable information, it's CORRECT INFORMATION. Sure it's mean but that girl needs to lose weight or she'll die: FACT. And if she doesn't die from over eating, she'll die from the diabetes or heart conditions that plague women AND MEN with obesity. And regarding her not getting work, Stern is surely referring to the double standards rampant throughout hollywood: Men age and double in size gracefully while women are shut out of roles for a couple wrinkles, grey hairs and flesh folds.
Get mad at the truth people, not STERN!
Hey, if Howie can make in show business with a face only a mother could love, and that is questionable, why can't a heavy set actress make it.
I love this. All of you who are crying about what Stern said. Yeah he isn't the nicest or smartest guy on the planet but come on, he told it like is. I'm sorry people, but the world is a harsh critical place and to feed this girl lies is worse than what Stern said. Oprah and the rest of Hollywood should be the ones who are chastised. They are filling this girl up with unrealistic expectations of becoming a start. Hollywood is shallow and cruel and unless this girl trims down, no way in hell is she getting another shot. Logical thinking people would thank Mr. Stern and chastise Oprah. But sense we are dealing with the American public, this won't ever happen.
If Howard is so worried about her health why didn't he call her and personally agree to take her to the doctor, get her help and stand by her on her journey to weight loss. Howard Stern is a loser making money for nothing. He should be going to the plastic surgeon, like so many others in Hollywood.
Well ... I am a 24 year old black male living in main stream america, i came from lower class areas and built my self to better living. nobody can be as real as me. I know mainstream america fro b oth sides of the ball. The fact of the matter is Howard Stern is only a host who says what people think, i watched Howard Sterns show for years but grew out of it. i can tell you unless howard is completly different person, this is nothing but another howard stern daily comment. Howard Stern is not racist nor is a hater of any kind. this freedom of speech thing is out of hand, that lady put her life of the screen for the world to see. When you do things like that you should already know it comes with pros in cons. you will be hated upon or praised. you will have people call you for what you are a great actress and a huge lady. there is nothing wrong with that. everybody talks him rude and what not, its not rude to call a big celebrity big. she clearly does not care what people think about her because she made a fing movie. if you dont like the way somebody talks, speaks, reacts, describes or handles somethings that is meant be looked at in those sorts of light then leave them alone. Howard Stern says what he feel and other people feel because the rest of the semi-celebritys are to afraid to.
Stern rules!!!
"I'm gonna get me some Chic-Fil-A and hit it hard"
He's right! She is completely unhealthy!!!! She needs to take care of herself so that she can have a future in the acting business. She should use her fame to set a better example. There is no reason for her to be stick skinny, but she needs to be healthy!
I don't really like or hate Howard Stern coz I've no time or energy to worst on him. But as a black woman I've to say the guy just said what most people think or were thinking. Somebody had to say something, and no black sisters were willing to. Let the truth be told if you are F.A.T you are FAT, and no wonder we live in an OBESE America coz all ya live in denial and just don't want to hear the truth. Now that Stern has said it, do something about it and quit yepping over nothing. Anytime she can die of heart attack and will that make you happy???
Howard Stern is great coz he tells it like it is.
@ 'B'. Funny. As if she 'gained' weight for her role. Honey, I can assure you she was already 400 pounds before this role. No one puts on that kind of weight for a role. Howard might usually be crude and out of line, but the fact is, Sidibe is killing herself. It is not mean, it is honest. Instead of doing it with drugs, alcohol, cigarrettes, she is using food. That is not attacking her talent, or the fact that she is a kind person, it is just telling it how it is. Are there other large actors out there? Yes, but she is twice as big as they are. Very sad.
LOL Now I understand why he's on satellite radio! He's so irrelevant that he no longer merits a mainstream audience! He's just jealous because his movies weren't nominated for Oscars. SIdibe is uber-talented and who cares if she is overweight??! That is her problem and something she needs to deal with. I am so tired of everybody worrying about everyone else's health. It's her body, her life, when it is time for her to decide to lose weight, she will do it. Leave the girl alone. I don't think she is going to have too much trouble getting other roles in Hollywood. Like one poster said, they'll write roles for her! Good luck, Gabourey!
Well Howard, now that you have a little money set aside, maybe you can get a haircut
Stern should have said it nicer? He's not Dr. Phil you Morons, he is an entertainer and he gets paid to make his many listeners laugh. Truth is he is a pragmatic individul whos says it like it is..if you can't handle the truth, don't listen.
I love how everyone is trashing Howard and calling him "Ugly". Everyone knows he is not good looking.....even HE knows it. But he doesn't have people call him "The most wonderful Prince Charming" at the Oscars as Oprah called her a new American Princess. Come on people! She is morbidly obese. She has no chance in Hollywood if she stays like that. Howard is just saying what EVERYONE was thinking but don't have the sack to say. If you tell me you saw her at the Oscars and didn't think "DAMN!!" when you did, you are lying to yourself.
I really don't see much disrespect in anything that he said. What a sweet thing it is to tell someone who is in risk of dying that she should get help to get healthy because she is someone we want to see succeed in life.
He was a bit crude in what he said, but he really is telling the truth. As is, this girl will never be cast in another movie unless morbid obesity is the main trait of the character she plays. In other words, her being fat has to be part of the story.
Of course she is talented enough to play other kinds of roles, but you can't overlook the way she looks, and every casting agent in Hollywood knows that. So there aren't going to be many opportunities for this girl, and the few that she may get will typecast her.
Her personality is just awesome. She's funny and sweet and humble. And she has talent far beyond her years. Howard Stern recognizes that, and he wants her to succeed. He knows that she won't succeed unless she drops about 150 pounds. And he thinks it wrong of people like Oprah to pretend that she doesn't have a problem. Especially when Oprah obsesses over her own weight.
If you listen to the audio clip on YouTube it was Robin Quivers who made the most disparaging remarks mentioned in this article NOT Howard Stern.
Stern is offensive, however, despite his lack of tact for saying what most everyone else is thinking, he is indeed correct. The woman is extremely unhealthy and should seek help now that she does have some money under her belt. No one should "look past" her physical problems because beauty is only skin deep, in this case taking that stance is ignoring a major health problem for the sake of being PC.
Howard is a bully picking on an easy target to get attention. It doesn't get any lower than that.
I love it how people take things that Howard says completely out of context and make some sort of ethical issue out of it.
The bottom line is that he never was someone that was trying to shock anyone. He is a comedian that contributes a social commentary. God forbid that he call out the beloved Oprah for making an assumption that the girl is going to have some kind of career. She simply fit the bill for a huge girl that got abused and mistreated. It was the story that brought her there. Everyone knows it, but are too scared to be honest about it.
If she were on Dr. OZ and he told her to her face that she needed to loose weight or she would die in a few years he would be praised for his honesty.
Howard Stern is one of the very (very) few entertainers that has the integrity and brilliance enough to be open and honest. By the way if you were actually listening to the Stern show then you would know that he is the first one to point out his own faults. He is an advocate for others well being, but knows how to make it interesting.
There is some reason why he is one of the highest paid entertainers in the history of the world and I am sure it isn't because he feels he should dumb down his opinions for those who do not pay to hear him on a dialy basis. Frankly you don't deserve to know whe he said about anything unless you are paying for it. That is unless you are breaking the law by checking out a video on youtube that I know for a fact that he does not want up there. I know because I am a listener and know his opinion on that......By the way, terrestrial radio is dying without him...
Cao Hala Gorani now I'm sure I'm in love with you and I would like to have sex with you.
You're an aggressive woman and that is what is missing in my life.
Answer me the address because I want to be friends and to leave this country.
It turns out that in Banja Luka, there is no woman for me and no real friends.
Peter Pecije 19, 78000 Banja Luka, Republika Srpska, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Baba Boey!! Baba Boey!
Stern was spot on!
These people do not understand me Hala have the same passion as I sense they are somewhat shallow mind.
I want to come to USA and to live in the American way, because here is boring and miserable life just is not my mentality.
And this is what the public will get if Stern winds up becoming a judge on American Idol, albeit I think that's a long shot. But if by chance it becomes a reality, then AI will die within 1 season – for good.
What are you, Mr. Stern, gaining by saying something like this? What are you getting by being a "bad, mean person"? Is this your true nature? Or is this really part of your act to attract a morbidness-seeking audience, who, in the end, will pay you the big bucks.... by just hurting people....
I don't get it. I don't think there is any need for this.
Honestly, Yes this girl is of an unhealthy weight, could Howard have said it nicer, sure in theory, but this is Howard Stern and this is what he does. I'm not saying that I'm in agreement with the statements as much, but I can guarantee that many people in the country think the same way. when you are in the spotlight, you are going to be judged on everything, you have to be ready to be under the microscope and take the criticism, It comes with the territory.
Stern tells the truth, if you want to hear lies then watch the news, or go to a city council meeting.
I am someone who has his entire life was neglected by family and society and we need a strong personality that will help me in life and for all these years in this city, I found this.
I know you're under various prejudices but I'll convince you that I am a good guy.
The anti-Stern people are just flat out DUMB. He knocks himself on his looks and physique all the time. So glass house, pot calling the kettle, etc., doesn't even apply. He knows he's no prom king. And to say he's talentless, well is there a word for "less than DUMB"? What he's saying about this grotesquely obese woman is dead on. Have some respect for yourself, and for the family and friends that love you, and lose some weight before your poor over-worked heart fails to support you.
Such blowhards. Free speech. He is not being rude. bababooey
How would you say to someone "you are fat and need to lose weight" in a nice way? You can't. Stern saying what 90% of us were thinking? No. He said what 100% of us were thinking. Poor girl does need to lose a little weight. The US spends between 100 and 200 billion a year on weight related health care alone. If we don't make fun of the fat people to pressure them to lose some weight, that number will only grow. Sorry fatties. I love you but the fat has to go. You can stay as long as you like!
The one thing I like about satellite radio is is got howard the duck off the pubic airwaves!
Thank you Sirius! I honestly hope he gets a raise so he will stay where he is so decent people who don't have satellite radio won't be subjected to his garbage.
Stern's a moron; he wasn't saying this stuff as health or career advice but just to ride her skirts. Who ever heard of Howard Stern lately? He's like a blast from the Nineties.
I'm a big Stern fan...have been for years, and this is exactly the reason why. He openly says what many people are thinking and will point out the truth. Her weight is extremely unhealthy. I'm a girl and by no means can be considered skinny, but there is a healthy weight everyone needs to maintain. Mo'Nique used to say to everyone that she 'celebrates' her heaviness...until she got diabetes. His methods may be harsh but his words are true.
hey lub2ski&surf
so you think that as long as he says what people are thinking, that's ok and socially acceptable?
well, how about this–i think you AND howard are idiots! people are thinking it and i'm just pointing out the truth.
thanks. i feel better. do you?
I started to think too much and now sounds silly but I really want to leave the change of environment and start a new life meet new people and for this I need a friend like you can not longer be with these people in this environment.
And you will all boil down to the sex because you are easier to accept me so.
I know that sometimes as far sounds silly and childishly as all the relax and begin to think a lot but I'm different when I do something and here I do not support or desire to be or to do.
He is a comedian people!! He says jokes about everyone. The problem is he is saying on the radio what a lot of people are saying at their local bars ,etc. Is he really saying she is not talented , no. But in Hollywood,where thin is almost a prerequisite for a career. He is just stating the truth. How many girls her size get steady work in Hollywood and are not just the "fat" girl in a movie with attractive stars? She was perfect for her role in this one movie, lets not act like she is healthy and should stay that size. Her acting talent must be separated from the point being discussed. That is it is not in her best interest to be that big from a health perspective. Just cause you don't like the way it's said, does not mean its not a valid point.
She is extremely heavy, but Howard's no jewel for sure ( and I really mean for-sure). Given what's left, their personalities, she wins no-contest.
Maybe she'll get a chik fil a contract to be their spokeswoman and advertising talent.
Yes, he is speaking the truth, just in the irritating, insensative Stern way. He's smart enough to know how to say things properly. His movie showed how he fell into broadcasting backasswards. I wonder what he would be do if he could not get another job in radio because of his big ego, mouth and little else.
I am sure that I succeeded in show business-and life in America and Hollywood just can not get it because they can not get a visa and you are cruel and want to help in this.
Salute Barack Obama when we finish some commitments here I will write a message for Obama and you provide him.
Be my Angels and I will be your pet and we all will be fine.
@ FRAN PHILLIPS
You're obviously a fat chick too
My mother in law is like a lot of you idiots out there...a woman who loves to yenta it up at work about how Howard is such a rude jerk and all he does is use bad language and make girls show their breasts...MEANWHILE, she's never heard the show, she only knows what other yenta's like herself say about him. Try listening for one day, I bet money you'll change your opinion of him
Bababooey to you all
Gabourey Sidibe could beat the sxxxt our of stern any day.
A) The presentation does not change the truth of the matter. She is morbidly obese, and her obesity will both preclude a Hollywood career with any longevity whatsoever and significantly impair her health and well-being.
B) Make fun of Howard's appearance all you want. His point was not that she was ugly, it's that she's fat and unhealthy. Howard is extremely healthy and continually admits he is ugly.
C) Almost 1,600 comments so far? Like him or not, Howard has obviously done something right that so many people deem a stupid comment about a woman being fat worth commenting on.
@Chinicuil, you are out of your mind. Have you ever been overweight? I have, she would run outta breath within the first 3 swings. Get realisitic.
she won an award .howard;thinks he can say whatever he wants.
she can lose weight but he cant get away with being the biggest loser alive.
OM NOM NOM NOM NOM
Yeah, it's so terrible that Howard made those comments that CNN now has a lead story based on the concept. Hypocrites.
http://www.cnn.com/2010/SHOWBIZ/Movies/03/10/gabourey.sidibe.career/index.html?hpt=C1
I'm not entirely in agreement with Stern. Hollywood (read: white America) loves mammy figures. Look at the Oscar guest list, past and present. Hattie McDaniel, Monique, etc. And they can't get enough Oprah. Stern even has a mammy on HIS show. The only thing they love more is the tragic mulatto...like Halle. There'll be roles. White folks love fat black women.
Stern speaks the truth! The people who say they hate Stern never listen to him! Besides he's being honest. What would u tell your friend if she were that large? Keep eating, you look great? If you really cared about this person you tell them the exact same thing! People need to hear the truth even if it does hurt. In the end they'll thank you for being honest...just like Stern!
who cares she is hot!
Let's leave the girl alone. It's her life. Sure we are all thinking the same thing: "Damn, that girl could stand to miss a meal or two." but who are we to judge. Also, i am not the skinniest girl in the world, but i am a vegetarian. so i know how to take care of myself. Personally, i think that she can be comfortable with her size, but hey, she could do a little better. i hope she does get healthier and find more roles. she is talented and i guess we would like to see her around alot more. Oh yeah, and Stern is a real ass anyway. Why the hell does his comments even matter? I think he's a real waste of sperm and egg. But that's just me....
...........And Howard is laughing all the way to the bank
Reply to Jenny – Stern doesn't need to be a 'hot guy', which is why even he admits as to why hes on RADIO! Good for him,,, Lots think, few speak
Howard Stern.....You are that ugly painful cancer that man will never find a cure for......
Howard is the lowest form of existence on our planet.
Howard Stern looks loke a Giraffe on crack with a bad wig, but they allow him in show business......
Howard Stern sucks! He's a hideous person who has no heart. He say's these horrible things about people to get publicity. Cause nobody cares if he has a radio talk show or not. Nobody cares about him. Not to mention, he looks like a crackhead!
Howard Stern, you broke down crappy ass ugly sob. How dare you make fun of this young lady. You are ugly inside and out, you need to take a good look in the mirror. You need a face lift, get rid of that nasty looking shitty ass long hair. Your face is too ugly for television, so you hide behind the radio. You nasty ass bastard. Gabby, keep your head up. You will make it, and have the last laugh.
You Stern haters don't listen to him anyway.. You can't handle the truth
.. the USA has become so PC that it's turn the country into a big joke
Bottom line is that Gabourey Sidibe is morbidly obese with a future filled with high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, early arthritis and early death. There is no controversy about that . . . its the just the painful and sad facts about those who are obese. Regardless of whether or not you like Howard Stern or how he relays the message, the bottom line is that Gabourey Sidibe is grossly overweight on her way to an early death if she doesn't lose weight. Period. End of Story.
All you holier than though jerks need to get a life. Whether you think Howard is a "cancer" on our society or a true trailblazing radio genius, he is right about Ms. Sidibe. She is morbidly obese and needs to lose weight, and lots of it. Otherwise, her acting talent will forever be overshadowed by her appetite. A dozen eggs for breakfast is fine if you are 6'5", 325 pound NFL lineman but not when you are a 20 year old girl. Oprah needs to learn how to speak the truth. She would sugar coat Osama Bin Laden if he ever came on her show. Worthless piece of TV trash.
I never could stand him. His schtick is not amusing. He's a one-man wrecking crew coarsening the culture.
Stern has no room to talk..Fortunately hes in radio now and I no longer have to see his "BUTT UGLY" face on tv much anymore...And look at his body, "Yuck"!! He is nothing to be desired. I dont know how any sane woman could put up with him...He needs to leave his comments to himself..Go Gabby!!!!!!!
The best part about all of this is that there is nothing you can say about Stern that would harm him in anyway. Call him coarse, ugly, and a horrible person, and he will agree with you!
Why do you think he has been around for so long? Because he is a breathe of fresh air compared to all the fake, politically correct entertainment that infests the media.
I would gaurantee that if half of the people on here who are taking shots at Stern were to actually listen to his show, they would have a change of mind.
To the other half who would despise him no matter what, get a sense of humor.
Bravo to all those calling Stern and his fans "the lowest for of human life"! Thats brilliant! I love it!
*form
Stern rules!
Awwww Howie, look! People are actually talking about your lame a$$. Ugh. Please – just dry up and blow away already.
He is a strange looking guy though. He kind of looks like the product of a man and a pelican if they could mate.
Howard Stern is wealthy white trash.
This World crisis will last longer than mine.
Finally, will the wise heads and Psychologists conclude that I am the psychopath that only the hip causes offending and solves nothing.
Albeit sometimes repent and apologize to the Prime Minister and fellow citizens because they are complaining because they are not allowed to deal with me and so calling them.
There are several answers why this work.
1. To cleanse and strengthen the 2nd Fun to me. 3. Known in World
To all that have commented on Stern's physical "appearance". Your doing the exact same thing Stern did which upset you to begin with! If I were that fat, Stern was my friend, he told told me I'm fat and need to lose weight then I go and lose that weight, Stern just saved my life! How many people do you let die every day by not being honest with them?
Will come a time when I am of you as a collective CNN seek specific service I hope to come across people and not similar.
These in my environment do not have Balls and too weak for me.
I hope not angry because of some inappropriate sentences is due to frustration from the nose. But when you improve it and be OK I hope that you respond to me in the right way.
I hope you will take advantage of me you'd just watched.
I am a little aggressive but I did not fool me, you must follow and meet me what I sought and seek. Now go bath.
You with the TV you are better than any woman can tell you all, and Clear, or what was the second at any time even when I start to listen to and meet the services to be perfection. The small sports reporter when I said resolutely stay with us would eat the TV passion.
Kate Gils wrong is that we're not beside me.
Thanks Howard! She probably would never have had another role but now that you've said it, someone will give her a role just to prove you wrong! Now that she has all that money, lets hope she can get healthy and not just lay on the couch and pay people to bring her the ringdings!
I cant stand stern, and never could-however he is correct this time.
Why is it that women insist on LYING to each other? If it were men-one of the friends would tell him "dude-you gotta lose some weight-you look like shit, and we want you around for a while".
For some reason women are afraid of hurting each others feelings, and it makes no sense. Friends tell each other the truth.
As for Oprah-EVERYTHING she does or says is 100% for her own personal gain. She has indeed done some fantastic, charitable things, but ONLY because her Return On Investment (time, money, or effort) is huge. And can ANYONE really beleive Oprah when she makes tatements like that?-Oh yes they can-because powerful women like Oprah are perpetuating the lies women tell each other.
Stern speaks the truth.
Even though this is all true, It just din'nt help anything or anybody to say it,Howard your just being mean.
Hey Howard
Have you ever looked in the mirror. That ugly in there is you. If you could see the inside you would see it goes all the way through. By the way Oprah could buy and sell you 10x over. How much money have you made in a movie?? I am glad that most people know that beauty comes from within I hope you get a part in a movie as the football
The king of all mucus is missing being in the headlines so he has to rattle his dung cage saying this about precious, or saying he should be an idol judge.
By the way, HIS movie career was pretty unimpressive. As for Mr Media, making your money in the gutter does not make you the King of anything.